6 min read

David Saw Babylon Coming and Taught Prayer to Rise Without an Altar

The guards would not let the column stop walking. The first ground the exiles were allowed to sit down on was the bank of the Euphrates.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. The Road With No Place to Sit
  2. Books of Sand
  3. The Harps Went Into the Willows
  4. The Fire That Chose Between Two Brothers
  5. Incense Without an Altar

God showed David the fire.

David Saw Babylon Coming and Taught Prayer to Rise Without an Altar Click for full size

Not a figure of speech about fire. The House his son would build, and the second House after it, both of them burning, both of them coming down. Rav Yehuda taught it in the name of Rav: the singer was shown the destructions before the foundation trench was ever dug.

He was at the height of everything. Jerusalem was his. The ark had come up the road with him dancing in front of it. He sat down and wrote a song about a river he would never see, for people who had not been born, about an empire that did not yet have an army big enough to reach him.

The Road With No Place to Sit

They came out of the city in chains and were not allowed to stop.

Not to rest. Not to bury. Not to sit down in the dirt and take the weight off for a minute. The guards kept the column moving and the ones who went down stayed where they went down, and the rest walked on past them. "We are pursued on our necks," they said about it afterward, and they were describing the road, not reaching for an image. The first ground they were permitted to sit on was the bank of the Euphrates.

Jeremiah had walked that far with them.

At the water Nebuzaradan gave him the choice of going on to Babylon or turning back, and Jeremiah turned back, because the people still left in the land had nobody at all. The exiles watched him go. Whatever they had been holding down for the length of that road came up out of them at the river's edge, and Jeremiah swore to them that they had wept the whole way, that not one step of it had been dry.

Books of Sand

Nebuchadnezzar marched the kings of Judah along the bank with their clothes taken off them.

They walked upright anyway. He noticed that. He had books filled with sand brought out and laid across their shoulders, one after another, until the backs bent and the heads came down, and that was the picture he had wanted.

Rabbi Acha bar Abba said that in that hour God came close to putting the world back the way it had been before the first day. Water with no shape. Nothing standing anywhere.

The world stayed. The kings kept walking with the sand on their backs.

The Harps Went Into the Willows

Rabbi Yochanan measured their grief a strange way. At home they had drunk rain and spring water and well water. On the Euphrates they drank the river, and the river killed them, and he weighed one fish out of that water against everything Nebuchadnezzar had done and said the fish was heavier.

Then the guards wanted entertainment.

Sing us one of the songs of Zion. Sing the Temple ones. The Levites who had sung on the Temple steps stood on a foreign riverbank with the instruments still in their hands and looked at the men asking.

They walked to the willows and hung the harps up in the branches and left them there. "How shall we sing the LORD's song in a strange land?" (Psalms 137:4). Nobody sang. The instruments swung over the water and the guards got nothing out of them.

The Fire That Chose Between Two Brothers

That kind of refusal ran in the family, and it had been tested by fire before.

Terach knew a generation ahead of time that one of his sons would be eaten by fire and another would carry a name through the whole world. He did not know which son was which until it happened in front of him.

Abraham stood up in front of the nations and said he belonged to the God of Heaven. They built the furnace for him. He walked out of it with nothing burned.

Haran did the arithmetic first. If Abraham comes out, he thought, I am with Abraham. If Abraham burns, I am with the crowd. He stood and waited for the result. When his brother came out alive, Haran shouted that he was of Abraham's party, and they put him in, and the fire took him at once. An angel carried the body out and laid it down in front of Terach, which is how a father came to bury a son while he was still alive to watch it (Genesis 11:28).

Two men in the same fire. The one who had decided before he knew the answer walked out of it.

Incense Without an Altar

David was writing for people who would be standing where Haran stood, with no way to know in advance whether they would come out.

He knew exactly what he had and what he did not. Some men lean on their own good deeds. Some lean on the merit of their fathers. He asked God to hurry to him, which is what a man says when there is nobody else in the room to say it for him. The officials are all busy with other cases. You are the judge and You are the advocate. Argue my side.

And when the altar was gone and the priests were scattered and nobody alive still knew the exact compound of the spices, there was an evening and there was a voice. "Let my prayer be set forth as incense before You" (Psalms 141:2). Set forth. Sent up. Climbing the way the smoke used to climb, out of a mouth instead of a bowl, off a riverbank instead of a courtyard.

The harps stayed in the willows. The words went up without them.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

4 sources

The texts behind this telling. Some cards carry a translation of the source; others are our own retelling of it, and each card says which. Every card links out to the original.

Midrash Tehillim 5:5Midrash Tehillim

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.Rabbi Mike Feuer, Jerusalem Anthology · CC-BY

Midrash Tehillim, a collection of rabbinic interpretations on the Book of Psalms, offers a glimpse into this very question, particularly in its fifth section.

It begins with a powerful statement: "For You are not a God who desires wickedness; evil cannot dwell with You." It's a declaration of God's inherent goodness. God doesn't delight in wrongdoing, nor can He tolerate evil. This isn't some abstract philosophical concept, but a core tenet of our faith. (Ezekiel 33:11) emphasizes this point: "As I live, says the Lord God, I have no pleasure in the death of the wicked, but that the wicked turn from their ways and live." God desires repentance and life, not destruction. This verse emphasizes God's commitment to giving even the wicked a chance to return.

So, where does anger and punishment fit in? The Midrash (rabbinic interpretive commentary) addresses this head-on, explaining that "the angel in charge of anger is far from God," citing (Isaiah 13:5): "They are coming from a far country, from the end of heaven, even the Lord and the instruments of His indignation." Rabbi Berachiah, in the name of Rabbi Levi, suggests that even God's instruments of wrath are distanced from His essence. It's as if anger is a tool, wielded with purpose, but kept at arm's length from the Divine itself.

The text then uses a compelling analogy: a king with two fierce armies. In (Psalm 3:6), David proclaims, "I will not fear the myriads of troops arrayed against me on every side." But there are other "armies" at play. (Psalm 97:3) tells us, "Fire goes before Him and consumes His foes on every side," and (Habakkuk 3:5) adds, "Before Him goes pestilence, and plague comes after Him." What are we to make of these destructive forces seemingly associated with God?

According to this Midrash, the innermost of these forces is righteousness. (Deuteronomy 24:13) states, "You shall surely give him, and your heart shall not be grieved when you give to him; because that for this thing the Lord your God will bless you in all your work, and in all that you put your hand unto." Righteousness, tzedekah, is the core. It’s not fire or plague, but acts of compassion and justice that are closest to God's heart.

Rabbi Yudan takes it a step further, proclaiming, "I will let you know how powerful righteousness is and how far the reward of those who do righteousness extends." It’s a bold statement, emphasizing the immense power and reach of our good deeds. And it concludes with a reassuring promise: "No harm befalls you."

This isn't a guarantee of a life free from all hardship, of course. But it speaks to a deeper truth: that righteousness creates a protective shield, a spiritual armor against the chaos and negativity of the world. Righteousness aligns us with God's will, and when we are aligned with the Divine, we are, in a very real sense, protected.

What does this all mean for us today? Perhaps it's a reminder that even in the face of anger, hardship, and seemingly divine retribution, the path of righteousness remains our strongest defense. It's a call to choose compassion over condemnation, justice over indifference. Midrash Tehillim invites us to consider what it truly means to be close to God – and to strive to embody that closeness in our daily lives.

Full source
Midrash Tehillim 118:11Midrash Tehillim

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.Rabbi Mike Feuer, Jerusalem Anthology · CC-BY

The Midrash (rabbinic interpretive commentary) teaches us that it's better to trust in God than to rely on the words of even our own parents. Why? Because human understanding is limited, and only God sees the whole picture. The story it uses to illustrate this point is nothing short of epic, a tale of fire, faith, and family.

It all starts with Terach, Abraham's father. Terach, He foresaw that his son Haran would be consumed by fire, and that his son Abraham would become a figure of immense importance, his name echoing throughout the world.

Abraham, a lone figure standing against the tide, declaring his unwavering devotion to the God of Heaven. According to this Midrash, his declaration angered the nations around him so much that they threw him into a fiery furnace! But here's the incredible part: he emerged unscathed. No city, no sanctuary, no fire, no sword could harm him because, as the verse says, "I am the Lord who brought you out." (referencing the Exodus, connecting Abraham's salvation to the future deliverance of the Israelites).

Then there’s Haran. He’s presented as… well, less resolute. The nations come to him and ask him who he is. He hesitates, calculating. "If Abraham escapes," he thinks, "I'll say I'm with Abraham. But if not, I'll side with you." When he sees Abraham miraculously saved, Haran cries out, "I am of Abraham!" But it's too late. He lacks the genuine faith, the inner conviction. He's thrown into the furnace, and this time, the fire consumes him instantly. The angel grabs his body and throws it before his father Terach, fulfilling the verse, "And Haran died before his father Terach" (Bereshit/(Genesis 11:2)8). A brutal and immediate consequence of a divided heart.

The Midrash then adds a layer of complexity. Terach, despite his wisdom, couldn’t foresee everything. He knew Abraham would have a descendant of great significance, but he didn't know whether that descendant would come through a son or a daughter. And here's where Sarah, Abraham's wife, enters the picture. She was the daughter of Haran, tying everything back together in a complex web of fate and family. "And Abram and Nahor took wives for themselves. Yiska was Sarah, and the whole world was filled with her influence” (Genesis 29). This emphasizes Sarah's pivotal role – her influence would fill the world.

So, what’s the takeaway from this fiery tale? It's not just about Abraham's miraculous escape or Haran's tragic end. It's about the power of unwavering faith. As David says in (Psalms 146:3), "Do not put your trust in princes, in human beings, who cannot save." The Midrash uses these powerful stories to drive home the point that true security, true salvation, comes from trusting in something greater than ourselves, something beyond the limitations of human understanding.

Where do we place our trust? Is it in the wisdom of those around us, in our own clever calculations, or in something deeper, something more profound? Perhaps the story of Abraham and Haran is a reminder that sometimes, the greatest strength lies not in hedging our bets, but in taking a leap of faith, even when the flames are rising.

Full source
Midrash Tehillim 137:1Midrash Tehillim

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.Rabbi Mike Feuer, Jerusalem Anthology · CC-BY

Our story today comes from Midrash Tehillim, a collection of interpretations on the Book of Psalms. It's a look at Psalm 137, which starts with the heartbreaking words: "By the rivers of Babylon, there we sat and wept as we remembered Zion." It’s not just a lament, though; it's a window into the soul of a people confronting loss, trauma, and the yearning for redemption.

Rav Yehuda, quoting Rav, tells us that God actually showed David the destructions of both the First and Second Temples. Heavy stuff. The Midrash (rabbinic interpretive commentary) paints a vivid picture of the exiles' journey. When Jeremiah reached the Euphrates, he refused to go with Nebuzaradan to Babylon because he knew the remaining exiles needed him. The exiles, seeing him leave, were heartbroken. Jeremiah swears to them that they cried all the way to Zion. He points out that they were so broken-hearted, they didn't even have a place to sit until they reached the Euphrates. They were forced to keep moving against their will. "We were pursued on our necks," they lamented.

Why did the Israelites cry so much by those rivers? Rabbi Yochanan offers a powerful reason: For them, the loss of even one fish from the Euphrates in Israel was more painful than all the evil Nebuchadnezzar had inflicted. When they were in their own land, they drank only rainwater, natural springs, and well water. In Babylon, they were forced to drink from the waters of the Euphrates, and they died. The exiles wept for those killed by their enemies, those who died on the journey, and those killed by the Euphrates.

The Midrash doesn't shy away from the humiliation. Nebuchadnezzar forced the kings of Judah to walk naked along the riverbanks in chains. When he noticed they were walking upright, he ordered books filled with sand placed on their shoulders until they bent over. "We are pursued on our necks," they cried. Rabbi Acha bar Abba says that at that moment, God almost returned the world to chaos but stayed his hand, saying, "Everything I have created, I have created for these people."

There's a poignant comparison drawn to a king's daughter who refuses a cup from her husband and is banished, only to later regret her pride when married to a leper. The exiled Israelites, in a similar vein, initially refused to sing for their captors, recognizing the sacrilege of performing sacred songs before idols. As Rabbi Yitzhak Bar Tabla puts it, they ultimately chose to bite their fingers rather than desecrate their heritage.

This refusal to compromise their faith came at a cost. Nebuchadnezzar, enraged, hung the corpses of those who refused to play. But despite the horror, they rejoiced that they did not sing before an idol. The Midrash tells us that God swore to Israel, "You have ruled yourselves and cut off your right fingers. Even I… have turned back my right hand because of the enemy, and I will not return it except to remind you."

So, what do we take away from all this? It’s more than just a historical account. It's a profound meditation on loss, resilience, and the enduring power of memory. The Midrash grapples with questions of excessive mourning, reminding us, as Rabbi Joshua says, that "a decree is not issued unless the majority of the congregation can uphold it."

How do we mourn without letting grief consume us? The Sages suggest practical measures: keeping a small reminder of Jerusalem in our homes, like ash on the head of the groom at a wedding, placed where tefillin (leather phylacteries worn during prayer) are worn, as a constant symbol of remembrance. It is taught in the Talmud, Sotah 49b, that a person should forsake everything he has in his house and leave only a small reminder of Jerusalem.

The Midrash Tehillim on Psalm 137 is a reminder that even in the darkest of times, hope and memory can sustain us. It's a call to remember, to mourn, but also to rebuild and to never forget the preciousness of what we hold dear. "If I forget you, O Jerusalem, let my right hand forget its skill."

Full source
Midrash Tehillim 141:1Midrash Tehillim

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.Rabbi Mike Feuer, Jerusalem Anthology · CC-BY

King David knew that feeling, and he gave voice to it in the Psalms. Psalm 141, to be exact. It begins, "I call upon you, O Lord; make haste to me; give ear to my voice when I call to you." But what does it really mean?

The Midrash Tehillim, an ancient collection of interpretations on the Book of Psalms, helps us unpack this powerful verse. It tells us that just as "bright eyes gladden the heart" (Proverbs 15:30), so too does God illuminate the eyes of the righteous, filling them with joy. This joy, it says, is like the satisfaction of "fat and marrowy bones" when receiving good tidings. And what is this good tidings? That "surely the righteous shall give thanks to your name" (Psalm 140:14). David, the Psalmist, yearns to be among those who see God's face.

He doesn't just want to be seen. He wants to be heard. "Make haste to me," he pleads. What does that even mean? The Midrash (rabbinic interpretive commentary) interprets this as a reciprocal desire. David desires to fulfill God's will, and he asks that God also desire him. That our relationship with the Divine isn't just a one-way street.

The Midrash then offers a compelling analogy. All the officials are busy, engaged with others. So, the person directly appeals to the ruler, saying, "I have no one to speak for me. You are the judge and the advocate. Please advocate for me."

David is doing something similar. He acknowledges that some people trust in their good deeds, others in the merit of their ancestors. But David? David trusts in God alone, even though he feels he lacks good deeds. "I have called upon you," he says. Therefore, "make haste to me." It's a raw, vulnerable plea for divine attention and support.

The Psalm continues, "My prayer shall be set before You…" The Midrash explores the meaning of "shall be set." David is speaking from a place of longing, remembering the time when the Temple stood. Back then, they would burn incense before God. But now? Now there's no altar, no High Priest. So, David asks that his prayer be accepted in place of the incense, that it might "tear through the firmament" and reach God.

This idea of prayer as a substitute for sacrifice is a powerful one. It speaks to the enduring nature of our connection with the Divine, even when the physical structures are gone. It's a theme we see echoed elsewhere in Jewish tradition.

The Midrash then connects this to (Ezra 9:4), "And to me were assembled everyone who trembled at the words of the God…" and (Psalms 55:18), "In the evening, and in the morning, and at noon, I will express my complaint and moan…" Why specifically in the evening?

The Midrash offers a poignant explanation: "Rather, all day long my soul is at ease in the world and I am not troubled, but in the evening I die and my intestines are exchanged." It's a vivid image of the inner turmoil that can surface at the end of the day. Therefore, the Midrash concludes, a person must confess their sins and supplicate in the Mincha prayer, the afternoon prayer. Hence, the phrase, "The lifting up of my hands as the evening sacrifice."

And so, we arrive at (Daniel 9:21), where Daniel says, "While I was still speaking in prayer, the man Gabriel, whom I had seen in the vision…" When does this happen? At the time of the Mincha prayer.

So, what does it all mean for us today? Perhaps it's a reminder that even when we feel alone, unheard, or unworthy, we can still turn to prayer. That our prayers, like incense, can rise up and reach the Divine. And that God, in turn, desires a relationship with us. A relationship built on mutual longing and reciprocal desire. Maybe, just maybe, that's enough to gladden the heart.

Full source