6 min read

Moses Stood at the Sea Like a Shepherd at a Cliff

Trapped between Pharaoh and the sea, Moses confessed he had no plan. The same man had already written eleven psalms for Israel to pray.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. The Shepherd's Admission
  2. What the Shepherd Wrote
  3. The Chorus Assembled Over Centuries
  4. The Merit That Carried Moses Up
  5. A Dwelling Place That Does Not Move

The sea was in front of him and moving nowhere. To the south sat Baal-zephon. To the north, Midgol's tower. Behind him, Pharaoh's chariots were raising dust across the plain. Moses had two million people at his back, and nothing ahead but water.

He prayed the only prayer left to him: the one that admits everything. "O Lord of the world," he said, "thou knowest that it is beyond human strength to surmount the difficulties standing in our way." He did not describe a strategy. He described a shepherd who walked his flock to the edge of a cliff and found nothing below but air (Exodus 14:10-15). That was the image he offered. Not the man who had turned the Nile to blood, not the prophet who had stood before Pharaoh nine times without breaking. A careless shepherd, lost at the rim.

The Shepherd's Admission

The prayer was not short. Moses laid out the geography, the armies, the impossibility, the faithfulness of a people who had walked out of Egypt on God's word alone. He pressed the case the way a man presses it when he knows he has no other counsel. The sea did not stir while he spoke. The chariots grew closer.

Then God answered, and the answer was not comfort. It was a command. Stop praying. Move. Raise your staff over the water and walk forward. The people are in distress, the sea is ahead, and talking about it longer will not part it.

Moses lifted his staff. The waters split (Exodus 14:21). Two walls of water stood upright while an entire nation walked dry ground between them. Pharaoh's army followed and the sea returned. By morning the Egyptian dead were washing onto shore.

What the Shepherd Wrote

Long before that morning, or long after it, the accounts are not precise about when, Moses wrote. He wrote eleven psalms, each tied to a tribe of Israel, each a specific address to God from a specific place of pressure. The first began with the words that a man under judgment would say: "Thou turnest man to destruction; and sayest, Return, ye children of men" (Psalm 90:3). That psalm was later linked to the tribe of Reuben, whose forefather had sinned and returned. The connection was deliberate. A psalm about punishment and return, given to a tribe whose story was punishment and return.

Eleven psalms. Moses gave eleven blessings at the end of his life and wrote eleven songs across his years. The number held a shape the tradition recognized.

The Chorus Assembled Over Centuries

Those eleven were not shelved. They were gathered into the Psalter, the book of prayer that bears David's name as primary author, but which the tradition knows as something wider. Adam contributed a psalm. Melchizedek, king of Salem, contributed one. Abraham contributed one. Solomon, the sons of Korah, Asaph the musician, who stood in the Temple and sang, they all contributed. The Psalter is the collected voice of everyone who ever found themselves somewhere impossible and had to speak.

Moses's psalms sit inside that book without announcement. Open to Psalm 90 and the heading reads: a prayer of Moses, man of God. The opening line runs: "Lord, thou hast been our dwelling place in all generations" (Psalm 90:1). It is not a line a man writes from safety. It is the line of someone for whom every other shelter has failed, or threatened to fail, or been taken away by decree. Only the one who stood at the cliff and counted up all the things he could not do would know, in his body, what it meant to say that God was the dwelling place.

The Merit That Carried Moses Up

When Moses ascended Sinai to receive the Torah, he did not climb alone. The tradition preserves this: the merit of the patriarchs, Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, rose and descended with him like the cloud itself. The mountain was chosen not because of its height. It was chosen because of what its ground carried. Moses stood on accumulated weight. He was not a solitary receiver. He was the latest point in a chain that ran from creation forward, through every man and woman who had stood at their own version of the sea and kept moving.

The eleven psalms carry that same weight. When Moses gave the tribe of Reuben a psalm about return, he was not composing theology. He was doing what psalmists do: he was handing a prayer to people who would need it for situations he could not name yet. He had already been at the cliff. He knew how the prayer goes when there is nothing else left.

A Dwelling Place That Does Not Move

Psalm 90 moves through human time with unusual speed. A thousand years, Moses writes, are in God's sight like a watch in the night (Psalm 90:4). Human days pass like grass that sprouts at morning and withers by evening. It is not a comforting psalm, exactly. It is honest about the math of mortality. But it ends with a petition: let the favor of the Lord rest on us, establish the work of our hands (Psalm 90:17). The man who confessed at the sea that he had no plan closes with a request that his efforts amount to something anyway.

The shepherd who reached the cliff did not stop being a shepherd. He kept the flock, kept walking, and kept writing prayers for the people who would follow him into places he could not predict and they could not avoid.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

3 sources

The texts this telling draws on, in full. Open a card to read inline, or expand it for a wider, quieter read.

Legends of the Jews 7:44Legends of the Jews

The sages saw it as a collection of voices, a chorus echoing through generations.

In Legends of the Jews, Moses himself contributed a significant portion! Just as Moses gave eleven blessings, he also composed eleven psalms. And these weren’t just lost to time; they were later incorporated into David’s Psalter, the very book we still cherish today.

Moses wasn't the only one. The Psalter, in this understanding, also includes psalms from figures like Adam, Melchizedek, Abraham, Solomon, Asaph, and even the three sons of Korah! What a gathering of spiritual giants!

Each psalm, in this tradition, is linked to a specific tribe of Israel. Moses’s first psalm, the one that says, "'Thou turnest man to destruction; and sayest, Return, ye children of men,'" is connected to the tribe of Reuben. Ginzberg, in his Legends, suggests this reflects forgiveness for the tribe’s forefather who sinned but returned to God.

Then there’s the powerful psalm, "He that dwelleth in the secret place of the most High shall abide under the shadow of the Almighty." This one? It’s for the tribe of Levi, the ones who dwelled in the sanctuary, under, as the psalm says, the shadow of the Almighty.

And what about Judah, whose very name, Yehudah, signifies "Praise the Lord?" Fittingly, the psalm "It is a good thing to give thanks unto the Lord" belongs to them.

The psalm "The Lord is apparelled with majesty" is linked to Benjamin. Why Benjamin? Because the sanctuary stood in his territory! That’s why the psalm closes with the words, "Holiness becometh Thine house, O Lord, forevermore." It's a direct connection to the Beit Hamikdash, the Holy Temple.

Then there’s the fiery psalm: "O Lord, Thou God to whom vengeance belongeth; Thou God to whom vengeance belongeth, shine forth." This one, according to tradition, was composed for the tribe of Gad. It speaks of Elijah, a member of this tribe, who was destined to destroy the foundations of the heathens and bring about the Lord’s vengeance. Talk about intense!

And finally, the psalm "O come, let us sing unto the Lord: let us make a joyful noise to the rock of our salvation" is given to the tribe of Issachar, the learned men. Because, as the tradition goes, this tribe dedicated themselves to the Torah, the book of praise itself.

So, what does this all mean? It shows us the Psalms are not just a collection of poems, but a weaving with the threads of Israel’s history, its tribes, and its relationship with the Divine. Each psalm, a voice resonating from a particular place, a particular time, a particular tribe, all contributing to the grand harmony of praise. It invites us to see the Psalms not just as words on a page, but as living echoes of our ancestors' prayers.

Full source
Legends of the Jews 1:22Legends of the Jews

By Louis Ginzberg, Moses, overwhelmed, turned to God in desperation. "O Lord of the world!" he cried, comparing himself to a careless shepherd who has led his flock to the edge of a precipice. He describes the impossible situation: Pharaoh bearing down from behind, Baal-zephon (a place of idolatry) to the south, Midgol (a fortified tower) to the north, and the vast, impassable sea ahead.

"Thou knowest," Moses pleaded, "that it is beyond human strength and human contrivance to surmount the difficulties standing in our way." He acknowledged that only God could deliver them, that they had no other hope but Him. He begged God to help Israel, who had left Egypt at God's command.

It's a very human impulse. But sometimes, maybe what's needed isn't more talking, but more action.

That's exactly what God tells Moses, cutting short his fervent prayer. Can you imagine the Almighty saying, "Enough already!"?

God says, "Moses, My children are in distress, the sea blocks the way before them, the enemy is in hot pursuit after them, and thou standest here and prayest!" Sometimes, God reminds Moses, shorter is better.

He continues, essentially saying, "If I could create dry land for Adam, wouldn't I do the same for this holy community?" The implication, of course, is yes. God assures Moses that He will save them, if only for the sake of Abraham's willingness to sacrifice his son Isaac, and for the sake of His promise to Jacob.

God even calls on the sun and the moon as witnesses to His promise to cleave the sea for the Israelites, who deserve His help for following Him into the wilderness without question. A pretty powerful statement!

But there's a condition. God tells Moses, "Do thou but see to it that they abandon their evil thought of returning to Egypt, and then it will not be necessary to turn to Me and entreat My help."

So, what's the takeaway? Perhaps it's that faith isn't just about prayer, but also about action and trust. God is there, ready to help, but we also need to do our part by turning away from our old ways and embracing the path ahead, even when it seems impossible. It reminds us that even in the face of insurmountable odds, hope and deliverance are possible, but they often require us to move forward in faith, even before we see the path cleared before us.

Full source
Shemot Rabbah 28:2Shemot Rabbah

The Shemot Rabbah, a classical collection of rabbinic interpretations on the Book of Exodus, gives us some fascinating answers.

"The Lord called to him from the mountain, saying.." Why specifically from the mountain? The Shemot Rabbah suggests it’s "due to the merit of the mountain." But then it quickly takes a turn. The mountain, it explains, "is nothing other than the patriarchs," Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. It cleverly references the prophet Micah (6:2), "Listen, mountains, to the Lord’s quarrel," to support this idea. So, the very ground upon which this momentous encounter takes place is steeped in the merit of our ancestors.

It continues, "Moses ascended to God." Not just physically, but spiritually. The text says, "He ascended in a cloud, and the merit of the patriarchs ascended and descended with him." It paints a picture of a two-way flow of divine grace, powered by the legacy of the patriarchs.

Then comes the intriguing instruction: "So you shall say to the house of Jacob… and tell to the children of Israel." A seemingly simple instruction, but the rabbis in the Shemot Rabbah dig deep. "The house of Jacob," we're told, refers to the women. Moses is told to share "the major principles" with them, "which they are capable of understanding." And "the children of Israel," the men, should receive "the fine points, which they are capable of understanding."

Why this distinction? The Shemot Rabbah offers several reasons. One is that women have "alacrity regarding mitzvot (commandments)," commandments. They're quick to embrace good deeds. Another is that they will then "guide their children to Torah." They are the key to passing on the tradition to the next generation.

But Rabbi Taḥlifa of Caesarea offers a more provocative explanation. He says that God, blessed be He, realized that when He created the world, He commanded only Adam initially. Eve was commanded later, and "she corrupted the world." The concern, as he puts it, is "Now, if I do not summon the women first, they will nullify the Torah." It’s a rather blunt assessment! So, addressing the women first is a preemptive move to ensure the Torah’s acceptance.

Rabbi Yoḥanan offers yet another interpretation. "So you shall say to the house of Jacob" refers to the Sanhedrin, the high court or council. He finds support for this in (Isaiah 2:5), "House of Jacob, come, let us walk by the light of the Lord." It’s a reminder that the Torah is meant to guide our leaders and institutions as well.

The Shemot Rabbah then shifts to the actual giving of the Ten Commandments: "God spoke all these matters, saying." It describes God acting "vis-à-vis Israel with protocols of royalty," quoting the Song of Songs (4:8), "With me, from Lebanon, my bride." Why this royal treatment? "Due to the merit of their saying: '[All that the Lord has spoken] we will perform and we will heed'" (Exodus 24:7). Their enthusiastic acceptance of the Torah earned them this divine honor. Their declaration of "na'aseh v'nishma", "we will do and we will understand", a commitment to action before comprehension, was a powerful act of faith.

So, what do we take away from all this? The Shemot Rabbah shows us that the giving of the Torah wasn't a simple, straightforward event. It was a complex, many-sided moment filled with layers of meaning. It highlights the importance of women in transmitting tradition, the legacy of the patriarchs, and the transformative power of embracing God's word with joy and commitment. It's a reminder that the Torah is not just a set of laws, but a living, breathing document that continues to speak to us today.

Full source