4 min read

How Sodom Built the Laws That Condemned It

The sin of Sodom was not one catastrophic crime. It was a system, built law by law, that turned cruelty into civic procedure and punished any act of kindness.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. The Four Judges and Their Names
  2. The Bed Law and the Money Law
  3. What Happened to Kindness
  4. Three Angels at the Tent Door

The Four Judges and Their Names

Sodom did not fall because of one violent act. It fell because cruelty had learned to write laws.

Four judges administered four cities of the Jordan plain: Serak, Sharkad, Zabnac, and Menon. They managed a court system so internally consistent, so precisely architected to achieve the opposite of justice, that a victim brought before it could barely argue against the verdict on its own terms. Eliezer, Abraham's servant, encountered this system personally. He renamed each judge. Shakra: Liar. Shakrura: Habitual Liar. Kezobim: Fabricator. Matzlodin: Perverter of Justice. He had met them. He knew.

The Bed Law and the Money Law

The bed law was this: if a stranger came to the city, the judges had beds installed in the public square. The stranger was brought to a bed and measured against it. Too short -- six men stretched him until he reached the bed's length or the gates of death. Too long -- the sides of the bed were folded in. Either way, when he cried out in agony, the judges replied with the same words: this is what we do to those who come into our land. Word spread. Strangers stopped coming.

The money law was more elegant. If a poor man arrived in Sodom, every resident gave him silver or gold, generously, with a flourish, until the man felt he had stumbled into a city of abundance. Each coin was marked with the giver's name. Then a proclamation went out: sell this man nothing. No bread. No water. When he died of starvation, his benefactors returned and retrieved their marked coins. If the dead man still had clothes worth disputing, the citizens fought over those too.

What Happened to Kindness

The Ginzberg tradition, drawing on the Book of Jasher's careful inventory of Sodom's legal innovations, preserves the fate of anyone who showed mercy. A girl in the city of Admah, daughter of a wealthy man, gave bread and water to a traveling stranger. The townspeople found out. They brought her before the judge. She was condemned to death. The execution method was designed to be visible and slow -- coated in honey and left in the sun at the city wall -- so that every resident would understand what generosity cost. After she died, the tradition records that her cry ascended to heaven and God descended to see for himself.

This is the architecture of the city's doom: not a single crime but a system perfected over generations, removing every instinct toward the stranger until the removal became structural, became law, became the definition of what it meant to belong to the community.

Three Angels at the Tent Door

When three angels arrived at Abraham's tent at the oaks of Mamre, they came to announce Sarah's pregnancy and to descend toward Sodom and see whether it was truly as described in the outcry that had reached heaven. Abraham rose from his tent door in the heat of the day to greet them. He had ten words for the three strangers who arrived: what can I bring you, sit under the tree, rest, let me bring bread. This was the precise opposite of Sodom's greeting.

The contrast is structural. The Midrash does not state it explicitly because it does not need to. The hospitality scene at Mamre and the destination of the angels afterward are placed in sequence, and the sequence does the work.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

4 sources

The texts this telling draws on, in full. Open a card to read inline, or expand it for a wider, quieter read.

Jasher 19Book of Jasher

The familiar story centers on their destruction, but the Book of Jasher, a non-canonical Jewish text that elaborates on stories from the Hebrew Bible, really paints a vivid picture. Chapter 19 gives us some truly disturbing details.

It starts with the judges of Sodom and Gomorrah – Serak, Sharkad, Zabnac, and Menon. Eliezer, Abraham's servant, apparently had a few choice nicknames for them, changing their names to Shakra, Shakrura, Kezobim, and Matzlodin – perhaps a satirical commentary on their wickedness.

The real horror begins with the beds. Yes, beds. The people of Sodom, driven by their judges, set up beds in the streets. And if a stranger happened to wander into town, they'd be forced onto these beds. Six men would measure the poor soul, and if he was too short, they’d stretch him until he screamed. Too tall? They’d hack off bits of him until he fit. “Thus shall it be done to a man that cometh into our land,” they’d say. Can you imagine?

The cruelty didn't stop there. They'd give a poor man silver and gold, but then forbid anyone from giving him food. The Book of Jasher tells us that if the stranger died of hunger, the townspeople would snatch back their coins and even fight over his clothes before dumping his body in the desert.

Eliezer himself witnessed this depravity firsthand when he visited Sodom to check on Lot. He saw a Sodomite stripping a poor man and, intervening, was promptly stoned in the forehead. The attacker then demanded payment for removing the "bad blood"! When Eliezer refused, he was dragged before Shakra (the judge), who sided with the attacker. Eliezer, in a moment of grim justice, then stoned the judge, arguing that he should now pay the attacker, since he was the one enforcing the twisted law.

It’s a brutal, eye-for-an-eye moment.

The story then shifts to Lot's daughter, Paltith. A poor man was starving to death in Sodom, just as described earlier in the chapter. Moved by compassion, Paltith secretly fed him bread, hiding it in her water pitcher. People were amazed at how this man survived for so long without food. They spied on her, caught her in the act, and, according to the Book of Jasher, burned her alive for the crime of showing kindness.

A similar fate befell a young woman in Admah. She gave a thirsty traveler bread and water, and for that act of hospitality, she was covered in honey and left to be stung to death by bees. The text makes it clear: "Her cries ascended to heaven."

It's no wonder, then, that the Lord was provoked. The Book of Jasher emphasizes that Sodom and its sister cities were not suffering. They had plenty, but they refused to share. As it says, "they had abundance of food, and had tranquility amongst them, and still would not sustain the poor and the needy." This lack of compassion, this active cruelty, made their sins "great before the Lord."

This brings us to the familiar story of the angels' arrival, Lot's hospitality, and the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah. Lot, his wife, and his daughters are warned to flee. But Lot’s wife, Ado, looks back. The Book of Jasher tells us it wasn’t out of mere curiosity, but because her compassion was moved for her daughters who remained in the city. And, as we know, she turned into a pillar of salt. A pillar of salt that, according to the Book of Jasher, was perpetually licked by oxen, only to regenerate each morning.

Lot and his two remaining daughters fled to a cave. Believing the world was destroyed, the daughters got their father drunk and slept with him. The resulting offspring were the ancestors of the Moabites and Ammonites. The firstborn called her son Moab, saying, "From my father did I conceive him." The younger also called her son Benami. It’s a disturbing conclusion to an already disturbing story.

Abraham, rising early the next morning, saw the smoke rising from the cities "like the smoke of a furnace."

So, what are we left with? The story of Sodom and Gomorrah isn't just about sexual sin, as it's often portrayed. The Book of Jasher highlights the utter lack of compassion, the institutionalized cruelty, and the horrific treatment of the vulnerable. It's a chilling reminder that a society's moral compass can become so twisted that even basic human kindness becomes a capital crime. And it leaves us to consider: what are the "Sodoms" of our own time, and what can we do to avoid repeating their mistakes?

Full source
Legends of the Jews 5:114Legends of the Jews

It’s closer than it first appears.

The scene: Sodom, ripe for the taking, its riches and food plundered by victorious armies. But amidst the spoils, they seize Lot, Abraham’s nephew, and with a boast, they reveal their true target: "We have taken the son of Abraham's brother captive!" It wasn't just about loot; it was about striking at Abraham himself. A direct attack, cloaked in the guise of war. Sneaky. And the timing! It was the first evening of Pesach (Passover), Passover, a night of sacred celebration. Abraham was partaking of the matzah, the unleavened bread, a symbol of freedom and remembrance. Then, boom, the archangel Michael arrives with news of Lot's capture.

This Michael.. he’s no ordinary angel. According to the legends, he bears another name: Palit, "the escaped." Why that name? Well, the story goes that when God cast Samael (the angel of death) and his rebellious host out of heaven, Samael, in a last-ditch effort, grabbed onto Michael, trying to drag him down too. Can you picture that? A celestial tug-of-war! Only through God's divine intervention did Michael manage to escape that fall.

So, there you have it. Abraham, celebrating Passover, suddenly faced with a threat to his family and a glimpse into the cosmic battle still raging. It just goes to show, doesn't it? Even in moments of peace and celebration, the echoes of conflict can reach us. And sometimes, those echoes carry the weight of heaven itself.

Full source
Jasher 18Book of Jasher

Book of Jasher turns to Three Angels Visit Abraham Before Sodom's Doom.

The tradition turns to the Book of Jasher. Now, this isn't part of the canonical Hebrew Bible, the Tanakh. It's considered a work of Jewish folklore and legend, a kind of midrashic (rabbinic interpretive commentary) expansion on biblical narratives.

Chapter 18 of Jasher dives into familiar territory. Remember how God commanded Abraham to circumcise himself and all the males in his household? Jasher elaborates: "And Abraham rose and did all that God had ordered him… And there was not one left whom he did not circumcise." Ishmael, Abraham's son, was thirteen at the time.

Then, on the third day after the circumcision, when Abraham was sitting at the door of his tent, recovering in the heat, God appeared to him in the plain of Mamre. Three angels, “ministering angels,” were sent to visit. Abraham, ever the hospitable host, rushed to greet them. He bowed, invited them in, offered them water to wash their feet, and placed them under a tree. He then ordered a calf to be prepared, and told Sarah to bake cakes. He brought them butter, milk, beef, and mutton, and they ate.

After the meal, one of the angels declared, "I will return to thee according to the time of life, and Sarah thy wife shall have a son.” This, of course, is the promise of Isaac's birth, a pivotal moment in the Abrahamic narrative.

But then, the story takes a dark turn.

The Book of Jasher abruptly shifts focus to the wickedness of Sodom and Gomorrah. We already know of the cities' impending doom, but here, we get a glimpse of the specific sins that warranted such divine judgment. "In those days all the people of Sodom and Gomorrah… were exceedingly wicked and sinful against the Lord… and their wickedness and crimes were in those days great before the Lord.”

The text paints a disturbing picture. Four times a year, the people would gather in a valley with springs and lush vegetation for festivals of "rejoicing." But these weren't innocent celebrations. During these gatherings, they would engage in widespread sexual immorality, with men taking each other's wives and daughters without protest. It's a stark depiction of moral decay.

And it gets worse.

The Book of Jasher details the Sodomites' abhorrent treatment of strangers. When a traveler came to their cities with goods to sell, the people would forcibly take his merchandise, giving him only a pittance in return. If the traveler complained, each person would claim to have taken only a small amount, mocking him. Then, they would drive him out of the city with noise and commotion.

The narrative then zooms in on one particularly unsettling incident. A traveler from Elam, passing through Sodom at sunset, found himself without lodging. A wicked man named Hedad offered him shelter, but with ulterior motives. He stole the traveler's fine mantle and cord. The next day, when the traveler asked for his possessions back, Hedad claimed he was interpreting a dream: the cord symbolized a long life, and the mantle, a fruitful vineyard. Hedad then demanded payment for his “interpretation.”

When the traveler protested, he was dragged before Serak, the judge of Sodom. But instead of justice, he encountered further corruption. The judge sided with Hedad, praising his supposed dream-interpreting skills. The traveler, distraught, was driven from the city, lamenting his experience in "the corrupt city of Sodom."

What’s striking about this account is the emphasis on the systemic nature of the evil in Sodom. It wasn't just a few bad apples; the entire society, from the ordinary citizens to the judge, was complicit in injustice and cruelty. The story of the traveler and Hedad, in particular, highlights the perversion of hospitality and the complete absence of moral compass.

As we reflect on this chapter from the Book of Jasher, we are left with a chilling reminder of the potential for societal corruption. It begs the question: what are the subtle ways injustice can become normalized within a community? And what responsibility do we have to challenge such norms, even when they are deeply entrenched?

Full source
Yalkut Shimoni on Torah 70:3Yalkut Shimoni on Torah

The men of Sodom have no share in the world to come, but they do stand in judgment, as it is said, "wicked and sinners" wicked in this world, and sinners in the world to come. Rabbi Nechemiah says: Neither these nor those stand in judgment, as it is said, "therefore the wicked shall not stand in judgment" (Psalms 1:5) this refers to the generation of the Flood "nor sinners in the assembly of the righteous" these are the men of Sodom. They said to him: They do not stand in the assembly of the righteous, but they do stand in the assembly of the wicked. Rabbi Yehuda says: "Wicked" with their bodies, and "sinners" with their money. "Wicked" with their bodies, as it is written, "and how can I do this great wickedness?" (Genesis 39:9). "Sinners" with their money, as it is written, "and it be a sin in you" (Deuteronomy 15:9). "Against the LORD" this is blasphemy of the Name. "Exceedingly" that they intend and sin deliberately. In a baraita it was taught: "Wicked" with their money, as it is written, "and your eye be evil against your needy brother" (Deuteronomy 15:9); "sinners" with their bodies, as it is written, "and I would sin against God" (Genesis 39:9); "against the LORD" this is blasphemy of the Name; "exceedingly" this is the shedding of blood, as it is said, "and Manasseh shed very much innocent blood" (2 Kings 21:16). Our Rabbis taught: The men of Sodom became arrogant only because of the goodness that the Holy One, blessed be He, lavished on them. For it is written, "a land out of which comes bread, and beneath it is turned up as it were fire; its stones are the place of sapphires, and it has dust of gold; a path no bird of prey knows" (Job 28:5-7). They said: Since bread comes out of our land, and gold-dust belongs to it, why do we need wayfarers, who come only to deplete us? Come, let us cause the law of the traveler's foot to be forgotten from our land, as it is said, "he breaks open a watercourse far from the inhabitant, places forgotten by the foot" (Job 28:4). They said: Whoever has one ox shall herd for one day; whoever has none shall herd for two days. A certain orphan, son of a widow, who had no ox, was given oxen to herd. He went, took them, and killed them. Whoever had an ox took one hide; whoever had none took two. Whoever crossed by the ferry paid one zuz; whoever crossed through the water paid two. A certain fuller came there once. They said to him: Give one zuz [for the ferry]. He said: I crossed through the water. They said: Then give two. He refused. They beat him. He came before the judge. The judge said: Pay them the fee for the bloodletting they did to you, and give two zuz for crossing through the water. Four judges were in Sodom: Liar, Awful-Liar, Forger, and Justice-Perverter. One who struck another man's wife and caused her to miscarry they would say to the husband, "Give her to him until she becomes pregnant for you again." One who cut off the ear of another's donkey they would say, "Give it to him until the ear grows back." One who wounded another they would say to the wounded man, "Pay him the fee for the bloodletting he did to you." Eliezer, Abraham's servant, happened to be there. They wounded him, and he came before the judge. The judge said, "Pay him the fee for the bloodletting he did you." Eliezer took a stone and wounded the judge, and said, "The fee that comes due to me from you, give it to that man, and let my own zuz stay where it is." They had a custom at a wedding feast. Eliezer came and sat at the very end of everyone. They said to him, "Who invited you here?" He said to the man beside him, "You did." That man took his cloak and fled. Eliezer sat beside the next, and said the same, until they all left, and he ate the whole feast. They had a bed on which they would lay travelers: if a man was too long, they would cut him down; if too short, they would stretch him. Eliezer happened there. They said, "Rise, lie on the bed." He said, "I made a vow from the day my mother Sarah died not to lie on a bed." When a poor man came among them, each one would give him a dinar with his name written on it, but no one would bring him bread, and when he died each one came and took back his own. There was a certain young woman who used to bring bread out to a poor man in her pitcher. After three days he had not died. They came and learned the matter, and they smeared her with honey and set her on the city wall, and hornets came and ate her. As it is said, "the outcry of Sodom and Gomorrah, because it is great" (Genesis 18:20). Rav Yehuda said in the name of Rav: on account of the young woman [riva]. And this is what is written, "I will go down now and see whether they have done according to its outcry" the outcry of this young woman.

Full source