5 min read

The Farmer Dug a Cistern Before the Drought Came

A careful tither cut half his field for a stone cistern. Neighbors mocked him until drought closed the wells and his watered half still fed the village.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. The Tenth Before the Miracle
  2. When the Earth Distorts Under False Hands
  3. Sixth-Year Fullness and Heaven's Store
  4. Why the Hole Was Wisdom

The farmer set stones in a ring while the rest of the village still trusted the sky. Half his best field stayed empty of seed. He lined a wide cistern and waited for winter runoff as if water were a guest that needed a proper house.

The Farmer Dug a Cistern Before the Drought Came Click for full size

Neighbors called it madness. He had cut his yield on purpose to dig a hole in good soil.

The Tenth Before the Miracle

Every season he had already given away what the law asked. Priestly portion. Levitical tenth. Poor-tithe. He did not shave the weights in lean years. He did not delay until the poor grew tired of asking at his gate. The habit of open hands made the next habit possible. When something in him pressed to take half a field out of cultivation, he listened without a prophet standing at the fence to force the choice.

In the Exempla of the Rabbis the tale is simple and stubborn. The cistern caught the rains. The next year drought came like a closed fist over the valley. Wells failed. Fields browned in rows. His remaining half, fed from the stone bowl, still put out grain and greens. He sold at drought prices and lived. More than that, he still had something left to give when faces appeared at dusk with empty sacks.

The hole in the ground had become a second field, only this field held water instead of stalks, and water was the only coin that still bought life.

When the Earth Distorts Under False Hands

Midrash Tanchuma on the double command "you shall tithe, tithe" (Deuteronomy 14:22) hears the earth itself twist when statutes break. Standing grain appears, then never becomes sheaves. Sheaves appear, then never become a clean heap on the floor. A threshing floor shows promise and then refuses a winnowed pile. The midrash names the broken statute of tithes among the reasons the ground will not finish its work for people who finish nothing for heaven or for the poor.

The farmer's neighbors learned that lesson the hard way. Their fields showed early green and then collapsed under heat. His field finished what it began because he had not treated the soil as a private vault. Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob appear in the same midrash as men who separated portions before blessing settled. Isaac measured a hundredfold so he could tithe it. The measure was not greed. It was readiness to give with numbers honest enough for a priest to check.

Jacob vowed, "and of all that Thou shalt give me I will surely give the tenth unto Thee" (Genesis 28:22). The farmer's cistern was a quieter vow, spoken in stone rather than in a dream of ladders.

Sixth-Year Fullness and Heaven's Store

When the land must rest in the seventh year, the question rises like dust in a dry throat. What will we eat if we stop squeezing the dirt? Targum Jonathan on Leviticus answers from heavenly treasuries. In the sixth year blessing descends and the produce covers three years. The miracle is not a trick of better plows. It is a storehouse opened above a people who dare to stop taking for one full turn of seasons.

The cistern was a small echo of that sixth-year logic. He surrendered half a field in ordinary time and found that ordinary time still held a hidden reserve. The land is Mine, the Targum insists. Israel lives as sojourner and guest. A guest who digs for rain while others mock him is still only tending what was never fully his to hoard.

Jubilee and liberty trumpets belong to the same family of ideas. Debt is temporary. Ownership is lease. Freedom is the default. The farmer who frees half a field from seed is practicing a miniature release before the calendar forces a larger one.

Why the Hole Was Wisdom

The story does not promise that every honest tither becomes rich in a dry summer. It promises that fidelity trains the eye. The man who already gives a tenth can hear when half a field should become a bowl for water. The man who cheats the poor cannot hear anything but his own hunger, which grows louder the more he feeds it with withheld grain.

When the drought broke, some neighbors asked him for seed and advice. He gave both without a speech about who had been right. The cistern stayed in the ground like a quiet argument against panic. Tithe first. Then dig. Then sleep while the wind does work you cannot force with your hands no matter how early you rise.

In later years children pointed at the stone ring and told the story wrong, making him a wizard of weather. He was not. He was a man who practiced portion until portion taught him where to put a hole.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

3 sources

The texts behind this telling. Some cards carry a translation of the source; others are our own retelling of it, and each card says which. Every card links out to the original.

Gaster, Exempla No. 106The Exempla of the Rabbis (1924)

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Exempla of the Rabbis, Moses Gaster (1924) · PD-US-pre-1929

There was once a farmer who paid his tithes with scrupulous care. Every year, on the appointed seasons, he set aside the priestly portion, the Levitical tenth, and the poor-tithe, and delivered each to its rightful recipient. He never shaved the weights or delayed the offering, even in lean years when every grain seemed to count against his own table.

One season, for reasons he could not fully explain, he felt moved to take half of his most productive field out of cultivation entirely. On that half he dug a wide cistern and lined it carefully with stone to catch the runoff from the winter rains. His neighbors thought he had lost his mind. He had voluntarily cut his yield in half to build a hole in the ground.

The next year, a drought fell on the region. Wells went dry. Neighbors' fields withered. The farmer's remaining half of the field, watered from his cistern, produced grain and vegetables when no one else's would. He sold at the prices a drought demands and made a fortune in a single summer (Gaster, Exempla No. 106).

The sages tell the story as a quiet teaching about maaser, the tithe. The one who gives a tenth away faithfully often finds that the Holy One whispers the right decision at the right moment, and the cistern gets dug before the rains stop coming.

Full source
Midrash Tanchuma, Re'eh 14Midrash Tanchuma

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.Townsend 1989 translation of Midrash Tanhuma, S. Buber Recension · CC-BY

Another explanation (of Deut. 14:22), “You shall tithe, tithe.” This is related to the verse (in Is. 24:5), “And the earth was distorted under its inhabitants, because they transgressed Torahs; they violated a statute; [they broke an eternal covenant].” R. Isaac said, “You have already been false to it, and [so] it is distorted for you. It [may] show you standing grain, but it does not show you a shock of sheaves. It [may] show you [a shock of sheaves, but it does not show you a threshing floor]. It [may] show you a threshing floor, but it does not show you a winnowed heap. Why [not]? (Ibid.) ‘Because they transgressed Torahs; they violated statutes,’ in that they did transgress two Torahs, the written Torah and the oral Torah; (ibid.) ‘they violated a statute,’ the statute of tithes; (ibid.) ‘they broke an eternal covenant,’ an ancestral covenant.” For that reason Moses warned Israel (in Deut. 14:22), “You shall surely tithe.” (Prov. 6:20:) “My child, keep your father's commandments, [and do not forsake the Torah of your mother].” R. Huna said, “Our earliest ancestors separated out terumot and tithes.” Abraham separated out the great terumah, as stated (in Gen. 14:22), “[Then Abram said unto the king of Sodom,] ‘I have lifted up my hand unto the Lord, God most high.’” A lifting up is nothing but a terumah (rt. rwm), as you say (in Numb. 18:26), “[Now you shall speak unto the Levites and say unto them, ‘When you receive tithes from the Children of Israel, the tithe that I have given you as your portion,] you shall lift (rt. rwm) out of it a terumah of the Lord, [a tithe from the tithe].’” Isaac separated out the second tithe, as stated (in Gen. 26:12), “So Isaac sowed on that land and reaped in that year a hundredfold, [for the Lord had blessed him]”; R. Eiba bar Kahana said, “Is it not true that a blessing does not rest on what is measured, on what is weighed, or on what is counted? So why did he measure them? In order to tithe them. This is what is written (ibid.), ‘for the Lord had blessed him.’” Jacob separated out the first tithe, as stated (in Gen. 28:22), “and of all that You give me, I will surely set aside a tithe for You.” A certain Cuthean (i.e., a Samaritan) came and questioned R. Meir. He said to him, “Do you not say that indeed your ancestor Jacob is truthful?” He said [back] to him, “Yes, as it is written (in (Micah 7:2)0), ‘You give truthfulness to Jacob.’” [The Cuthean] said to him, “He separated out the tribe of Levi [as a tithe] for the tribes, [i.e.,] one out of ten. Should he not have separated out [a tithe] from two more [tribes]?” R. Meir said to him, “You have said that there were twelve, but I say that there were fourteen, as stated (in Gen. 48:5), ‘Ephraim and Manasseh shall be mine like Reuben and Simeon.’” He said to him, “So here you are supporting me. You have added flour. Have you added water?” He said to him, “Do you not admit that there are four matriarchs that had four first-borns? Take away from [the fourteen] the four firstborn (of Jacob's four wives), since the firstborn is not tithed. Why? Because he is holy, and something holy does not redeem for use something [else that is] holy.” He said to him, ‘It is good for your people that you are among them.” Hence it is written (Prov. 6:20), “and do not forsake the Torah of your mother (immekha),” [i.e.,] your people (ummatekha). That is what David said (in Ps. 40:9), “To carry out Your will, my God, is my desire, [for Your Torah is within my belly].” R. Aha bar Ulla said, “Is there Torah within the belly? And is it not so written (in Jer. 31:33), ‘and upon their heart (not their belly) I will write it?’ It is simply that David said, ‘May [a curse] come upon me, if something goes down into my belly, except when it is tithed.’ This is what is written (in I Chron. 27:25), ‘And over the treasuries of the king was Azmaveth ben Adiel; and over the treasuries in the country in the cities, in the villages, and in the towers was Jonathan ben Uzziah.’” For that reason Moses warned Israel (in Deut. 14:22), “You shall surely tithe.”

Full source
Targum Jonathan on Leviticus 25Targum Jonathan

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Targum of Jonathan ben Uzziel, trans. J. W. Etheridge, London, 1862 · Public Domain

Leviticus 25 introduces the sabbatical year and the Jubilee. The Targum Jonathan addresses the most obvious objection: if the land rests every seventh year, what will people eat?

God's answer in the Targum goes beyond the Hebrew: "I will command My blessing upon you from My treasures of goodness, which are in the heaven of My Presence, in the sixth year, and it will create produce that will suffice for three years." The Hebrew says the blessing will come "in the sixth year." The Targum locates the source: heavenly treasuries. The miracle is not just agricultural. It descends from a specific divine storehouse.

The Jubilee, every fiftieth year, brought radical economic reset. All sold land returned to its original owner. All Israelite slaves went free. The Targum names it Jubela and adds the sound of the "trumpet of Liberty" that proclaimed it on Yom Kippur (the Day of Atonement). The land "shall not be sold absolutely, for the land is Mine; for you are sojourners and guests with Me." The Targum renders Israel's relationship to the Holy Land as a divine lease, not ownership.

The anti-usury laws get personal addresses: "My people of the house of Israel, you shall not take usuries or remunerations." The phrase "My people" is a Targum addition, turning a legal prohibition into a direct plea from God to God's children.

If an Israelite sells himself to a non-Israelite, the Targum specifies the buyer as "the uncircumcised stranger" or "the stock of a strange religion." Redemption is mandatory: "forthwith redemption shall be his." A brother, uncle, cousin, or the whole congregation may redeem him. No Israelite can permanently belong to a foreigner, "for the sons of Israel are Mine."

The Jubilee system assumed that economies could be reset, that debt was temporary, and that freedom was the default state. The Targum frames all of it as a consequence of the Exodus: "I brought you out redeemed from the land of Egypt."

Full source