We all do sometimes. But maybe... maybe we should think twice before we do.
The Pesikta DeRav Kahana, a collection of rabbinic teachings for special Sabbaths and festivals, dives into this very human tendency. It all starts with a verse from Eicha (Lamentations) 3:39: "Why should a living man complain? A man for his sins."
R’ Aba bar Yodan puts it bluntly: "What is it that a person complains about while he is still alive? It is enough that he lives!" Just being alive is a gift.
R’ Berachia adds a touch of dark humor: "I lived next to you, he lives and complains." We all know that neighbor. The one who always finds something to grumble about, no matter how good things are.
But R’ Levi gets to the heart of the matter. Why complain to the Life-giver of the worlds? Instead, he suggests, "If one wants to complain, let him complain of his sins." It’s a powerful idea – focusing on self-improvement rather than external grievances. R’ Yodan echoes this, urging us to "stand up like a man and confess his sins, and not complain." Take responsibility. Own your actions.
Then Rebbe (often referring to Rabbi Judah the Prince, compiler of the Mishnah) delivers a zinger, attributing a statement to the Holy One: "Malcontents, the children of malcontents they are!" Ouch.
And then comes a series of examples, each more pointed than the last. Think of them as cautionary tales.
First, Adam. God, in His infinite wisdom, "busied Himself with finding Adam a companion… 'I will make him a helpmate opposite him.'" (Genesis 2:18). But what does Adam do? He complains, "The woman whom You gave [to be] with me, she gave me…" (Genesis 3:12). He blames God and Eve!
Next up, Jacob. God makes it His "business to make his son king in Egypt," as we see in Genesis 42:6: "Now Joseph was the ruler over the land…" Yet, Jacob complains, "...My way has been hidden from the Lord..." (Isaiah 40:27). Seriously?
Even Jacob's sons aren't spared. In the wilderness, God chooses "out for them refined food, like that which kings eat, in order that none of them would have indigestion or be seized with diarrhea." Sounds pretty good. But they complain, "...we are disgusted with this rotten bread" (Numbers 21:5). The manna, the miraculous food from heaven, is now "rotten bread."
Finally, Zion. God busies Himself "with her to remove the kingdoms from the world… have I not already removed Bavel, Maday and Greece and in the future will remove this wicked kingdom?" (referring to Rome). Despite all this, Zion complains, "The Lord has forsaken me, and the Lord has forgotten me" (Isaiah 49:14).
What's the takeaway here?
These examples, drawn from our most foundational stories, paint a clear picture: ingratitude is a recurring theme. We, as humans, are prone to complaining, even when we are surrounded by blessings. As Ginzberg retells these stories in Legends of the Jews, we see this tendency played out across generations.
So, the next time you feel the urge to complain, maybe take a moment to pause. Is it really that bad? Are you focusing on what you lack, rather than what you have? Could you, perhaps, find something to be grateful for instead? Maybe, just maybe, that shift in perspective is all it takes to turn a complaint into a blessing.