4 min read

The Law of Moses Tried the Liars Who Lied in the Name of the Law

After Daniel caught the two elders in contradicting testimony, the crowd brought them back to the court where they had falsely condemned Susanna.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. The Same Court, Different Defendants
  2. The Law They Had Sworn to Uphold
  3. Saved from Shedding Innocent Blood
  4. Hilkiah and His Wife Praised God

The Same Court, Different Defendants

They were brought back to the same place where they had stood as judges. The crowd that had been moving toward an execution had turned around and returned, and now they were standing in the court where two respected men had testified to something they had not seen and watching those same men account for it. The situation had reversed completely. The elders who had presented themselves as witnesses were now the subject of examination. The woman they had condemned was free. The men who had condemned her were not.

Daniel had already done the critical work. He had separated them, questioned them apart, and they had named different trees in the same garden on the same afternoon. The inconsistency was not ambiguous and it was not small. It was a clean break between two stories that were supposed to be one story. The testimony was false. The witnesses were liars.

The Law They Had Sworn to Uphold

The law that applied was Deuteronomy 19:19: you shall do to the false witness as he had intended to do to his brother. This is one of the cleaner formulations in the entire Torah. There is no principle to apply, no analogy to work through, no competing precedent to weigh. The false witness receives what he planned to give to his victim. The elders had testified falsely to secure Susanna's death. Under the law they had invoked as their authority, the law of the community they served as judges, their punishment was death.

The assembly did not hesitate over the application. The trial had been brief. The crime was simple. The law was direct. They applied it.

Saved from Shedding Innocent Blood

The account closes with a phrase that repays attention: they were saved on that day from shedding innocent blood in Israel. Saved. The community had nearly killed an innocent woman through the false testimony of two men it trusted. The execution of the elders was presented not as revenge and not as simple retributive justice but as a rescue: the community was rescued from itself, from the act it had almost committed, from the stain of innocent blood that would have attached to every member of the assembly that had believed the lie and walked toward the killing.

The phrase innocent blood in Israel is specific and heavy. The Torah treats the shedding of innocent blood as a defilement of the land itself, a contamination that does not wash out with ordinary legal processes. The community's near-miss was that close to something irreversible. Daniel's intervention had not simply saved Susanna. It had saved everyone present from what they were about to do to themselves.

Hilkiah and His Wife Praised God

Susanna's parents, Hilkiah and his wife, praised God for their daughter's vindication, along with her husband Joakim and all her relatives. The text notes that she had not been found doing anything shameful, which is the kind of phrase that carries the weight of community reputation behind it. She had been nearly executed on the word of two men whose authority the community had trusted, and the praise that followed her vindication was proportional to the danger she had been in.

Daniel was acclaimed after that day. The text says that he became great in the sight of the people from that day forward. He had stepped out of a crowd with no position and no authority and stopped an execution by asking one question separately of each of two men who had not compared their stories. The community had turned around when he said to turn around. After that, they knew who he was.

LawWomenDanielSusannaMosesApocrypha
← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

4 sources

The texts this telling draws on, in full. Open a card to read inline, or expand it for a wider, quieter read.

The Book of Susanna 1:76The Book of Susanna

We've been following her story, a tale of beauty, faith, and unjust accusation in ancient Babylon. Two corrupt elders, consumed by lust, had falsely accused her of adultery. Her life hung by a thread, the word of these respected men seemingly enough to condemn her.

Remember, truth has a way of surfacing, doesn't it? Even when the odds seem stacked against it. And in Susanna's case, truth arrived in the form of a young, wise man named Daniel.

He intervened, challenging the elders, separating them, and questioning them individually. The discrepancies in their stories became glaringly obvious. They contradicted each other on the type of tree under which Susanna supposedly met her lover. The lie unraveled.

Now? Now comes justice. The Book of Susanna tells us that the elders were dealt with according to the law of Moses: "And you shall do to him as he had intended to do to his brother." (Susanna 1:45). Their evil plot backfired, and they suffered the fate they had intended for Susanna.

"And they killed them, and they were saved on that day from shedding innocent blood in Israel." (Susanna 1:46). Susanna was vindicated, her innocence proven. The community was spared the stain of executing an innocent woman.

Imagine the relief, the joy! "And Hilkiah and his wife gave praise and glory to God for the matter of their daughter, for no shameful thing was found in her." (Susanna 1:47). Her parents, who must have been living an absolute nightmare, could finally breathe again. Their faith in God, and in their daughter, was rewarded.

"And so her husband Jehoiakim and his entire family did too." (Susanna 1:48). Can you imagine the celebration in their household? The nightmare was over. Their wife, their daughter-in-law, was safe.

And what of Daniel? "And Daniel became great and esteemed in the eyes of the people from that day forward, and further until the day of his death." (Susanna 1:49). This brave, insightful young man had not only saved Susanna, but he had also exposed corruption and upheld justice. His wisdom and courage became legendary, solidifying his position as a leader and a figure of immense respect.

Susanna's story isn't just a historical account. It's a reminder that even in the face of overwhelming injustice, hope and truth can prevail. It's a evidence of the power of faith, the importance of standing up for what is right, and the enduring strength of the human spirit.

It makes you wonder, doesn't it? How many other "Susannas" are out there, waiting for someone to see the truth and fight for them? What can we learn from this ancient story to make the world a little more just, a little more compassionate, today?

Full source
The Book of Susanna 1:71The Book of Susanna

Our story comes from The Book of Susanna, a short but powerful addition to the Book of Daniel. It’s a tale of beauty, betrayal, and ultimately, vindication. Susanna, But her virtues made her a target.

Two respected elders, judges in the community, became consumed with lust for her. They stalked her, and when she refused their advances, they concocted a wicked plan. They accused her of adultery, claiming to have caught her in the act with a young man. In those days, such an accusation, especially coming from respected figures, carried immense weight. Susanna was brought to trial, facing almost certain death.

What could she do? She was trapped.

Unlike others of her time, Susanna "did not listen to your voice of prostitution." She held firm to her values, even when faced with unimaginable pressure. This detail highlights her strength and moral integrity. It's a small line, but it speaks volumes about her character.

The elders, confident in their deception, presented their false testimony. They were asked to identify the specific tree under which they supposedly witnessed the act. One elder, in his arrogance, declared it was "under an oak tree."

But here's where our hero, Daniel, steps in. A young man, filled with wisdom and righteous anger, senses something is amiss. He interrupts the proceedings, declaring, "May falsehood cover your face in disgrace! See, the angel of the Lord is waving his sword over you to destroy you."

Strong words. But Daniel wasn't finished. He cleverly separates the two elders and questions them individually. He asks each of them the same crucial question: "Under what kind of tree did you see them?" And, miraculously, they give different answers! One says an oak, the other… well, the text doesn't tell us which tree he names, but the point is: their stories didn't align. Their lie was exposed!

Can you imagine the collective gasp? The shift in atmosphere?

The people, realizing the elders’ deceit, turned on them. "And all the people heard and lifted up their voices to give thanks to God, the savior of all those who hope for His kindness." This wasn’t just a legal victory; it was a moment of profound spiritual significance.

"And all of them rose up against the two elders who had been caught by the sayings of their mouths, by the hand of Daniel, for they had testified falsely against Susanna." Justice prevailed. Susanna was saved, and the corrupt elders faced the consequences of their actions.

The story of Susanna reminds us that appearances can be deceiving. It highlights the importance of integrity, the power of truth, and the possibility of redemption, even in the darkest of times. It’s a story about the strength of one woman, the wisdom of a young man, and the unwavering hope for justice in a world often filled with deceit. It's a story that continues to resonate, reminding us to look beyond the surface and to stand up for what is right, even when it's difficult.

Full source
The Book of Susanna 1:61The Book of Susanna

Sometimes, the most righteous outcomes arise from the most unexpected places. to a fascinating story from the Book of Susanna, a tale of false accusations, quick thinking, and divine intervention.

The scene is set: two respected elders, pillars of their community, approach a young man named Daniel. They ask him to sit with them, to lend his wisdom to their judgments, to discern if God has indeed appointed him as a man of judgment and justice.

Sounds reasonable. But Daniel, a young man touched by divine inspiration, senses something amiss. He isn't swayed by their respected status. "Separate the witnesses," he declares, "each from the other. I will question each man individually." It’s a bold move, challenging the established order.

Why did he do that? What did he suspect?

As soon as they are parted, Daniel calls forth the first elder. He confronts him, saying, "The elder in days and in crimes now will lay his hands on your head." A striking accusation! And then, Daniel lays bare the elder's sin: "You have judged unfairly, justifying the wicked and condemning the righteous, even though God has said, 'Do not kill the innocent and the righteous.'"

Strong words, aren't they?

Daniel doesn't just accuse. He invokes divine law, reminding the elder of the fundamental principle of justice: protecting the innocent. It's a powerful moment, a young man standing up against corruption, armed only with his faith and his sharp intellect.

What’s so compelling here is the courage of Daniel. He doesn't flinch in the face of authority. He trusts his intuition, his sense of right and wrong, and he dares to challenge the status quo. It reminds us that true justice isn't about age or position, but about integrity and a commitment to truth. It’s a message that resonates just as powerfully today as it did then.

Full source
The Book of Susanna 1:50The Book of Susanna

The Book of Susanna turns to Susanna Falsely Accused by Two Lustful Elders.

The scene is stark. Susanna is confronted, the elders point their fingers, and the community, swayed by their status and seemingly credible testimony, is ready to condemn her. They press her, demanding to know the identity of her supposed lover. "Who is the young man?" they demand. But Susanna, innocent and resolute, refuses to answer. Why? Because any answer she gives would only further entangle her in their lies. Silence becomes her only defense, a desperate act of defiance against a rigged system.

Here's the gut punch: "The people believed in the words of the elders, and the judges judged her with the death penalty." Condemned to die, based on fabricated evidence, fueled by malice. The weight of that injustice is crushing. It’s a stark reminder of how easily truth can be twisted, how readily power can be abused.

Even in the face of death, Susanna doesn't break. She turns to the only source of true justice: God. Her prayer, a desperate cry from the depths of her soul, is the emotional core of the story. "Adonoy Our lord," she cries out, using the Hebrew name for God, "all mysteries and hidden things are revealed to you; You know them before they come to be." It's a recognition that earthly justice has failed, that only divine intervention can save her.

Susanna continues, "You also know there is no truth in their mouths, and that they testify falsely against me." She lays bare the elders' deception, appealing to God's omniscience. It's a powerful statement of faith, a refusal to be silenced by the lies that surround her.

And then, the heartbreaking resignation: "And now behold, I am going to die, though I have done nothing that these wicked men have charged me within their malicious hearts." She knows the earthly verdict. She accepts the impending doom, not as an admission of guilt, but as a evidence of the injustice she faces. It's a moment of profound sorrow, a chilling reminder of the vulnerability of the innocent in the face of corruption.

What would you do? How would you react, facing such overwhelming injustice? Susanna's story, even in this moment of despair, is a evidence of the power of faith, the importance of truth, and the enduring human spirit that refuses to be broken, even in the face of death. The story is far from over, but this moment of raw emotion sets the stage for the divine intervention that is to come. Hold that feeling, that tension. We'll need it as the story unfolds.

Full source