“Whose [heart] is snares and nets” – as she traps in the sea and on dry land. “Her hands, shackles,” Rabbi Elazar said: Had he not written in her regard: “Her hands, shackles,” she would seize a man in the marketplace and say: ‘Have relations with me.’141The midrash interprets the verse to mean that the woman’s hands are shackled, meaning that she is too inhibited to demand relations outright. Instead, her “heart is snares and nets” – in her heart she desires relations, and she finds ways to entice men.
This is analogous to a biting dog whose owner holds it on a chain; even though it is tied, it would grasp onto a person in the marketplace by his clothes. So, had he not written in her regard: “Her hands, shackles,” she would abduct a person in the marketplace. See what is written: “She seized him by his garments, saying: Lie with me” (Genesis 39:12). “One who is good before God will escape from her” – this is Joseph; “but the sinner will be captured by her” – this is Potifar.
Alternatively, “good” – this is Pinḥas, “but the sinner” – this is Zimri. Alternatively, “good” – this is Palti, “but the sinner” – this is Amnon. Rabbi Isi of Caesarea interpreted the verse regarding heresy. “Good” – this is Rabbi Elazar, “but a sinner” – this is Yaakov of the village of Nevurya.142He was a heretic.
Alternatively, “good” – this is Elazar ben Dama, “but a sinner” – this is Yaakov of the village of Sama.143See Kohelet Rabba 1:8 for a story pertaining to Elazar ben Dama and Yaakov of Sikhanya, who some commentaries equate with the Yaakov of Sama mentioned here. The midrash there also mentions the other individuals identified here as good or as heretics. Alternatively, “good” – this is Ḥananya, son of Rabbi Yehoshua’s brother, “but a sinner” – these are the residents of the village of Naḥum.144These heretics employed sorcery to apprehend Ḥananya, but Rabbi Yehoshua rescued him; see Kohelet Rabba 1:8.
Alternatively, “good” – this is Yehuda ben Nekosa, “but a sinner” – these are the heretics. Alternatively, “good” – this is Rabbi Natan, “but a sinner” – this is his disciple.145He went and joined the heretics. Alternatively, “good” – this is Rabbi Eliezer and Rabbi Yehoshua, “but a sinner” – this is Elisha.146Elisha ben Avuya, who ultimately adopted a sinful path.