4 min read

God Drained the Chaos and the World Appeared Underneath

Bereshit Rabbah reads creation as a refining job. The world was already there, hidden under chaos. God drained it, and the craft appeared below.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. A bathtub with two bowls at the bottom
  2. Tohu va-vohu was not nothing
  3. The serpent's trial that never happened
  4. Two kinds of removal

A bathtub with two bowls at the bottom

The first day of creation is usually read as production: God speaking light into existence out of nothing, building the world from scratch. Bereshit Rabbah, compiled in fifth-century Palestine, read it as subtraction.

Rabbi Eliezer, quoting Rabbi Yaakov, opened with a metalworker's image from Proverbs 25:4: remove the dross from silver, and a vessel will emerge for the smith. The verse was not about cosmology. It was about a man hunched over a forge, skimming impurities off molten metal until something usable appeared underneath. The rabbis decided this was how creation worked.

Picture a bathtub filled past the rim. Two ornate bowls sit at the bottom, etched with patterns so fine that a craftsman could look at them for an hour and find something new each time. But the water is in the way. You see surface, not artistry. The bowls exist but they cannot be seen. Then someone pulls the plug. The water drops, slowly at first, then faster. The bowls appear. The craft was always there. The removal revealed it.

Tohu va-vohu was not nothing

That was creation. The Torah's opening phrase, tohu va-vohu, usually translated as unformed and void or formless and empty, was not absence. The rabbis read it as a flooded basin. The heavens and the earth were fully made from the beginning, sitting at the bottom of a chaos that hid them. What looked like nothing to the eye was everything, obscured.

God's first act on the first day was not to manufacture a cosmos. It was to pull the plug. The waters of chaos, the deep that covered everything, drew back as God separated light from darkness, water from water, sea from dry land. Each act of separation was an act of removal. The world was being revealed, not built.

The rabbis found this reading more accurate than the production model because it matched what Proverbs said about wisdom and what metalworkers knew about silver. Nothing worth having comes clean from the furnace. The form is always hidden inside the raw material, waiting for the dross to be taken away.

The serpent's trial that never happened

The second passage in the same collection turned from cosmology to justice. After Adam and Eve ate the fruit, God called them each in turn and asked what happened. Adam pointed to Eve. Eve pointed to the serpent. Then God turned to the serpent.

God did not ask the serpent anything. The serpent received no hearing, no question, no opportunity to speak. The curse landed immediately: because you did this, you are cursed above all cattle and all animals of the field. On your belly you shall crawl, and dust you shall eat all the days of your life.

Bereshit Rabbah 20 noticed this and asked why the serpent got no trial. A verse from Proverbs answered: a contrary man incites strife, and a malcontent distances the ruler. The serpent was precisely the contrary man, the one who spread dissension between Adam and Eve, who stood at the root of the separation. A creature whose entire purpose was to create distance between things that should be unified did not get to stand before God and argue its case. The court recognized what the defendant was, and the verdict came without the argument.

Two kinds of removal

The two passages were not obviously related, but the collection placed them together because both turned on the same insight about what completion requires. Creation was completed by removing the chaos that hid the world's form. Justice was completed by removing the hearing that the chaos-maker did not deserve.

In the bathtub image, the bowls were always beautiful. The water was the problem, and the solution was to take the water away. In the garden, Adam and Eve were formed for something better than they chose. The serpent was the problem, and the solution was to identify it as such and act without debate.

SerpentAnimalsMidrash RabbahBereshitDross
← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

3 sources

The texts this telling draws on, in full. Open a card to read inline, or expand it for a wider, quieter read.

Bereshit Rabbah 10:2Bereshit Rabbah

Rabbi Ḥama kicks things off with a powerful image, quoting (Proverbs 25:4): “Remove the dross from silver [and a vessel will emerge for the smith].” It's a verse about refining, about taking something raw and making it beautiful. But how does that relate to the creation story?

Rabbi Eliezer, in the name of Rabbi Yaakov, offers a brilliant analogy. Imagine a bathtub filled to the brim with water, and nestled within it are two ornate bowls. As long as the tub's overflowing, you can't really appreciate the craftsmanship of these bowls, can you? The water obscures the details, the artistry.

Then, someone pulls the plug. The water drains away, and suddenly – bam! – the intricate designs of the bowls are revealed in all their glory. The hidden beauty emerges as the water recedes.

That, my friends, is what the creation story is all about. "As long as the world was emptiness and disorder," Rabbi Eliezer explains, "the labor of the heavens and the earth was not visible." Before there was order, before there was light, before there was… well, anything really… the potential for beauty was already there, waiting to be revealed.

The tohu vavohu, the "emptiness and disorder" – it wasn’t just a void. It was a canvas, a lump of clay waiting for the artist's touch. According to Ginzberg's Legends of the Jews, this primordial state wasn't just nothingness; it was a chaotic mixture of the elements that would eventually form the world.

And then, God began to sculpt. To refine. To remove the "dross," as Proverbs puts it.

"Once the emptiness and disorder was uprooted from the world," Rabbi Eliezer continues, "the handiwork of the heavens and the earth became visible." It's like the water draining from the tub, revealing those exquisite bowls.

The verse goes on: “A vessel [keli] will emerge for the smith” (Proverbs 25:4). The heavens and the earth, once chaotic and formless, became finished vessels, ready to be filled with life, with meaning, with purpose. This is echoed in the verse: “The heavens and the earth and their entire host were completed [vaykhulu].” The root of vaykhulu implies both completion and perfection, suggesting a sense of fulfillment and purpose.

So, what does all this mean for us? Perhaps it's a reminder that even in the midst of chaos, in the times when life feels like that overflowing bathtub, there's still beauty waiting to be revealed. Sometimes, all it takes is draining away the excess, clearing away the clutter, to see the artistry that was there all along. Just like the world itself, we too are vessels in progress, constantly being refined and shaped by the Divine hand.

Full source
Bereshit Rabbah 20:2Bereshit Rabbah

Being sentenced without a trial. No discussion, no back-and-forth, just BAM – the hammer drops. Jewish tradition offers a fascinating glimpse into a moment just like that, right after the infamous episode in the Garden of Eden.

The familiar story is this: the serpent, the woman, the fruit, the knowledge. But Bereshit Rabbah 20, a midrash (rabbinic interpretive commentary), or interpretation, on the book of Genesis, dives into God's specific reaction to the serpent, and it’s… different.

The verse in question is straightforward: "The Lord God said to the serpent: Because you did this…" But the midrash doesn't just accept that at face value. It connects this moment to a verse from Proverbs (16:28): “A contrary man incites strife, and a malcontent distances the ruler.” for a second. It's all about sowing discord and undermining authority.

In this interpretation, the serpent wasn't just offering a snack; it was actively creating conflict. The midrash casts the serpent as the "contrary man" who twisted God's words. It was a malcontent, voicing grievances against its Creator by telling the woman, “You will not die!” (Genesis 3:4). And ultimately, it distanced the ruler – alienated humanity from God, leading to the immediate curse.

Now, here’s the really intriguing part. With Adam, God has a discussion before the consequences hit. With Eve, too, there's a dialogue. But with the serpent? Silence. Judgment. Why?

The Midrash gives us a powerful insight into the mind of God (if we dare to anthropomorphize the Divine like that). The Holy One, blessed be He, recognizes that the serpent is just too clever, too slippery. The serpent is a rasha, a wicked one, who already has all the answers, all the justifications.

Imagine God trying to reason with the serpent. According to Bereshit Rabbah, God anticipates the serpent’s response: "You commanded them, and I commanded them. Why did they forsake your command and follow my command?" The serpent would essentially deflect blame, turning the situation into a theological debate.

So, instead of engaging in a futile argument, God simply delivers the sentence. No discussion. No negotiation. Just the consequences.

This passage raises so many questions, doesn't it? Is there a point where dialogue becomes pointless? Are some individuals so entrenched in their own justifications that any attempt at reasoning is a waste of time? The ancient Rabbis certainly seemed to think so.

It makes you wonder: in our own lives, are there times when we should skip the debate and focus on action? When dealing with someone intent on sowing discord, is silence sometimes the most powerful response?

This little snippet from Bereshit Rabbah offers a powerful lesson about the nature of conflict, the limits of dialogue, and the importance of recognizing when it’s time to simply say, "Enough."

Full source
Bereshit Rabbah 12:4Bereshit Rabbah

Before (Genesis 1:1), when "the earth was without form and void?" Jewish tradition grapples with this very question. It's a question about origins, about chaos, and about the very nature of creation itself.

Our sages, wrestling with the text of Genesis, offer some fascinating insights. to a passage from Bereshit Rabbah, a classic collection of rabbinic interpretations of the Book of Genesis. We'll be looking specifically at section 12.

The verse Rabbi Abahu makes a crucial distinction: he says that whenever the word eleh appears, it excludes what came before it. In contrast, the word ve’eleh adds to what came before.

So, what does eleh exclude in this context? According to Rabbi Abahu, it excludes…emptiness, disorder, and darkness. These are the very things that (Genesis 1:2) tells us characterized the world before God began to create. This interpretation suggests a clean break, a decisive move away from the primordial chaos. It's as if God said, "Enough! Let there be light, and let there be order."

But the discussion doesn't end there. We then have a debate between Rabbi Yehuda and Rabbi Nehemya about the timing of creation. Rabbi Yehuda emphasizes the phrase "The heavens and the earth…were completed” (Genesis 2:1), arguing that everything was created at its designated time. He extends this to "and their entire host" (Genesis 2:1), implying that the heavens and the earth, and all their contents, were created on separate days, each in its own time.

Rabbi Nehemya disagrees. He points back to (Genesis 2:4), "These are the outgrowths of the heavens and of the earth when they were created [on the day that the Lord God made the earth and the heavens]." He understands this to mean that the heavens and the earth brought forth their outgrowths, their potential, on the very same day they were created.

How can we reconcile these seemingly contradictory views? Rabbi Nehemya offers a beautiful analogy: He compares it to people picking figs. All the buds are there at the beginning of the season, but they ripen gradually, each at its own pace. Similarly, the outgrowths of the heavens and the earth were present in an initial form from the beginning, but they grew into their final form over the subsequent days. It's a process of unfolding, of potential becoming reality.

Rabbi Berekhya supports Rabbi Nehemya’s teaching with a verse from (Genesis 1:12): "The earth brought forth [vegetation]." The phrase "bringing forth" suggests that something was already stored inside the earth, waiting to emerge. It wasn't created ex nihilo, out of nothing, on that specific day, but rather it was a potential that was realized.

What does this all mean? It seems that our sages are wrestling with the very nature of time, creation, and potential. Was everything created instantaneously, or was it a gradual process? Was there truly nothing before creation, or was there a latent potential waiting to be unleashed?

These questions don't have easy answers, but the very act of confronting them, of engaging with the text in such a profound way, is what makes Jewish tradition so rich and enduring. Perhaps the most important takeaway is this: creation isn't just a one-time event. It's an ongoing process, a continuous unfolding of potential into reality. And we, as part of that creation, have a role to play in bringing that potential to fruition.

Full source