Parshat Vaera5 min read

Moses Sat on God's Throne While God Stepped Aside

At Sinai's peak, Philo pictures Moses seeing a cloud-high throne, receiving a scepter and crown, and watching the figure who had been sitting there step away.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. Philo Put a Throne at the Summit
  2. Ben Sira Knew the Older Claim
  3. Thirty Thousand Angels and the Fiery Gates
  4. The Cloud That Swallowed Him

The figure on the throne was not waiting for Moses to approach. He was waiting for Moses to sit.

Philo of Alexandria, writing in the first century CE, follows Moses past the tablets, past the commandments, past everything the Sinai narrative in Exodus stops to record, to a throne so vast its top reached through the clouds of heaven. What happens there is not recorded in the plain text of scripture. Philo found it in the logic of Moses's elevation, in the verse from Exodus 7:1 where God tells Moses I place you in the role of God to Pharaoh, and in the accumulated weight of what the tradition said this man had become.

Philo Put a Throne at the Summit

Life of Moses 1:155-158, Philo's biographical and philosophical account of Moses composed in Alexandria, gives the scene with characteristic restraint. Moses climbs the peak. He sees a figure of noble bearing seated on a throne that touches the clouds. The figure wears a crown. He holds a scepter. He calls Moses forward, hands him the scepter, places a crown on Moses's head, and withdraws. The throne is now empty except for Moses.

The withdrawal is the shock. Moses is not merely receiving authority. He is being seated in the place where authority resides. Philo reads this as the logical extension of the divine declaration in Exodus 7:1. To be placed in the role of God to Pharaoh was a legal formulation about delegated power. In Philo's reading, that delegation was not figurative. Moses's face shone with divine radiance after Sinai (Exodus 34:30) because he had been in contact with divine fire at its source. He came back carrying something that had changed his face.

Ben Sira Knew the Older Claim

Ben Sira, composed in Hebrew around the early second century BCE and preserved in the Apocrypha, describes the same elevation in different terms. Chapter 45 says God honored Moses and strengthened him in the heights. With his words, the letters sped up. He stood before Pharaoh strengthened by God. The people saw his glory. This is the biography of a man whose power over language was not a personal gift but a transmitted one. God gave Moses his words. The letters moved faster because of what was behind them.

Ben Sira does not describe the throne. It describes the effect: glory visible enough for the people to see, strength sufficient to face Pharaoh, an elevation into the heights that left marks on Moses that others could observe. The Philo account makes explicit what Ben Sira leaves implicit in the imagery of height and honor.

Thirty Thousand Angels and the Fiery Gates

The Legends of the Jews, Louis Ginzberg's early twentieth-century synthesis drawing on midrash, Talmud, and later sources, turns Moses's ascent into a gauntlet. God sent thirty thousand angels to escort Moses upward, fifteen thousand to his right and fifteen thousand to his left. Moses was terrified. He cried out to Metatron, the angel who had been Enoch before his transformation, who identified himself as Moses's ancestor and the one charged by God to accompany him to the throne.

The gates of the lower heavens were guarded. The first angel Moses encountered was Qemuel, commander of twelve thousand angels of destruction who challenged Moses immediately: you come from a place of defilement and dare walk in a place of purity. Moses answered simply: I am the son of Amram, and I have come to receive the Torah for Israel. Higher up was Hadarniel, who stood sixty thousand parasangs above the other angels, whose every word sent twelve thousand sparks of lightning into the air. Moses was afraid of him. God rebuked Hadarniel, and he became Moses's guide.

In the seventh heaven, Moses beheld the Hayyot, the holy living creatures that support the throne of God. He met Zagzagel, the prince of Torah, the angel of wisdom whose task was to teach Torah in seventy languages to the souls of humankind. The Torah existed up there before Moses arrived to carry it down. His ascent was a retrieval operation, not a commission. He went up to take back what had always been destined for Israel.

The Cloud That Swallowed Him

The Chronicles of Jerahmeel, a twelfth-century Hebrew chronicle drawing on earlier Jewish legendary material and translated by Moses Gaster in 1899, describes the moment Moses first encountered the cloud at the top of Sinai. He did not know whether to ride it or grab hold of it. The cloud opened, swallowed him inside, and carried him upward. Then Moses walked across the firmament the way a person walks across the earth. He was inside the sky. It supported him the way ground supports a man who has not yet thought about whether the ground will hold.

This is the kind of detail the Philo account leaves out. Philo gives the throne and the crown and the withdrawal of the figure who was sitting there. The Jerahmeel account gives the physical texture of an ascent that was strange enough to require improvisation at every step. Together they describe the same journey from two different angles: the philosophical summit and the terrifying approach to it.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

5 sources

The texts this telling draws on, in full. Open a card to read inline, or expand it for a wider, quieter read.

Life of Moses 1:155-158Philo of Alexandria

It sounds radical, I know.

Some accounts say God bestowed immense honor upon Moses, gifting him dominion over the entire earth, the seas, the rivers – all the elements themselves. He granted Moses the world as a fitting inheritance, proclaiming him both God and King of the entire nation. As it says in (Exodus 7:1), "See, I place you in the role of God to Pharaoh."

Moses entering the darkness where God resided, perceiving realities beyond the grasp of ordinary humans. He dwelt within those mysteries until he was crowned with light, adorned in a radiant robe, his face shining with a divine beam.

The story continues that when Moses ascended to the peak of Mount Sinai, he beheld a throne of such immense scale that it touched the very clouds of heaven. Upon it sat a figure of noble bearing, crowned and holding a scepter. With a gesture, this being beckoned Moses forward. Moses approached and stood before the throne. The figure then handed the scepter to Moses, inviting him to ascend the throne and bestowing upon him a crown of light. Then, the figure withdrew.

And Moses sat upon the great throne, and wrote what his Lord had taught him.

This powerful imagery echoes similar enthronement myths surrounding other pivotal figures in Jewish tradition, like Adam, Enoch, Jacob, and King David.

Now, who was the figure on the throne? Some interpretations suggest it was a manifestation of the Kavod (כָּבוֹד), the Glory of the Lord. Think of Ezekiel's vision in (Ezekiel 1:26-28), where he describes a human-like figure seated upon a sapphire throne. It's a powerful image of divine presence.

Philo, a Hellenistic Jewish philosopher, even saw Moses as transcending the role of prophet, approaching a messianic or divine status. In this astonishing myth, Moses is invited to take the place of the enthroned figure who clearly seems to represent God.

While these ideas might seem unusual within mainstream rabbinic Judaism, similar traditions are found in Samaritan texts like Memar Markah and Samaritan hymns. The Samaritans, a Palestinian sect closely related to Judaism, held Moses in incredibly high regard, almost as a messianic figure. So, it's perhaps not entirely surprising that their texts sometimes elevate Moses to a godlike status.

Ezekiel the Tragedian even describes the actual enthronement of Moses. At the end of the enthronement, it seems as if God turns over His scepter and His throne to Moses and withdraws.

What does it all mean? Is Moses truly elevated to divine status? Perhaps. Or perhaps these stories are powerful metaphors, illustrating the immense authority and responsibility entrusted to Moses, the prophet who brought God's law to the Israelites and shaped their destiny. It's a evidence of the profound impact one human being can have, and the ways in which that impact can be interpreted, generation after generation.

Full source
Ben Sira 45:6Ben Sira

Ben Sira chapter 45 gives us a glimpse, a whisper of what it meant for Moses and Aaron to be elevated by God.

"And God honored him, and strengthened him in the heights." It begins with Moses. for a second. Honored. Strengthened. Not just on some earthly plane, but "in the heights." It paints a picture of divine empowerment, a soaring elevation beyond the ordinary.

"With his words, the letters He sped up, and He strengthened him before the king; and He commanded the people, and they saw His glory." The text continues, highlighting the power of Moses's words. And not just any words, but the words, the very letters of the divine communication. We see Moses standing before Pharaoh, strengthened by God, his words imbued with a force that commanded attention, a glory that even a hardened king could not ignore. It wasn't just about rhetoric; it was about the divine presence shining through.

"In his faithfulness and his humility, He chose him from all flesh." This is key: faithfulness and humility. It wasn't brute strength or worldly power that earned Moses his place. It was his unwavering devotion, his willingness to submit to a higher purpose, coupled with a profound humility. He was chosen not because of who he was, but because of who he strived to be.

And the intimacy of the divine connection deepens. "And He caused him to hear his voice, and He drew him to the thick cloud." Imagine that moment: standing at the foot of Mount Sinai, the mountain shrouded in a thick cloud, and hearing the very voice of God. As we find in (Exodus 24:18), Moses entered the cloud and was with God for forty days and nights. This isn't just about receiving instructions; it's about a profound, personal encounter with the divine.

"And He placed in his hand the commandment, the Torah of life and understanding; to teach Yaaqov His laws, and His statues and ordinances to Israel." The Torah, the Law, the very essence of Jewish life, placed directly into Moses's hand. This wasn't just a set of rules; it was a "Torah of life and understanding," a guide to living a meaningful, purposeful life, a gift to be shared with Yaaqov (Jacob), a symbolic name for the entire Israelite people.

But Moses wasn't alone in his divinely appointed role.

"And He raised Aharon, he the tribe of Levi, to holiness, and He placed him as an eternal law." Now we turn to Aaron, Moses's brother, elevated to the priesthood, a lineage blessed for generations. The text emphasizes his holiness, his separation for a sacred purpose. As (Numbers 25:13) states, Aaron and his descendants received a "covenant of perpetual priesthood".

So, what does all this mean for us?

These verses from Ben Sira aren't just ancient history. They're a reminder that we all have the potential to be "chosen" in our own way. Not necessarily to lead a nation or receive divine commandments, but to live with faithfulness and humility, to listen for the still, small voice within, and to strive to embody the principles of the Torah in our daily lives. To find our own "heights" where we are strengthened. Perhaps that’s the real message: not that only a select few are capable of greatness, but that greatness lies in the choices we make every day to live with purpose and integrity.

Full source
Legends of the Jews 4:164Legends of the Jews

Moses did not climb through heaven alone. God sent thirty thousand angels to escort him upward.

Moses, our leader, the one who spoke to God on Mount Sinai, is about to begin a journey unlike any other. God Himself commands Metatron, the Angel of the Face – a powerful angel who stands in God's presence – to escort Moses to the celestial realms. Not only that, but God orders thirty thousand angels to serve as Moses' personal bodyguard! Fifteen thousand to his right, fifteen thousand to his left.

Naturally, Moses is terrified. I mean, wouldn’t you be? Overwhelmed by the sheer magnitude of what's happening, Moses cries out to Metatron, "Who art thou?" And the angel replies with a revelation: "I am Enoch, the son of Jared, thy ancestor, and God has charged me to accompany thee to His throne."

Enoch! As Ginzberg tells us in Legends of the Jews, Enoch, of course, is the biblical figure who "walked with God" and then, mysteriously, "was not, for God took him" (Genesis 5:24). Jewish tradition holds that Enoch was transformed into the angel Metatron. What a family reunion this is turning out to be!

But Moses, understandably, still hesitates. "I am but flesh and blood," he protests, "and I cannot look upon the countenance of an angel." He knows his limitations. He remembers the awe-inspiring power he felt on Sinai. He knows the celestial realm is a whole other level.

This is where the story takes an even more incredible turn. To prepare Moses for this unprecedented encounter, Metatron transforms him. According to this legend, Metatron changes Moses' flesh into torches of fire, his eyes into Merkabah (the Divine Chariot) wheels – those mystical chariot wheels we read about in Ezekiel's vision – his strength into an angel's, and his tongue into a flame.

Wow.

Essentially, Moses is being upgraded, transformed into something beyond human, so he can withstand the intensity of the divine presence. Only then, with a retinue of thirty thousand angels flanking him, does Metatron lead Moses into heaven.

What does this story tell us? It speaks to the incredible potential within each of us, the ability to be transformed, to rise above our limitations, to connect with something greater than ourselves. And it reminds us that even the most righteous among us, like Moses, sometimes need help, guidance, and even a little celestial re-engineering, to reach their full potential.

It's a reminder that the journey towards holiness is rarely a solitary one. We are surrounded by a support system, seen and unseen – angels, ancestors, and perhaps even sparks of divine fire within ourselves – ready to help us ascend.

Full source
Legends of the Jews 4:174Legends of the Jews

Some of the Jewish mystical tradition points to a pretty incredible source: the heavens themselves.

Moses, not just receiving the Torah on Mount Sinai, but first journeying through all seven heavens. What did he see there? Ginzberg’s Legends of the Jews paints a breathtaking picture.

In the seventh heaven, the highest of them all, Moses beholds the Hayyot, the holy living creatures that support the very throne of God. It’s a vision of immense power and majesty, a glimpse into the divine engine room. But it gets even more fascinating.

He also encounters Zagzagel. Who is Zagzagel? Well, he’s described as the prince of the Torah, the angel of wisdom. And his job? To teach the Torah in seventy languages to the souls of humankind. Think of it! Before we even get here, our souls are already learning the divine precepts.

The Zohar tells us that everything has a spiritual counterpart, a celestial blueprint. Zagzagel embodies that for the Torah, ensuring its wisdom permeates all of creation. And according to Ginzberg's retelling, it was from this very angel, this celestial teacher, that Moses himself learned "all the ten mysteries." Moses, the great lawgiver, the prophet who spoke face to face with God, was taught by an angel! It adds another layer to the story, doesn't it? It's not just about divine dictation; it’s about a process of learning, of transmission, of celestial education.

So, Moses has seen these wonders, absorbed these teachings. He’s standing in the presence of God in the highest heaven. And what does he do? He negotiates! "I will not leave the heavens unless Thou grantest me a gift," he says. Talk about chutzpah!

But God, of course, understands. And what does He offer? "I will give thee the Torah, and men shall call it the Law of Moses."

It’s a beautiful exchange. Moses, having witnessed the celestial origins of wisdom, now brings that wisdom down to earth. He doesn't just receive it; he earns it, through his journey, his vision, and his bold request.

And that Torah, that Law of Moses, isn't just a set of rules. It's a gift from the heavens, filtered through the soul of a prophet, and accessible to us all. Perhaps, when we study it, we're not just reading words on a page, but reconnecting with that celestial wisdom, that spark of divine knowledge that Zagzagel planted within us long ago.

Full source
Chronicles of Jerahmeel LIIChronicles of Jerahmeel (Gaster, 1899)

When Moses ascended to heaven to receive the Torah, a cloud crouched before him like a living creature. He did not know whether to ride it or grab hold of it. The cloud opened, swallowed him inside, and carried him upward. Then Moses walked across the firmament the way a person walks across the earth.

The first angel he encountered was Qemuel, commander of 12,000 angels of destruction who guard the gates of heaven. Qemuel rebuked him immediately. "You come from a place of defilement and dare walk in this place of purity? What is one born of woman doing in a place of fire?" Moses answered simply: "I am the son of Amram, and I have come to receive the Torah for Israel."

Next came Hadarniel, who stood 60,000 parasangs above the other angels. Every word Hadarniel spoke sent 12,000 sparks of fire flying from his mouth. Moses heard that voice and wept, trembling so violently he nearly fell from the cloud. But God intervened, telling Hadarniel that the angels had been nothing but accusers since the day of creation, and that without Israel receiving the Torah, neither God nor the angels would have a dwelling in the firmament at all.

Hadarniel immediately became Moses' guide, walking before him like a student before a teacher, until they reached the fire of Sandalphon. This angel stands so far above his peers that it would take a journey of 500 years to cross from his head to his feet. Sandalphon weaves crowns of prayer for God from the words of Israel, and when the crown reaches the Throne of Glory, every heavenly host trembles.

Moses pressed on through the river Rigyon, a stream of fire where angels are born and consumed daily, and past the angels of terror that surround the Throne of Glory itself. They tried to burn him with their breath, but God spread the glory of His throne around Moses like a shield. Moses challenged them: "What use is the Torah to you? The Exodus does not apply to you. You do not worship idols or swear false oaths." At that, every angel became his friend. Each one handed him a secret, and even the angel of death revealed his own mystery. Then God opened the seven firmaments, showed Moses the heavenly temple, and sent him back down carrying the Torah like a captured bride, while 120 myriads of angels placed two crowns on every Israelite who said, "We shall do and we shall obey."

Full source