She wasn't done. This time, she wanted her story, the story of her courage and her people’s deliverance, enshrined within the Holy Scriptures.
But the sages hesitated. Big time. Adding to the Tanakh, the Jewish Bible, which is traditionally divided into the Torah (the Five Books of Moses), Nevi'im (the Prophets), and Ketuvim (the Writings or Hagiographa)? It was a monumental decision. A big deal. They were reluctant, to say the least. They had already established a "triple Canon," and changing it wasn't taken lightly.
But Esther, she was persuasive. She knew what she was doing. The text tells us that they refused her… again. But she persevered. She quoted from Exodus 17:14, "'Write this for a memorial in a book,' spoken by Moses to Joshua, after the battle of Rephidim with the Amalekites." See, Haman, the villain of the Purim story, was considered a descendant of Amalek. Esther cleverly argued that just as Moses was commanded to record the victory over Amalek, so too should her victory over the "Amalekite" Haman be memorialized.
The sages, as the story goes, began to see the bigger picture. It wasn't just about adding another book. It was about recognizing the ongoing battle between good and evil, between the Jewish people and those who sought their destruction. It was, in essence, about acknowledging God's hand in history.
And, according to the tradition, there was something more to it than just historical accuracy. The sages realized that the Book of Esther was no ordinary historical account. As the text tells us, it couldn't have been composed without divine inspiration, without a touch of the Ruach Hakodesh, the holy spirit.
The final decision, the canonization of the Book of Esther, was "resolved upon 'below'" – meaning agreed upon by the earthly sages – and then, crucially, "endorsed 'above.'" A heavenly seal of approval! And this is according to Legends of the Jews!
The implications are profound. Because the Book of Esther became an integral and indestructible part of the Holy Scriptures, the Feast of Purim, the holiday celebrating the events in the book, is destined to be celebrated forever. Not just now, but in the future world as well. Esther, through her courage and her righteous actions, earned herself a good name, not only in this world, but in the world to come.
So, what does this all mean for us today? Perhaps it's a reminder that even seemingly small acts of courage and faith can have lasting consequences. Perhaps it's a call to recognize the divine hand at work in our own lives, even when we don't see it clearly. And perhaps, most importantly, it's a testament to the enduring power of a good story, especially one that's been endorsed both here and in the heavens.