4 min read

When God Brought Down Nimrod and Raised Up Abraham

God reverses four trees in one verse. Pirkei DeRabbi Eliezer reads them as Nimrod cast down, Abraham lifted, Sarah dried and made to flower again.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. Four Reversals in One Verse
  2. The High Tree Falls
  3. The Low Tree Rises
  4. The Green Tree Dries
  5. The Dry Tree Blooms

Four Reversals in One Verse

The verse from Ezekiel speaks to Babylon about Babylon. All the trees of the field shall know that I the Lord have brought down the high tree, have exalted the low tree, have dried up the green tree, and have made the dry tree to flourish. Four movements. Four reversals. The plain meaning addresses the cedar of Lebanon and the political fortunes of kingdoms competing for dominance in Ezekiel's age.

Pirkei DeRabbi Eliezer, the narrative midrash from eighth-century Palestine, does not hear Ezekiel speaking about cedars. It hears four moments from the beginning of the world, four specific people whose fates were set in motion when the God of Israel chose to overturn the visible order of earthly power.

The High Tree Falls

The high tree is Nimrod. He appears in Genesis as the first mighty man on earth, a hunter before the Lord, founder of Babylon and Nineveh, the builder of the earliest empire. Tradition assigned him the Tower of Babel, the monument to human ambition aimed at Heaven. Nimrod is the original figure of earthly power achieved without reference to the God of Israel, power that acknowledges no authority above itself, power that looks up and decides to compete.

He held that position at the summit of human dominance. He commanded armies and cities and labor and the allegiance of nations. Then God brought the high tree down. The tower failed. The languages were scattered. The empire that was supposed to reach Heaven discovered that Heaven had moved beyond reach.

The Low Tree Rises

The low tree is Abraham. One man, born inside the civilization that Nimrod built, raised in Ur of the Chaldeans, the heartland of the empire that reached for Heaven and fell. Abraham smashes his father's idols. He refuses the logic of the world he was born into. Nimrod throws him into a furnace. Abraham walks out alive.

That confrontation between the highest tree and the lowest is the exact reversal the verse describes. Nimrod is at the summit when God brings him down. Abraham is a single man from a family of idol-makers when God exalts him. The measure of the reversal is the distance between where they started and where they ended. Nimrod built empires. Abraham walked from city to city with a tent and a promise, and the promise outlasted every stone the empires laid.

The Green Tree Dries

The green tree is Sarah. She is alive, capable, at the height of her powers when Abraham enters Egypt and asks her to say she is his sister. She does it to protect him. The tradition sees in this the drying of a flourishing life, the compression of a woman's freedom and safety into the necessity of a husband's survival. She passes through Pharaoh's house, through Abimelech's court, through situations no one designed for her flourishing, and the green tree is scorched by what she had to endure.

The Dry Tree Blooms

The dry tree is Sarah too, or rather Sarah at ninety, the woman who laughs when she hears the angels' promise because the laugh is the only honest response available to her. She is dry in the way the tradition uses that word: past bearing, past the ordinary possibility of new life. And God makes the dry tree flower. Isaac is born.

The four reversals form a single story. The empire that could not be stopped is stopped. The nobody from Ur becomes the father of nations. The woman who gave up safety to save her husband is given back her body's promise. The same verse in Ezekiel, the rabbis argued, held all of it because God's reversals are not scattered events. They are a pattern, legible once you know where to look.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

2 sources

The texts this telling draws on, in full. Open a card to read inline, or expand it for a wider, quieter read.

Pirkei DeRabbi Eliezer 52:3Pirkei DeRabbi Eliezer

Our tradition wrestles with this too, offering some pretty powerful imagery to explain it.

Consider this from Pirkei DeRabbi Eliezer, a fascinating early medieval text filled with stories and interpretations of the Torah. It zeroes in on a verse, (Ezekiel 17:24): "All the trees of the field shall know that I the Lord have brought down the high tree, have exalted the low tree, have dried up the green tree, and have made the dry tree to flourish.”

What does it all mean?

The text doesn’t leave us hanging. It sees those “trees of the field” as representing the nations of the world. Okay, so far so good. But who are these specific trees? Well, the “high tree” that God brings down? That’s Nimrod.

Nimrod, as you might recall, was a mighty hunter, a king who, according to tradition, led the building of the Tower of Babel – a symbol of humanity's arrogance and attempt to reach God. He represents the height of earthly power, a power ultimately humbled.

And who is the “low tree” that God exalts? Abraham, our father. Abraham starts as one man, almost insignificant in the vast landscape of the ancient world. Yet, through his faith and his covenant with God, he becomes the patriarch of a nation, a beacon of monotheism, and an enduring symbol of spiritual strength. The ultimate underdog story. But the imagery doesn't stop there. What about the drying up of the "green tree" and the flourishing of the "dry tree"? Pirkei DeRabbi Eliezer interprets the "green tree" as the breasts of the wives of the nations. A slightly strange image, perhaps, but stick with me. It's about to get interesting.

The "dry tree" that flourishes? That’s Sarah.

Specifically, Sarah's breasts.

Now, we know Sarah's story. She was barren for many years, considered past the age of childbearing. Yet, God miraculously granted her a child, Isaac, in her old age. Her ability to nurse Isaac becomes a symbol of divine favor and a evidence of the impossible becoming possible.

But the story goes even further! Pirkei DeRabbi Eliezer adds a remarkable detail: the other women of the world brought their children to Sarah to be nursed! "For Sarah gave suck to all their children in peace," the text says, referencing (Genesis 21:7), "'Who would have said unto Abraham, that Sarah should give children suck?'"

What a powerful image! Sarah, the once barren woman, now nourishes not only her own child but the children of others. It speaks to a universality, a sense of shared humanity, and the transformative power of faith. It's almost a vision of redemption, where even the most unlikely source can provide sustenance and blessing to all.

So, what can we take away from this? Maybe it's a reminder that power isn't always what it seems. That true strength can arise from unexpected places. That even in times of upheaval and change, there's a deeper pattern at play. A divine hand, perhaps, shaping the world in ways we can only begin to understand.

Full source
Legends of the Jews 5:49Legends of the Jews

The story of Abraham offers a powerful lesson on this very topic. It's not just about being righteous, but about doing righteous deeds, about actively choosing faith even when it's difficult. Abraham lived in a world steeped in idolatry. King Nimrod, a figure often depicted as a tyrannical ruler, held sway. You might expect the truly righteous to stand up and be counted. But according to the Legends of the Jews, as retold by Ginzberg, that wasn't quite the case.

It first appears that the pious figures of the time, like Noah, Shem, Eber, and Asshur, would be natural allies in Abraham's quest to spread the belief in one God. But the tradition paints a slightly different picture. Noah, fresh off the Ark, seemed more interested in the pleasures of his vineyard than in spreading the word. Can you blame him? Maybe. But it does show us something about human nature.

Shem and Eber? They kept to themselves, hiding away. As for Asshur, he threw up his hands and essentially said, "I can't deal with these sinners!" and left the land.

So what set Abraham apart? Why is he considered such a pivotal figure in Jewish tradition?

It wasn't just that he was righteous, but that he chose to be. While others retreated or indulged, Abraham stood firm. He declared, "I will not forsake God." This unwavering dedication, this active choice to embrace faith, is what made him exceptional. The text emphasizes that even when his own parents weren't aligned with his beliefs, he didn't falter.

This reminds us that faith isn't passive. It's not enough to simply believe. It requires action, courage, and a willingness to stand up for what you believe in, even when it's unpopular or challenging. Abraham's story is a evidence of the power of individual conviction and the importance of actively choosing faith, day after day. It’s a powerful reminder that true faith isn’t just something you inherit; it's something you actively cultivate and live out in the world.

Full source