The Widow at the Grave and the Borrowed Corpse

Midrash Aggadah Kiddushin 80b

Curated by The Jewish Mythology Team · Published January 14, 2025

The Talmud (Kiddushin 80b) tells a grim little tale to justify a rule about guarding appearances. Once a woman stood weeping over her husband's fresh grave. Not far off, a guard kept watch over the body of a man the king had ordered executed.

Grief is a strange doorway. In the hours of mourning, an affection sprang up between the guard and the widow — and while they were lost in it, the body he was guarding was stolen away. The guard panicked. The king's decree hung over his head; losing the corpse meant losing his own life.

The widow steadied him. "Do not be afraid," she said. "Exhume my husband. Hang him in the other man's place. No one will know." And it was done.

Rashi and the Tosafot cite this story not to praise it, but to warn: a woman's grief is so quickly repurposed, a grave so quickly reopened, that the sages ruled against leaving a mourning woman alone with a stranger even for an hour.

The dead cannot speak for themselves, so the law must speak for them.

Themes

Ethics Women of the Bible Death

Continue Reading

Midrash Aggadah The Widow Who Traded Her Husband's Corpse for a Watchman There was once a widow who wept over her husband’s grave day and night. The rabbis kept the story as a bitter para... Midrash Aggadah A Betrothed Couple Sold as Slaves Who Kept Their Vow A short, chilling ma'aseh from the rabbinic tradition, preserved as exemplum no. 73 in Moses Gaster's 1924 collection Th... Midrash Aggadah Rabbi Yose Wept Because Israel Was a Ship of Many Beams On his deathbed, Rabbi Yose began to weep. His students, surprised, asked why. He had been a great scholar, a faithful t... Midrash Aggadah The Wife Who Built a Rest House From a Cart of Coals A man in the Gaster manuscripts left his wife after many years of marriage. His reason was the oldest reason in the worl... Midrash Aggadah The Divorce Plot That Shammai's Disciple Unraveled A certain man in Jerusalem wanted to divorce his rich wife. The problem was that her marriage contract — her ketubah — s... Midrash Aggadah The Beautiful Children of Rabbi Ishmael Who Died in an Embrace When the wicked kingdom destroyed the Temple and carried the people into slavery, the son and daughter of Rabbi Ishmael ... Midrash Aggadah Rabbi Akiva Rules That Voluntary and Forced Are Different A man had publicly dishevelled the hair of a Jewish woman in the street, a humiliating act in the ancient world, where a... Midrash Aggadah Rabbi Gidel and the Women Who Were Like White Geese Rabbi Gidel was a sage of the third century CE, a disciple of Rav in Babylonia, known for his rigor in halakhah. He also... Midrash Aggadah Rabbi Joshua Taught a Lesson by a Widow and a Child Rabbi Joshua ben Chanania, one of the greatest sages of the first and second century CE, used to say: In my whole life, ...