Parshat Bereshit6 min read

Creation Was Hidden Before It Appeared in Six Days

Earth pulled itself to the gate before heaven could look lazy, and Ben Zoma stared at the gap between waters until the world took him.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. Ben Zoma Stared at the Gap Between Waters
  2. All at Once or Day by Day in the Kitchen of Creation
  3. Living Things Placed in Empty Air
  4. Why Fish Require No Slaughter
  5. Heaven and Earth Were Already Finished Before Anyone Saw Them

Earth dragged itself to the gate before the sun was up.

The king had ordered all his servants to gather at the gate at dawn. When he arrived, he found the crowd already waiting. He looked them over and chose whom to praise first, not the ones always known for rising early, but the one known for sleeping late who had pulled himself up anyway, who had come against his own nature to honor the king.

Genesis names heaven before earth in the first verse, but turns in the second verse to describe the earth alone: formless and void, dark, deep. The sages asked why earth receives the first full description when heaven was named first. The answer came from the parable. Heaven always rises. Earth is heavy. Earth had to try. And God praised the one who tried.

Ben Zoma Stared at the Gap Between Waters

The spirit hovering over the face of the waters drove some sages into a stillness that bordered on absence. Ben Zoma once stood so lost in thought that Rabbi Yehoshua greeted him twice and received no answer. The third time, Ben Zoma looked up, distracted and far away.

He had been gazing into the work of creation, he said. He had realized that between the upper waters and the lower waters there was a gap of only three fingerbreadths. His proof was the word hovering. The verse does not say the spirit was blowing over the waters. It says hovering, like a bird trembling above its nest, wings brushing the fledglings below without quite touching them. Three fingerbreadths of separation, and the whole sky in between.

Rabbi Yehoshua walked away and told his students: "Ben Zoma is gone." Within a few days, Ben Zoma had left this world. The abyss he had looked into was too wide for a living man to look across.

All at Once or Day by Day in the Kitchen of Creation

Did God build the world step by step across six days, or create everything at once and merely reveal it in stages? The sages kept both readings without forcing a verdict.

Rabbi Yehudah pointed to the phrase and it was so, repeated day by day, as proof that each day did real and distinct work. Rabbi Nechemyah countered that the whole world was finished on day one, and when day three says let the earth bring forth, the earth is only yielding what was stored in it from the beginning. The vegetation was already there. The command just let it out.

A Roman noblewoman challenged Rabbi Yose ben Chalafta on this point. "Your God took six days?" She ran through the whole of Scripture in a day. Rabbi Yose turned her challenge back into her kitchen. Had she ever prepared a banquet for guests all at once, or did she work through it in steps? She admitted she cooked in stages. Then, said Rabbi Yose, the King who made the world built it the same way, in the order that served the guests best.

Living Things Placed in Empty Air

A human king builds a palace and fills the upper floors and lower floors with tenants. But no earthly king can house someone in the empty space between walls, in pure air with no floor, no beam, nothing holding the resident up but the building's atmosphere. That is impossible. No contractor has ever fulfilled such a lease.

The creation account says let birds fly above the earth across the open expanse of the sky. The sages stopped at that phrase. Open expanse means nothing but air. The Holy One placed living, breathing creatures in the open air itself, with nothing holding them up but the word. The bird rides emptiness, and the emptiness holds it. No human architect can manage that. God built a floor out of nothing and leased it to winged things.

Why Fish Require No Slaughter

The Torah demands ritual slaughter for cattle, a single cut for birds, and nothing at all for fish. The sages traced each requirement back to the morning of creation. A beast was formed from dry land, so it requires the full slaughter of both windpipe and gullet. A bird was formed from the mud where water and land meet, and so it requires only one cut. Fish were drawn straight from water, and so they need nothing, because the water itself covers them.

One sage noticed that birds carry scales on their legs, just like fish, proof that they straddle two worlds. One verse says birds came from water, another says God formed them from the ground. The school of Rabbi Yishmael resolved the contradiction: they came from a mixture of both, from the boundary material where water and earth met on the third and fifth days of creation.

Heaven and Earth Were Already Finished Before Anyone Saw Them

What does it mean that heaven and earth were finished? The sages reached for the bathhouse. Picture a basin brimming with water, and at the bottom two finely made ornaments lying unseen in the murk. While the water fills the basin, the craftsmanship is invisible. Pull the plug, shake out the water, and suddenly the ornaments shine into view. They were always there. What changed was that the covering was drained away.

So it was with creation. As long as formlessness and void filled the world, the finished work could not be seen. The design, the completed vessels, the order were already prepared under the chaos like ornaments under the bathwater. God did not build the world and then add chaos. He prepared the world beneath the chaos and then drained the chaos away. Creation began with concealment. What we call the six days of making is the unveiling.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

6 sources

The texts this telling draws on, in full. Open a card to read inline, or expand it for a wider, quieter read.

Yalkut Shimoni on Torah 4:7Yalkut Shimoni on Torah

(Genesis 1:2) And the earth was formlessness. Now since Scripture opened with the heaven first, what is the reason it explains the matters of the earth first? A parable: to what is the matter comparable? To a king of flesh and blood who said to his servants, Rise early and come to my gate. He rose early and found men and women there. Whom does he praise? The one whose custom it is not to rise early, and yet rose early.

Full source
Yalkut Shimoni on Torah 4:10Yalkut Shimoni on Torah

Another interpretation: And the spirit of God, this is the spirit of Adam the first man, as it is written (Psalms 139:5), Behind and before You have formed me, behind, for the work of the last day, and before, for the work of the first day. Rabbi Chaggai in the name of Rabbi Pedat says, And the spirit of God hovered, a covenant was made with the waters, that even in the hour of scorching heat a wind blows gently.

And already Rabbi Shimon ben Zoma was standing and lost in wonder. Rabbi Yehoshua passed by and greeted him once and twice, and he did not answer. The third time he answered him in haste. He said to him, What is this, Ben Zoma? From where do the feet come [where are you]? He said to him, I was contemplating. He said to him, I call heaven and earth to witness against me that I shall not stir from here until you tell me from where the feet come. He said to him, I was gazing into the work of creation, and there is between the upper waters and the lower waters only three fingerbreadths, as it says, And the spirit of God hovered. It is not written here blowing but hovering, like this bird that flutters with its wings, touching and not touching, as it is written, He hovers over his fledglings. Rabbi Yehoshua turned and said to his disciples, Ben Zoma is gone. And not many days passed, and Ben Zoma was no longer in the world.

Now this verse, And the spirit of God hovered, when is it written? On the first day. But the separation of the waters was on the second day, as it is written (verse 6), Let it divide between water and water. Rabbi Abbahu said, From the beginning of the world's creation the Holy One, blessed be He, foresaw the deeds of the righteous and the deeds of the wicked. And the earth was formlessness, these are the deeds of the wicked. And God said, Let there be light, these are the deeds of the righteous. But I do not know in which of them He delights. From what is written, And God saw the light, that it was good, it follows that He delights in the deeds of the righteous and does not delight in the deeds of the wicked.

Rabbi Chiyya the Great says, From the beginning of the world's creation the Holy One, blessed be He, foresaw the Temple built and destroyed and rebuilt. In the beginning God created, and so on, behold it is built, as you say (Isaiah 51:16), To plant the heavens and lay the foundations of the earth. And the earth was formlessness, behold it is destroyed, as you say, I saw the earth, and behold, it was formlessness. And God said, Let there be light, built and perfected in the time to come, as you say (Isaiah 60:1), Arise, shine, for your light has come.

Full source
Yalkut Shimoni on Torah 5:13Yalkut Shimoni on Torah

Rabbi Yehudah says: The world was created over six days, with each and every day's work, as it is written, "and it was so." But Rabbi Nechemyah says: From the first day the entire world was created, as it is said, "let the earth bring forth" (Genesis 1:24), a thing that had been prepared from the very beginning. A noble lady [matrona] asked Rabbi Yose ben Chalafta: In how many days did the Holy One, blessed be He, create His world? He said to her: From the first day. She said to him: From where do you know this? He said to her: Did you prepare a banquet? She said to him: Yes. He said to her: And how many kinds of dishes did you have? She said to him: Such and such. He said to him: And did you set them all before the guests at one time? She said to him: No; rather, I cooked all the dishes together, and I brought them in before the guests one by one. [So too God prepared all at the start and brought each forth in turn.] And all of this is from the verse, "for He is the Fashioner of all things" (Jeremiah 10:16).

Full source
Yalkut Shimoni on Torah 12:1Yalkut Shimoni on Torah

"And let birds fly" (Genesis 1:20). It is the way of the world that a king of flesh and blood builds a palace and settles dwellers in the upper stories and in the lower stories, but can he settle them in the open air? Yet the Holy One, blessed be He, settles dwellers in the open air, as it is said, "And let birds fly."

Full source
Yalkut Shimoni on Torah 12:2Yalkut Shimoni on Torah

How do we know that fish do not require ritual slaughter? Shall we say it is from what is written, "Shall flocks and herds be slaughtered for them to suffice them, or shall all the fish of the sea be gathered for them?" (Numbers 11:22), meaning by mere gathering? But then, from "and they gathered the quail" (Numbers 11:32), should we likewise say that quail require no slaughter? They reply: there [regarding quail] gathering is not written in place of the slaughter of other creatures, whereas here [regarding fish] gathering is written in place of the slaughter of other creatures.

Over the Galilean expounded: a beast, which was created from the dry land, its fitness for eating is by two signs [the slaughter of windpipe and gullet]; fish, which were created from the water, their fitness is by nothing at all; a bird, which was created from the mud [the mixture of water and earth], its fitness is by one sign. Rav Shmuel of Cappadocia said: know this, for birds have scales on their legs like fish.

He further questioned him: "Let the waters swarm with swarms of living creatures, and birds" (Genesis 1:20), evidently they were created from the water; yet it is written, "And the LORD God formed out of the ground every beast of the field and every bird" (Genesis 2:19), evidently they were created from the earth. He said to him: they were created from the mud. He saw his students looking at one another. He said to them: Does it trouble you that I pushed off my adversary with a straw? They were created from the water, and why then were they brought to the man to give them names? And some say: in the first formulation he was speaking to his students, and in the latter formulation he was speaking to that governor, because it is written concerning "and He formed."

Full source
Yalkut Shimoni on Torah 16:13Yalkut Shimoni on Torah

"And the heavens and the earth were finished" (Genesis 2:1). This is like a bath that was full of water and had within it two beautiful ornaments. As long as it was full of water, the work of the ornaments was not visible; once one opens it and shakes the water out of it, the work of the ornaments becomes visible. So too, as long as there was formlessness and void in the world, the work of the heavens and the earth was not visible; after the formlessness and void were uprooted, the work of the heavens and the earth became visible and they were made into finished vessels.

Full source