6 min read

Simeon and Levi Waited for a Festival to Strike Shechem

Their father never forgave them. On his deathbed he told Simeon and Levi that the swords on their hips were stolen goods that belonged to Esau.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. Dinah Went In to See the Women
  2. The Third Day, When the Pain Was Worst
  3. The Gods Buried Under the Oak
  4. Jacob Called Them Brothers for Degradation
  5. Two Men at the Same Door
Simeon and Levi Waited for a Festival to Strike Shechem Click for full size

Dinah Went In to See the Women

The city was keeping a festival the day Dinah walked into it. She had come to look at the clothes the women of that country wore. She was the only daughter in her father's camp, and nobody stopped her at the gate.

Shechem, son of King Hamor, saw her in the crowd and took her by force. Afterward he could not let her go. He went to his father and asked him to arrange a marriage.

Hamor rode out to the tents and made the offer politely, one house to another. Jacob was caught between two things he could not do. He could not tell a king to his face that his son was not good enough, and he could not hand his daughter to a stranger. He asked for time to think it over. Hamor went home expecting good news.

Then Jacob told his sons what had been done to their sister, and asked them what he should do. Most of them stood there with nothing to say.

Simeon and Levi had the same mother as Dinah. They said nothing in front of their father either. They settled it between themselves, outside, and then carried a condition back to Hamor. Every male in the city was to be circumcised. After that the two households could marry and become one people. Hamor put the terms to his men, the men agreed, and a whole city went under the knife for a wedding.

The Third Day, When the Pain Was Worst

The brothers waited until the third day.

The holiday was still running. Men lay about in the ease of a feast with the wound of the third day in them, and the watch on the wall had fallen asleep. Simeon and Levi came through the gate with drawn swords and killed every male in Shechem, the king and the king's son among them. They spared the women. They took Dinah out of Shechem's house and walked her back to camp, and their brothers came behind them and carried off everything the city owned.

Jacob was appalled. "You have made me a stench to the Canaanites and the Perizzites," he said. "We are few. If they gather against us, we are finished."

"Should he have treated our sister like a prostitute?" they answered.

Jacob had nothing to say back to that.

The Gods Buried Under the Oak

God spoke to him instead. Take courage. Purify the household. Pay the offerings promised at Bethel on the night of the ladder.

Going through his own tents to purify them, Jacob turned up the household gods of Laban. He had never known they were in his camp at all. Rachel had taken them out of her father's house years earlier and said nothing. Jacob dug a hole under an oak at Shechem and buried them in the dirt of the city his sons had just emptied, and went on to Bethel and made his sacrifice there.

The road cost him Rachel. Near Ephrath she went into labor in the night and did not survive it. She named the boy Son of My Sorrow. His father called him Benjamin. Jacob set a pillar on the road above her grave, and of all his household she was the only one who never came to the cave at Hebron.

Jacob Called Them Brothers for Degradation

Decades later Jacob lay dying at Hebron and called his sons in to be blessed. Reuben went first and came away with his ears drooping.

Then his father called the next two in together. "Simeon and Levi are brothers," he said, and made the word an accusation. Brothers for degradation. "You were brothers for Dinah, and each of you took his sword. You were not brothers for Joseph. You sold him."

He went after the swords next. Weapons of villainy, he called them, and said they were stolen property. They belonged to Esau, who had been promised that he would live by his sword. An old man on his last morning, telling two grown sons that the blades on their hips were their uncle's.

Then Jacob spoke past their lifetimes. Let my soul not enter their council, he said. When a prince of Simeon takes a Midianite woman in front of the whole camp, keep my name out of it. Let my glory not join their assembly. When a Levite raises a congregation against Moses, keep my name out of that too. The records obeyed him. Zimri son of Salu, a prince of a father's house among the Simeonites. Korah son of Izhar son of Kehat son of Levi. Neither line runs back as far as Jacob.

Two Men at the Same Door

"Cursed is their anger, for it is fierce, and their wrath, for it is cruel."

He cursed the anger and left the men out of it. Generations later Balaam stood on a hill above the camp, hired to curse Israel, and could not find a place to start. A father in a rage had cursed nothing but the rage.

The sentence was the last line of the blessing. I will divide them in Jacob and scatter them in Israel. It came due on a plain in Moab, where twenty-four thousand men of the tribe of Simeon fell over the business with Zimri, and twenty-four thousand widows were left behind them and parcelled out two thousand to every tribe. Ever since, the man who goes from doorway to doorway with his hand out belongs to Simeon.

Levi circulates too. God saw to that, and then gave him a clean way to do it and made it holy. A tenth of every harvest in Israel belongs to the tribe of Levi.

So the Levite walks up the same road, stops at the same doorway, and says, "Give me my portion."


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

4 sources

The texts behind this telling. Some cards carry a translation of the source; others are our own retelling of it, and each card says which. Every card links out to the original.

Antiquities I.21-22Antiquities of the Jews (Josephus)

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.Antiquities of the Jews, trans. William Whiston · Public Domain

Simeon and Levi waited for the festival. That was the key to their plan. While the men of Shechem feasted and drank, the two brothers slipped past the sleeping guards, entered the city, and killed every single male, including the king and his son. Then they took their sister back.

The massacre began with a violation. Jacob had settled near Shechem, a Canaanite city, and during a local festival his only daughter Dinah went to see the women's finery. Shechem, the prince and son of King Hamor, saw her there and raped her. Then, astonishingly, he fell in love and begged his father to arrange a marriage. Hamor approached Jacob with the proposal. Jacob was trapped, he could not easily refuse a king, but giving his daughter to a foreign prince violated everything he believed. He stalled, asking for time to consult his sons.

Most of the brothers had no idea what to do. But Simeon and Levi. Dinah's full brothers through Leah, already knew. They chose the night of the Shechemite festival, when the city would be drunk and unguarded. The slaughter was total. Josephus reports they spared only the women. Jacob was horrified by the scale of what his sons had done.

Then God spoke to Jacob, not to condemn the killing, but to command purification. Jacob was told to cleanse his household, fulfill the vows he had made at Bethel years ago, and offer sacrifice. While purifying his camp, Jacob discovered that Rachel had stolen her father Laban's household idols, something he never knew. He buried them under an oak tree in Shechem and moved on.

The journey cost him Rachel. Near Ephrath, she died giving birth to her second son. With her last breath, Jacob named the boy Benjamin, a name born from sorrow. Rachel alone among Jacob's family was buried on the road, not in the ancestral tomb at Hebron. Jacob continued south to Hebron, where he found his father Isaac still alive. They lived together briefly before Isaac died at one hundred and eighty-five years old, and his sons Esau and Jacob buried him beside Rebekah in the family sepulcher.

Full source
Bereshit Rabbah 80:2Bereshit Rabbah

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Sefaria Midrash Rabbah, 2022 · CC-BY

That’s a feeling that echoes through the story of Dinah in the Book of Genesis, and it explodes with dramatic force in the rabbinic interpretations.

Dinah, daughter of Leah, ventures out. It A young woman wanting to see the world. But according to Bereshit Rabbah, specifically section 80, that act sets off a chain of events that leaves us confronting questions of justice, revenge, and collective responsibility.

The verse from Hosea (6:9) that opens this section is stark: "Like troops of robbers waylay a man, a company of priests murders its way to Shekhem, for they have formulated a plot. The Rabbis of the Midrash (rabbinic interpretive commentary) aren’t pulling any punches here. They're using this vivid comparison to paint a picture of what Simeon and Levi did in response to the rape of their sister, Dinah.

The text asks, is the comparison to "a company of priests" surprising? After all, priests are supposed to be holy. Shouldn’t they be paragons of virtue? The Midrash answers by pointing out that priests come together at the threshing floor to claim their due portion. Similarly, Simeon and Levi gathered in Shekhem to take what they believed was their due: vengeance. The Rabbis aren't necessarily condoning their actions. But they're trying to understand the mindset, the sense of righteous indignation that fueled such a violent response. Was it justified? The text implies that the brothers felt it was: “Murders its way to Shekhem” – it was proper for Simeon and Levi to have killed in Shekhem."

But why?

Because, as the brothers themselves exclaimed, "Shall he render our sister a harlot?” In other words, “Are we going to stand by and let our family be treated with such disrespect?" It’s a question of honor, of maintaining their dignity in the face of a terrible transgression.

And then comes the kicker. The Midrash lays the blame, at least in part, at Dinah’s feet: "Who caused it? 'Dinah, daughter of Leah…went out.'"

Ouch.

Now, before we jump to conclusions, let's remember this isn't about victim-blaming. It's about exploring the complexities of cause and effect. The Rabbis are asking us to consider how even seemingly small choices can have enormous repercussions. This idea of personal responsibility rippling outwards is something that resonates deeply within Jewish thought.

The Rabbis aren't letting Simeon and Levi off the hook for their violent actions, nor are they completely excusing Shekhem's crime. Instead, they're creating a multi-layered narrative, forcing us to confront uncomfortable truths about human nature and the cyclical nature of violence. It's a story that continues to challenge us, thousands of years later, to examine our own actions and their potential consequences.

Full source
Bereshit Rabbah 99:7Bereshit Rabbah

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Sefaria Midrash Rabbah, 2022 · CC-BY

One particularly intense moment: Jacob's words about Simeon and Levi.

It all starts with the verse: "Simeon and Levi are brothers; weapons of villainy are their heritage" (Genesis 49:5). But what does it mean?

The Midrash (rabbinic interpretive commentary), specifically Bereshit Rabbah 99, unpacks this loaded statement, revealing layers of family drama and moral reckoning. Imagine Reuben, Jacob’s eldest, walking around dejected. Why? Because Jacob is laying into Simeon and Levi. Jacob calls them "brothers for degradation." He reminds them, "You were brothers for Dina," referencing their violent revenge after Shechem violated their sister, as it's written: "Two sons of Jacob, Simeon and Levi, Dina’s brothers, each took his sword" (Genesis 34:25). But, Jacob pointedly asks, were they brothers when it came to Joseph? Because they certainly didn’t act like it when they sold him into slavery.

Rabbi Simlai adds another layer. He reminds us that it's written about Reuben: “In order to deliver him from their hand, to restore him to his father” (Genesis 37:22). This tells us that Reuben wasn't involved in selling Joseph. And Judah, another older brother, even questioned, "What profit [is there if we kill our brother]?" (Genesis 37:26). So, if Reuben and Judah were against it, who was behind it? Bereshit Rabbah suggests that it must have been Simeon and Levi, who organized the sale.

Want more proof? When the brothers later went to Egypt, who did Joseph (in disguise, of course) single out? Simeon. "He took Simeon from them [and incarcerated him before their eyes]" (Genesis 42:24). This is why Jacob lumps the two together.

Then comes the phrase, "weapons of villainy." What are those? Jacob says they were "stolen" by them. They belong to Esau, Jacob’s brother, who was told, "By your sword you shall live" (Genesis 27:40). The Midrash connects "villainy" to Esau, referencing the verse: "For the villainy to your brother Jacob" (Obadiah 1:10). So, according to Jacob, Simeon and Levi are wielding weapons that aren't even rightfully theirs; they belong to the archetype of the villain, Esau.

The text then explores the meaning of "their heritage [mekheroteihem]". Rabbi Yoḥanan suggests it might be a Greek expression, makhirin, meaning swords or daggers. Others say it refers to "their residences [meguroteihem]," linking it to the verse: "Your origins [mekhorotayikh] and your birthplace" (Ezekiel 16:3). This could imply that their violent tendencies are deeply ingrained, part of their very being.

Jacob continues, "Let my soul not come in their company; with their assembly let my glory not be associated; for in their anger they killed men, and with their will they hamstrung oxen" (Genesis 49:6). The Midrash interprets this as Jacob disassociating himself from future misdeeds of their descendants. When Zimri, a Simeonite, commits a public act of immorality with Cozbi, Jacob doesn’t want his name mentioned there. And when Korah, a Levite, leads a rebellion against Moses, Jacob wants no association. In both cases, the lineage is traced back to Simeon or Levi, but stops short of Jacob.

But what about the phrase "they killed men [ish]"? Didn't they kill all the males of Shechem? The Midrash answers that, from God’s perspective, they were all considered as one man. Just as Isaiah says: “Behold [hen], nations may be regarded like a drop from a bucket…” (Isaiah 40:16). Hen, in Greek, means "one." So, their actions were seen as a singular, unified act of violence.

Finally, Jacob pronounces: "Cursed is their anger, as it is fierce, and their wrath, as it is harsh; I will divide them in Jacob, and I will disperse them in Israel" (Genesis 49:7). Notice he curses their anger, not them directly. The Midrash connects this to Bilam, who says, "How will I curse, where God has not cursed?" (Numbers 23:8). Even in anger, Jacob is careful.

"I will divide them in Jacob." How does this play out? The tribe of Simeon dwindles after the incident with Zimri. Tradition says that the widows of the fallen warriors had to be absorbed by other tribes. The tribe of Levi, on the other hand, becomes the priestly tribe, supported by tithes. Even though they are elevated, they still circulate, asking for their portion, fulfilling Jacob’s prophecy. The Holy One blessed be He elevated [Levi] and gave him one-tenth, and he circulates and says: ‘Give me my portion.’

So, what do we take away from this complex and troubling passage? It's a meditation on the nature of anger and violence, and how even in moments of intense emotion, restraint and careful consideration are paramount. And perhaps most profoundly, it’s a glimpse into the burdens and complexities of family, and the enduring legacy – both positive and negative – that we inherit and pass on. What aspects of your family's legacy do you find yourself confronting?

Full source
Book of Jubilees 33:1Book of Jubilees

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.Sefaria Community Translation · CC-BY

The birth of a child, for instance, can be a moment of overwhelming happiness tinged with the pain of labor, the worry for their future. The story of Benjamin's birth, as recounted in the Book of Jubilees, captures this very essence.

It's a story of life, loss, and the enduring strength of family.

It expands on the narratives, often providing specific dates and details that add layers to the familiar accounts.

In this telling, we learn that Rachel, Jacob's beloved wife, gave birth to a son late one night. In her pain, she named him "Ben-Oni", "Son of my sorrow." Can you imagine the raw emotion in that moment? The physical toll on her body, the vulnerability of bringing new life into the world.

But Jacob, ever the patriarch, steps in. He renames the child Benjamin, meaning "Son of my right hand," or perhaps, "Son of the South." This renaming is significant. It’s Jacob reclaiming the narrative, choosing hope and blessing over sorrow and pain. The Book of Jubilees tells us this happened on the eleventh day of the eighth month, in the first year of the sixth week of this particular jubilee cycle. It's a level of detail that makes the story feel so concrete, so real.

Tragically, Rachel dies during or shortly after childbirth. A moment of immense joy is immediately followed by profound grief. She is buried in the land of Ephrath, which the text clarifies is the same as Bethlehem. Think of that: Bethlehem, the future birthplace of another figure central to faith and history. The layers of significance just keep unfolding.

Jacob, in his sorrow and love, erects a pillar on her grave, marking her final resting place. It’s a physical reminder of his love, a landmark for future generations. The Book of Jubilees tells us the pillar was built “on the road above her grave”. A lasting monument to a love story cut short.

After this devastating loss, Jacob journeys on, settling south of Magdalâdrâ’êf. We don’t know much about this location, but its inclusion emphasizes the continuing journey of Jacob and his family. Life goes on, even in the face of unimaginable grief.

The story of Benjamin's birth and Rachel's death in the Book of Jubilees is more than just a historical account. It's a deeply human story of joy, sorrow, love, and loss, all intertwined. And perhaps, most importantly, it shows us the power of choosing hope, even when sorrow seems overwhelming. What name would you choose for your child in such a moment?

Full source