6 min read

God Drew a Plan for the World and It Would Not Stand

The drawing kept collapsing. Nothing held until God made repentance and set it down beside the Throne, before there was any light to see it by.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. The Plan That Would Not Stand
  2. The Torah Told Him to Make Someone to Watch
  3. Snow, a Garment, and a Corner Left Open
  4. Five Rods Laid Out Before the Man
  5. What It Cost the Man Who Used It
God Drew a Plan for the World and It Would Not Stand Click for full size

The Plan That Would Not Stand

God drew the plan of a world, and the plan would not stand.

A man who wants to put up a palace has to settle the foundations first, and the doors, and where people will come in and go out. Otherwise he cannot lay a single stone. So God set the world out in front of Him the same way, and it kept coming apart in the drawing. There was nobody yet to blame for this. There was no light, no water, no ground, no first day. There was God, and His name, and a design that collapsed every time He looked at it.

He made repentance. Then it stood.

Seven things were finished before anything else was started: the Torah, repentance, the Throne of Glory, the Garden of Eden, Gehinnom, the ground the Temple would be built on, and the name of the Messiah. The way back was in place two thousand years before there was anywhere to come back from.

The Torah Told Him to Make Someone to Watch

The Torah in those years lay in the lap of God, written in black fire on white fire. Paradise was already open on His right and Gehinnom (the realm of judgment after death) on His left. In front of Him stood a sanctuary with a jewel set into its altar, and cut into the jewel was the name of the Messiah, and out of that sanctuary a voice was already calling, "Return, children of men." It called to nobody. There were no men.

When God decided to build, He asked the Torah what she thought.

"A king with no army and no courtiers and nobody in attendance hardly deserves to be called a king," she said. "There is nobody near him to give him the honor that is due."

The answer pleased Him a great deal. Every earthly king who has ever taken advice before acting learned it from that conversation.

Snow, a Garment, and a Corner Left Open

He took the brightness off His own covering and spread it out, and the heavens went on stretching until He said, "Stop," and they stopped. For the earth He reached under the Throne of Glory, took up the snow that lies there, and scattered it across the water. The water froze and became dust.

Then He made four winds. Light comes into the world out of the eastern corner. The dews of blessing come down from the south. Snow and hail and cold and heat and the rains all come out of the storehouses in the west.

The northern corner He started and did not finish. "Whoever calls himself a god," He said, "let him come and finish this corner that I have left, and then everyone will know he is a god." Nobody has. The gap is still open, and what lives in it are the demons, the earthquakes, the evil spirits and the shedim, and they come out of it into the world through the unfinished edge.

Two seraphim took up their places beside Him, six wings each. Two wings over the face, so as not to look at the Shechinah (the Divine Presence). Two over the legs. The reason given for the legs is that they are not to be reminded of the calf, which had not happened yet. A river of fire runs down from the faces of the holy creatures, and the creatures themselves do not know where His glory is. They call out from wherever they are standing, "Blessed is the glory of the Lord in His place."

Five Rods Laid Out Before the Man

"Before I made the man," God said, "I got five rods ready for him." He named them: spot, scab, bright spot, rash, burn.

A man once went to buy a slave, and he already knew the slave was bad. He brought chains and rods along with him to the sale. When the slave misbehaved, he chained him and beat him with the rods, and the slave said, "You knew from the start what I was. Why did you buy me?"

"Because I knew," the buyer said. "That is why I brought these."

Woe to the dough whose own baker testifies that it is bad. God said it plainly enough: the inclination of a man's heart is evil from his youth, and He made him anyway, with the rods already cut.

Rabbi Avin told it from the other side. A noblewoman came into the palace and saw the whips and the rods hanging on the wall and went pale. The household said to her, "Do not be frightened. Those are for the slaves and the maidservants. You are here to eat and drink and be honored." When Israel heard the curses and the leprosies read out and started shaking, Moses said the same thing to them.

What It Cost the Man Who Used It

Judah called his sons around him when he was dying and gave them his inventory first. He had outrun a hind and caught it. He had taken a bear by the paw and thrown it off a cliff and heard it break. He had caught a leopard by the tail in Hebron and smashed it on the rocks. He had seized a wild ox by the horns, spun it until it staggered, and killed it. He had lifted a stone of sixty pounds and killed a giant's horse under him. His father had seen in a vision that an angel of strength walked behind him everywhere so that he would not be beaten.

Then he told them the rest. A king who goes after a woman is stripped of his kingship, he said, and he knew it because of what he had handed over one night at a gate. "I gave my staff, which is the support of my tribe. I gave my girdle, which is my power. I gave my crown, which is the glory of my kingdom." He got them back. Getting them back was not the end of it.

"And I repented of these things," the old man said. "Wine and meat I have not eaten until my old age, and I have seen no joy."

Repentance was made before light was made. That is what it looks like in a body: an old man on a mat, refusing his supper, seventy years after the night.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

4 sources

The texts behind this telling. Some cards carry a translation of the source; others are our own retelling of it, and each card says which. Every card links out to the original.

Legends of the Jews 1:3Legends of the Jews

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Legends of the Jews by Louis Ginzberg (1909) · Public Domain

Imagine, if you will, two thousand years before heaven and earth. A time of pure potential. What was brewing in the cosmic kitchen?

In Legends of the Jews, a monumental work compiled by Louis Ginzberg, seven extraordinary things already existed. Think of them as the blueprints and building blocks of reality.

First, there was the Torah itself. Not just the physical scroll, but the very blueprint of creation, written, amazingly, with black fire on white fire, resting in the lap of God. Mind. Blown.

Then, the Divine Throne, ready for its occupant. It was erected in the highest heaven, the one poised above the Hayyot, those celestial beings who carry God’s chariot, as described in Ezekiel.

And of course, Paradise, situated on God’s right, and its opposite, Hell, on His left. Already, the destinations of souls were prepared, the ultimate reward and consequence laid out before creation even began.

Next, the Celestial Sanctuary, positioned directly in front of God. In this otherworldly space stood an altar adorned with a jewel, upon which was engraved the very Name of the Messiah. And from this sanctuary emanated a powerful Voice, crying out, "Return, ye children of men." A constant invitation, a call to repentance woven into the very fabric of existence. But it gets even more interesting when we consider the role of the Torah in the creation itself.

When God decided to create the world, He didn’t just snap His fingers. He consulted with the Torah! The Torah, personified as wisdom itself, advised Him, "O Lord, a king without an army and without courtiers and attendants hardly deserves the name of king, for none is nigh to express the homage due to him." for a second. The Torah isn’t just a set of rules; it's a guide, a partner in the act of creation. It’s suggesting that creation needs beings to appreciate and acknowledge the Divine. God wants relationship.

God was so pleased with this advice! This detail, according to the tradition, teaches all earthly kings – and, by extension, all of us – to seek counsel before acting. Before making big decisions. Before creating anything new.

It's a profound lesson about humility, collaboration, and the importance of seeking wisdom. As we find in Midrash Rabbah, the ancient rabbis constantly sought guidance from the Torah and from each other.

So, what does all this mean for us today? Perhaps it’s a reminder that even before the universe as we know it existed, the seeds of relationship, wisdom, and purpose were already planted. Are we listening to the wisdom around us? Are we consulting with our own inner Torah before we act? Are we creating a world worthy of praise?

Full source
Chronicles of Jerahmeel IChronicles of Jerahmeel (Gaster, 1899)

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Chronicles of Jerahmeel, trans. Moses Gaster (1899) · Public Domain

God drew up the blueprints for a world. They failed. According to the Chronicles of Jerahmeel, a 12th-century Hebrew chronicle compiled by Jerahmeel ben Solomon and first translated by Moses Gaster in 1899, the cosmos could not stand until God created one thing first: repentance.

Seven things existed before the world itself. The Torah. Repentance. The Throne of Glory. The Garden of Eden. Gehinnom (the place of spiritual purification after death). The site of the Temple. And the name of the Messiah. These were the foundations on which everything else would rest. Without them, creation had no architecture.

The heavens were made from the brilliance of God's own garment. He peeled it off like a covering and spread it out, and the heavens kept stretching until He said "Enough." The earth came from the snow beneath the Throne of Glory. He scattered it upon the waters, and the waters froze into dust.

Four winds emerged from four corners. Light from the east. Blessed dew from the south. Snow and rain from the west. But the north corner God left unfinished on purpose. "Whoever declares himself God," He said, "let him come finish this corner." That incomplete edge became the dwelling place of demons, earthquakes, and evil spirits.

Four bands of angels surround the divine throne. Michael on the right. Gabriel in front. Uriel on the left. Raphael behind. The throne itself is suspended in midair, half fire and half snow, with the Ineffable Name written across God's forehead. Two seraphim stand beside Him, each with six wings. Two wings cover their faces so they cannot gaze upon the Shekinah (שכינה), the Divine Presence. Two wings hide their feet to avoid recalling the sin of the golden calf. And with the remaining two, they fly, crying "Holy, holy, holy."

Full source
Bamidbar Rabbah 13:4Bamidbar Rabbah

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Sefaria Midrash Rabbah, 2022 · CC-BY

From that small verse, the Midrash (rabbinic interpretive commentary) launches into a fascinating exploration of Judah, the tribe of lions, fiery furnaces, and ultimately, God's presence in the world. How? Well, it all starts with another verse: “God is known in Judah…” (Psalms 76:2).

The Midrash asks, how did Judah become so well-known? One answer lies in Judah's own act of confession. Remember the story with Tamar (Genesis 38:26)? Judah publicly admitted, "She is more righteous than I." According to the Midrash, he didn’t withhold the truth from Jacob or from Shem's court. This act of humility and truthfulness, the Midrash suggests, echoes through generations. Because Judah rescued Tamar and her twin sons from being burned alive, Bamidbar Rabbah connects this to the later rescue of Hananya, Mishael, and Azarya from Nebuchadnezzar's fiery furnace! See the connection? One courageous act leading to another, displaying God's presence.

The connections don't stop there. The Midrash continues: “God is known in Judah” – when Daniel descended into the lion’s den and was rescued (Daniel 6). Why Daniel? Because he prayed to God, who is metaphorically called a "lion," as it's written: “They will follow the Lord, He will roar like a lion” (Hosea 11:10). And Daniel himself is from the tribe of Judah, which is also called a "lion," as in “Judah is a lion cub” (Genesis 49:9). It’s like a cosmic echo: let a Lion (God) come and rescue a lion (Daniel) from the mouth of a lion (the literal lions!).

The Midrash offers another reason for Daniel's safety: maybe he resembled the lions! Or, perhaps he wasn't thrown into the furnace because he was seen as Nebuchadnezzar's god. The text points to (Daniel 2:46), where Nebuchadnezzar prostrates himself to Daniel. The Midrash suggests that God intervened to prevent Daniel from being burned, to further reveal His might.

Then, the text shifts gears slightly, addressing a different kind of exile – that of the ten tribes of Israel. The Midrash quotes (Hosea 5:9): “Ephraim will become desolation…among the tribes of Israel I proclaim certainties.” When Judah and Benjamin weren’t exiled initially, the nations questioned God’s fairness. But when Judah was eventually exiled, it served as a stark reminder: no one is exempt from accountability. “God is known in Judah,” even through punishment.

The Midrash then brings in (Psalms 27:3), "If an army besieges me, my heart will not fear." How? By trusting in Moses' blessing: “This for Judah…Hear, Lord, the voice of Judah…and You will be a helper against his adversaries” (Deuteronomy 33:7).

And what about the verse "His name is great in Israel" (Psalms 76:2)? The Midrash interprets this through the lens of (Proverbs 19:29): “Punishments are prepared for cynics.” It's a stark reminder that God anticipates human failings. Before creating humanity, the text says, God prepared the consequences for wrongdoing. It's like a craftsman knowing the flaws in his material beforehand.

The text then touches on the power of prayer, linking "His name is great in Israel" to (Malachi 1:11): “For, from the rising of the sun to its setting, My name is great among the nations…”. But, the Midrash asks, are sacrifices actually offered everywhere? No! Rather, it's about the prayers offered by Jews worldwide. The afternoon prayer (minḥa), the morning prayer connecting to Abraham's actions (Genesis 18:23), and the evening prayer (ketoret) – each evidence of God's presence.

Ultimately, “God is known in Judah” when He takes revenge on their enemies, as (Joel 4:19) states: “Egypt will become desolation and Edom will become a desolate wilderness, due to the villainy against the children of Judah…”.

Finally, we return to Naḥshon at the Red Sea. As the Israelites hesitated, Naḥshon bravely leapt into the waves. As (Psalms 69:2) says, "Rescue me, God, for the waters have come up to my soul." God tells Moses to stop praying and command the Israelites to move forward (Exodus 14:15). Because of this act of faith, God exalted Naḥshon, granting him the honor of presenting his offering first.

So, what does this all mean? Bamidbar Rabbah 13 shows us how interconnected the Jewish tradition is. It's a web of stories, verses, and interpretations, all pointing to one central idea: that God's presence is revealed through acts of courage, humility, prayer, and even through the consequences of our actions. And perhaps, most importantly, it shows us that God is always known, always present, in the midst of it all.

Full source
Testament of JudahTestaments of the Twelve Patriarchs

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs, R. H. Charles (1917) · Public Domain

Judah, fourth son of Jacob and Leah, gathered his sons and told them everything. His mother had named him Judah, saying, "I give thanks to the Lord, because He has given me a fourth son also" (Genesis 29:35). He was swift in his youth, obedient to his father, and his father blessed him: "You shall be a king, prospering in all things."

Judah was a warrior of terrifying power.

He raced down a hind and caught it. He mastered roes in the chase and overtook everything in the plains. He caught a wild mare and tamed it. He slew a lion and plucked a kid from its mouth. He seized a bear by the paw and hurled it off a cliff. He outran a wild boar and tore it apart while running. A leopard leaped upon his dog in Hebron, and Judah caught it by the tail and smashed it on the rocks. He found a wild ox in the fields, grabbed it by the horns, whirled it, stunned it, and killed it.

In battle, he was worse. When two Canaanite kings came armored against their flocks, Judah rushed single-handed upon the king of Hazor, struck him on the greaves, dragged him down, and slew him. A giant warrior on horseback hurled javelins in all directions. Judah picked up a stone weighing sixty pounds, hurled it, and killed the man's horse. He fought the giant for two hours, split his shield in two, chopped off his feet, and killed him. When nine of the giant's companions attacked, Judah wrapped his garment around his hand, slung stones, killed four, and the rest fled.

City after city fell. Hazor. Aretan. Tappuah. Jobel. Makir. Gaash. Thamna. Judah scaled walls under a rain of stones, infiltrated cities disguised as an Amorite, opened gates for his brothers in the dead of night. His father Jacob saw in a vision that an angel of might followed Judah everywhere, ensuring he would never be overcome.

But the warrior had weaknesses. Two of them: wine and women.

Judah married Bathshua, a Canaanite, against his father's counsel. Her father was a king who adorned her with gold and pearls and made her pour wine at the feast. "The wine turned aside my eyes," Judah confessed, "and pleasure blinded my heart. I became enamored, and I lay with her, and transgressed the commandment of the Lord and of my fathers." She bore him Er, Onan, and Shelah. Two of them the Lord struck down for wickedness (Genesis 38:7-10).

Then came the incident with Tamar. After Bathshua refused to let Shelah marry Tamar, and after Tamar had waited two years as a widow, she disguised herself and sat at the gate of the city Enaim. Judah, drunk with wine, did not recognize her. He went in to her and gave her his staff, girdle, and royal diadem as a pledge. When he discovered she was pregnant, he wanted to kill her. But she sent back his pledges, and Judah was shamed into silence (Genesis 38:13-26). "It was from the Lord," he admitted. He never went near her again.

"Be not drunk with wine," Judah commanded his sons, "for wine turns the mind away from truth and inspires the passion of lust. The spirit of lust has wine as its minister. If a man drinks to drunkenness, it disturbs his mind with filthy thoughts, heats the body for sin, and he is not ashamed." He pointed to himself: before the eyes of the whole city, he had turned aside to Tamar, uncovered his sons' shame. Drunk, he gave away the three symbols of his kingship: the staff that was the stay of his tribe, the girdle that was his power, the diadem that was his glory.

"There are four evil spirits in wine," Judah warned. "Lust. Hot desire. Profligacy. Greed. If you would live soberly, do not touch wine at all."

He then spoke of a deeper truth. "Two spirits wait upon every person," he said, "the spirit of truth and the spirit of deceit. Between them stands the spirit of understanding, which can turn whichever way it chooses. The works of truth and deceit are written upon the hearts of men, and the Lord knows each one. There is no time at which the works of men can be hidden, for on the heart itself they have been inscribed before the Lord."

Judah commanded his sons to love Levi, for God had given the priesthood a rank above the kingship. "As the heaven is higher than the earth, so is the priesthood of God higher than the earthly kingdom," he said. The angel of the Lord had told him plainly: God chose Levi above Judah, to draw near to Him and eat of His table.

Looking to the future, Judah saw destruction: wars, divisions, captivity among the nations. But afterward, "A star shall arise from Jacob in peace (Numbers 24:17), and a righteous one shall arise, walking with the sons of men in meekness and righteousness, and no sin shall be found in him." The heavens would open. The scepter of Judah's kingdom would shine forth, and from his root a rod of righteousness would grow.

Judah died at a hundred and nineteen years old. He asked for no costly burial garments. They carried him to Hebron and buried him with his fathers.

Full source