4 min read

Reuben Violated His Father's Bed and Was Struck for Seven Months

The firstborn was thirty years old when he committed the act. God struck him with a plague in his loins. Jacob's prayer saved his life.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. The Firstborn Who Knew Better
  2. What Bilhah Did
  3. The Plague That Lasted Seven Months
  4. The Confession at the End

The Firstborn Who Knew Better

Reuben was thirty years old. Not a young man acting in ignorance, not a boy carried away by something he could not name. He was Jacob's firstborn, the one who held the double portion and the priestly claim and the leadership of the brothers by right of birth. He was the one who had stood between Joseph and death at Dothan and said to his brothers: do not shed blood. He was a man who understood the difference between what was permitted and what was not.

He entered Bilhah's tent while his father was absent.

What Bilhah Did

She woke and understood what was happening and pulled her hand back from him and he fled. She did not consent. She told Jacob what had happened. Jacob heard her, and he was exceedingly wroth, and from that day he did not touch Bilhah again. Her shame and her release from Reuben's grip in the dark when she recognized him, these the tradition recorded without elaboration, simply and plainly.

A law was being built around this moment, the tradition said, even though no Sinai had yet occurred. The prohibition against a son lying with his father's wife was written in heaven before it was written on earth. Reuben had violated a law whose full weight would not be announced to Israel for another generation. But the law was real before it was announced.

The Plague That Lasted Seven Months

God struck Reuben with a plague in his loins. For seven months he suffered, and the suffering was not ambiguous in its source. He had violated the sanctity of his father's household in the most direct way possible, had reached for a place he had no right to enter, and the body that had done this was the body that was punished.

Jacob prayed for him. The man who had been wronged beyond measure, the father whose household had been violated, whose grief over Rachel's death had barely settled before his firstborn did this, that man prayed for his son's recovery. He prayed, and after seven months Reuben was healed. He would never recover the things he had forfeited: the birthright, the double portion, the priestly claim. Those Jacob removed without public declaration, quietly, and they would be given in the end to Joseph and Levi and Judah. But Reuben's life was preserved because his father asked for it.

The Confession at the End

When Reuben was dying, at one hundred and twenty-five years old, he called his sons to him and told them what he had never said plainly while he was at full strength. He confessed the act. He called God as witness. He told his children: at thirty years old I defiled my father's bed. Walk not in the sins of youth and lust as I did. He named the seven spirits of deceit that had worked through him. He told his sons to fear God and to flee fornication.

The confession was his final act of authority. He had spent ninety years living under the consequence of a single night. He used his last speech to make sure none of his descendants repeated what he had done.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

3 sources

The texts this telling draws on, in full. Open a card to read inline, or expand it for a wider, quieter read.

Book of Jubilees 33:6Book of Jubilees

Book of Jubilees turns to Reuben's Secret Sin Against His Father's Bed.

One such moment, a rather uncomfortable one found in the Book of Jubilees. Now, the Book of Jubilees isn't part of the standard biblical canon for most Jewish and some traditions, but it's a fascinating text that expands on the stories in Genesis. It offers a unique perspective on the lives of our ancestors.

Our story centers on Jacob, his son Reuben, and Bilhah, one of Jacob's wives.

Here's what unfolds, according to Jubilees chapter 33: Bilhah, seemingly unknowingly, finds herself in an intimate situation with Reuben. The verse reads, "and discovered that it was Reuben. And she was ashamed because of him, and released her hand from him, and he fled. And she lamented because of this thing exceedingly, and did not tell it to any one." The shame, the confusion, the immediate impulse to keep it a secret. Can you imagine the turmoil she must have felt?

Then, when Jacob returns and looks for her, Bilhah is faced with a terrible choice. She explains to Jacob, "I am not clean for thee, for I have been defiled as regards thee; for Reuben hath defiled me, and hath lain with me in the night, and I was asleep, and did not discover until he uncovered my skirt and slept with me."

The accusation is stark, and the consequences are far-reaching. The phrase "uncovered his father's skirt" is a euphemism; we see it used elsewhere in the Hebrew Bible to refer to incestuous relationships. Jacob, understandably, is furious. "And Jacob was exceedingly wroth with Reuben because he had lain with Bilhah, because he had uncovered his father's skirt."

The implications are enormous. This act, whether intentional or not (and the text leaves room for interpretation), has severe repercussions for Reuben's status within the family.

What's interesting is how this story is told. It’s direct, almost blunt. There isn't a lot of emotional exposition, leaving us to fill in the gaps. We're left to ponder the motivations, the uncertainties, and the long-term effects of this event on the family dynamic.

Why does this somewhat obscure passage matter? It reminds us that even in the stories we hold sacred, the people involved were flawed, vulnerable, and capable of making mistakes. It is a reminder that the human experience, with all its complexities and imperfections, is woven into the very fabric of our traditions. It humanizes the biblical narrative, making it all the more relatable.

The story of Reuben and Bilhah in Jubilees 33 is a challenging one, no doubt. But it's also a reminder that confronting these difficult stories can deepen our understanding of ourselves, our history, and the enduring power of the human spirit to navigate even the most turbulent waters. What do you make of this difficult story? What does it tell us about family, power, and the ever-present shadow of human fallibility?

Full source
Book of Jubilees 33:17Book of Jubilees

Book of Jubilees turns to Reuben and the Patriarchs of Bilhah.

Chapter 33. It's a short passage, but it packs a punch. The core message? Incest is absolutely, unequivocally forbidden. And the penalty? Well, it's pretty stark: ".to no man who doeth so in Israel is it permitted to remain alive a single day on the earth, for he is abominable and unclean." But then it gets interesting. The text anticipates a potential objection. What about Reuben? You remember Reuben, Jacob's eldest son? The Torah tells us he "lay with Bilhah his father's concubine" (Genesis 35:22). It’s a messy situation, to say the least. So, the Book of Jubilees asks: why was Reuben seemingly granted life and forgiveness? And what about Bilhah herself? She had a husband. Jacob, still very much alive.

The answer the text offers is fascinating. ".until that time there had not been revealed the ordinance and judgment and law in its completeness for all…" In other words, the full weight of the law hadn't yet been revealed. It was a time of transition, a period before the definitive rules were laid down. Think of it like the early days of a new game. You're still figuring out the rules, experimenting with the boundaries. But once the rulebook is finalized, everything changes.

The Book of Jubilees declares that now, in the author's time, the law has been revealed. It's complete. It's a "law of seasons and of days, and an everlasting law for the everlasting generations." This isn't just a temporary guideline. This is the standard, forever and always.

What’s so interesting is the implied argument here. The author of Jubilees isn't just stating a law. They are actively defending it, anticipating challenges, and providing a justification for its perceived inconsistencies with earlier narratives. They are confronting the complexities of tradition and trying to make sense of the past in light of the present.

And doesn’t that resonate with us today? We, too, are constantly re-evaluating our values, revisiting our understanding of right and wrong. We look to our traditions for guidance, but we also wrestle with their complexities, seeking to create a moral framework that is both rooted in the past and relevant to the present.

The Book of Jubilees reminds us that morality isn't static. It evolves. It deepens. And sometimes, it requires us to confront uncomfortable truths about our own history as we strive to build a more just and compassionate future.

Full source
Testament of ReubenTestaments of the Twelve Patriarchs

Reuben, firstborn son of Jacob and Leah, lay dying in the hundred and twenty-fifth year of his life. Two years had passed since Joseph fell asleep forever. Now Reuben's own sons gathered at his bedside, along with his brothers Judah, Gad, and Asher. The old man raised himself up, kissed each of them, and spoke.

"Raise me up," he said, "that I may tell you what I have hidden in my heart."

What he had hidden was shame.

"I call the God of heaven as witness against you this day," Reuben began, "that you walk not in the sins of youth and lust, as I did when I defiled the bed of my father Jacob." He confessed it plainly: at thirty years old, he had violated Bilhah, his father's concubine (Genesis 35:22). For this, God struck him with a plague in his loins for seven months. Had Jacob not prayed for his son, the Lord would have destroyed him entirely.

After the sin, Reuben repented for seven years. He drank no wine. He ate no meat, no pleasant food. He mourned ceaselessly, for his transgression was greater than any yet committed in Israel.

Then Reuben revealed what he had learned in his repentance: the seven spirits of deceit that wage war against every human soul. Seven dark powers, each one seated in the body like a parasite. The first is the spirit of lust, rooted in the senses. The second is the spirit of insatiable appetite, lodged in the belly. The third is the spirit of fighting, coiled in the liver and gall. The fourth is the spirit of flattery and manipulation, making a person seem fair while scheming underneath. The fifth is the spirit of pride, breeding arrogance. The sixth is the spirit of lying, poisoning relationships with deceit and jealousy. The seventh is the spirit of injustice, driving theft and greed, working hand-in-hand with all the others.

And over all of them hovers an eighth spirit: the spirit of sleep, which brings the trance of fantasy and error, darkening the mind of every young person until they cannot see the truth of God's law.

"Pay no heed to the face of a woman," Reuben warned. "Do not associate with another man's wife. Do not meddle with affairs of womankind." He explained his own fall: he had seen Bilhah bathing in a covered place, and the image burned in his mind until he could not sleep. While Jacob had gone to visit Isaac, and the family was camped near Ephrath in Bethlehem, Bilhah became drunk and fell asleep uncovered. Reuben entered her chamber. He committed the act without her perceiving it, and departed. But an angel of God immediately revealed the crime to Jacob, who came and mourned over his son and never touched Bilhah again.

The shame was total. "Until my father's death," Reuben said, "I had not boldness to look in his face, or to speak to any of my brethren." Even now, on his deathbed, his conscience still tormented him.

He pointed to Joseph as the counterexample. The Egyptian woman had done everything to seduce him: summoned magicians, offered love potions. But the purpose of Joseph's soul admitted no evil desire. "If lust overcomes not your mind," Reuben declared, "neither can Beliar overcome you."

Reuben then spoke of the Watchers, those angels who existed before the Flood. They gazed upon mortal women continually, lusted after them, and changed themselves into the shape of men. The women, desiring these beings who seemed to reach unto heaven, gave birth to giants (Genesis 6:1-4). This was the ultimate corruption: even celestial beings fell through the power of lust.

"God gave sovereignty to Levi," Reuben told his sons. "Hearken to Levi, because he shall know the law of the Lord and shall give ordinances of judgment and shall sacrifice for all Israel as the anointed High Priest." He commanded them to do truth to their neighbors, to love one another, and to draw near to Levi in humbleness of heart.

Having given these commands, Reuben died. They placed him in a coffin and carried him up from Egypt to be buried in Hebron, in the cave where his father lay.

Full source