5 min read

Isaiah Waited for the Messiah While Solomon Came Close

Solomon had peace, the Temple, and the name Jedidiah. Isaiah saw what the messianic age required. Neither man fully grasped what he held.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. The Name That Arrived Before Him
  2. The Silence of the Temple's Construction
  3. What Solomon Understood and Could Not Keep
  4. What Hezekiah Was Offered and Did Not Take

The Name That Arrived Before Him

Solomon was not yet named when Nathan the prophet came to David with a message from God. The child would be called Jedidiah: Beloved of God. The Legends of the Jews records that Solomon received six other names as well, each encoding a different dimension of his mission and his destiny. Peace defined his reign. Building defined his work. Wisdom defined his reputation. And the name God gave him at birth defined his potential: this was the king who was beloved, the one through whom the divine promise to David's line might finally arrive at its destination.

The rabbis read Isaiah alongside David's line. Isaiah's messianic chapters were composed in the shadow of the Assyrian crisis, in the period when Hezekiah was king and Jerusalem had just survived a siege. But the imagery Isaiah used, the prince of peace, the government on his shoulders, the reign of justice and righteousness that would have no end, reached back to Solomon as much as forward. Solomon's reign had looked like the opening act of that reordering. Every nation sent ambassadors. Every creature submitted. The Temple stood. The fire came down from heaven and the priests could not enter for the cloud of glory. For one moment, it all seemed to be arriving.

The Silence of the Temple's Construction

No iron tool was heard during the Temple's construction. This is the detail the tradition returns to, because it pointed toward something beyond the building itself. The messianic age is defined by the absence of instruments of war. Hammers, chisels, the tools of conquest and coercion, all fall silent. What rises in their place rises through different means. Solomon built the Temple with the labor of conscripted demons working under angelic supervision, without a single hammer blow heard in Jerusalem while the stones went up. The silence was the sign. The silence said: this is how the world was meant to be built.

Isaiah had seen the same silence in his visions. Nation shall not lift up sword against nation, neither shall they learn war anymore. The messianic age and the Temple's construction shared the same defining quality: the weapons put away, the coercive noise stilled. Solomon achieved it for the building. He could not sustain it for the reign.

What Solomon Understood and Could Not Keep

He understood the Torah's restrictions on kings. Multiply not horses. Multiply not wives. Multiply not silver and gold. He read those prohibitions and decided, somewhere in the accumulation of his wisdom, that they applied to kings who might be corrupted, not to a king wise enough to manage what he possessed. He multiplied all three. The horses, the wives, the treasure. The tradition is explicit about the sequence: the wisdom preceded the excess, and the wisdom was not sufficient to prevent it.

The sacred fire that fell at the Temple's dedication, the fire that no priest had kindled, that came from heaven when Solomon finished his prayer, was the divine confirmation of what had been built. It consumed the burnt offering and the sacrifices. The people fell on their faces. That fire was the same fire that had accepted Abel's offering and rejected Cain's, the same fire that had spoken from the burning bush, the primordial fire of divine attention descending on the prepared place. It fell on Solomon's Temple. Then the king who received it began multiplying what he had been told not to multiply.

What Hezekiah Was Offered and Did Not Take

Hezekiah came later, after Solomon's kingdom had divided and most of it had been carried away. The Talmud says that during Hezekiah's reign every person in Israel knew the laws of purity and impurity. Not just the scholars. Every person. This had never happened before. The sun went backward for him. God intended to make him the Messiah. But Hezekiah did not compose a song after the Assyrian army was destroyed overnight outside his walls. He did not sing. He accepted the rescue and went back to his life, and the absence of the song was interpreted as the failure of the vessel. Isaiah waited. The song did not come. The moment passed.

This is the picture Isaiah presented to his generation and to every generation that read him: the messianic conditions have been present repeatedly, in Solomon's peace, in Hezekiah's rescue, in the moments when everything aligned. They have passed because the person who stood at the center of the alignment did not recognize what he was holding, did not rise to meet it, did not sing or did not stop multiplying. The hope was not extinguished. It transferred to the next vessel, and the next, and the waiting continued.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

4 sources

The texts this telling draws on, in full. Open a card to read inline, or expand it for a wider, quieter read.

Legends of the Jews 5:4Legends of the Jews

You might know him as Solomon, the wise king. But did you know that wasn't his only name? According to tradition, he was actually born with the name Jedidiah, meaning "friend of God." But "Solomon" stuck, and for a beautiful reason: it reflects the shalom, the peace, that reigned during his time.

Wait, there's more! The sages tell us he had other names too. The text mentions Ben, Jakeh, and Ithiel. Ben, because he was the builder, the one who would construct the magnificent Temple. Jakeh, because his rule extended over the entire world. And Ithiel, because God was with him, always. Pretty powerful stuff. It makes you think about how names can carry so much meaning, so much destiny.

Solomon’s path to the throne wasn't without its bumps, though. Remember Adonijah? He had plans to lead a rebellion, to seize power for himself. But luckily, David, in his wisdom, had Solomon publicly anointed as king. This preemptive move effectively squashed the rebellion before it could even begin.

Get this: Solomon didn't just ride any old donkey to his anointing. Oh no. He rode a special she-mule. Now, this wasn't your average mule, born of the usual crossbreeding. Legend has it, this mule was created specifically for the occasion! A one-of-a-kind creature for a one-of-a-kind king. It really makes you wonder, doesn’t it? What other incredible things happened that we don't even know about? What other stories are waiting to be uncovered? What does it mean to be truly chosen?

Full source
Vayikra Rabbah 10:2Vayikra Rabbah

The familiar picture has them as these larger-than-life figures, effortlessly delivering divine messages. But what if it wasn't that simple? What if accepting the role of prophet meant accepting hardship, even abuse?

The ancient collection of rabbinic sermons known as Vayikra Rabbah, in its tenth section, gives us a glimpse into just that. It tells a story, attributed to Rabbi Azarya in the name of Rabbi Yehuda bar Simon, that reimagines the moment the prophet Isaiah received his calling.

It all starts with Isaiah in his study hall, minding his own business, when he overhears God's call: "Whom shall I send, and who will go for us?" (Isaiah 6:8). God, according to this midrash (rabbinic interpretive commentary), or interpretation, had already sent other prophets. Micah, for example, was sent, and what did the people do? They struck him on the cheek! As it says, "With a rod they strike on the cheek" (Micah 4:14). Then there was Amos. Rabbi Pinḥas tells us that his name, Amos, is related to the Hebrew word amus, meaning "cumbrous," because he was considered slow of speech.

So, God asks again, "Whom shall I send and who will go for us?" And Isaiah, bless his heart, steps up. "Here I am, send me" (Isaiah 6:8).

But here's where it gets interesting. God doesn't just say, "Great, pack your bags!" Instead, God lays out the terms: "Isaiah, My children, they are troublesome and insubordinate. If you accept upon yourself to be demeaned and to be stricken by My children, you will go on My mission, but if not, you will not go on My mission."

In other words, are you willing to be rejected, scorned, even physically harmed by the very people you're trying to help?

Isaiah, incredibly, agrees. He says, "I am willing to accept this condition; 'I gave my body to those who smite and my cheeks to those who pluck' (Isaiah 50:6). But I am not worthy to go on a mission to Your children.”

It's a powerful moment of humility. Isaiah is willing to endure suffering, but he still feels unworthy.

God responds with reassurance: "Isaiah, 'you love righteousness,' you love to vindicate My children; 'and detest wickedness,' you detest condemning them. 'Therefore, God your God, has anointed you.'"

And then, God reveals something truly special. "What is 'over your counterparts'?" God asks. The answer? Unlike other prophets who received their prophetic inspiration from other prophets – think of Elijah and Elisha, where "The spirit of Elijah has rested upon Elisha" (II (Kings 2:1)5) – Isaiah will receive his directly from God. "The spirit of the Lord God is upon me, because the Lord has anointed.." (Isaiah 61:1).

As the midrash continues, all the other prophets prophesy simple prophecies, but Isaiah will receive "compound prophecies of consolation." The text then strings together a series of comforting prophecies found in the Book of Isaiah itself: "Awaken, awaken," "Comfort, comfort My people" (Isaiah 40:1), and so on.

What does this all mean? It suggests that prophecy isn't just about delivering messages. It's about empathy, about being willing to suffer alongside those you're trying to reach. It's about loving righteousness and hating wickedness, even when it's difficult. It’s about a direct line to the Divine, unmediated and intensely personal. And sometimes, it's about offering comfort, even when the world seems bleak.

This passage from Vayikra Rabbah, based on interpretations from Isaiah, reminds us that true leadership, true service, often requires sacrifice. It forces us to ask ourselves: how far are we willing to go to make a difference, to bring a message of hope and healing to a world that desperately needs it?

Full source
Shir HaShirim Rabbah 8:3Shir HaShirim Rabbah

It's a story about perspective, gratitude, and maybe even a missed opportunity to usher in... the Messiah!

The passage begins with a verse from Song of Songs, "Look from the peak of Amana" (Song of Songs 4:8). The rabbis, in their beautiful way, see this verse as alluding to the patriarchs. "The peak of Amana" is Abraham, the man who "believed in the Lord" (Genesis 15:6). "From the peak of Senir" is Isaac. And here's a clever bit: just as Senir is hostile to plowing (soneh nir), Isaac only faced one major ordeal in his life – the Binding of Isaac. "And Ḥermon" is Jacob. The text emphasizes that all the good – priesthood, the Levites, the kingship – comes from Jacob. He was the culmination of the patriarchs.

Then the verse shifts to "the dens of lions" – Siḥon and Og, those mighty, haughty kings. Shir HaShirim Rabbah tells us they were so arrogant, they didn't even bother to help each other, despite being only a day's walk apart! And "the mountains of leopards" are the Canaanites, as brazen and shameless as leopards. The text even references (Joshua 8:17), noting how the men of Ai all came out after Israel, showing their audacity.

Here's where the story takes an interesting turn. Rabbi Berekhya, quoting Rabbi Elazar, says it would have been fitting for Israel to sing a song of victory after defeating Siḥon and Og. And similarly, Hezekiah should have sung a song after the downfall of Sennacherib. But, as we read in II (Chronicles 32:25), Hezekiah "did not reciprocate according to the reward bestowed upon him."

Why not? Because "his heart had grown haughty." Now, wait a minute! Hezekiah, a righteous king, haughty? The text clarifies: Hezekiah was too proud to sing a song! He thought his Torah study was enough.

Rabbi Abba bar Kahana explains that Hezekiah believed his Torah study atoned for the lack of song. Rabbi Levi adds that Hezekiah felt recounting God's miracles was unnecessary because they were already known throughout the world – after all, hadn't the sun stood still (II (Kings 20:1)1), displaying God's power to everyone?

Rabbi Yishmael ben Rabbi Yosei, citing Rabbi Abba, even brings in Pharaoh of Egypt and Tirhaka of Kush! They were involved in the miracle of the sun standing still and came to aid Hezekiah. Sennacherib sensed their presence and bound them, but an angel struck Sennacherib’s troops. In the morning, Hezekiah found the kings bound, released them, and they went on to spread the news of God's miracles. (Isaiah 45:14) is then interpreted as referring to these events, with Egypt and Kush ultimately acknowledging God's greatness.

Isaiah, witnessing all this, cries out, "Indeed [akhen] You are God who conceals Himself" (Isaiah 45:15). The text plays on the word akhen, asking, "Where [ekhan] are You hiding, God?" It's a powerful moment of recognizing God's hidden hand even in the midst of miraculous events.

But here's the kicker. Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi says that if Hezekiah had sung a song after Sennacherib's defeat, he would have become the Messianic king, and Sennacherib would have been the equivalent of Gog and Magog! But he didn't. Instead, he recited (Psalms 20:7)–8, acknowledging God's power and anticipating a future king, "His anointed one [meshiḥo]," implying that he himself wouldn't be the Messiah.

Wow. So, what's the takeaway? Is it about the importance of singing praises? Is it about recognizing God's miracles, even when they seem obvious? Maybe it's about not letting our accomplishments, even righteous ones, blind us to the need for gratitude and humility. Perhaps Hezekiah’s story is a reminder that sometimes, the greatest acts of service are not enough if they are not accompanied by a song of the heart. And perhaps, just perhaps, sometimes singing the right song at the right time can change the course of history.

Full source
The Book of Maccabees II 2:12The Book of Maccabees II

The Second Book of Maccabees, a historical and religious text not included in the Hebrew Bible but important for understanding the Second Temple period, tells us a fascinating story about the prophet Jeremiah. He’s reminding the people about the wisdom of Solomon, and especially about the dedication of the Temple. Can you imagine the scene? The culmination of years of work, the House of the Lord finally standing in all its glory!

It wasn't just about the building itself. It was about the connection to God, the acceptance of their devotion. And how did that acceptance manifest? Through fire.

The text highlights how Solomon offered sacrifices when he finished erecting the Temple. Think of it: the smoke rising, carrying the prayers and hopes of an entire nation heavenward. The key here is that this wasn’t just Solomon's thing. It echoes back to Moses himself.

Remember when Moses prayed? The Second Book of Maccabees tells us that a fire "left from the presence of The Lord" and consumed the burnt offering. It’s a powerful image, isn’t it? A literal sign from God, an undeniable stamp of approval. And just like that moment with Moses, Solomon's prayer was also answered with fire descending from the heavens, consuming the burnt offering and sacrifices.

But there's an interesting detail tucked away in this passage. It mentions Moses searching for the ram of the sin offering, and finding it charred, uneaten. Why is that significant? The text doesn't explicitly say, but it hints at the completeness of the offering, the utter devotion. Nothing was held back. No one partook. This kind of sin offering was completely dedicated to God. According to II Maccabees, Solomon also offered sacrifices for eight days, echoing the dedication of the altar in the wilderness.

It makes you wonder, doesn't it? About the power of ritual, the weight of history, and the enduring connection between humanity and the divine. The fire, in this context, isn't just destruction. It's transformation. It's acceptance. It’s a visual representation of God's presence, a confirmation that the prayers have been heard, the sacrifices accepted. It’s a reminder that even the smallest act of devotion, offered with a pure heart, can ignite something truly extraordinary.

Full source