5 min read

Jethro Returned the Idols and Was Cast Out of Midian

Jethro had been the chief idol priest of Midian. Then he gave the idols back and said nothing about why. The city placed him under a ban.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. The Priest Who Could Not Continue
  2. Life Under the Ban
  3. The Egyptian at the Well
  4. The Priest Who Had Heard Everything

The Priest Who Could Not Continue

Jethro had spent his life in the service of the Midianite gods. He was the chief priest of the city, the man who stood before the idols and performed the sacred rites, the one the community turned to for intercession, blessing, and the maintenance of the divine order as they understood it. He knew the rituals precisely and had performed them for years without doubt.

Then he looked at what he was doing and could not do it anymore.

He did not make a dramatic announcement. He went before the townspeople and told them he had grown too old for the duties of the priesthood. He gathered up all the paraphernalia of idol worship, the implements and vessels and sacred objects, and returned them to the community. He told them to appoint whoever they thought best to take his position. He said nothing about why he was leaving. He offered no theological argument and no public declaration. He had arrived at his conviction quietly and he left his post quietly, and the silence around his reasons only made the people more suspicious.

Life Under the Ban

They placed him under the ban. In the ancient Near East this was a severe social execution: no one was permitted to perform Jethro the slightest service. The shepherds of Midian would not pasture his flocks. No neighbor would speak to him on the road. His seven daughters had to manage everything themselves, including the work of watering the animals, which meant going daily to the well and filling the troughs. Even there they were not safe. The male shepherds drove them away from the troughs they had filled and watered their own flocks with the water the women had drawn.

This had been going on long enough that it had become routine. The daughters knew to expect it. They did not expect Moses.

The Egyptian at the Well

The day Moses arrived at the well in Midian, the shepherds went further than usual. They drove the women away from the troughs and threw them into the water with intent to drown them. Moses pulled them out, drove the shepherds off, and helped the women water their flocks himself. The daughters came home early, and their father asked why they were back before their usual time. They told him an Egyptian man had rescued them and drawn water for them. Jethro asked: where is he? Why did you leave him there? Go bring him and give him bread.

Moses came to the house and stayed. He stayed for years. He married Zipporah, Jethro's eldest daughter, and tended Jethro's flocks, and Jethro was restored to something like a functioning household through the presence of the man who would later lead an entire people out of slavery. The ban was a kind of preparation: it created the isolation and need that made Jethro's household the right place for Moses to land.

The Priest Who Had Heard Everything

There is another element to Jethro's history that explains why his conversion from idolatry to the knowledge of God was more than incidental. He had been a counselor of Pharaoh, one of the three advisors in the royal court alongside Balaam and Job. When Pharaoh first consulted about what to do with the multiplying Hebrews, Jethro was in the room. Balaam said to oppress them. Job kept silent. Jethro spoke up for the Hebrews, argued against the oppression, and was banished from Egypt for it.

He had earned his exile from Midian by rejecting idols and his earlier exile from Egypt by protecting the enslaved. Both rejections preceded Moses. Jethro arrived at the position of the man worthy to receive Israel's lawgiver as a son-in-law through a series of costly separations, each one isolating him further from the systems of power around him and placing him in the desert margin where Moses, when he ran, would finally find him.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

2 sources

The texts this telling draws on, in full. Open a card to read inline, or expand it for a wider, quieter read.

Legends of the Jews, IV. Moses In Egypt, JethroLegends of the Jews

Legends of the Jews (Ginzberg) turns to Jethro.

In Ginzberg's retelling in, Legends of the Jews, Jethro lived for many years in the city of Midian – a place named for a son of Abraham and Keturah. There, he served as a priest to idols. But something wasn't sitting right with him. He became increasingly convinced of the futility – the hevel, the emptiness – of idol worship. It became repugnant to him.

So, Jethro decided to resign. He stood before his townsmen and basically said, "Look, I'm getting too old for this. You choose someone else to take my place." He handed over all the paraphernalia of idol worship and told them to give it to his successor. But they suspected his motives. They figured he was up to something, and they weren't happy about it. As a result, the people put him under a ban. Nobody was allowed to help him in any way. Even the shepherds wouldn't pasture his flocks. He was on his own. The only option was to put his seven daughters in charge of the work.

This transformation from idolatrous priest to God-fearing man is reflected in Jethro's many names. It's fascinating! He was called Jether, because, the tradition says, the Torah contains an "additional" section about him. He was called Jethro because he "overflowed" with good deeds. He was also known as Hobab, "the beloved son of God"; Reuel, "the friend of God"; Heber, "the associate of God"; Putiel, "he that hath renounced idolatry"; and Keni, he that was "zealous" for God and "acquired" the Torah. Quite the resume. The story goes that because of the town's hostility, Jethro's daughters had to arrive at the watering troughs early, before the other shepherds. But even that didn't always work. The shepherds would often drive them away and water their own flocks using the water the young women had drawn.

Enter Moses. When he arrived in Midian, he stopped at the well. And what happened there? Well, his experience mirrored that of Isaac and Jacob. Like them, he found his future helpmeet at a well. Remember, Rebekah was chosen as Isaac's wife while she was drawing water. Jacob first saw Rachel while she was watering her sheep. And at this well in Midian, Moses met his future wife, Zipporah.

But the shepherds' rudeness reached a new level on the very day Moses arrived. First, they stole the water the daughters had drawn and then, unbelievably, they tried to do violence to them, even throwing them into the well with the intent to kill them!

That’s when Moses stepped in. He rescued the maidens from the water and watered the flocks – first Jethro's, then the shepherds', even though they didn't deserve it. True, it wasn't much trouble for him. He only had to draw one bucketful, and the water flowed so abundantly that it sufficed for all the herds. And it didn't stop flowing until Moses left the well. This, according to tradition, was the same well where Jacob met Rachel, and the same well God created at the beginning of the world, revealing its opening on the twilight of the first Sabbath eve. Incredible, isn't it?

When Jethro's daughters thanked Moses for his help, he brushed it off, saying, "You should be thanking the Egyptian I killed. If it weren't for him, I wouldn't be here now."

So, what do we take away from the story of Jethro? Perhaps it’s a reminder that even those who seem to be on the wrong path can turn towards good. That even a priest of idols can become a man of God. And sometimes, all it takes is a little kindness at a well to change the course of history.

Full source
Legends of the Jews 4:29Legends of the Jews

It’s a scene ripe with drama, intrigue, and conflicting advice.

The story begins, as many of the best stories do, with a betrayal. Jethro, also known as Reuel, later to become Moses' father-in-law, dared to speak out against Pharaoh’s growing hostility towards the Hebrews. That Pharaoh was "exceedingly wroth with him," and Jethro was promptly dismissed from his position in disgrace, forced to flee to Midian. Ouch. Imagine the courage it took to stand up to a king, especially one as powerful as Pharaoh!

Left without Jethro's counsel, Pharaoh turned to other advisors, seeking their opinions on how to deal with the growing "problem" of the Hebrew population. First up was Job. Yes, that Job, the one of immense suffering and unwavering faith. And what was his advice? Well, not much, actually. As the text recounts, Job essentially washed his hands of the situation, saying, "Behold, all the inhabitants of the land are in thy power. Let the king do as seemeth good in his eyes." It's a bit disappointing, isn't it? Especially coming from someone known for his moral fortitude.

Finally, Pharaoh called upon Balaam. Balaam, a fascinating and complex figure, was a non-Israelite prophet known for his powerful blessings and curses (Numbers 22-24). Now, Balaam's advice is where things get really interesting. According to Ginzberg's retelling in Legends of the Jews, Balaam essentially warned Pharaoh that any attempt to destroy the Hebrews through methods that had challenged their forefathers would fail. "From all that the king may devise against the Hebrews, they will be delivered," Balaam declared.

He reminded Pharaoh that the Hebrews’ God had saved Abraham from the fiery furnace, as we see in the Book of Genesis and elaborated upon in various Midrashic (rabbinic interpretive commentary) traditions. "If thou thinkest to diminish them by the flaming fire, thou wilt not prevail over them, for their God delivered Abraham their father from the furnace." He further pointed out that Isaac had been spared from sacrifice, referencing the binding of Isaac (Akeidah) in Genesis 22. "Perhaps thou thinkest to destroy them with a sword, but their father Isaac was delivered from being slaughtered by the sword.” And, he added, even the back-breaking labor that Jacob endured while working for Laban couldn't break the Hebrews. "And if thou thinkest to reduce them through hard and rigorous labor, thou wilt also not prevail, for their father Jacob served Laban in all manner of hard work, and yet he prospered.”

So, what WAS Balaam's advice? His suggestion was chilling: target the newborn male children by throwing them into the Nile. "If it please the king, let him order all the male children that shall be born in Israel from this day forward to be thrown into the water. Thereby canst thou wipe out their name, for neither any of them nor any of their fathers was tried in this way.”

This was a tactic that hadn’t been used before, a way to circumvent the protective hand that had guided the patriarchs. A truly horrific suggestion! It’s a stark reminder of the depths of cruelty to which fear and prejudice can lead. We read in (Exodus 1:22), "Then Pharaoh commanded all his people, ‘Every boy that is born to the Hebrews you shall throw into the Nile, but you shall let every girl live.’"

What's so fascinating about this whole episode is the way it highlights the power of memory and the weight of history. Pharaoh and his advisors weren't just dealing with a present-day population; they were confronting a people deeply connected to their past, a past filled with divine interventions and miraculous escapes. Did Pharaoh truly believe he could outsmart the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob? Maybe. Or perhaps he was simply blinded by fear and a desperate desire to maintain control. It makes you wonder: what "advice" are we listening to today that might lead us down a similarly dark path?

Full source