Parshat Vayera6 min read

Lot Chose Sodom and God Found David There

Lot looked east, saw grass, and moved his tents toward the city. Two of Israel's royal lines walked out of the cave above it at dawn.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. He Picked the Green Side of the Valley
  2. Two Angels Pulling on Four Wrists
  3. The City That Never Saw That Sunrise
  4. Two Girls in a Cave Above the Smoke
  5. Where Did I Find David
Lot Chose Sodom and God Found David There Click for full size

He Picked the Green Side of the Valley

The herdsmen had been fighting over water for weeks when Abraham finally gave his nephew the choice.

Take whichever half you want, he said. If you go left I will go right. If you go right I will go left.

Lot climbed to where he could see and looked east. The whole plain of the Jordan was watered the entire way down, green in a country that was not green, and the phrase that stuck to it afterward was that it looked like the garden of God, and it looked like Egypt. So he took it. He moved his tents down onto the plain and kept moving them east until they were pitched at the edge of Sodom.

He was not choosing a moral climate. He was choosing grass.

The inventory of what he brought with him is short and slightly wrong: flocks, cattle, and tents. Not a tent. Tents. Rabbi Toviya bar Yitzhak counted the plural and said Lot was carrying two dwellings that had not been pitched yet, and would not be pitched for centuries, and were named Ruth and Naama.

Two Angels Pulling on Four Wrists

The night the city came apart, the men who had eaten at Lot's table stopped being guests.

Get up, they told him. Take your wife and your two daughters who are found here, or you will be swept away in the punishment of the city.

He went out and tried to talk to the men who had married his daughters and they thought he was joking. He came back and stood in the doorway of his own house and could not make his feet move. So the angels took him by the hand, and took his wife by the hand, and took the two girls by the hand, four wrists in two grips, and hauled the family out through the gate and set them down outside the wall and told them not to look behind them.

Lot argued even then. Not the mountains, he said. Let me go to that little town instead. And they let him, and he ran, and the sun came up over the earth as he came into Tzoar.

The City That Never Saw That Sunrise

Behind him it began.

Brimstone and fire came down out of heaven on Sodom and on Gomorrah, and the sages of fifth century Palestine, reaching for something to set beside it, reached for small hidden dyings. A snail dissolving as it drags itself along, leaving nothing but its own slime. A mole that works its whole life underground and goes back into the earth without ever having seen the sun once. A woman who has conceived a child she cannot explain and carries it out at night and puts it down in the dark, before any light can fall on its face.

That was the shape of it. Sodom went into the ground at sunrise on a morning it never got to see.

Lot saw it. That is the entire difference between the two halves of the verse. The sun rose upon the earth, and Lot came to Tzoar, and everything behind him was smoke.

Two Girls in a Cave Above the Smoke

He did not stay in Tzoar. He was afraid of it, so he went up into the hill country and lived in a cave with his two daughters, and his wife was a pillar of salt on the road behind them.

From up there the whole plain was ash. No towns. No roads with people on them. Nothing moving between the ruins for as far as they could see.

The older daughter said to the younger one that their father was old and there was not a man left in the earth to come to them. They gave him wine two nights running. The older bore a son and called him Moab. The younger bore a son and called him Ben-Ammi. Two nations came out of that cave, and both of them spent the next thousand years at war with Israel.

Where Did I Find David

The word the angel used for the daughters was not a neutral word. It is the word for a thing found, the way a coin is found, the way a lost object is found and claimed.

So the sages counted the found things forward. Out of Moab, generations later, came a widow named Ruth who followed her mother in law across the border on foot and gleaned barley behind strangers in Bethlehem and married into the house of Judah. Out of Ammon came Naama, who married Solomon and bore Rehoboam, the next king to sit in Jerusalem. Two women. Two tents. One throne.

And then Rabbi Yitzhak set the psalm down on top of it. I have found David My servant, God says. Where did I find him?

In Sodom.

Not despite Sodom. In it. The line that would carry Israel's kingship was already lying in the worst city on earth on the night the fire came down, close enough to the flame to feel it, and it walked out of the gate at dawn holding an angel's hand.

LotSodomDavidRuthRedemption
← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

3 sources

The texts behind this telling. Some cards carry a translation of the source; others are our own retelling of it, and each card says which. Every card links out to the original.

Bereshit Rabbah 41:4Bereshit Rabbah

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Sefaria Midrash Rabbah, 2022 · CC-BY

Bereshit Rabbah notices one small word in Lot's property list: tents.

Rabbi Toviya bar Yitzḥak sees something profound in that word "tents." In Hebrew, "tent" (ohel) can sometimes be a euphemism for one's wife. And Rabbi Toviya suggests that Lot possessed not just physical tents, but two very special "tents," two women whose descendants would leave an indelible mark on history. Who were they? Ruth the Moabitess and Naamah the Ammonitess. Ruth, a Moabite woman, through an act of incredible loyalty and devotion, becomes the great-grandmother of King David. Naamah, an Ammonite princess, becomes one of King Solomon's wives and the mother of Rehoboam, who would become king after Solomon's death. From Lot, a man associated with moral failure, spring forth these two women, each playing a crucial role in the lineage of Israel's monarchy.

Rabbi Yitzḥak adds another layer. He connects the verse "I found David My servant" (Psalms 89:21) to Sodom. How so? He interprets the phrase "your two daughters who are found" (Genesis 19:15), the daughters Lot was trying to protect from the mob in Sodom, as alluding to Ruth and Naamah. In other words, the seeds of David's line, and by extension, the messianic line, were sown in the very place most associated with depravity!

This idea, found in Bereshit Rabbah 41, challenges us to look beyond surface appearances. It shows that even the actions of flawed individuals can have unforeseen, positive consequences. Nothing is wasted. Everything is connected.

The Zohar tells us that sparks of holiness can be found even in the darkest corners. Maybe Lot's story isn’t just a cautionary tale about bad choices. Maybe it's also evidence of the enduring power of hope, the unexpected pathways of destiny, and the idea that even from the most unpromising beginnings, greatness can arise.

Is it possible that even our mistakes, our "Sodoms," can somehow contribute to a brighter future?

Full source
Bereshit Rabbah 51:1Bereshit Rabbah

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Sefaria Midrash Rabbah, 2022 · CC-BY

The Book of Genesis (19:24) tells us plainly: "And the Lord rained down brimstone and fire upon Sodom and upon Gomorrah from the Lord, from the heavens." But the rabbis, in their endless quest to understand the deeper meanings, looked closer. Much, much closer.

Bereshit Rabbah, that magnificent collection of rabbinic interpretations of Genesis, dives into the verse, drawing a disturbing parallel. It begins by quoting (Psalms 58:9): "Let them be like snails that melt away as they go along, like a nefel mole which has never seen the sun.."

A nefel mole. What is that? The text describes it as a kind of subterranean animal.

The rabbis of the Midrash (rabbinic interpretive commentary) see in this verse a chilling echo of the fate of Sodom. Like a kilei-silei – a snail, a slug – dissolving into nothingness, the people of Sodom were annihilated. Imagine that: disappearing, not with a bang, but a slow, agonizing fizzle. Like a mole that never sees the sun before returning to the earth.

But the analogy goes even further, taking a truly uncomfortable turn. The Bereshit Rabbah compares the destruction to a married woman – eshet ish – who has committed adultery. She's so ashamed of the resulting fetus that she casts it away at night, before it can even see the sun. A secret, shameful act hidden from the light.

Why this comparison? What are the rabbis trying to tell us? Perhaps it's about the utter depravity and hidden nature of Sodom's sins. Sins so vile, so contrary to the natural order, that they deserved not just punishment, but obliteration. A wiping away, as if they'd never existed. Sins hidden, like the adulterous woman's shame.

The Midrash then links this back to (Genesis 19:23): "The sun rose upon the earth and Lot came to Tzoar." This seemingly simple statement gains a new layer of meaning. The people of Sodom, like that hidden fetus, never got to see the sun rise on a new day. They were annihilated at sunrise, their wickedness extinguished before the light could expose it.

So, what do we take away from this exploration of a single verse? It's more than just a story of divine retribution. It's a meditation on the nature of evil, the consequences of hidden sins, and the terrifying power of complete annihilation. It challenges us to look beyond the surface of the biblical narrative and confront the uncomfortable truths about human nature and divine justice. It's a reminder that some sins are so corrosive, so fundamentally opposed to life and light, that they demand a complete and utter end.

Full source
Yalkut Shimoni on Torah 84:7Yalkut Shimoni on Torah

Translation of the source text.Torat Emet (Yalkut Shimoni) · CC-BY-NC

"Arise, take your wife and your two daughters who are found here" (Genesis 19:15). Two "found ones" [precious finds] came from these survivors: Ruth the Moabite and Naamah the Ammonite. As it is written, "I have found David My servant" (Psalms 89:21). Where did I find him? In Sodom. And it is written, "Behold, I have come; in the scroll of the book it is written concerning me" (Psalms 40:8).

Full source