Whose Honor Is a Eulogy, the Living or the Dead

Yalkut Shimoni on Torah 102:12

"And Abraham came to mourn for Sarah and to weep for her" (Genesis 23:2). They inquired: Is a eulogy an honor due to the living [the surviving relatives] or an honor due to the dead? What practical difference does it make? It makes a difference for one who said, "Do not eulogize that man [me]"; or, alternatively, to exclude the heirs [from the cost], what is the ruling? Come and hear: "And Abraham came to mourn for Sarah." If you say it is on account of the honor of the living, would Abraham have left Sarah unburied [merely] for the sake of Abraham's own honor? Sarah herself was content, since through it Abraham would be honored. Come and hear: Rabbi Natan says, it is a good sign for the dead that punishment is exacted from him after death: a corpse that was not eulogized and not buried, or that a wild beast dragged off, or upon whose bier the rains were dripping. Learn from this that it is an honor due to the dead. Learn from this.

Themes