7 min read

The Dead of Ashkenaz Came Back to Collect Their Due

A violin cut from leftover coffin wood, a ghost army hauling its own wagons, and spirits loosed before Shabbat to strike the careless living.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. The Corpse Who Demanded His Board Back
  2. The Army That Hauled Its Own Wagons
  3. The Body the Soul Cannot Take Off
  4. The Spirits Loosed Before the Gates Shut

The carpenter looked at the offcut on his bench and saw a violin. The coffin was built, nailed, lowered. This last length of board was good wood, well-grained, and it would be a waste to burn it. His neighbors told him to leave it. "Do not take that piece," they said. He took it anyway, planed it thin, bent the sides over heat, strung it, and drew a bow across it until it sang.

That night the dead man came to him.

The Corpse Who Demanded His Board Back

In the dream the buried man stood close, the way the living do not stand. He had been measured for that wood. He knew every plank that had gone into the dark with him, and he knew the one that had not. "You were warned," the dead man said. "Break the instrument, or you will come to harm." The carpenter woke, remembered the cold of the dream, and reached for his bow. The sound was too sweet to give up. He played on.

Then the fever took him. It climbed through the winter and would not break, and the carpenter lay shrinking in his bed while the violin hung silent on the wall. His son understood what his father would not. He took the instrument down, carried it past the edge of town to the cemetery, and found the grave of the man whose coffin had been short one board. He raised the violin over the headstone and brought it down. The wood cracked apart. He left the splinters scattered on the grave, and by the time he reached home his father's fever had begun to fall.

Whoever mocks the poor, the old verse says, insults his Maker. The dead man had been poor in the one thing the dead still own, the wood that wraps them, and a stranger had stolen a strip of it for a toy.

The Army That Hauled Its Own Wagons

A different night, a different road. A man rode alone through open country, the moon full enough to throw shadows. He was crossing waste ground, scrub and stone, when he saw what looked like a marching army ahead, wagons and great wagons, a whole baggage train laboring across the moonlit ground.

Something was wrong with the shape of it. The wagons were not pulled by oxen or horses. Men were in the traces. Men strained against the ropes and dragged the loads forward, and on top of the wagons other men rode at their ease, doing nothing, going where the haulers took them.

He rode closer to understand it, and as he came up beside the column he began to recognize faces. He knew these men. He had stood at some of their funerals. "What is this?" he asked them. "Why do you pull the wagons all night while the others sit and ride?"

They answered without stopping, because they could not stop. "Because of our sins," they said. "When we were alive in that world we chased women and girls and took what we wanted and called it nothing. Now we pull until we cannot pull, until our legs give and our breath is gone. Then the ones on the wagon climb down, and we climb up, and we ride and rest while they drag us. When they fail, we trade again. It does not end." The whip in that place was held by the upright, who drove the haulers the way a man drives a beast that has stopped earning its feed. Whoever had lived like an animal now labored like an animal, harnessed and lashed, hauling through the dark the weight of everything he had once made others carry.

The Body the Soul Cannot Take Off

These were not phantoms with nothing inside them. Among the dead the soul carries the body still. A spirit is fine and thin, but it stays wrapped in the scent of the flesh it wore, and the flesh stays wrapped in the scent of its clothes, and even fire does not strip that scent away. Burn the man, burn his house, burn the furniture, and the smell of it still rises to testify, because the dead grasp everything they touched in life and bring it with them.

So the dead choose their clothes. When they wish to be seen, and permission is granted, they appear to their children in whatever garment they please, sometimes the shroud they were buried in, sometimes a coat from years before the grave. Only the robbed are naked. Strip the shroud off a corpse, steal the cloth it was buried in, and that spirit stands exposed before itself, with no garment its soul can wear.

One man wore his Shabbat clothes into death and never the shroud. Rabbenu HaKadosh came back to his household dressed as he had dressed at the Shabbat table, in his finest, so they would know he was not like the ordinary dead. He had not been released from the commandments. He was strong enough still to lift the cup and say the Kiddush for the whole house, and so he came in living clothes and blessed the wine, and the righteous, who are called living even in their graves, kept their seat at the table.

The Spirits Loosed Before the Gates Shut

But not every spirit sits at a table. The truly wicked do not go down to Gehinnom at all. When they die their spirits turn into something that hunts, harmful things, the way the dead of Cain's line turned harmful, their souls remade into mazzikim that wander loose and strike. And there is one seam in the week where they run free.

On the eve of Shabbat, as the day comes in and the fires of Gehinnom bank low for the rest, the gates that hold the punished stand open for a breath, and the spirits that are not penned inside come out. Permission is given them to harm. They go for the ones who scorn the day, who labor through it, who sit sour while everyone else lights the lamps, who take no delight in it at all. So a sickness comes at the turn of the week, an illness no physician's hand can reach, because no human medicine touches a wound a spirit makes. Against that injury there is one defense. The household sings the song against harmful encounters beside the song for the Shabbat day, asks aloud for deliverance to rise and for health of the body, and waits for the One who wounds and heals His own blow to close the gates again.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

4 sources

The texts this telling draws on, in full. Open a card to read inline, or expand it for a wider, quieter read.

Sefer Chasidim 727Sefer Chasidim

A story: they made a coffin for a dead person, and some of the wood remained. A Jew said, "I will take that piece and make a violin." They said to him, "Do not take it." He paid no attention and made a musical instrument from that piece.

He saw in a dream the dead person for whom they had made the coffin. The dead person had told him, before he made the instrument from the leftover coffin wood, that if he made it, he would take vengeance on him. He did not pay attention and made it. He also said to him that if he did not break the violin, he would be in danger. He did not pay attention and became ill.

When he became very ill, his son took that musical instrument and broke it on the grave of the dead person who had appeared to his father. He left the broken pieces on the grave, and his father recovered. Concerning this matter it says, "Whoever mocks the poor insults his Maker" (Proverbs 17:5).

As for what is said, "the dead know nothing" (Ecclesiastes 9:5): if the dead person comes in a dream concerning a matter of commandments, as in the case where he said that the money was second-tithe money, dreams neither raise nor lower the matter.

Full source
Sefer Chasidim 169Sefer Chasidim

A story: a man was riding alone at night, and the moon shone that night. He was riding in the wilderness, and he saw a great army, wagons and great wagons. On the wagons sat human beings, and the ones pulling the wagons were human beings.

He wondered what they were doing. When he came near them, he recognized some of them who had already died. He said to them, "What is this, that you pull the wagons all night while some of you sit on the wagons?"

They said to him, "Because of our sins. When we were alive in that world, we played with women and maidens. Now we pull the wagon until we are so tired and weary that we can no longer drive. Then those on the wagon come down, and we go up and rest, and they drive us until they are tired and weary. Afterward they go up and rest."

This is what is said: "Behold, I will press you down in your place, as a wagon presses that is full of sheaves" (Amos 2:13). It is also written, "Woe to those who draw iniquity with cords of falsehood, and sin as with cart ropes" (Isaiah 5:18). The upright strike those who pull, as one drives an animal and a wagon, as it is said, "He is like the beasts that perish" (Psalms 49:21), and it is written, "The upright shall rule over them in the morning" (Psalms 49:15).

Whoever acted like an animal in life must labor like an animal in that world. Whoever enslaves human beings or casts his terror over human beings is enslaved in that world like an animal. Even one who torments his animal too much is judged there.

Full source
Sefer Chasidim 1129Sefer Chasidim

This was copied from another Sefer Chasidim.

The soul is in death as in life. This is what our sages of blessed memory said: one who has relations with a designated maidservant is bound together with her. They also said: one who has relations with a gentile woman, his circumcision is sealed, and he does not appear circumcised. So in death, in Gehinnom, it is as in life.

The spirit is very fine, while the scent of the body is thick and clothed in the scent of the body, and the body is clothed in the scent of its garments. Even if a person was burned, the scent has not ceased. So too the furnishings of his house testify against him. Even if they were burned, their scent has not ceased.

Therefore, when the dead wish, they dress in whatever garment they desire. Only if they were stripped, if the shrouds in which they were buried were taken, then they appear to themselves as naked. Since the soul has not ended with the body, with what spirit will the spirit ascend to wrap itself? But if the garment ended with him or was burned with him, they can wrap themselves in it.

Therefore Daniel and his companions were thrown into the fire in their cloaks (Daniel 3:21). So too with the red cow: its hide, its flesh, its blood, its dung, and its bone are all burned to purify those made impure by the dead (Numbers 19:5), for the dead grasps everything.

If the dead wish to be seen, permission is given for them to be seen. Even though a person was buried in shrouds, the dead can appear to their children in whatever garment they want, sometimes in the garment in which they were buried and sometimes in a garment from before then.

Rabbenu HaKadosh would appear in fine garments, the ones he wore on Shabbat, and not in shrouds, to show that he was still in his strength and could discharge the many from their obligation in Kiddush of the day. He was not like other dead, who are free from the commandments, but like a living person in the garments he wore in life. The righteous are called living even in their death, and he discharged his household in Kiddush.

Full source
Sefer Chasidim 1170Sefer Chasidim

Why do the spirits injure on the eve of Shabbat? Because the spirits are not in Gehinnom. That is, the spirits of the wicked, after their death, become harmful spirits, like all the descendants of Cain who died, whose souls became harmful spirits. Permission is given to them to harm those who desecrate Shabbat, or those who are sad on Shabbat, or even one who does not delight in it.

Therefore there is an illness of spirits on Shabbat, and for this reason the Song Against Harmful Encounters is placed next to the song for the day of Shabbat. Therefore one says on Shabbat, "Let deliverance arise" and "health of the body," but not on a festival day. For souls that harm, a person has no healing through human medicines, only through his Creator. "He has wounded, and He will heal His blow."

Full source