Parshat Beshalach6 min read

Amalek Waited Outside the Seven Clouds of Glory for Israel to Stumble

Esau told his grandson he had failed to kill Jacob and left him the job. Watch for the stumble, he said. That is the only opening you get.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. The Bones on the Short Road
  2. Seven Walls Around a Nation
  3. The Letters on the Cloud's Arms
  4. Esau's Advice to His Grandson
  5. The Day the Walls Came Down
Amalek Waited Outside the Seven Clouds of Glory for Israel to Stumble Click for full size

The Bones on the Short Road

There was a fast way out of Egypt. Up the coast, past the Philistine towns, into Canaan in a matter of days. God would not let them take it.

Bones were lying on that road. Two hundred thousand fighting men of the tribe of Ephraim had counted the four hundred years of the servitude, decided the arithmetic was finished, and walked out of Egypt thirty years too early with shields and lances and everything a man needs for a raid. They went down to Gath to take the flocks. The Philistines killed all of them and nobody came back to bury anyone.

So the newly freed slaves were turned south instead, into open desert, the long way, because a column of people three days out of slavery who came around a bend and saw their own relatives bleached along the roadside would have turned around and gone back to Egypt on the spot.

Centuries later a prophet named Ezekiel stood in a valley full of dry bones and was asked whether they could live. Those were the bones.

Seven Walls Around a Nation

What they got instead of the short road was a house.

Four clouds stood at the four sides of the camp. One spread over the top, so no hail came down on them and no rain and the sun did not burn them. One lay underneath, so that in forty years of walking across a desert nobody put a foot on a thorn or a snake or a scorpion.

The seventh went out in front and did the work. It filled in the valleys and it took the hills down flat. It killed the snakes and the scorpions along the route before anyone arrived. It swept the road and sprinkled it so the dust would not rise in their faces.

Inside that enclosure nobody needed to light anything for forty years. If a man went into the darkest room he had, a beam of the cloud came in after him. If he had to walk out past the edge of the camp at night, a fold of it detached and went with him and covered him until he came back.

It went with Israel and no one else. The mixed crowd that had come up out of Egypt with them walked outside the walls.

The Letters on the Cloud's Arms

The seventh cloud had arms.

Four banners stood at the four points of the camp. Judah in the east under a lion. Reuben in the south under the figure of a man. Ephraim in the west under a fish. Dan in the north under a serpent. On the top of each pole were hooks of gold that came to a point like a spearhead, and on each of those points an arm of the cloud rested, and each arm had three letters cut into it, one for Abraham, one for Isaac, one for Jacob, and the letters burned with the light of the Shechinah (the settled presence of God).

One letter was left over. It was the He that God had taken out of His own name and added to Abram's. That letter was set with a Yod on the cloud that stood above the ark, and the two of them together spell the Name that the world was made with. That cloud went around the camps all week and lit them like the sun by day and like the moon at night, so people could still tell which was which.

When it was time to move, the cloud with those two letters lifted off the ark, and the four lettered clouds pulled off the banner tops and followed it. The priests saw them go and blew the trumpets, and the four winds of the earth blew myrrh and frankincense down the line of march.

Esau's Advice to His Grandson

Outside all of this, somebody was watching for a gap.

Esau had gone to his grave with one piece of business unfinished, and he handed it to his grandson before he died. I took every pain I could and I did not manage to kill Jacob, he said. You will avenge me on his children.

Amalek asked the obvious question. How am I supposed to beat them?

"Watch," Esau said. "The moment you see them stumble, jump."

Amalek made that his whole method. When Israel started asking out loud whether the Lord was among them or not, he appeared. When the spies came back and the camp shouted that they should choose a captain and march back to Egypt, he was there before the shouting stopped.

The Day the Walls Came Down

Then Aaron died on the mountain, and the clouds went with him.

The camp came apart in fear. Nothing had been able to get in at them while the walls stood. Now there was sand on every side and the horizon was visible for the first time in forty years, and every one of them understood at once what that meant.

It meant Amalek. He heard that Aaron was dead and the clouds were gone and he was moving the same day. He came from behind, at the tail of the column, where the exhausted and the slow and the ones who could not keep up were walking without a wall behind them anymore.

He kept the policy for centuries. When Nebuchadnezzar's army came up to destroy Jerusalem, Amalek took a position one mile from the city and sat there. If Israel wins, he said, I will say I came to help them. If Babylon wins, I will stand on the road and cut down whoever runs.

Babylon won. He stood at the crossroad and killed the ones who came past him, and shouted things at them about their God while he did it.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

9 sources

The texts behind this telling. Some cards carry a translation of the source; others are our own retelling of it, and each card says which. Every card links out to the original.

Targum Pseudo-Jonathan on Exodus 13:17Targum Pseudo-Jonathan on Exodus

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Targum of Jonathan ben Uzziel, trans. J. W. Etheridge, London, 1862 · Public Domain

The Targum Pseudo-Jonathan on (Exodus 13:17) answers a question the Torah only gestures at. Why did God not send Israel by the short coastal road through the land of the Philistines? It was the nearest route. And yet God turned them south, into the desert.

The Targum tells a story to explain the detour. Long before the Exodus, two hundred thousand men of the tribe of Ephraim had calculated the end of the four hundred years of servitude and decided to leave Egypt early, thirty years before the appointed time. Armed with shields and lances, they marched out and went down to Gath to raid the Philistine flocks. But they had "transgressed against the statute of the Word of the Lord." The Philistines cut them down.

Here the Targum drops an astonishing identification. Those two hundred thousand slaughtered Ephraimites are the same dry bones the prophet Yechezekel later saw resurrected in the vale of Dura (Ezekiel 37:1-14). The vision of the valley of dry bones is the vision of the early-leaving tribe.

So why the detour? Because if the newly freed slaves saw the battlefield strewn with Ephraimite skeletons, they would panic and run back to Egypt. The long way was an act of mercy. God routed His people around a trauma they could not yet bear to see.

Takeaway: the Targum teaches that geography can be pastoral care, and that God sometimes hides the graveyard from the freed.

Full source
Chronicles of Jerahmeel LIIIChronicles of Jerahmeel (Gaster, 1899)

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Chronicles of Jerahmeel, trans. Moses Gaster (1899) · Public Domain

While the Israelites traveled through the wilderness, seven clouds of glory surrounded them on every side. One cloud went in front, one behind, two flanked them on each side, and one hovered above to shield them from the sun and the cold. According to the Chronicles of Jerahmeel, a 12th-century Hebrew chronicle compiled by Jerahmeel ben Solomon and translated by Moses Gaster in 1899, a seventh cloud went ahead of the people, leveling the high places and raising the low ground so that no one would stumble.

The most extraordinary detail involved the four tribal banners and the letters engraved on each arm of that seventh cloud. The banner of Judah stood in the east, shaped like a lion, with golden hooks ending in a sword-like pike. On its arm of the cloud, three Hebrew letters were engraved: Alef for Abraham, Yod for Isaac, and Yod for Jacob. These letters blazed with the light of the Shechinah, the Divine Presence itself.

In the south stood the banner of Reuben, shaped like a man holding mandrakes. The north held the banner of Dan, in the form of a serpent. The west belonged to Ephraim, whose banner took the shape of a fish. Each banner carried its own set of three ancestral letters, drawn from the Hebrew names of the three patriarchs, and each set shone with the Shechinah's radiance.

One letter remained unaccounted for: the He that God had added to Abram's name when He renamed him Abraham. That extra letter was reserved for God's own name. The cloud above Israel carried all twelve tribal letters simultaneously, illuminating the wilderness camp with a light that came from the patriarchs themselves. The Shechinah did not merely protect Israel. It turned the banners of twelve scattered tribes into a single glowing sanctuary in the desert.

Full source
Legends of the Jews 4:354Legends of the Jews

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Legends of the Jews by Louis Ginzberg (1909) · Public Domain

Legends of the Jews turns to Raamses's Journey.

The Exodus begins in Raamses. Moses, living in the city of Mizraim, a journey of forty days away, urges his people to leave. And then, something incredible happens. They cover the distance from Raamses to Succoth – normally a three-day march – in an instant. An instant! What must that have felt like?

Then comes the truly awe-inspiring part. According to Legends of the Jews, that wonderful collection of aggadic tales compiled by Louis Ginzberg, God surrounds them with seven Clouds of Glory. image for a moment. Seven shimmering, protective clouds. Four hovered around them, front, back, and sides. One floated above, shielding them from rain, hail, and the scorching desert sun. Another cloud nestled below, protecting their feet from thorns and snakes.

There was one more cloud, the seventh. This one went ahead of them, smoothing their path, leveling valleys and hills. It’s like God was personally landscaping the desert just for them. This is how they wandered for forty long years.

Now, picture this: No need for lamps or candles. A beam of light from the celestial cloud followed them everywhere, even into the darkest corners. If someone had to leave the camp at night, a fold of the cloud would accompany them, a personal bodyguard of divine light.

But how to tell day from night? Simple. As evening approached, a pillar of fire replaced the cloud. Never, not for a single moment, were the Israelites without guidance. The pillar of fire glowed until the pillar of cloud reappeared in the morning. It was a seamless transition, a constant reminder of God's presence.

But here's a fascinating detail: These clouds of glory and the pillar of fire? They were exclusively for the protection of Israel. As Ginzberg tells us, the "mixed multitude" that joined them had to walk outside the cloud enclosure. A clear distinction. A visible sign of God's special covenant with His people.

About divine protection, about chosenness, and about the responsibility that comes with it.

Full source
Targum Pseudo-Jonathan on Exodus 13:9Targum Pseudo-Jonathan on Exodus

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Targum of Jonathan ben Uzziel, trans. J. W. Etheridge, London, 1862 · Public Domain

The Targum Pseudo-Jonathan on (Exodus 13:9) hears a strange instruction and decodes it into practice. The verse says the deliverance from Egypt shall be "a sign upon your hand, and a memorial between your eyes." The Targumist reads that not as metaphor but as blueprint. The miracle must be inscribed and set forth on the tephilla of the hand, fastened to the top of the left arm, and on the tephilla of the head, set between the eyes on the forehead.

Here the Aramaic paraphrase quietly transforms the verse. What was a poetic memorial in Hebrew becomes tefillin, the black leather boxes Jews still bind each weekday morning. The Targum does not argue for this reading. It simply assumes it: the sign on the hand is the hand-tephilla, the memorial between the eyes is the head-tephilla.

The purpose? "That the law of the Lord may be in thy mouth, because in strength, with a mighty hand, the Lord brought thee forth from Mizraim." The straps around the arm and the box above the brow are not amulets. They are a daily tether to a memory: the hand of a freed slave touching the hand of God that freed it. The Targumist wants the Jew who binds tefillin every morning to feel that the leather on the arm is the continuation of the outstretched arm that split open Egypt.

Takeaway: mitzvot are not abstract. The Targum teaches that a commandment can be a memory you wear on your body.

Full source
Legends of the Jews 5:76Legends of the Jews

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Legends of the Jews by Louis Ginzberg (1909) · Public Domain

The ancient Israelites knew it well, and their experience is a powerful lesson about faith, doubt, and the persistent shadow of enmity.

In Legends of the Jews, when the protective Clouds of Glory vanished after Aaron’s death, a wave of terror swept through the Israelite camp. These weren't just ordinary clouds; they were a divine shield, a constant reminder of God’s presence and protection. No enemy had dared to approach while they were present. But now? Now they were vulnerable.

Who was waiting in the wings to exploit that vulnerability? None other than Amalek.

Amalek isn't just a name; it's a symbol. A symbol of relentless, opportunistic hatred towards Israel. His actions, Ginzberg tells us, were guided by the twisted legacy of his grandfather, Esau. Remember Esau? He never forgave his brother Jacob (later known as Israel). And on his deathbed, Esau charged Amalek with a dark mission: "Avenge me upon his descendants."

Amalek, ever the pragmatist, asked, "How can I possibly defeat Israel?" Esau’s chilling advice: "Wait for them to stumble. The moment you see them falter, attack!"

And that's exactly what Amalek did. He saw the Israelites question, "Is the Lord among us, or not?" – a moment of doubt, a lapse in faith – and he struck. We see this pattern repeated. When the spies returned from scouting the land and the people cried, "Let us make a captain, and let us return into Egypt," – another moment of despair and lack of trust – Amalek was there, ready for battle.

Amalek doesn't fight fair. He doesn't engage in open, honorable combat. He waits for weakness, for moments of doubt, and then he pounces.

The story doesn’t end there. Even in later times, Amalek’s hateful legacy continued. The text describes how, when Nebuchadnezzar marched on Jerusalem to destroy it, Amalek positioned himself just a mile outside the city. His plan? According to Legends of the Jews, he planned to declare support for Israel if they won. But if Nebuchadnezzar prevailed, he would cut off the fleeing Israelites, adding insult to injury with vile insults against God and the people.

Tragically, Nebuchadnezzar was victorious. And Amalek, true to his word, preyed upon the fleeing refugees, embodying the worst kind of opportunism.

What are we to take away from this grim tale? Perhaps it's a reminder that vulnerability invites attack. That doubt weakens our defenses. And that some enemies are relentless, waiting for any opportunity to exploit our weaknesses. It also highlights the importance of faith, and the strength that comes from unwavering trust, even when the protective clouds seem to disappear. Because sometimes, the greatest battles are fought not against external enemies, but against the internal doubts that make us vulnerable in the first place.

Full source
Midrash Tanchuma, Beshalach 3Midrash Tanchuma

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.Townsend 1989 translation of Midrash Tanhuma, S. Buber Recension · CC-BY

And the Lord went before them by day (Exod. 13:21). You find that there were seven clouds of glory in all. And the Lord went before them by day in a pillar of cloud (ibid.) was the first; and Thy cloud standeth over them (Num. 14:14) was the second; In a pillar of cloud (ibid.) was the third; That the cloud tarried (Num. 9:22), the fourth; And the going up of the cloud (Exod. 40:36), the fifth; And whenever the cloud was taken up (ibid., 37), the sixth; and For the cloud of the Lord was upon the Tabernacle (ibid., v. 38) was the seventh. Four of the clouds were at each of the four sides; one was above them, another below them, and the seventh cloud preceded them. The last of the clouds lowered the high places, raised the low places, burnt the serpents and the scorpions, and sprinkled the road (to lay the dust) before them.

Full source
Yalkut Shimoni on Torah 228:1Yalkut Shimoni on Torah

Translation of the source text.Torat Emet (Yalkut Shimoni) · CC-BY-NC

"And the LORD went before them by day" (Exodus 13:21). You thus find that there were seven clouds. "And the LORD went before them by day in a pillar of cloud"; "and Your cloud stands over them" (Numbers 14:14); "and in a pillar of cloud"; "and when the cloud lingered" (Numbers 9:19); "and when the cloud was taken up" (Exodus 40:36); "and if the cloud was not taken up"; "for the cloud of the LORD was upon the Tabernacle" (Exodus 40:38). Behold, there were seven clouds: four from the four directions, one above, one below, and one that traveled before them, raising every low place and lowering every high one, as it is said, "every valley shall be lifted up and every mountain and hill shall be made low," and so forth. And it would strike down snakes and scorpions, and sweep and sprinkle before them. Rabbi Yehudah says: thirteen, two for each direction and two below and one that traveled before them. Rabbi Yoshiyah says: four. Rabbi says: two. "And the LORD went before them by day" - to teach you that by the measure a person measures, so it is measured to him. Abraham accompanied the ministering angels, as it is said (Genesis 18:16), "And Abraham walked with them to send them off," and the Holy One, blessed be He, accompanied His children in the wilderness forty years. Of Abraham it is written (Genesis 18:4), "let a little water be taken," and the Holy One, blessed be He, raised up the well for His children, as it is said, "Then Israel sang." Of Abraham it is written (Genesis 18:5), "and let me take a morsel of bread," and the Holy One, blessed be He, brought down manna for His children, as it is said (Exodus 16:4), "Behold, I will rain down for you bread from heaven." Of Abraham it is written (Genesis 18:7), "And Abraham ran to the herd," and the Holy One, blessed be He, drove the quail to His children, as it is said, "And a wind went forth from the LORD." Of Abraham it is written (Genesis 18:4), "and recline under the tree," and the Holy One, blessed be He, spread out for His children seven clouds of glory, as it is said, "He spread a cloud for a covering." Of Abraham it is written (Genesis 18:8), "and he stood over them," and the Holy One, blessed be He, shielded their houses in Egypt so they would not be struck, as it is said (Exodus 12:23), "and the LORD passed over the entrance." "And the LORD went before them" - is it possible to say so? Has it not already been said, "Do I not fill the heavens and the earth?" and it says (Isaiah 6:3), "And one called to another and said," and so forth, and it says (Ezekiel 43:2), "And behold, the glory of the God of Israel," and so forth? Then what does "and the LORD went before them" teach? Rabbi says: Antoninus would sometimes sit in judgment on the platform until nightfall, and his sons would sit in the dark beside him. After he left the platform he would take the lantern and give light before his sons, and the great ones of his kingdom would approach him and say, "We will take the lantern and give light before your sons," and he would say to them, "No, rather I will take the lantern and give light before my sons, in order to make known to you the affection in which I hold my sons, that you should treat them with honor." So too the Holy One, blessed be He, made known the affection of Israel before the nations of the world, that they should treat them with honor. And it was not enough that they do not treat them with honor, but they put them to death by cruel and strange deaths, one worse than another. Concerning this it says, "And I will gather all the nations and bring them down to the valley of Jehoshaphat," and so forth. I might think it is concerning idolatry, sexual immorality, and bloodshed; therefore it teaches (Joel 4:2), "concerning My people and My inheritance Israel, whom they scattered among the nations," "[and] Egypt shall become a desolation," and so forth; at that hour "[and] Judah shall dwell forever," and it says, "and I will hold their blood guiltless, which I have not held guiltless," when? "and the LORD dwells in Zion" (Joel 4:21). Rav Chisda said: a father who waives his honor, his honor is waived; a master who waives his honor, his honor is not waived. And Rav Yosef said: even a master who waives his honor, his honor is waived, as it is said, "And the LORD went before them by day." Rava said: how can these be compared? There the Holy One, blessed be He, the world is His, He may waive what is His; here the Torah is His. Then Rava said back: yes, the Torah is His, as it is written (Psalms 1:2), "and in His Torah he meditates," and even so he ought to act with deference. Rav Ashi said: even according to the one who says a nasi who waives his honor, his honor is waived, a king who waives his honor, his honor is not waived, as it is said (Deuteronomy 17:15), "you shall surely set a king over you" - that his awe shall be upon you.

Full source
Targum Pseudo-Jonathan on Exodus 12:37Targum Pseudo-Jonathan on Exodus

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Targum of Jonathan ben Uzziel, trans. J. W. Etheridge, London, 1862 · Public Domain

The most famous number in Targum Pseudo-Jonathan's account of the Exodus is seven. On (Exodus 12:37), as Israel moves from Pilusin (Pelusium) toward Succoth, one hundred thirty thousand strong at the core with about six hundred thousand men walking, the Aramaic says they were protected by seven clouds of glory on their four sides.

The arithmetic does not quite add up to seven geometrically, and that is on purpose. The clouds are not simply directional. The Targum enumerates their functions. One cloud above, so that neither hail nor rain fell on them and the sun could not burn them. One cloud beneath, so that thorns, serpents, and scorpions could not hurt their feet. One cloud in front, flattening the valleys and lowering the mountains, preparing a habitation in advance. The remaining clouds went to the sides and the rear.

This image of the clouds became central to rabbinic theology. The Talmud in Sukkah 11b says that the festival of Sukkot commemorates these clouds, the protective canopy under which Israel walked for forty years. The flimsy sukkah roof that Jews build today echoes the original cover: more spiritual than physical, but real enough to protect a nation for four decades.

The Targum also adds a homely detail. The children rode. The six hundred thousand men went on foot, but each man had five children mounted on beasts of burden. Israel did not leave Egypt alone. They left with their families, their sons and daughters, carried out into the desert under the cover of God's glory.

Takeaway: Israel walked out of Egypt inside a traveling cathedral of clouds. Every sukkah ever since is a small reminder of that roof.

Full source
Midrash Tehillim 105:9Midrash Tehillim

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.Rabbi Mike Feuer, Jerusalem Anthology · CC-BY

It sounds like a simple thing, but when you're surrounded by endless sand, under a blazing sun, or a star-filled sky that all looks the same... well, you need a little divine help!

In Midrash Tehillim, a collection of rabbinic teachings on the Book of Psalms, God provided just that. It speaks of a miraculous cloud appearing over the Tabernacle, the portable sanctuary that housed the Ark of the Covenant. But The text says, “A cloud appeared over the screen and fire illuminated the night.”

Rabbi Meir, a prominent sage of the 2nd century, insists there were actually two clouds. He bases this on the verse: "For the cloud of the Lord was upon the tabernacle by day" (Numbers 9:15-23). So, one cloud for the day, presumably to provide shade, and another, fiery one, to illuminate the night! A pretty practical solution. But Rabbi Elazar ben Shamu'a disagrees. He sticks with the idea of a single, shape-shifting cloud that adapted to the time of day. He reads the verse differently, emphasizing the cloud's dual nature: a cloud by day, and a fiery beacon by night.

Then Hezekiah chimes in with another perspective. Perhaps this miraculous cloud and fire underwent changes because of the presence of the "impure and diseased" among the Israelites. This idea suggests that the cloud wasn't just a practical tool, but also a divine indicator, a way for the people to discern not just day from night, but also purity from impurity. It was a visual reminder of their spiritual standing.

But the story doesn’t end there. The Midrash (rabbinic interpretive commentary) then shifts to another miracle: the rock that provided water for the Israelites in the desert. Remember that? Moses striking the rock? Well, Rabbi Chama bar Chanina adds a rather… colorful detail to that story.

He says that initially, when Moses struck the rock, it didn't gush forth water. Oh no. It brought forth blood. And of course, the "mockers of the generation" – there's always a few. – they scoffed, saying, "Now we will put our mouths to it and drink the blood!"

But then, the miracle truly happened. The rock transitioned, and instead of blood, it poured forth life-giving water. And not only that, but this water then washed away the mockers and their mockery, cleansing them, as the verse says, “Streams flooded forth." So, according to Rabbi Chama bar Chanina, the water was a purification as well as a provision.

So, what do we take away from all this? It's more than just a simple children's story about miracles in the desert. It’s about how we interpret those miracles, how we learn from them, and how they reflect our own spiritual state. The cloud, the fire, the rock, the water… they’re all symbols, open to interpretation, inviting us to look deeper into the relationship between God and humanity.

Are these stories literal accounts? Perhaps. Are they allegorical lessons wrapped in a fantastical narrative? Probably. But either way, they offer us a glimpse into the minds of the Rabbis, and a chance to consider how even the simplest of miracles can hold profound meaning.

Full source