Why Joseph's Ten Brothers Went Down to Egypt to Buy Grain

Midrash Tanchuma Buber, Miketz 10:2

“So Joseph recognized his brothers” (Genesis 42:8)—when they fell into his hand; “but they did not recognize him”—when he had fallen into their hand. David said, “Give ear, O Shepherd of Israel, who leads Joseph like a flock” (Psalms 80:2). Thus did Rabbi Tanchuma expound: “Go down (redu) there”—for he saw that they would go down and be enslaved in Egypt two hundred and ten (RD"U) years. Another interpretation: “Go down (redu)”—to teach you that whoever buys produce from the marketplace, it is a going down for him. “And Joseph’s ten brothers went down”: it is not written here “the children of Israel,” but rather “Joseph’s brothers,” because at first they did not act toward him with brotherhood, in that they sold him; and in the end they regretted it, and said, “When shall we go down to Egypt and return Joseph to our father?” And when their father told them to go down to Egypt, they all went of one mind to bring him back. Therefore it is written, “And Joseph’s brothers went down.” And why ten? Because it was within their power to bring the punishment to an end and to annul the decree. Thus you find with Sodom that Abraham went down from fifty to ten; and once he did not find ten, Abraham the Righteous fell silent. And because there were not ten in the generation of the Flood, they were not saved, for there was no one there except Noah and his three sons and their wives—that is, eight.

Themes

Biblical References