Legends of the Jews turns to Benjamin Leaves Egypt.
The climax arrives with the discovery of Joseph's silver cup in Benjamin's sack. Joseph had ordered the cup to be placed there, of course, but Benjamin and his brothers are completely in the dark. The accusation hits them like a thunderbolt.
The brothers are understandably furious. "O thou thief and son of a thief!" they shout at Benjamin, as Ginzberg recounts in Legends of the Jews. They’re not just calling him a thief; they're dragging his mother, Rachel, into it, accusing her of past thievery and suggesting that dishonesty runs in his blood. Harsh words indeed! It's a moment of intense pressure, fueled by fear and desperation.
Benjamin, in his defense, throws back some serious shade of his own. "Is this matter as evil as the matter of the kid of the goats, as the deed of the brethren that sold their own brother into slavery?" Ouch. He’s not just denying the accusation; he's reminding them of their past sins, the time they sold Joseph into slavery. He's essentially saying, "You want to Let's "
It’s a powerful moment because it forces the brothers to confront their past actions. As we see in this brief exchange, the past always has a way of resurfacing, doesn't it? The weight of their guilt, buried for years, is suddenly brought to the surface by Benjamin's sharp retort. Was Benjamin truly innocent? Or was he perhaps a pawn in a much larger game orchestrated by his long-lost brother? What do you think?