6 min read

Moses Heard What the Angels Could Not Bear

Six hundred thousand people backed away from Sinai saying the voice would kill them if it spoke again. Moses was told to come closer.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. Israel Stepped Back From the Mountain
  2. Come Close and Hear
  3. A Prophet Is Called an Angel
  4. Miriam's Drums and Doeg's Report
  5. Even Moses Reached the Edge
Moses Heard What the Angels Could Not Bear Click for full size

Israel Stepped Back From the Mountain

Sixty myriads of them stood at the foot of the mountain, and the voice came out of the fire, and they could not take it.

They said so out loud. If we hear the voice of the Lord our God any more, we will die. That was not a turn of phrase. Six hundred thousand grown men and their households had just been addressed directly by the One who made them, and it had very nearly finished them, and they moved back down the slope and asked for somebody to stand in between.

They got somebody.

Come Close and Hear

Come close, Moses was told. Come close, and hear.

So he walked toward the thing an entire nation had just fled from, and he went in, and the voice spoke to him. Later it called him by name out of the Tent and he answered it and came out unmarked.

The ministering angels cannot do that. A thousand thousands serve at the Throne, and when the Lord gives voice in front of His army the whole camp of God shakes at the sound of it. Hearing is all they can manage, and hearing costs them.

Moses heard what sixty myriads could not survive and what the angels can only endure by trembling. He heard it standing up. Mighty in strength are the doers of His word, and there was never anyone mightier at it than Moses.

A Prophet Is Called an Angel

An angel brought Israel out of Egypt. That is how it is written, and there was no angel in it. There was a man with a staff and a bad tongue.

Prophets are called angels. Haggai is named the angel of the Lord outright. The angel who came up from Gilgal to Bochim and stood in front of the weeping people was Phinehas. When the wife of Manoah ran to her husband and told him a man of God came to me and his face was like the face of an angel of God, very terrible, she did not mean the man had wings. She meant he was a prophet, and she was right.

An angel is a message with a body attached to it. That is the entire job. Which makes the man standing in front of a congregation something other than a man being listened to. He is a delivery in progress. Anyone who fouls that delivery has not merely been rude.

Miriam's Drums and Doeg's Report

Miriam talked about her brother. She and Aaron spoke against Moses, and by the end of it she was standing outside the camp, leprous, white as snow.

The work of her hands went with her. She had come up out of the sea with a timbrel in her hand and the women behind her, drumming, and that was what her hands had made in this world. The voice that came out of her mouth about a righteous man cost her the drums.

Doeg the Edomite stood among Saul's servants and reported something he had watched. I saw the son of Jesse come to Ahimelech at Nob. That was all of it. One accurate sentence, handed to a frightened king.

Eighty-five men who wore the linen ephod were killed for that sentence, and the town of Nob was put to the sword behind them, and Doeg never had to explain himself, because a report is not a weapon and everyone agrees it is not a weapon.

Do not be rash with your mouth, and do not let your heart hurry to bring out a word. A man pledges generously where the whole room can hear him, gives stingily when the time comes, and then tells the prayer leader who arrives to collect that there was a mistake, he did not know what he was saying. Why should God be angry at your voice and ruin the work of your hands? Because the voice already left the room. Nothing brings it back in.

Even Moses Reached the Edge

Zophar the Naamathite, who was no comfort to Job whatsoever, put the question flatly. Can you find out the deep things of God? Higher than heaven, what can you do? Deeper than Sheol, what can you know? Longer than the earth, broader than the sea.

And the man who went up to the highest heaven and took the Torah out of God's own hand did not find it out either. Moses hit a wall. Not a rebuke, not a failure of nerve. The thing has no far side to reach.

So at the water, when the angels came forward to speak against Israel while the sea was still standing up on both sides, He would not permit them. The pillar of cloud that had been travelling in front of the camp swung around and stood behind it, and the angels stayed behind the cloud. Then a crowd of former slaves with wet feet opened their mouths and sang.

Who can speak the mighty acts of the Lord, who can make all His praise heard? Nobody has managed it. The ones who had just walked through the seabed sang anyway, and they were the only ones allowed to go first.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

3 sources

The texts behind this telling. Some cards carry a translation of the source; others are our own retelling of it, and each card says which. Every card links out to the original.

Midrash Tehillim 52:1Midrash Tehillim

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.Rabbi Mike Feuer, Jerusalem Anthology · CC-BY

Words, once spoken, can’t be unsaid. But what about the spiritual consequences? Midrash Tehillim, specifically psalm 52, to explore the power – and the potential danger – of our words. This particular psalm is linked to Doeg the Edomite, that infamous gossip, who snitched on David to Saul, setting off a chain of tragic events.

The Midrash (rabbinic interpretive commentary) opens by quoting (Ecclesiastes 5:5): “Do not be rash with your mouth, nor let your heart be hasty to utter a word before God.” It’s a stark reminder to think before we speak, especially when making promises, particularly about charitable giving. Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi interprets the verse, “Do not give your mouth to sin against your flesh” (Ecclesiastes 5:6), as a warning to those who decide on charitable donations. Be careful not to promise generously and then give stingily.

What about when we try to weasel out of those promises? The verse continues, "And do not say before the angel" (Ecclesiastes 5:6). Here, the Midrash interprets "angel" as the prayer leader, the one who reminds us of our commitments. If you then claim, "There was a mistake, and I did not know what I was saying," you risk divine anger. "Why should God be angry with you?" Because you uttered a promise and then broke it. The consequence? "And ruin the work of your hands" (Ecclesiastes 5:6) – you lose the merit of the good deeds you intended to do.

Rabbi Levi offers another take: This verse is about hypocrites. The flattery they utter with their mouths leads to God’s anger, and the little bit of good they do manage to do gets all mixed up. That even our good intentions can become twisted when we aren't sincere.

But it's not just about money. The Midrash takes a fascinating turn, bringing in the story of Miriam, Moses' sister. Remember when she spoke against Moses in (Numbers 12:1)? "And Miriam and Aaron spoke against Moses." What happened? She was struck with leprosy, becoming "leprous, like snow" (Numbers 12:10).

Here, the "angel" in "Do not say before the angel" is interpreted as Moses himself! As (Exodus 23:20) says, "And he sent an angel and brought us out of Egypt." But was it really an angel? The Midrash suggests it was Moses. The lesson: even speaking negatively about a righteous leader like Moses can have severe consequences. The "work of your hands" that gets ruined? According to the Midrash, it's Miriam's drums, a reference to (Exodus 15:20): "Miriam the prophetess, the sister of Aaron, took the drum." The very instruments of her joy and praise are affected by her words.

The Midrash then connects evil speech to leprosy, stating that those who cause their flesh to sin by what they utter are punished with it. "Do not say in the presence of the angel, this is the priest," it continues, drawing on (Malachi 2:7): "For the lips of the priest should guard knowledge, and they should seek instruction from his mouth." The priest is the one who diagnoses leprosy, as (Leviticus 14:2) states: "This shall be the law of the leper." The one who speaks evil is brought to the priest, as (Leviticus 14:3) notes: "And he shall be brought to the priest." Again, the link between speech and physical manifestation of spiritual illness is made. The "guilt of your hands" is the little Torah you possess – lost because of your slander.

And finally, we come back to our original culprit: Doeg the Edomite. He worried and spoke evil of David, and the Midrash suggests he too was afflicted with leprosy, referencing (Psalm 41:6): "And if he comes to see me, he speaks falsehood; his heart gathers iniquity to itself; he goes out and speaks it." The phrase "he shall break down the house" is linked to (2 (Samuel 15:1)3), highlighting that Doeg's slander against David, as recounted in (1 Samuel 22:9) ("Then Doeg the Edomite… said, 'I saw the son of Jesse come to Ahimelek…'"), ultimately led to the downfall of others.

So, what’s the takeaway? The Midrash isn’t just about historical figures or ancient laws. It's about us. They have consequences, both seen and unseen. They can affect our relationships, our communities, and even our own spiritual well-being. Before we speak, perhaps we should all take a moment to consider: what kind of world are we building with our words?

Full source
Midrash Tehillim 103:13Midrash Tehillim

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.Rabbi Mike Feuer, Jerusalem Anthology · CC-BY

Midrash Tehillim turns to Moses and Creation of Haggai.

Midrash Tehillim, a collection of interpretations on the Book of Psalms, dives into this very question in its discussion of Psalm 103. The verse says, "The Lord bless His angels." But the text asks, isn’t "all His host" (all of His armies) already inclusive of the upper angels? So, who else could be meant here?

The Midrash (rabbinic interpretive commentary) suggests that this verse refers to the "lower angels." Okay, but how do we know that these "lower angels" are even called angels in the first place? The text brings a prooftext from (Numbers 20:16), "And He sent His angel and took us out of Egypt." Now, was that really an angel in the traditional sense? The Midrash offers a startling suggestion: it was Moses!

Wait, what? How can a human be an angel? The answer lies in understanding the term "angel" as a messenger, a representative of God. The prophets, the Midrash argues, are also called angels. We see this in (Haggai 1:13), which refers to "Haggai, the angel of the Lord." And Rabbi Judah bar Simon even identifies Phinehas as "the angel of the Lord" in (Judges 2:1).

This idea that individuals, specifically prophets, can embody the role of an angel, a divine messenger. The wife of Manoah in (Judges 13:6) even thought the angel who visited her was a prophet! So, according to the Midrash, prophets are called angels.

But the text doesn't stop there. It goes on to praise those who are "mighty are the doers of His word, to hearken to the voice of His word." Rabbi Huna, citing Rabbi Aha, says that the commandments were explained at Sinai. They acted before they listened! As it says in (Exodus 24:7), "All that the Lord spoke, we will do and we will hear." This powerful statement of commitment – Na'aseh V'Nishmah – embodies the spirit of those who are truly devoted.

Rabbi Isaac offers another interpretation, connecting "mighty are the doers of His word" to those who observe the shmita, the sabbatical year.: Most commandments are performed for a limited time – an hour, a day, a Sabbath. But observing shmita means abstaining from working the land for an entire year, every seven years! That's a serious commitment.

Then, Rabbi Tanhum bar Hanilai takes it even further, stating that "mighty are the doers of His word" refers to none other than Moses himself. He argues that Moses possessed a unique ability to hear God's voice, something that the entire Israelite nation struggled with at Mount Sinai. (Deuteronomy 5:22) tells us, "If we hear the voice of the Lord our God any more, we shall die." Yet, (Exodus 20:16) says, "Come close, and hear," referring to Moses.

The Midrash emphasizes that Moses heard what sixty myriads (600,000 people) could not. The voice called to him in (Leviticus 1:1), "And He called to Moses," and he was unharmed! This, the Midrash concludes, demonstrates that the righteous, like Moses, are even greater than the ministering angels. Angels can only hear His voice and tremble, while the righteous can hear His voice and remain steadfast.

As (Joel 2:11) says, "The Lord gives voice before His army, for His camp is very great." The Midrash equates this "camp of God" with the angels mentioned in (Genesis 32:2) and (Daniel 7:10) ("A thousand thousands ministered to Him"). But even among this celestial host, who can truly hear His voice? According to the Midrash, those who are mighty in deed, like Moses, are the ones who can truly understand God's message. Behold, he is a hero of great strength – this is Moses.

So, what does this all mean? Perhaps the Midrash is inviting us to reconsider our understanding of "angels." Maybe it's not just about winged beings in the heavens, but also about the righteous individuals among us who dedicate themselves to fulfilling God's will. People who, through their actions and devotion, become messengers of the divine in their own right. Are we all, in some way, capable of becoming angels?

Full source
Midrash Tehillim 106:2Midrash Tehillim

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.Rabbi Mike Feuer, Jerusalem Anthology · CC-BY

That feeling, that sense of the utterly unknowable, it’s a thread that runs deep through Jewish thought. The Midrash Tehillim, a collection of interpretations on the Book of Psalms, grapples with this very idea, specifically in relation to Psalm 106. It asks, essentially, “Who can truly express or understand the Divine?”

The text draws on a passage from the Book of Job, where Zophar the Naamathite throws down the gauntlet: "Can you fathom the mysteries of God? They are higher than the heavens above, what can you do? They are deeper than the depths below, what can you know?" (Job 11:7-9). It's a stark reminder of the limits of human comprehension.

The Midrash (rabbinic interpretive commentary) then echoes this sentiment by referencing (Exodus 15:11): "The heights of the heavens, what can you do? Deeper than Sheol [the underworld], what can you know?" Even Moses, our greatest prophet, who ascended to the heavens and received the Torah [the Five Books of Moses] directly from God, didn’t fully grasp the Divine mystery.

Rabbi Huna, quoting Rabbi Yirmeyah in the name of Rabbi Hiyya the Great, cites Kohelet (Ecclesiastes) 8:17: "No one can comprehend what goes on under the sun. Even if the wise claim they know, they cannot really comprehend it." This, the Midrash suggests, applies even to the Torah itself. We hold it, we study it, but its ultimate depths remain elusive. After all, (Exodus 32:16) tells us, "The tablets were the work of God; the writing was the writing of God, engraved on the tablets." How can we, finite beings, fully grasp something so inherently Divine?

It’s like Kohelet 3:11 says: "He has made everything beautiful in its time. He has also set eternity in the human heart; yet no one can fathom what God has done from beginning to end." We have a sense of the infinite, a yearning for something beyond ourselves, but the full picture remains beyond our grasp.

So, who can praise Him? According to Devarim (Deuteronomy) 33:29, it is His children: "Blessed are you, Israel! Who is like you, a people saved by the Lord?" And why is that? Bereishit (Genesis) 18:19 tells us that God chose Abraham "so that he will direct his children and his household after him to keep the way of the Lord by doing what is right and just." It’s about living a life dedicated to tzedek [righteousness] and mishpat [justice], embodying His values in the world.

The Midrash then paints a vivid scene: After the Exodus from Egypt, when the Israelites were safe and the sea had parted, the angels wanted to sing God’s praises, but they were held back. As (Exodus 14:20) says, "And the angel of God. withdrew and went behind them." Why? Because the praise needed to come from the people who had experienced God’s salvation firsthand. Only they could truly understand the magnitude of the miracle. The angels, as (Isaiah 6:3) tells us, are always proclaiming, "'Holy, holy, holy is the Lord Almighty; the whole earth is full of his glory.'" Their praise is constant, unwavering. But human praise, born of struggle and gratitude, carries a different weight.

God tells Moses and the Israelites, "They will praise me," referencing (Exodus 15:1), the Song of the Sea. And it's not just any praise, but praise that comes from lived experience.

Rabbi Yudan adds an interesting point: earthly kings are often mocked for their perceived weaknesses. But with God, it's different. "Every time a person criticizes God, it increases his greatness." This is a radical idea! It suggests that even our doubts, our questions, our struggles with faith, paradoxically contribute to a deeper understanding of the Divine. King David echoes this sentiment in (Psalms 78:4): "The praises of God will not be hidden from their children; they will tell the next generation about the Lord's praises."

So, what does it all mean? Perhaps it's this: we may never fully comprehend God, but that doesn't mean we can't praise Him. Our praise, born of our imperfect understanding, our struggles, and our triumphs, is evidence of our relationship with the Divine. And as (Psalm 79:13) concludes, "We are with you, your sheep and the flock of your pasture; we give you thanks." We are part of something larger, something mysterious, and our act of giving thanks, even when we don't fully understand, is a profound act of connection.

Maybe the point isn’t to undo the mystery, but to live within it, to praise within it, and to pass that sense of wonder on to the next generation.

Full source