7 min read

Jacob Made Joseph Swear to Carry His Body Out of Egypt

The firstborn was in the room. So was the son who would be king. Jacob sent for neither of them, because neither one could get a body past the border.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. He Sent for the Wrong Son
  2. The Kindness Nobody Can Repay
  3. What Egypt Turned Into
  4. Tunnels Under the Ground
  5. What They Asked For at the End
Jacob Made Joseph Swear to Carry His Body Out of Egypt Click for full size

He Sent for the Wrong Son

Jacob had seventeen years in Egypt and he spent the last of them getting his affairs in order.

He had already dealt with the two boys Joseph fathered in that country. He took Ephraim and Manasseh onto his knees and adopted them as his own sons, and when Joseph set the elder at his father's right hand, Jacob crossed his arms and put the right hand on the younger and would not be corrected.

Then he came to the thing he actually wanted, and for that he called one son by name.

Not Reuben, who was the firstborn and standing right there. Not Judah, who was the king in everything but title. He passed over both of them and sent for Joseph, and the reason was not affection. Joseph was the one man in that family who could sign a permit. The hour belonged to him. He was the only one who could actually do the thing.

"If I have found favour in your eyes, do not bury me in Egypt."

The Kindness Nobody Can Repay

"It was for your sake I came down here at all," the old man said. "For your sake I said, now I can die. So do this for me as a true act of love. Not because you are frightened of me. Not because it would look bad. Carry me out of the land of idols and put me in the ground where God has made his name live, in the cave where four husbands and four wives lie, and I will be the last of them."

There was a saying about this that everyone in that world knew. If your friend's son dies, sit with him, because your friend is alive and will one day sit with you. If your friend himself dies, let it go. Nothing you do for him now comes back.

Which is why Jacob asked for kindness and truth in the same breath. A kindness done for a dead man is the only kindness that cannot be repaid, and so it is the only one that is entirely true.

His reasons were not sentimental. The soil of Egypt is going to be struck with lice, he said, and they will crawl through my body. And: if I am buried here they will make a god out of me, and punishment falls on the thing worshipped as surely as on the man who worships it. Daniel knew that when Nebuchadnezzar fell on his face in front of him and called for incense and a meal offering, and Daniel would not take any of it. Hiram of Tyre did not know it, said in his heart that he was a god, and ended thrown down on the ground in front of other kings so they could stand and look at him.

The last reason was the coldest. These people bow down to a lamb, he said, and I have been called a lamb. Do not let them earn anything by keeping my bones.

What Egypt Turned Into

Joseph swore it, and the family stayed on, and the country went bad around them.

The Egyptians grew soft and greedy and began to hate the Hebrews for prospering, and then the crown passed to a family that had never met Joseph and owed him nothing. So they put them on the river works, cutting channels to hold the flood off the fields, and on the city walls, and on the ramparts, and on the pyramids, and kept them at it four hundred years, each side waiting to see which of them broke first.

Then one of the sacred scribes came to the king and told him a child was about to be born to the Israelites who would bring Egypt low. The king gave the order that every Hebrew boy was to be thrown in the river, and put Egyptian midwives at the beds of the Hebrew women to make certain of it.

Jacob got his body out of that country. His great-grandchildren did not get theirs out.

Tunnels Under the Ground

The patriarchs all wanted the same soil, and the rabbis who came long after wanted it too, and they said why out loud. The dead of the land of Israel stand up first. A man who dies outside it and is buried outside it has died twice.

Rabbi Simon pushed back. Then the righteous who happen to die abroad are simply cheated, he said, and that cannot be how it works.

So this is what God does for them. He hollows out passages under the earth and shapes them like channels, and the bodies roll along inside those channels, mile after mile, until they come up under the land of Israel. There he puts the breath back into them and they stand.

Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi was walking with Rabbi Eliezer by the gates outside Tiberias when a coffin came up the road from abroad to be buried in the land.

"What has this one gained?" Rabbi said. "You made my inheritance filthy while you were alive, and now you come and defile my land in your death."

"Once he is in the ground here," Rabbi Eliezer said, "God forgives him. The earth of this place atones for the people in it."

What They Asked For at the End

Every one of them left instructions, and the instructions are how you learn what a man was afraid of.

Rabbi Yohanan told the people who would handle his body: bury me in clothes dyed green. Not white and not black. If I am stood up among the righteous I do not want to be shamed, and if I am stood up among the wicked I do not want to be disgraced, and green will do for either line.

Rabbi Yoshiya, dying, said, "Bring me my students." When they were all in the room he told them: bury me in white. I am not ashamed to go and meet my Creator with what I have done.

Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi left three orders. Do not move my widow out of this house. Do not have me eulogized in the towns of the land of Israel. And do not let a stranger touch my bier. The man who looked after me while I was living will look after me now.

He had lived in Tzippori seventeen years, and in those years he kept coming back to one line and reading it out over himself. Jacob lived in the land of Egypt seventeen years.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

3 sources

The texts behind this telling. Some cards carry a translation of the source; others are our own retelling of it, and each card says which. Every card links out to the original.

Antiquities II.9Antiquities of the Jews (Josephus)

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.Antiquities of the Jews, trans. William Whiston · Public Domain

Jacob lived seventeen years in Egypt after reuniting with the son he had mourned as dead. Seventeen years of peace, of proximity to Joseph, of watching his family flourish in the land of Goshen. Then his body failed, and he gathered his sons to deliver a set of prophecies that would shape the destiny of an entire nation.

The Josephus says Jacob foretold where each of his sons' descendants would settle in the land of Canaan, a remarkable act of faith given that his family was currently living as guests in a foreign empire with no immediate prospect of return. He spoke as though the Promised Land was already theirs, because God had said it would be.

Jacob did something unexpected before the blessings. He adopted Joseph's two Egyptian-born sons, Ephraim and Manasseh, elevating them to the same status as his own twelve sons (Genesis 48:5). This doubled Joseph's inheritance and ensured that the boy his brothers had tried to erase from the family would have two tribes bearing his children's names.

The dying patriarch's final praise went to Joseph himself. Jacob spoke at length about how Joseph had never used his power to take revenge on the brothers who sold him into slavery. Instead, Joseph had showered them with gifts and land and protection. In Jacob's telling, this restraint was Joseph's greatest achievement, not the interpretation of dreams, not the governance of Egypt, but the decision to repay cruelty with kindness.

Jacob's last request was to be buried not in Egypt but in Hebron, in the cave of Machpelah alongside Abraham and Isaac (Genesis 49:29-31). He died at one hundred and forty-seven years old, and Pharaoh granted Joseph permission to carry his father's body back to Canaan for burial, a journey that must have felt like both a homecoming and a farewell.

After the burial, the brothers panicked. With their father gone, they feared Joseph would finally punish them. But Joseph told them what he had said before: he held no grudge, because everything had unfolded according to God's plan. He lived to one hundred and ten, governing Egypt with what Josephus calls "moderation", the quality that made him beloved by Egyptians despite being a foreigner who had arrived in their country as a teenage slave in chains. Before he died, Joseph made his brothers swear an oath: when the Hebrews eventually left Egypt, they would carry his bones with them back to Canaan. It would take four hundred years, but they kept that promise.

Full source
Legends of the Jews 1:358Legends of the Jews

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Legends of the Jews by Louis Ginzberg (1909) · Public Domain

In the twilight of his life, Jacob, also known as Israel, had very specific instructions for his son, Joseph.

We find this poignant scene in Legends of the Jews, Louis Ginzberg's masterful compilation of rabbinic lore. Jacob, nearing his end, makes Joseph swear he won't be buried in Egypt. It’s more than just a request; it’s a heartfelt plea, a final act of devotion.

"If I have found grace in thy sight," Jacob implores Joseph, "bury me not, I pray thee, in Egypt." He emphasizes that his descent into Egypt was solely for Joseph's sake. "Only for thy sake did I come down into Egypt, and for thy sake I spoke, Now I can die.” It's a powerful statement, emphasizing the deep bond between father and son, a bond strong enough to dictate the very place of his eternal rest.

Why not Egypt? It wasn't simply about avoiding foreign soil. Jacob is very clear about his reasoning, instructing Joseph to "carry me out of the land of idolatry, and bury me in the land where God hath caused His Name to dwell." He yearns to be in the land of Israel, the land promised to his ancestors, the land imbued with God's presence. He wants to be laid to rest in a place of holiness.

Jacob also instructs Joseph to "do this for me as a true service of love, and not because thou art afraid, or because decency demands it." What a powerful thing to say! He is not just asking for a favor, but seeking a demonstration of genuine love and respect, a mitzvah (a good deed) performed from the heart. He doesn't want Joseph to fulfill his duty out of obligation or fear, but out of pure, unadulterated love.

And then, there's the specificity of the burial site itself: "and put me to rest in the place in which four husbands and wives are to be buried, I the last of them." He wants to be with his family, his lineage, in the ancestral burial ground. This is more than just a plot of land; it's a connection to his past, his heritage, his very identity. Jacob, surrounded by his loved ones, finally at peace in the land of promise.

Jacob's request is a reminder that even in death, we seek meaning and connection. We yearn for belonging, for a place where we feel rooted, where we can rest alongside those who came before us. It’s a universal desire, expressed here with profound tenderness and a deep sense of Jewish identity. What kind of legacy do we want to leave behind, and where do we want to be remembered?

Full source
Bereshit Rabbah 96:5Bereshit Rabbah

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Sefaria Midrash Rabbah, 2022 · CC-BY

It seems like a strange thing to worry about when, well, we're no longer around to worry about anything. But the story of Jacob, as he nears the end of his life in Egypt, gives us some fascinating insights into this very question.

In (Genesis 47:29), we read that Jacob calls for his son, Joseph, and makes him swear an oath: "Please do not bury me in Egypt." But why Joseph? Why not Reuben, his firstborn, or Judah, the one destined for kingship? Bereshit Rabbah, a classic collection of rabbinic interpretations of Genesis, explores this very question. It suggests that Jacob chose Joseph because he was the one with the power to actually carry out his request. He was in a position of influence in Egypt, capable of ensuring his father's wishes were honored.

Jacob’s request goes further: "Perform kindness and truth with me." Now, what's with the "kindness and truth" part? Is there such a thing as false kindness? The Rabbis, in their characteristic way, explore the nuances. They bring up a folk saying: "If the son of your friend dies, bear with him, because he can repay the kindness. If your friend dies, cast off… because he cannot repay the kindness." In other words, kindness shown after death is a true kindness because there's no expectation of reciprocation. It's pure and selfless.

Why not Egypt? Jacob gives a few reasons, each layered with meaning. One reason is a bit…uncomfortable. He says he doesn't want to be buried in Egypt because the land will eventually be struck with lice, and, well, those lice would swarm his body. Yikes!

Another reason is far more profound. Jacob was concerned that the Egyptians might turn him into an object of idolatrous worship. The Rabbis in Bereshit Rabbah remind us that just as punishment is meted out to those who worship idols, so too is it meted out to the one who is worshipped. They bring examples like Daniel refusing worship from Nebuchadnezzar, and the downfall of Hiram, who declared himself a god.

Jacob also worried that his burial in Egypt might inadvertently grant the Egyptians merit they didn't deserve. They worshipped lambs, and Jacob was likened to a lamb ("Israel is a scattered lamb," says (Jeremiah 50:1)7). The Egyptians' flesh was likened to that of donkeys (Ezekiel 23:20), and "the firstborn of a donkey you shall redeem with a lamb" (Exodus 34:20). The symbolism is complex, but the core idea is that Jacob didn't want his burial to somehow benefit a society steeped in idolatry.

So, why did all the patriarchs – Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob – insist on being buried in the Land of Israel? Rabbi Elazar simply calls them "cryptic matters." But Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi offers an explanation: "I walk before the Lord in the land of the living" (Psalms 116:9). The Land of Israel, he says, is the "land of the living."

Rabbi Ḥelbo, cited in the name of our Rabbis, gives us two reasons: First, the dead of the Land of Israel will be the first to come back to life in the messianic era and enjoy those messianic years. Second, Rabbi Ḥanina adds that someone who dies outside the Land of Israel and is buried there undergoes "two deaths" – death and burial, as exemplified by the prophet Jeremiah's words about Pashhur (Jeremiah 20:6).

But what about those righteous people who do die outside the Land? Are they out of luck? Rabbi Simon offers a remarkable image: God makes tunnels and channels in the earth, and the bodies of the righteous roll through them until they reach the Land of Israel! Then, God breathes life back into them. As (Ezekiel 37:12) states, "Behold, I am opening your graves, and I will take you up from your graves, My people, and I will bring you to the soil of Israel." Then, "I will place My spirit into you and you will live" (Ezekiel 37:14). Reish Lakish finds further support in (Isaiah 42:5), "Who places a soul in the people upon it."

There's even a story about Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi and Rabbi Eliezer encountering a coffin being brought from outside the Land to be buried in Tiberias. Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi wasn't impressed, suggesting the person had defiled the land in life and continued to do so in death. But Rabbi Eliezer countered that burial in the Land of Israel atones for their sins, citing (Deuteronomy 32:43): "His earth will atone for his people."

Even on his deathbed, Rabbi Yoḥanan was concerned with appearances, asking to be buried in green garments, "so if I stand among the righteous we will not be shamed, and if I stand among the wicked we will not be disgraced." Rabbi Yoshiya, on the other hand, had no such qualms, requesting to be buried in white, "Because I am not ashamed to greet my Creator because of my actions."

The story of Jacob's request, and the Rabbis' interpretations, reveal a deep connection between the Jewish people and the Land of Israel, a connection that transcends even death. It's a connection rooted in history, destiny, and a profound belief in the power of the land to bring about redemption. It prompts us to consider what truly matters in life, and what kind of legacy we hope to leave behind, even after we're gone.

Full source