6 min read

Hananya, Mishael, and Azarya Were Held to an Oath Sworn at Sinai

The king gave them three chances to bow. They told him their God might not save them, and that it made no difference to what they were going to do.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. Three Chances to Bow
  2. The Blood Moses Divided in Half
  3. The Sword Drawn Over the Oath
  4. Zedekiah Broke an Oath and Lost His Eyes
  5. The Blood of Your Covenant
Hananya, Mishael, and Azarya Were Held to an Oath Sworn at Sinai Click for full size

Three Chances to Bow

Nebuchadnezzar did not want them dead. He wanted them bent, once, briefly, with the music playing loud enough to cover it.

He offered it in front of the whole assembled apparatus of his empire, and when they did not take it he offered again, and again. The furnace stood lit behind him the entire time. It would have cost them one motion of the spine, and instead three young Judeans told a king who could burn them within the minute that they had no need to answer him on this matter. Their God was able to bring them out of the fire. And if He did not, they said, it changed nothing at all. They were not going to serve his gods or bow to the gold he had set up.

Hananya, Mishael and Azarya promised heaven nothing and claimed to know nothing. They only said what they would not do.

The Blood Moses Divided in Half

What stood behind that refusal was six hundred years old and had been sealed in blood at the foot of a mountain.

Moses got up early that morning and built an altar under Sinai and stood up twelve pillars for the twelve tribes. He offered burnt offerings and peace offerings. Then he took the blood and divided it exactly in half.

How a man measures half a basin of blood by eye is a question the rabbis would not let alone. One said the blood divided itself. One said it changed color while he looked at it, half going black and half staying red. One said an angel came down wearing Moses' own face and did the dividing for him. One said a voice came out of Horeb and called, "Half the blood is to here." One said Moses knew the laws of blood better than any man alive and simply knew. On the basins they agreed. The two vessels were the same size, neither larger than the other, so that no one could argue afterward about whose share had been bigger.

Then Moses stopped and asked what to do with them. "What is to be done with Your portion?" he said. "Sprinkle it on the people." "And with theirs?" "Throw it against the altar." Each side of the agreement went home wearing the other side's blood.

He had read the terms out first. Sabbatical years, jubilee years, blessings, curses, down to the closing line about the statutes given between God and the children of Israel. Some said he read further back than that, all the way to the opening of Genesis. The people answered that they took it on themselves. Then the blood went over them and he told them what they now were. "You are tied," he said. "You are bound. You are held fast. Tomorrow come and take on the rest of it."

The Sword Drawn Over the Oath

Rabbi Yohanan put the terms of it plainly. The two of them had made a commitment between them, that He would not disavow Israel and Israel would not disavow Him.

Rabbi Yitzhak gave the picture. When a king swears his legions in, he does it with the sword out, so that every man taking the oath can see the blade and understand exactly where it will pass if he breaks his word.

The word for what Israel walked into that day was ala, and the rabbis fixed its meaning from the harshest place available to them. A priest stands a woman accused by her husband in front of the sanctuary, with no witness against her and nothing proved, and puts her under the oath of ala, and if she has lied her own body will publish it. That is the weight of the word. Not a pledge. A binding under curse, with the consequence written into flesh.

Zedekiah Broke an Oath and Lost His Eyes

Judah had produced its demonstration of the cost already, one king earlier, at the hands of the same emperor and in the same city where the three of them were now standing.

Zedekiah had sworn allegiance to Nebuchadnezzar and then broken it. He was caught on the run, and the Babylonians put his eyes out. He had broken two oaths, the recent one to the king and the old one at the mountain, and the blinding was read as payment laid on top of payment, sentence upon sentence. The verse said it would be placed on his head, and the rabbis asked why only the head, and answered that the eyes sit in the head. A man is punished through the part of him that swore.

The Blood of Your Covenant

So three men walked into a furnace in Babylon holding up their half of an agreement none of them had signed, and no one alive had watched being made.

What God answered them with, the rabbis found in Zechariah: because of the blood of your covenant, I have sent your prisoners out of the pit where there is no water. Not because of your nerve. Because of the blood. The blood at the mountain, split into two basins of exactly equal size, half of it thrown over the people and half of it thrown against the altar, and never once written off from either direction.

The ropes on their arms burned through and dropped away. Nothing else on them was touched, not their coats, not their hair. The king counted the men walking around in the fire and got four.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

4 sources

The texts behind this telling. Some cards carry a translation of the source; others are our own retelling of it, and each card says which. Every card links out to the original.

Vayikra Rabbah 6:5Vayikra Rabbah

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Sefaria Midrash Rabbah, 2022 · CC-BY

The Torah tells us of an agreement, a covenant, between God and the Israelites. But the details, as explored in Vayikra Rabbah, are far more intricate and, frankly, a little.

Rabbi Pinḥas, in his interpretation of the verse regarding Israel before Mount Sinai, immediately throws us into the heart of the matter. Citing Deuteronomy, he reminds us of the Israelites' sin and the voice of adjuration they heard from the fire. Rabbi Yoḥanan adds a crucial point: this wasn't just a one-sided deal. It was a commitment made on both sides – God wouldn't disavow them, and they wouldn't disavow Him. A mutual promise.

What does this covenant look like? Rabbi Yitzḥak offers a powerful analogy: a king administering an oath to his legions with a sword, a stark reminder of the consequences of breaking the oath. And then comes the fascinating image of Moses and the blood – half sprinkled on the altar, half on the people. How did Moses know how to divide it?

We get a flurry of opinions! Rabbi Yehuda ben Rabbi Ilai suggests the blood divided on its own, miraculously. Rabbi Natan says its appearance changed, half black, half red. Bar Kappara even envisions an angel in the image of Moses doing the dividing! Rabbi Yitzḥak speaks of a voice from Mount Horev. Rabbi Yishmael teaches that Moses was an expert in the halakhot (laws) of blood. What are we to make of all these interpretations? Perhaps it's a way of showing us the multi-faceted nature of divine assistance.

Rabbi Huna, quoting Rabbi Avin, points out a subtle detail in the text: the word for "basins" (baaganot) is written in a way that could also be read as singular (baaganat), implying the basins were of equal size. This seemingly small detail emphasizes the equality of the commitment: God's portion and the people's portion were treated with the same reverence.

Rabbi Berekhya and Rabbi Ḥiyya, citing Rabbi Yosei bar Ḥanina, drive home the point of the mutual oath. God takes an oath to them, referencing Ezekiel, and they take an oath to Him, referencing Deuteronomy. The term ala (אלה), meaning oath, is highlighted, reinforcing the binding nature of this agreement.

So, what happens when the agreement is broken? Well, according to Rabbi Pinḥas, citing Hosea, God is understanding because He is God and not man. Rabbi Ahava bar Ze’eira, in a somewhat comforting thought, referencing Lamentations, said that God only implemented half of his statement concerning the punishment to which Israel would be subject.

Then, Vayikra Rabbah takes a darker turn, discussing the consequences of violating the covenant. Rabbi Berekhya cites Leviticus, mentioning a "sword avenging the vengeance of the covenant." Rabbi Azarya and Rabbi Aḥa, in the name of Rabbi Yoḥanan, connect this to the blinding of King Zedekiah by the Babylonians, a punishment for breaking his oath to Nebuchadnezzar and violating the covenant with God. A double whammy!

But even in the face of exile and suffering, there's a glimmer of hope. Remember Hananya, Mishael, and Azarya, who refused to worship Nebuchadnezzar's idol? Rabbi Pinḥas says that God remembered the blood of the covenant at Sinai and released them from the fiery furnace.

The passage concludes with a powerful reminder of Israel's role as witnesses to God's divinity. If they fail to share this knowledge with the world, they will bear the consequences.

So, what do we take away from this deep dive into Vayikra Rabbah? It's a covenant, a two-way street that demands commitment, responsibility, and a willingness to uphold our end of the bargain. And even when we stumble, there's always the possibility of redemption, a chance to remember the blood of the covenant and renew our commitment.

Full source
Vayikra Rabbah 6:4Vayikra Rabbah

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Sefaria Midrash Rabbah, 2022 · CC-BY

Vayikra Rabbah turns to The Suspected Wife and Her Trial by Sacred Waters.

Our focus is on a rather delicate matter: the sota, the woman suspected of adultery. The Torah dedicates a section to her ordeal (Numbers 5:11-31), a trial by ordeal, really, involving a special mixture and a powerful oath.

Rabbi Yosei bar Ḥanina offers us a glimpse into the motivations and consequences at play here. He begins with the verse, "And if a person will sin…" (Leviticus 5:1). But Rabbi Yosei focuses on the context: "She sinned to her husband, who feeds her and supports her, and she goes and acts corruptly with another."

A violation of trust within the very foundation of a marriage.

The verse continues, "And hear the voice of adjuration…" Rabbi Yosei connects this to the priest administering "the oath of the curse" (Numbers 5:21). This wasn't just any oath; it was a ritualized declaration invoking divine consequences if the woman was indeed guilty.

Then comes a truly intriguing point: "And he is a witness…" Here, Rabbi Yosei references the passage stating, "And there is no witness against her" (Numbers 5:13). No witness, yet divine judgment is invoked.

Rabbi Yosei resolves this beautifully: "And it was hidden from the eyes of her husband," he says, quoting (Numbers 5:13) again, "but not from the eyes of the Holy One, blessed be He." Even if human eyes haven't seen the transgression, even if there's no earthly proof, God sees. There's no hiding from the divine gaze.

The Rabbi continues, "'Or knew' – and she was secluded and she was defiled” (Numbers 5:13). The implication is clear: knowledge of the act, even without direct evidence, plays a role.

Finally, the consequences of silence: "If he does not tell, he shall bear his iniquity." Rabbi Yosei connects this to the grim outcome described later: "If she does not tell the priest, 'her belly shall distend and her thigh shall fall'" (Numbers 5:27). This is a description of a physical manifestation of guilt, a divine punishment for concealing the truth.

What are we to take away from this ancient interpretation? It’s not just about adultery; it’s about the weight of secrets, the inescapable nature of divine awareness, and the consequences of dishonesty. It's a powerful reminder that even when we think we're alone, even when we believe we've gotten away with something, there's a higher power watching, and ultimately, truth will prevail. It's a sobering thought, but also, perhaps, a comforting one. After all, if God sees everything, then God also sees our struggles, our pain, and our genuine efforts to be better.

Full source
Mekhilta Tractate Bachodesh 3:5Mekhilta DeRabbi Yishmael

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.Mechilta, translated by Rabbi Shraga Silverstein · CC-BY

R. Yishmael says: What is written at the beginning, viz. (Leviticus 25:1-3) "And the L–rd spoke to Moses on Mount Sinai, saying … then the land shall rest a Sabbath to the L–rd. Six years shall you sow your field, etc.", sabbatical years, Jubilee years, blessings and curses. What is written at the end? (Ibid. 26:46) "These are the statutes and the ordinances and the Toroth that the L–rd gave between Himself and the children of Israel on Mount Sinai by the hand of Moses." (At this,) they said: We take it upon ourselves. When Moses saw this, he took the blood and sprinkled it on the people, viz. (Exodus 24:8) "And Moses took the blood and sprinkled it upon the people," saying to them: You are (hereby) tied and bound and committed. Tomorrow come and take upon yourselves all of the mitzvoth (commandments). R. Yossi b. R. Yehudah says: On that day all of the acts (of their induction into the covenant) were performed....

Full source
Yalkut Shimoni on Torah 279:1Yalkut Shimoni on Torah

Translation of the source text.Torat Emet (Yalkut Shimoni) · CC-BY-NC

"And the LORD said unto Moses, Go unto the people" [today] - this is the fourth day. "And tomorrow" - this is the fifth day. "And let them be ready for the third day" (Exodus 19:11) - this is the sixth day, on which the Torah was given. And what did Moses do on the fifth? He rose early in the morning and built an altar beneath the mountain, as it is said, "And he rose up early in the morning and built an altar under the mount" (Exodus 24:4), and set up twelve pillars for the twelve tribes of Israel - the words of Rabbi Yehudah. And the Sages say: twelve for each tribe. He built an altar and offered upon it burnt offerings and peace offerings; he took from the blood of the burnt offering in two cups, a portion for the Omnipresent and a portion for the congregation, and from the blood of the peace offerings in two cups, a portion for the Omnipresent and a portion for the congregation, as it is said, "And Moses took half of the blood and put it in basins" (Exodus 24:6) - this is the portion for the Omnipresent - "and half of the blood he sprinkled on the altar" - this is the portion for the congregation. "And he took the book of the covenant," etc., but we have not heard from where he read in their ears. Rabbi Ishmael son of Rabbi Yose says: from the beginning of Genesis until here. Rabbi says: the commandments that Adam the first man was commanded, and the commandments that the sons of Noah were commanded, and the commandments they were commanded in Egypt and at Marah, and all the rest of the commandments. Rabbi Ishmael says: at the beginning of the matter, what does it say? "And the land shall keep a Sabbath unto the LORD... six years you shall sow" (Leviticus 25:2-3) - sabbatical years, jubilees, blessings and curses; at the end of the matter, what does it say? "These are the statutes and the ordinances and the laws," etc. They said: we accept upon ourselves. When he saw that they had accepted upon themselves, he took the blood and sprinkled it upon the people. He said to them: behold, you are bound, tied, and held fast; come quickly and accept upon yourselves all the commandments. Rabbi Yose son of Rabbi Yehudah says: on that same day all these acts were done. "And they washed their garments" - and how do we know they required immersion? Behold, I reason: if in a place where they are not required to wash garments they are required to immerse, here, where one is required to wash garments, is it not logical that they should require immersion? There is no washing of garments in the Torah without requiring immersion. "Go unto the people and sanctify them today and tomorrow" - and what was their sanctification in the wilderness? There were no uncircumcised among them; manna came down to them from heaven; water they drank from the well; clouds of glory surrounded them. Rather, it was concerning the impurity of marital relations, that they should abstain. What did Moses do? He added one day of his own. The Holy One, blessed be He, said to him: Moses, how many souls of Israel were to come into being on that night - rather, let what you have done be done, as it is said, "And let them be ready." A ruling: a man of Israel who betroths a woman, who must pay the fee for writing the document of betrothal? Thus the Sages taught: one does not write a document of betrothal and marriage except with the consent of both parties, and the groom gives the fee. And from whom did they learn it? From the Holy One, blessed be He, at the time He betrothed Israel at Sinai, for thus He wrote, "Go unto the people and sanctify them." And who wrote the document for them? This is Moses, as it is said, "And Moses wrote this law" (Deuteronomy 31:9). And what reward did the Holy One, blessed be He, give him? The shining of the face, as it is written, "And Moses knew not that the skin of his face shone" (Exodus 34:29).

Full source