Matityahu Named His Sons, Then One Did Not Come Home

Matityahu stood his five sons in the small room and did not give them a speech about courage. He fitted them to older men who had already killed and already paid.

Click for full size

"Yonathan, my son, you are like Yonathan the son of Shaul, who slew the Plishtim."

He turned. "El'azar, my son, you are like Pinhas (פינחס) the son of El'azar who was jealous for his God's sake, and thus delivered the children of Israel."

The names sat in the air after he stopped. Inheritance here was not land. It was a job that could put a boy in the ground before evening.

You Are Like Pinhas

Pinhas had not waited for a vote when the camp mixed with Midian. He took a spear and the plague stopped. Matityahu wanted that speed in sons who could still wait for better politics.

Yonathan son of Saul had gone up a cliff against Philistines with a roar behind him. Matityahu wanted that climb in a boy who still slept under his roof.

The five went out that day. They fought. They slew many. Yehudah did not come back on his feet.

The field kept him. Dust stuck to the living. Blood dried in the seams of their sandals on the walk home. No one spoke the old names on that road. The names had done their work.

Why Have You Returned

Matityahu looked at the doorway and counted four where there had been five. He did not ask who had won. He asked the worse question.

"Why have you returned?"

They answered him without dressing it. "Because our brother who was the equal of all the rest of us, is slain."

He had called them after the dead heroes of Israel's wars. One of those calls had already been spent. The room that had heard "you are like" now heard that the equal of all the rest was gone. No one argued with the count.

Yehudah had been the weight that made the other four feel light. Without him the doorway looked too wide. Matityahu put his hand on the post and did not bless the day. A father who conscripts his sons with old names has to take the empty chair as part of the lesson.

Willows at the Cleansed Altar

Later, when the courts were no longer a place for insult, men took willows of the brook and branches of palm in their hands. They sang praise to the Lord, who had given them courage and salvation to purify the Temple of His holiness.

The song did not bring Yehudah back. It filled the space the idol had used. Palm slapped willow. Clean fire took on the altar again. They sent a voice through all the cities of Judah to keep the day every year, so a child who had not seen the doorway would still have to hear that a brother had been the equal of the rest.

The festival was not invented as winter decoration. It was the scar the calendar kept after the House was scrubbed. Men who had come home without one of their number now stood in a crowd that could still sing. The willows shook. The palms did not hide the graves.

A Carpenter Took the Weight

Years after that, a man who would not put his name on the page took the war onto his shoulders. He was not afraid of the burden, he said, because it would benefit whoever still wanted the record. He left some stories in the shape the first writer had given them. His work was only to shorten.

He compared himself to a carpenter. The carpenter worries the foundation and the beams. He leaves the paint to someone else. This is what he did. Historians hunt every incident, he wrote, and then they set the events in an order they can live with.

He set Matityahu's naming next to the willows. He set the empty doorway next to the clean altar. He did not decorate the graves. He left that to the mouths that still say the names at the table when oil is lit and a child asks who Judah was.

Four sons had come home. One had not. The father who had said "you are like" had to hear why. The carpenter took that sentence and put it in a house of words so it would not blow away when the palms dried.