6 min read

Maimonides Walked Out of the Lime-Kiln and Became the Lion of Cairo

A trap meant to burn Maimonides alive closes on his accuser, he turns into a lion to break cruel decrees, and Ibn Ezra comes hunting his equal.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. The Warrant He Carried Was His Own Death
  2. The Ruling That Set the City on Fire
  3. The Name on His Lips Made Him a Lion
  4. The Scholar Who Came Looking for His Equal
  5. The Three Pearls Sold to the King

Cruel decrees came down on the Jews like a slow weight, and into that weight walked a physician who set up his table in the royal city's market square and offered to treat the patients every other doctor had given up for dead. His name was Maimonides. When the king himself fell ill and rose again healed, the physician climbed in a single season from stranger to favorite. That nearness was a wound to the Vice-Regent, who had stood beside the king for years, and his jealousy hardened into a plan.

The Warrant He Carried Was His Own Death

He pressed the king until the king bent, but only partway. The king had sworn never to lift a hand against Maimonides, so the killing had to be done at a slant. The royal lime-kiln roared at the edge of the city, its mouth white with heat, and its attendant received one instruction: kill and burn the first man who arrives today bearing a message from the palace. Then the king would send Maimonides out on some small errand, and the kiln would do the rest.

Maimonides left the palace with the order folded in his fingers, not knowing he carried his own warrant. On the road he passed a synagogue at the hour for the afternoon prayer and stepped inside. A poor family was there, holding the brit milah of their newborn son, and they would not let the great physician go. He stayed for the cutting and the small trembling joy of it.

Out at the kiln the Vice-Regent could not bear to wait and rode to confirm his trap, a message from the palace in his hand. The attendant looked at the messenger, looked at his instructions, and obeyed them to the letter. When Maimonides finally arrived, the ashes were still warm. The king heard how the snare had folded shut on the man who set it, and he said aloud, "The God of Israel is mighty."

The Ruling That Set the City on Fire

The next decrees were built not to kill the Jews but to shame them. If a gentile so much as brushed against a Jew, the gentile's garment was to be burned, the Jew was to pay for it, and the gentile had to bathe seven times to wash off the touch. If a gentile beat a Jew, the Jew owed him payment for the trouble of the beating.

A case came before Maimonides, who sat now as judge as well as counselor. A Jew had been beaten, and the court ordered him to pay the man who had struck him. Maimonides paid it from his own purse, twenty gold pieces for the burned clothes, seven more for the cold winter bath. Then he answered the cruelty with a performance of his own.

He arranged for two Jews to fall into a loud quarrel at the city gates and bring it to him for judgment where the gentile crowd could hear. A mouse, they said, had fallen into one man's cask of oil, and a gentile had touched the other's cask of wine. What was the law? Maimonides answered in a voice that carried across the square. The oil the mouse had spoiled could still be burned in lamps or boiled into soap, for a mouse does not defile past saving. But the wine a gentile had touched was ruined beyond recovery and had to be poured into the gutter.

The gentiles in the crowd heard what the ruling said about them, that a single touch of theirs was worse than a drowned mouse, and they came apart with rage. The king ordered the physician dragged to the city square and burned.

The Name on His Lips Made Him a Lion

The guards came for him. Maimonides spoke the Shem HaMeforash, the Ineffable Name, and his shape tore open. Where the man had stood there was now a lion, vast and terrible, and it went through the soldiers massed against him until seventy thousand lay dead in the square. Only the king he spared, because the king had thrown himself down and begged. From the dust the king swore to undo every shaming decree, and he kept the oath, and the Jews of the city breathed again.

The Scholar Who Came Looking for His Equal

Word of such a man traveled, and it reached Rabbi Avraham ibn Ezra, who had begun to wonder whether anyone in the world stood at his own height. He was told there was one, named Maimonides, and set out at once to find him.

He came first to the physician's garden, ate a few cucumbers off the vine, and left a knife behind among the leaves. At the door the servants said the master could not be disturbed, for he was mixing a medicine for the king. "I see him in the house," Ibn Ezra said, "mixing a recipe for the king," for walls were nothing to his sight. Maimonides answered back through the door. "Tell the guest I know he ate my cucumbers and left his knife in the garden, but I still cannot see him now."

The Three Pearls Sold to the King

When Ibn Ezra returned, Maimonides welcomed him in, and the visitor came with a scheme already shaped. Tell the king, he asked, that I am your brother. Maimonides agreed. Before the throne the king asked his trade, and Ibn Ezra said, "I trade in pearls."

At that moment a poor Jew shuffled in with three pearls to sell, and Ibn Ezra threw out his arm and cried that the pearls were his and the poor man a thief. The Jew swore he was no thief. The king set a test. "Whoever can describe the qualities of these pearls is their rightful owner." The poor man could say nothing. Ibn Ezra named them. The white pearl, ground to powder and swallowed, would make an old man young. The red one, shown to a rebellious city, would force it to its knees. The green one would lay bare hidden treasure. Each was tested, and each claim came true.

Then Ibn Ezra bowed and confessed. The pearls were never his. They belonged to the poor Jew. He had raised the false alarm only to make the king want them badly enough to pay a high price. The king paid, the poor man walked home wealthy, and Maimonides had stood by in silence and let it run to its end. Charity had come into the palace wearing the costume of a thief.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

3 sources

The texts this telling draws on, in full. Open a card to read inline, or expand it for a wider, quieter read.

Gaster, Exempla No. 345The Exempla of the Rabbis (1924)

Gaster's Exempla (1924), No. 345, preserves a late medieval legend about Maimonides (1135–1204) surviving a plot against his life. Cruel decrees had gone out against the Jews. Maimonides set up his medical practice in the market square of the royal city and offered to treat anyone whom other physicians had failed to cure.

The king fell ill. Maimonides cured him and rose rapidly in favor. The king's Vice-Regent, who had held that privileged place for years, grew jealous and began plotting the rabbi's death. He pressed the king until finally the king, bound by a prior promise not to harm Maimonides personally, agreed to a subtle alternative. The Vice-Regent would instruct the royal lime kiln attendant to kill the first man who arrived that day carrying a message from the palace. Then the king would dispatch Maimonides on a routine errand and the deed would be done.

Maimonides left the palace with the written order in his hand, not knowing it was his own death warrant. But as he walked, he passed a synagogue and stepped inside for the afternoon prayer. A poor family was holding a brit milah, the circumcision of their newborn son. Maimonides could not refuse an invitation. He stayed through the ceremony and the small celebration.

In the meantime, the impatient Vice-Regent rode out to the kiln himself to confirm the trap. He arrived carrying a message from the palace. And the attendant, following his instructions exactly, killed and burned him. When Maimonides finally arrived, the Vice-Regent's ashes were still hot.

The king, shaken, confessed openly: "The God of Israel is mighty." A detour into a poor family's circumcision, a slight delay in the afternoon. And a noose prepared for one man closed around another.

Heaven often saves a righteous man through the most ordinary delays.

Full source
Gaster, Exempla No. 344The Exempla of the Rabbis (1924)

In the days of Maimonides. Rabbi Moshe ben Maimon, 1138-1204 CE, evil decrees were issued against the Jews of his city. The laws were designed to humiliate.

If a gentile were so much as touched by a Jew, the gentile's garment was to be burned and the Jew was to pay heavy damages. The gentile also had to bathe seven times in ritual purification from the "defilement" of Jewish contact. If a gentile beat a Jew, the Jew was required to compensate the attacker for the effort of beating him.

A case came before Maimonides in which a Jew had been beaten by a gentile, and the court demanded the Jew pay for the beating. Maimonides, serving as judge and as counselor to the king, paid the sum himself: twenty gold pieces for the gentile's burned clothes, seven more for the inconvenience of bathing in winter.

Then Maimonides began a small counter-performance. He arranged for two Jews to quarrel at the city gates and to bring their dispute to him for judgment. The question they posed was this: a mouse had fallen into a cask of oil belonging to one of them, and a gentile had briefly touched a cask of wine belonging to the other. What was to be done?

Maimonides issued his ruling in a booming voice, where the gentile crowd could hear: the mouse-tainted oil could still be used for lamps or soap, for a mouse does not defile beyond repair, but the wine touched by a gentile must be poured down the drain, destroyed completely, because contact with a gentile had made it irrecoverable.

The gentiles understood what the ruling implied about them. They exploded in fury. The king ordered Maimonides brought to the city square and burned.

When the guards came for him, Maimonides pronounced the Shem HaMeforash, the Ineffable Name. His form changed. He became a lion, enormous and terrible, and in the confusion he slew seventy thousand of the soldiers arrayed against him, sparing only the king himself, who had begged his life. The king, humbled, revoked every one of the evil decrees. Israel rejoiced (Gaster, Exempla No. 344).

The story is a legend, not a historical record. Maimonides never turned into an animal. But the Jewish people, telling this story under the weight of medieval persecution, needed to imagine a sage who could answer cruelty with a strength that overflowed human form. The moral is not that the righteous become lions. The moral is that the righteous become more than themselves when the community is truly in danger.

Full source
Gaster, Exempla no. 346 (Codex Gaster 66)The Exempla of the Rabbis (1924)

Rabbi Avraham ibn Ezra, the great twelfth-century Spanish Jewish scholar, once wanted to know who his equal might be in the world. He was told: Maimonides. He set out at once to find him.

When Ibn Ezra arrived in the town where Maimonides lived, he walked first into the famous physician's garden. He ate some cucumbers growing there. He accidentally left a knife among the vines. Then he went to the front door and knocked. The servants answered. They told him the master was inside but could not be disturbed, for he was preparing a medicinal recipe for the king. Ibn Ezra replied, "I see him in the house, mixing a recipe for the king." He could see through walls. Maimonides, hearing the exchange, sent back his own message: "Tell the guest I know he ate my cucumbers and left his knife in the garden, but I still cannot see him now." Each scholar had demonstrated that he could match the other from a distance.

When Ibn Ezra returned later, Maimonides received him warmly. Ibn Ezra had a plan. He asked Maimonides to tell the king that Ibn Ezra was his brother. Maimonides agreed. The king summoned both men. He asked Ibn Ezra his business. "I trade in pearls," Ibn Ezra answered.

At that moment a poor Jew entered with three pearls to sell. Ibn Ezra shouted that the pearls belonged to him, that the poor Jew had stolen them. The Jew protested. The king ordered a test. "Whoever can describe the qualities of these pearls is their rightful owner." The poor Jew could not. Ibn Ezra stepped forward. The white pearl, he said, if ground and swallowed, would rejuvenate an old man. The red one, if shown by the king to a rebellious city, would force the city's submission. The green one would reveal hidden treasure.

The pearls were tested and the claims proved true. Ibn Ezra then bowed and confessed. The pearls were not his. They belonged to the poor Jew. He had raised the dispute only to force the king to pay a high price. The king bought them. The poor Jew went home wealthy. Ibn Ezra had risked a false accusation to lift a stranger out of poverty, and Maimonides had let him do it. Charity, Gaster's sources suggest, sometimes wears the costume of fraud.

Full source