But Jewish tradition, in its beautiful, often paradoxical way, has some fascinating answers.
Let's dive into Bereshit Rabbah, one of the oldest and most important commentaries on the Book of Genesis. Specifically, we're looking at section 9, which wrestles with the phrase, "And behold, it was very good" (Genesis 1:31), said after God completes creation.
Rabbi Shimon ben Elazar poses a fascinating question. He says that "And behold it was very good" — and behold, sleep is good. But then he stops us right there. Wait a minute, is sleep really "very good?" He answers with another question, a rhetorical one: Didn’t we learn in the Mishnah (Sanhedrin 5:5) that "Wine and sleep are beneficial for them [the wicked] and beneficial for the whole world?"
Think about it. Sleep? Beneficial to the wicked? It seems counterintuitive, doesn't it? But the Rabbi isn't finished. He explains that even a little bit of sleep allows a person to wake up refreshed and toil extensively in Torah. So, sleep isn't just about rest; it's about fueling our spiritual work. It's a tool for something greater.
But here's where it gets really interesting. Rabbi Naḥman bar Shmuel bar Naḥman, quoting Rav Shmuel bar Naḥman, takes us in an even more unexpected direction. He says that "Behold it was very good" refers to both the good inclination – the yetzer hatov – and the evil inclination – the yetzer hara.
Hold on. Did we just hear that right? The evil inclination is "very good?" How can that be? Again, it's a rhetorical question.
The answer is profound. Were it not for the yetzer hara, a person would never build a house, never marry, never have children, never engage in commerce! It’s that drive, that ambition, that sometimes pushes us in the wrong direction, but also fuels our desire to create, to build, to connect, to live.
Think about it. What motivates us to achieve, to strive, to leave our mark on the world? Often, it's a desire for something, a lack that we feel, an ambition that burns within us. And that, in its rawest form, is the yetzer hara.
As King Solomon wisely observed in Ecclesiastes 4:4, "[And I have considered all toil and all excelling in work,] that it is each man’s envy of his counterpart." In other words, competition, the desire to outdo others – even that has a place in the grand scheme of things.
So, what does this all mean? It means that even the things that seem negative, the things that challenge us, the things that we might even consider "evil," can ultimately contribute to the "very good" of creation. Sleep, and even the yetzer hara, serve a purpose. They are part of the intricate, beautiful, and sometimes baffling tapestry of existence.
Perhaps the key isn’t to eliminate the yetzer hara, but to channel it, to refine it, to use its energy for good. To recognize that even our flaws, our desires, and our ambitions can be tools for growth and creation. It's a challenging thought, but one that offers a powerful perspective on the complexities of being human. And isn't that what Jewish wisdom is all about?