Parshat Naso4 min read

Issachar, the Tribe That Offered Torah in Metal

When Issachar's prince brought his Tabernacle offering, every weight and animal was a verse. The sages read it like scripture.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. The Order That Was Not Arbitrary
  2. What the Silver Charger Weighed and What It Remembered
  3. The Gold Spoon and What the Incense Said
  4. The Animals and the Count

The Order That Was Not Arbitrary

Judah offered first. Issachar offered second. The prince of Reuben, whose forefather was Israel's eldest, pushed back. His tribe should go before Issachar. The logic seemed obvious: birth order, precedence, the respect owed to the firstborn line.

Moses redirected him. The offering order followed the march order. God had arranged the camp, assigned the standards, and set the sequence in which the tribes moved through the desert. That sequence was not a military convenience. It was a theological statement. Judah led because Judah was the tribe of kings. Issachar followed because Issachar was the tribe of scholars, and scholarship came immediately after kingship in the order of things that mattered most.

The prince of Issachar was Nathaniel son of Zuar. His name already carried information. Nathaniel meant gift of God. Zuar meant small. The man from the tribe of learners, carrying a name that pointed toward divine gift and humility, approached the altar second on the second day of the Tabernacle's dedication.

What the Silver Charger Weighed and What It Remembered

Nathaniel brought a silver charger weighing one hundred and thirty shekels. The rabbis who read Numbers found the number impossible to leave alone. Midrash Rabbah, the great fifth-century Palestinian compilation, saw the one hundred as the Written Torah and the thirty as the thirty tractates of the Oral Torah. The charger was not a dish. It was a portable library, its weight calibrated to the entirety of what Issachar studied.

The silver bowl he brought weighed seventy shekels. Seventy for the seventy faces of Torah, the tradition that every verse of scripture could be read in seventy distinct ways, each one legitimate, each one uncovering a different layer of what had been written. A tribe that spent its life inside a text whose depth was counted in the tens of thousands had brought seventy shekels of silver to say what could not be said more simply.

The Gold Spoon and What the Incense Said

The gold spoon weighed ten shekels. Its incense was full. Ten for the Ten Commandments. Ten for the Ten Utterances through which the world had been made. The incense inside it represented, in the sages' reading, the spirit that animated all learning: the desire to come close to what is holy by understanding it.

A tribe whose scholars had proposed the dedication offerings in the first place, whose greatest teachers had served the nation as its calendar-keepers and legal authorities, had brought a golden spoon full of incense weighing ten shekels. The arithmetic was not accidental. It was the tribe's self-description compressed into metal and aromatic resin.

The Animals and the Count

The animals Nathaniel brought corresponded to categories of teaching: one young bullock, one ram, one lamb for the burnt offering. Three animals for the three parts of what Issachar studied: the Pentateuch, the Prophets, and the Writings. One goat for a sin offering. Two oxen, five rams, five male goats, five male lambs for the peace offerings.

The number five ran through the peace offerings like a signature. Five is the number of the books of the Torah. Issachar brought peace offerings calibrated to the shape of the text that defined them. The peace was not the absence of conflict. It was the state that Torah study created in the people who gave themselves to it completely.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

3 sources

The texts this telling draws on, in full. Open a card to read inline, or expand it for a wider, quieter read.

Legends of the Jews 3:93Legends of the Jews

It’s not always as simple as it seems. Take the dedication offerings in the desert, for example.

The scene: the Tabernacle is complete, the tribes are eager to present their offerings, and each day a different tribe steps forward. But who goes first? It wasn't as obvious as it first appears! We see this play out with the prince of Reuben. He was ready to step up, saying, "Enough is enough! Judah went first, surely it's our turn!" But Moses had to set him straight. According to God's plan, the tribes offered their gifts in the order they marched through the desert.

So, who followed Judah? The tribe of Issachar. Now, Issachar had some pretty strong arguments for being among the first. Why? Because, as the verse says, this tribe dedicated itself entirely to the study of Torah. The greatest scholars in Israel came from Issachar, and they were even the ones who suggested bringing the dedication offerings in the first place!

Because they were the tribe of erudition, of deep learning, their gifts were symbolic. The silver charger and the silver bowl? They represented the Written Torah and the Oral Torah, respectively. Think of the Written Torah as the text itself, the words on the page. The Oral Torah, or Torah She'baal Peh, is the interpretations, the discussions, the traditions passed down through generations that bring the text to life. And both are filled with fine flour.

Why flour? Because the two laws, the Written and Oral, aren't enemies! They're not antagonistic forces. Instead, they form a unity, containing the highest teachings. It's a beautiful image, isn't it?

But it doesn't stop there. The fine flour was mixed with oil, just as the knowledge of Torah should be combined with good deeds, with mitzvot (commandments). The text says that someone who dedicates themselves to Torah, performs good deeds, and avoids sin, fills the Creator with delight. It's a reminder that learning isn't just about intellectual pursuit, but about living a life of meaning and purpose.

And the golden spoon, weighing ten shekels? That symbolizes the two tablets, the luchot, on which God wrote the Ten Commandments with His own hand. The Zohar tells us that these tablets held not just the commandments themselves, but also all the particulars of the Torah, just as the spoon was filled with incense, a fragrant offering.

The text goes on, unpacking even more symbolism. The three burnt offerings, the bullock, the ram, and the lamb, correspond to the three groups within the Israelite community: priests (kohanim), Levites (levi'im), and Israelites (yisraelim). And the kid of the goats? That alludes to the proselytes, those who convert to Judaism. The Torah wasn't just revealed for Israel, but for all the world! "A proselyte who studies the Torah," the text proclaims, "is no less than a high priest." As Ginzberg recounts in Legends of the Jews, this emphasizes the inclusive nature of Torah, open to all who seek its wisdom.

Finally, the two oxen of the peace offering represent the Oral and Written Torah. The study of both brings peace – shalom – on earth and peace in heaven. It's a complete and harmonious vision, where learning, action, and community all come together.

So, what do we take away from all this intricate symbolism? Perhaps it's a reminder that everything in the Torah, even the seemingly mundane details, is pregnant with meaning. It invites us to delve deeper, to look beyond the surface, and to find the profound wisdom that awaits us. As we find in Midrash Rabbah, the Torah is not just a book, but a living, breathing source of guidance and inspiration, waiting to be explored.

Full source
Bamidbar Rabbah 13:17Bamidbar Rabbah

the dedication offerings brought by the princes of the tribes. "On the third day, prince of the children of Zebulun, Eliav son of Ḥelon" (Numbers 7:24). Why, the Rabbis ask, is the order different for Judah and Issachar? With most princes, their tribe is mentioned first, then their name. But with Judah (through Nahshon) and Issachar (through Netanel), it's name first, then tribe. What's up with that?

Bamidbar Rabbah suggests it's because Nahshon was a king and Netanel was a "king of Torah." As (Proverbs 8:15) states, "Through me kings reign." The king, in every circumstance, precedes his people, just as (Micah 2:13) says, "Their king passed before them…" Makes sense. Kingship and Torah leadership earn a certain precedence.

Here's a twist! While everyone else is called "prince," Nahshon isn't. Why not? Because he brought his offering first. The Rabbis are teaching us a profound lesson about humility. If Nahshon were to get too cocky, thinking his early offering made him superior, the others could remind him, "You're just a commoner! Everyone else is called 'prince,' but not you!" This echoes (Proverbs 16:5): "Anyone haughty of heart is an abomination to the Lord." And as (Psalm 138:6) reminds us, "Though the Lord is exalted, He sees the lowly; the haughty He knows from afar."

Let's get to Zebulun. Why was he privileged to present his offering third? This is where it gets really interesting. Bamidbar Rabbah tells us it's because he loved Torah and generously supported Issachar. Zebulun ensured that Issachar could dedicate himself to Torah study without worrying about making a living. So, Zebulun became a partner in Torah, and that's why he followed Judah and Issachar in the offering order. "A man’s giving expands him, and will guide him before the great" (Proverbs 18:16).

This partnership is then beautifully illustrated through the specifics of Eliav's offering. "His offering was one silver dish, its weight one hundred and thirty; one silver basin of seventy shekels, in the sacred shekel; both of them full of high quality flour mixed with oil as a meal offering" (Numbers 7:25). The "silver dish" corresponds to the sea, Zebulun's portion, as (Genesis 49:13) states, "Zebulun will dwell at the shore of seas." The "silver basin" represents the land, Issachar's portion, because "He saw rest, that it was good, and the land, that it was pleasant" (Genesis 49:15).

The weights of the silver (130 and 70 shekels, totaling 200) correspond to the 200 heads of the Sanhedrin (the supreme rabbinic court) who came from the tribe of Issachar. But why the larger tally for Zebulun? Because, the text argues, the one who causes the action is greater than the one who performs it. Without Zebulun's support, Issachar couldn't have devoted himself to Torah study. Zebulun fed him, gave him wine, and even provided silver for all his needs, echoing (Ecclesiastes 10:19): "For laughter one prepares bread, wine brings joy the living, and silver answers everything."

The "high quality flour mixed with oil" symbolizes that both Zebulun and Issachar receive the reward for Torah together. They both earn a livelihood together.

The text continues, referencing the "one gold ladle, ten shekels, full of incense" (Numbers 7:26) and the various animal offerings. The "ladle" (kaf) connects to Zebulun's blessing of dwelling at the "shore" (ḥof) of the seas. Kaf and ḥof are closely related words, highlighting the connection between the blessing and the offering.

The offerings themselves are linked to Moses' blessing of Zebulun and Issachar in (Deuteronomy 33:19): "Because they will be nourished by the bounty of the seas, and the hidden treasures of the sand." The two cattle correspond to the "bounty of the seas," and the five rams, goats, and sheep represent the five words in the verse, "Rejoice, Zebulun, in your departure, and, Issachar, in your tents" (Deuteronomy 33:18).

The Rabbis conclude, when God saw Eliav's offering, reflecting the beautiful partnership between Zebulun and Issachar, He lauded it: "This was the offering of Eliav.." This echoes (Proverbs 3:18): "It is a tree of life for those who grasp it", that's Issachar, "and its supporters are happy", that's Zebulun.

So, what can we take away from this intricate interpretation? It's a powerful reminder that true wealth isn't just about money or knowledge. It's about partnership, generosity, and recognizing the value of supporting those who dedicate themselves to something greater. Maybe, just maybe, the key to unlocking our own blessings lies in how we support others in pursuing theirs.

Full source
Bamidbar Rabbah 13:16Bamidbar Rabbah

It all starts with Issachar.

The text dives right in: "One silver dish" (Numbers 7:19), marking the offering of the prince of Issachar. But it's not just about the silverware. This offering, Why Issachar? Because, they loved Torah more than all the other tribes. How do we know?

Well, (I Chronicles 12:33) says of them: "From the children of Issachar, possessors of understanding of the times, to know what Israel should do." That phrase, "understanding of the times," is key. Rabbi Tanhuma explains it means "to perform matters in a timely fashion." Rabbi Yosei takes it even further, connecting them to the crucial work of intercalation – adjusting the calendar. They knew "what Israel should do" and, crucially, when they should do it – like observing the festivals.

the verse says, Issachar produced two hundred heads of the Sanhedrin (the ancient Jewish high court). "And all their brethren at their command," meaning others would agree to the halakha (Jewish law) in accordance with their opinion. They weren’t just scholars; they were the go-to authorities.

The text even pulls in a quote from (Genesis 49:14-15), where Issachar is described as one who "bent his shoulder to bear," meaning they bore the yoke of Torah. And "he became an indentured servant," because if anyone erred in halakha, they would turn to Issachar for clarification.

So, what's the deal with the "silver dish"? It corresponds to the Torah itself, which is called "bread," as it says in (Proverbs 9:5), "Come, partake of my bread." And remember the showbread in the Temple? (Exodus 25:29) tells us about the dishes used to shape it. These dishes, we learn, were molds, shaping the bread.

Now, for some numerical gymnastics! "Its weight one hundred and thirty" (Numbers 7:19). The text asks us to calculate twenty-four books of the written Torah, plus eighty of the mishna (the oral law) that begin with the letter mem – from "me’ematai" ("From when.") in Berakhot 1:1 to the final mem in Okatzin 3:12. (Mem has the numerical value of 40, so two mems equal 80.) Add that all up, and it equals 104, representing the written and oral Torah combined.

But wait, there's more! The beginnings of the six orders of Mishna also total eighty. Mem from "me’ematai" (Zera’im), yod from "yetziot haShabbat (the Sabbath)" (Shabbat, Moed), ḥet from "ḥamesh esre nashim" (Yevamot, Nashim), alef from "arba’a avot nezikin" (Bava Kama, Nezikin), kaf from "kol hazevaḥim" (Kodashim), and alef from "avot hatuma" (Teharot). (Each letter represents a numerical value: Mem – 40, yod – 10, ḥet – 8, alef – 1, kaf – 20, alef – 1 = 80.) Add the Torah and the Oral Torah, and you arrive at one hundred and four.

The Torah was given after twenty-six generations from Adam to Moses, which, added to the previous sum, brings us to 130. Hence, the dish's weight. Deep breath!

The "one silver basin" (mizrak) corresponds to the Torah, likened to wine (Proverbs 9:5: "Drink of the wine that I mixed"). Wine is typically drunk from a bowl (also called mizrak), as in (Amos 6:6): "Who drink from wine bowls." Its weight? "Seventy shekels," corresponding to the seventy aspects of the Torah, since the numerical value of "wine" (yayin) is seventy. (Yod – 10 + yod – 10 + nun – 50 = 70.)

Why "one" dish? Because the Torah must be one, as (Numbers 15:16) says: "One Torah and one law shall be for you." Because both the written and oral Torah come from one shepherd – said by one God to Moses at Sinai. And why silver? Because "The sayings of the Lord are pure sayings, like silver purified in the furnace" (Psalms 12:7).

"Both of them full (mele’im) of high quality flour" (Numbers 7:19) signifies that the Bible and the Mishna are complementary. "High quality flour," like the finest flour that floats atop the sieve (tzafa/nafa). And "mixed with oil" represents the Torah mixed with good deeds, because, as we learn in Mishna Avot 2:2, Torah study is best with good deeds.

The offering continues: "One gold ladle, ten shekels, full of incense" (Numbers 7:20). The ladle (kaf) corresponds to the tablets written by God (Exodus 32:16). "Gold…ten shekels" represent the Ten Commandments (Deuteronomy 10:4). "Gold," like "His hands are rods of gold" (Song of Songs 5:14) and "They are more desirable than gold" (Psalms 19:11).

"Full of incense," meaning the six hundred and thirteen mitzvot (commandments). From "I am…" (Exodus 20:2) to ".or anything that is your neighbor’s" (Exodus 20:14), there are six hundred and thirteen letters corresponding to the mitzvot, plus seven more for the seven days of Creation. The whole world was created for the sake of Torah!

Even the word "incense" (ketoret) holds a secret. If you replace the letter kof with dalet using the at bash gar dak substitution cipher (a system where letters are systematically replaced), the numerical value equals six hundred and thirteen!

"One young bull" (Numbers 7:21) corresponds to the priests, "one ram" to the Levites, and "one lamb" to the Israelites. "One goat as a sin offering" (Numbers 7:22) represents the proselytes, because "a man shall perform and live by them" (Leviticus 18:5) – not just priests, Levites, and Israelites. Even a convert who studies Torah is equivalent to a High Priest.

"And for the peace offering, two cattle" (Numbers 7:23) represent the two Torahs: the Bible and the Mishna. "Five rams, five goats, five sheep" correspond to three verses relating to the Torah, alluding to the six orders of Mishna. Each verse consists of two passages, and each passage contains five words. These are: "The Torah of the Lord is perfect…The testimony of the Lord can be trusted…The precepts of the Lord are upright…" (Psalms 19:8-10).

Rabbi Tanhuma connects each verse to a different order of the Mishna. "The Torah of the Lord is perfect, restoring the soul" is Nashim, which cautions against forbidden relations. "The testimony of the Lord can be trusted, making the simpleton wise" is Zera’im, about believing in this world and sowing. "The precepts of the Lord are upright, causing the heart to rejoice" is Mo’ed, which contains all the festivals. "The mitzvot of the Lord are clear, enlightening the eyes" is Kodashim, distinguishing between the non-sacred and the consecrated. "Fear of the Lord is pure, enduring forever" is Teharot, distinguishing between impurity and purity. And "The judgments of the Lord are true and righteous together" is Nezikin, containing civil laws.

Finally, why five words for each order? Because the Torah is five books, teaching us that they are the essence of the Torah.

And so, "This was the offering of Netanel son of Tzuar" (Numbers 7:23). The text concludes that God lauded Netanel's offering because it corresponded to the orders of the Torah.

What does it all mean? It seems that the text wants us to recognize that true connection to Torah isn't just about following the rules. It's about understanding the deeper connections, the numerical harmonies, and the way everything – from the silver dishes to the sacrifices – points back to the divine word. And maybe, just maybe, strive to be a little more like Issachar.

Full source