The Goring Ox and Liability for Children and Converts Alike

Yalkut Shimoni on Torah 341:2

Curated by Arthur·Told by Maggid·

"Whether it gores a son or gores a daughter" and so forth (Exodus 21:31), why is this said? Because it says, "and it killed a man or a woman" (Exodus 21:29), I would know only of adults; from where do I derive minors? Scripture teaches, saying, "whether it gores a son or gores a daughter." I would know only a fully developed son or daughter; from where do I derive one of indeterminate sex and a hermaphrodite? Scripture teaches, saying, "whether it gores a son" and so forth. I would know only the son or daughter of another; from where do I derive his own son or daughter? Scripture teaches, saying, "according to this judgment it shall be done to him." I would know only an Israelite; from where do I derive converts? Scripture teaches, saying, "according to this judgment it shall be done to him."

Themes

LawJusticeCommandments

Continue Reading

Yalkut Shimoni on TorahRabbi Akiva on Whether a Woman's Damages Pass to Her HeirsWhen the verse says the ox killed "a man or a woman," Rabbi Akiva asks what new teaching the word "woman" adds, since liability for harming a woman was already Yalkut Shimoni on TorahWhy Eye for Eye Means Payment and Not MutilationFew verses have been twisted by outsiders more than an eye for an eye. The sages refuse to read it as butchery. When one person injures another, they teach, theYalkut Shimoni on TorahGoring Children Like Adults and the Tame and Forewarned OxThe sages work out how far an owner's liability reaches when his ox gores. The starting question is whether the law treats a child's death like an adult's. LogiYalkut Shimoni on TorahThe Fixed Thirty Shekels When an Ox Gores a SlaveWhen a dangerous ox kills a free person, the owner pays the victim's assessed worth. A slave was technically covered by that same general law. Yet the Torah pulYalkut Shimoni on TorahWhen the Ox Is Not Stoned the Owner Owes No Thirty ShekelsResh Lakish reads the verse as a tightly linked pair. The owner gives thirty shekels to the slave's master, and the ox is stoned. He insists these two consequenMekhilta DeRabbi YishmaelWhy Does the Torah Specify You and Your Sons at AllThe Mekhilta, the tannaitic midrash on Exodus dating to the 2nd century CE, zeroes in on a single phrase from the Passover laws to clarify exactly who was oblig