Hanina ben Dosa's Prayer That Pulled a Son Back from Fever

Midrash Aggadah Gaster, Exempla of the Rabbis, no. 166; cf. Berakhot 34b

Curated by The Jewish Mythology Team · Published January 17, 2025

The son of Rabbi Yohanan ben Zakkai had fallen dangerously ill. His father, the greatest sage of his generation, prayed — and nothing happened. Yohanan then sent word to a strange, poor mystic who lived alone in the hills: Rabbi Hanina ben Dosa.

Hanina was not a scholar of the first rank. He had no academy, no disciples, no wealth. But he had a reputation for prayer the way other rabbis had reputations for legal brilliance. When Hanina prayed, things happened.

The messenger arrived at Hanina's simple house. Hanina withdrew to an upper room. He prayed — the tradition says he rested his head between his knees in the ancient posture of concentrated plea. And somewhere in Yohanan's household, the son's fever broke.

When Hanina came down, he said simply, "The child will live."

The messenger rode back. Yohanan's wife asked her husband why Hanina's prayer could do what her husband's could not. Yohanan answered, "I am a prince in God's court. He is a slave. The slave has freer access to the Master than the prince does."

Gaster's Exempla (no. 166, 1924) preserves this story as a one-sentence pointer to a longer tradition in Berakhot 34b. The sages kept it close because it pushed against one of their own assumptions. Scholarship does not corner the market on prayer. Sometimes the poor man in the hills, who knows nothing but how to kneel, is heard first.

Themes

Rabbis Prayer Healing Miracles Humility

Continue Reading

Midrash Aggadah Hanina ben Dosa Knows by His Prayer That the Fever Has Broken Hanina ben Dosa, the humble hasid of the first century, was known for prayers that went through the roof. When Rabban Ga... Midrash Aggadah The Burning Bush Formula Against Fever Tractate Shabbat (folio 66, column 2) preserves something most modern readers will find startling: a rabbinic prescripti... Midrash Aggadah When the Sun Moved Backward for Hezekiah King Hezekiah of Judah lay dying. The prophet Isaiah came to his bedside with what should have been the last message: se... Midrash Aggadah The Adder That Died While Biting Rabbi Hanina ben Dosa Rabbi Hanina ben Dosa, the first-century miracle worker whom the Mishnah (Berakhot 5:5) calls a man whose prayers could ... Midrash Aggadah Why Akiva Blessed the Lost Lamp, the Ass, and the Rooster Rabbi Akiva had a saying he repeated so often his disciples knew it by heart: Kol de'avid Rachmana letav avid — "Whateve... Midrash Aggadah Maimonides at the Egyptian Court and the Rank He Refused When Maimonides — Rabbi Moshe ben Maimon, known to Jewish tradition as the Rambam — fled the persecutions in Andalusia a... Midrash Aggadah The Short Prayer and the Long Prayer of Rabbi Eliezer Two men once prayed at length before Rabbi Eliezer. The first stretched his Amidah far beyond the usual length, swaying ... Midrash Aggadah When Rabbi Shimon b. Halafta's Prayer Saved a Baby's Life Rabbi Shimon ben Halafta was invited to a brit milah — the circumcision of an eight-day-old child. He arrived, sat with ... Midrash Aggadah How Rabbi Meir Talked a Serpent Out of Killing Judah HaNasi Rabbi Meir was walking one day when he overheard something no human being is meant to overhear. A bat kol — a heavenly v...