5 min read

Joshua Kept His Oath to People Who Tricked Him

The bread was still warm when they left home. Three days later Israel found the camp next door, and the princes wanted blood.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. Moldy Bread at the Gate
  2. The Camp Wanted the Oath Torn Up
  3. The Hail That Had Waited Since Egypt
  4. Saul Treated the Oath as Old Paper
  5. Seven Walked Past the Ark
Joshua Kept His Oath to People Who Tricked Him Click for full size

Moldy Bread at the Gate

They had scuffed the sandals on purpose. The wineskins were cracked because someone had sat the night before and cracked them. The bread had been baked that morning, then left in the sun until it looked like a long road.

They arrived at Joshua's camp dressed as travelers from a country so far off that the war would never reach it. They had heard of the God of Israel, they said. They had come a great distance to make peace.

Joshua made a covenant with them. He swore an oath in God's name that he would not harm them. The princes of Israel swore along with him.

Three days later the scouts came back with a short report. Gibeon was a neighbor. One of the Canaanite cities the conquest had already named. The worn leather had been theater. The mold had been a morning's work.

The Camp Wanted the Oath Torn Up

Israel had crossed the Jordan behind this man. Jericho. Ai. Weeks of hard campaigning. Now their commander had bound the whole nation to protect a city that had walked in with a costume and a lie. The talk in the tents was simple. Fraud. Nullify it. Kill them.

Joshua kept the word anyway. The oath had been sworn in God's name. What the Gibeonites deserved did not change what that Name weighed. He had sworn. The oath stood.

He gathered them in front of him and told them what the deception had cost. Their lives were under the covenant. Their standing was not. They would be servants to the community, hewers of wood and drawers of water for the altar and the sanctuary. They had come in through a back door. They would live in the rooms servants live in, doing the labor that makes a sanctuary run, taking no share in the honor of it.

They accepted. They had obtained protection from a man they had cheated. They were in no position to bargain for dignity as well.

The Hail That Had Waited Since Egypt

When the other kings of Canaan closed on Gibeon, Joshua hesitated. These were the people who had tricked him. The alliance was offensive and defensive, and it had been stolen, and for a moment he stood with the question in his mouth.

God spoke first.

"If thou dost not bring near them that are far off, thou wilt remove them that are near by."

He went. The hot hailstones that Moses had held in the air over Egypt, the ones that never finished falling on the Egyptians, came down now on the armies around Gibeon. Then the sun stopped. The sixth great wonder since the world was made. The day stretched until the oath had been paid in full on the field, and the people who had lied their way under Israel's wing walked off the field alive because Joshua had not put the Name back in his pocket.

Saul Treated the Oath as Old Paper

Centuries later Saul broke it. Not in one speech. In a policy of pressure, then displacement, then killing. He drove Gibeonites from their settlements. He treated a sworn covenant as an arrangement a dead commander had made, which a living king could revoke.

After Saul's death the famine lasted three years. David inquired and got the answer straight. The land was starving because Saul had broken what was sworn in God's name. The king who broke it was already in the ground. The Name was not.

David went to the survivors and asked what would satisfy them. They named terms. Seven of Saul's descendants.

Seven Walked Past the Ark

They made Saul's posterity pass by the Ark of the law. Those the Ark arrested were the designated dead. Mephibosheth, Jonathan's son, would have been one of them. David prayed. Mephibosheth was also the man who had taught David Torah. He walked past unchecked.

The others did not. The Gibeonites took them. The famine ended.

Joshua had honored what he swore to people who had tricked him, and Israel ate. Saul treated that same oath as paper, and Israel starved. The chain ran across three centuries and stopped at an Ark that knew which feet to let go.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

3 sources

The texts behind this telling. Some cards carry a translation of the source; others are our own retelling of it, and each card says which. Every card links out to the original.

Legends of the Jews 1:15Legends of the Jews

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Legends of the Jews by Louis Ginzberg (1909) · Public Domain

The Gibeonites were a Canaanite group who cleverly tricked Joshua into making a covenant with them. They knew the Israelites were conquering the land, and so they pretended to be travelers from a distant country, thereby getting Joshua to swear an oath to protect them.

Here's the thing: Joshua and the Israelites soon discovered the ruse! They realized the Gibeonites were actually their neighbors, people they were supposed to drive out of the land. So, what do you do?

Well, Joshua, bound by his oath, kept his word. He spared the Gibeonites, but relegated them to being servants. According to Legends of the Jews, Joshua kept his promise to them, "in order to sanctify the name of God, by showing the world how sacred an oath is to the Israelites." It was all about upholding the sanctity of an oath, showing the world that the Israelites honored their commitments, even when based on deception. It wasn't about liking the Gibeonites, or even thinking they deserved mercy. It was about something bigger: the reputation of the Israelite people, and ultimately, the name of God.

The story doesn't end there. As time went on, it became clear that the Gibeonites weren't exactly model citizens. They weren't worthy of being fully integrated into the Jewish community. So, King David, following Joshua's lead in a way, took a further step. He permanently excluded them.

And here’s the kicker: this exclusion, according to the tradition, wasn’t just for David's time. It was forever! "A sentence that will remain in force even in the Messianic time," Ginzberg tells us in Legends of the Jews. Even in the idealized future, the Gibeonites would remain separate.

What does this all mean? It seems like it's a complex dance between justice, mercy, and the absolute importance of keeping one's word. It raises some profound questions: What do we do when we realize we've made a mistake? How do we balance the needs of the present with the promises of the past? And how do we ensure that our actions reflect the values we claim to hold dear? These are questions that continue to resonate today.

Full source
Legends of the Jews 1:17Legends of the Jews

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Legends of the Jews by Louis Ginzberg (1909) · Public Domain

The story of Joshua and the Gibeonites is a powerful lesson in just that. Joshua, successor to Moses, found himself in a bit of a quandary. He'd made an alliance with the Gibeonites, a people who weren't exactly on anyone's "most trustworthy" list. They'd secured this treaty through trickery, pretending to be from a far-off land to avoid being slaughtered like the other Canaanite tribes (Joshua 9).

So, what did Joshua do when the Gibeonites were attacked? He hesitated. He really did. As Ginzberg tells us in Legends of the Jews, Joshua wasn't sure if he should come to their aid. After all, they’d deceived him!

Then, God spoke. The message? Profound. "If thou dost not bring near them that are far off, thou wilt remove them that are near by. What it means is this: neglecting your obligations to those who are distant, even if they aren't the most deserving, can ultimately undermine your relationships with those who are close. Your integrity, once compromised, is hard to repair.

That was enough for Joshua. Duty called, and he answered.

And here's where the story gets truly epic.

God, it seems, was pretty pleased with Joshua's decision. In fact, He granted Joshua a few extraordinary favors in this conflict. Remember those hailstones that Moses held back during the plagues in Egypt? The ones ready to fall upon the Egyptians? According to the ancient stories, they were still hanging up there, waiting. Now, they were unleashed upon the Canaanites attacking the Gibeonites! Talk about divine intervention!

But the real showstopper? The sun standing still. Yes, you read that right. The sun. Stopped. In the sky.

The Zohar, the foundational text of Jewish mysticism, speaks of great wonders that have occurred since the creation of the world. And this, the sun standing still, was considered the sixth of these monumental events. A battle raging, and the sun just… pauses. Time seemingly suspended.

Why? So that Joshua and his army could complete their victory. So they could fulfill their oath to protect the Gibeonites.

That sometimes, doing the right thing, even when it's hard, opens the door to something truly extraordinary.

What promises are you struggling to keep today? What "Gibeonites" are you hesitant to defend? Maybe, just maybe, this ancient story can offer a little bit of courage, a little bit of faith, and a whole lot of perspective.

Full source
Legends of the Jews 4:73Legends of the Jews

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Legends of the Jews by Louis Ginzberg (1909) · Public Domain

The story revolves around a famine in Israel, a famine attributed to King Saul's transgression against the Gibeonites. long ago, Joshua had made a pact with the Gibeonites, promising to protect them. But Saul, in his zeal, had broken that promise, attempting to exterminate them. And now, years later, the land was suffering.

So, what to do? How do you appease not only the Gibeonites, but also, seemingly, God himself? The answer, as relayed in II Samuel 21, is a grim one: the surrender of seven of Saul's descendants to the Gibeonites, who would then execute them.

How exactly were these seven individuals chosen? According to the Legends of the Jews, as retold by Rabbi Louis Ginzberg, a rather. unique method was employed. All of Saul's descendants were made to pass before the Aron Hakodesh (Ark of the Law), the sacred chest containing the luchot (tablets) of the Ten Commandments. Those who were "arrested" before it, meaning, those who couldn't pass, were deemed the designated victims.

The scene: each member of Saul's lineage, walking past this powerful symbol of God's law, their fate hanging in the balance. A moment of terrifying suspense.

Mephibosheth, Jonathan's son and Saul's grandson, was almost among those chosen. But here's where the narrative takes a slight turn, highlighting the power of prayer and loyalty. David, who had a deep bond with Jonathan, prayed that Mephibosheth be spared. And, according to the Legends, his prayer was answered. Mephibosheth was allowed to pass by the Ark unchecked.

But why was David's prayer so effective? Ginzberg suggests an additional reason: Mephibosheth wasn't just the son of David's friend; he was also David's teacher, instructing him in the Torah. This adds another layer to their relationship, emphasizing the respect and affection David held for him.

It's a dark and disturbing episode, no doubt. The execution of Saul's descendants is a harsh reminder of the consequences of broken promises and the complexities of divine justice. But according to the Legends, this grim act had an unexpected, positive outcome.

The heathen, witnessing this act of atonement, were deeply moved. "There is no God like unto the God of Israel," they exclaimed, "there is no nation like unto the nation of Israel; the wrong inflicted upon wretched proselytes has been expiated by the sons of kings." This display of Jewish justice, however severe, inspired awe and admiration.

The Legends go on to state that this event led to the conversion of one hundred and fifty thousand heathens to Judaism. A staggering number! It seems that even in the face of tragedy, the Jewish commitment to justice, however difficult, could inspire and transform.

What are we to make of this story? It’s a challenging one, forcing us to confront difficult questions about collective responsibility, the nature of justice, and the long shadow of the past. Can an act of violence, even one intended to atone for past sins, truly bring about a positive outcome? And can genuine faith truly emerge from the darkest of circumstances?

Full source