6 min read

Joseph Refused the Gold and Moses Absolved God's Vow After the Calf

Princesses on the rooftops threw bracelets down to make Joseph look up. He kept his eyes on the road. His family later threw their gold into a fire.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. The Daughters of Princes Threw Gold Down at Him
  2. The Cure at Marah Was as Bitter as the Water
  3. God Blamed Moses for the Crowd He Had Let In
  4. Moses Wrapped His Robe and Sat Down as a Court
  5. A King Counts His Sheep After the Wolves
Joseph Refused the Gold and Moses Absolved God's Vow After the Calf Click for full size

The Daughters of Princes Threw Gold Down at Him

They climbed onto the flat roofs when the viceroy's chariot came through, the daughters of Egypt's great houses, and they threw jewellery into the street. Bracelets. Neck chains. Good gold, thrown at a man's feet for one reason, which was to make him look up and find out who had thrown it.

Joseph kept his eyes on the road ahead of the horses. Every time. The Aramaic paraphrase of Jacob's deathbed blessing says he would not lift his eyes toward a single one of them, and gives the reason in his own voice: he did not want to stand guilty on the great day of judgment.

Old Jacob, dying, blessed that son for none of the things a father usually praises. Not the dreams. Not the granaries. Not the twenty years of power. He blessed him for a refusal. You were strong against the pull of sin, he said, and you beat every magician and wise man in Egypt without a weapon, and when they went to Pharaoh with lies about you, you put your hope in God and outlasted them. So take the blessing my fathers gave me. And because of what your eyes would not do, you are the father of two tribes instead of one.

The Cure at Marah Was as Bitter as the Water

Three days past the sea, the people were licking dry lips and saying things they would regret. Moses did not make a speech out of the prayer. He asked God to overlook what frightened men had shouted, and to give them something to drink, and he kept it short, and the answer came back at the same speed.

Take a piece of a laurel tree. Write the great Name on the wood. Put it in the water.

A man sweetens a bitter thing by adding something sweet to it. God sweetened the pool at Marah by throwing in a branch as bitter as the pool. The people drank, and then they came back to Moses and said they had sinned in complaining about water. God kept them standing there and handed them the Sabbath, the marriage laws, and the civil code on the spot, and told them that if the diseases of Egypt ever came near them, He would be their physician.

God Blamed Moses for the Crowd He Had Let In

The calf came later, and the argument on the mountain went badly for Moses before it went well.

I told you in Egypt to bring the people out, God said. I did not tell you to bring the mixed multitude with them. You stood there and talked Me into it, all mercy and modesty, and I gave in knowing exactly how it would end. Your people made that calf. Yours.

Moses ran out of things to say and got ready to stop asking. Then God spoke gently, because He had never meant to destroy them and only wanted to hear the man argue. Even in Egypt I could see what they would do afterward, He said. You saw Sinai coming. I saw Sinai and the calf both.

Moses took that as an opening and pushed. Lord of the world, they have set up a rival to You. The calf will summon the stars and the moon while You bring up the sun. You send the dew and he sends the wind. You send the rain and he calls the plants out of the ground.

You are as confused as they are, God said. The thing is nothing at all.

Moses had him. Then why is the Almighty angry with His people over a nothing?

Moses Wrapped His Robe and Sat Down as a Court

God fell back on the oath. I have sworn that whoever sacrifices to any god but the Lord is to be destroyed, and once a word leaves My mouth I do not take it back.

You gave us a law for that, Moses said. A learned man can release a person from a vow. And any judge who wants his rulings honored has to live under the rulings he issues. You wrote the law of release. Now put Yourself under it and let me release You.

He did not wait for permission. Moses pulled his cloak around him the way a judge robes, sat himself down, and convened a court of one on the mountain with God standing before it. He told God what a petitioner says. Say that You regret the harm You intended for Your people.

God said it.

Then Moses gave the ruling out loud, the formula any village court would use. You are released from Your oath and from Your vow.

A King Counts His Sheep After the Wolves

Moses came down the second time with light coming off his face, and the people were not comforted by it.

We were brought low over what we did, they said. You tell us we are forgiven. You were brought low with us, and now we can see You raised up again, and we are still down here.

He went straight back up with it. When You humbled them You humbled me. If I am lifted, lift them.

So count them, God said. Let the world see how close to Me they are. Moses asked why Israel and no one else, out of all the nations. Because the others are not Mine, God said, and a man values most the property he paid the most for.

Moses had one objection left. You promised Abraham his children would be like the stars. Am I to stand in the sand and number the stars? So God gave him a shortcut, the letters of the tribal names added up, and the sum came out at six hundred thousand less the three thousand the plague had taken after the calf.

That was the reason for the counting. A king hears that wolves have been in among his flock. He does not go out and look at the wolves. He sends word to the shepherds to count the sheep, so he knows what it cost him.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

5 sources

The texts behind this telling. Some cards carry a translation of the source; others are our own retelling of it, and each card says which. Every card links out to the original.

Legends of the Jews 1:403Legends of the Jews

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Legends of the Jews by Louis Ginzberg (1909) · Public Domain

Legends of the Jews turns to Joseph, Jacob's Transgression.

Jacob begins, according to Legends of the Jews, by acknowledging Joseph's upbringing: "O son whom I bred up, Joseph, whom I raised..." Right away, you sense the deep connection, the years of shared experience and love. But then comes the real kicker: "...and who wast strong to resist the enticements of sin." This isn't just about being a "good" person. It's about actively fighting against temptation, standing firm in the face of immense pressure. Jacob recognizes that Joseph didn't just stumble into righteousness; he actively chose it, time and time again.

He continues, "Thou didst conquer all the magicians and the wise men of Egypt by thy wisdom and thy pious deeds." Joseph, a foreigner in a land of powerful magic and ancient knowledge, outshone them all, not through trickery or force, but through his wisdom and devotion to God. As Ginzberg's retelling in Legends of the Jews emphasizes, it wasn’t just intellect, but pious deeds that secured him the victory.

Then comes an almost unbelievable detail: "The daughters of princes cast their jewels before thee, to draw thine eyes upon them when thou didst pass through the land of Egypt, but thou didst not look their way, and therefore wast thou made the father of two tribes." Imagine the scene: wealth, beauty, power, all offered to him, and he turned away. This, Jacob says, is why Joseph was blessed with the fatherhood of two tribes. It wasn't just about avoiding temptation; it was about the strength of character it demonstrated.

Even when faced with slander and defamation, Jacob reminds Joseph, "The magicians and the wise men of Egypt sought to defame thee before Pharaoh and slander thee, but thou didst set thy hope in the Almighty." This act of trusting in El Shaddai (the Almighty) becomes the foundation for the blessing that follows.

So, what exactly is this blessing? It's a powerful affirmation: "Therefore may He who appeared unto me as El Shaddai bless thee and grant thee fertile soil and much cattle." It's a wish for prosperity, for abundance, for a flourishing legacy. But it's more than that.

The blessing continues, reaching back through generations: "May the blessing thy father giveth thee now, and the blessing that his fathers Abraham and Isaac gave him, and that called forth the envy of the great of the world, Ishmael, Esau, and the sons of Keturah--may all these blessings be a crown upon the head of Joseph, and a chain upon the neck of him that was the ruler of Egypt, and yet diminished not the honor due to his brethren."

This is truly remarkable! It’s an accumulation of ancestral blessings, a weight of expectation and promise. And notice the inclusion of "envy." Even the blessings that sparked jealousy and conflict are now channeled towards Joseph. The blessing is so powerful, it adorns him like royalty, yet it doesn't diminish the honor of his brothers. It elevates Joseph while maintaining family unity.

It's not just about receiving good fortune. It's about earning it through resilience, integrity, and unwavering faith. It's about recognizing the power of character and the importance of staying true to one's values, even when faced with immense pressure. And perhaps most importantly, it's a reminder that the blessings we receive are often built upon the foundations laid by those who came before us.

Full source
Legends of the Jews 1:79Legends of the Jews

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Legends of the Jews by Louis Ginzberg (1909) · Public Domain

They did what any of us might do: they complained. Loudly. But Moses, ever the leader, knew what to do. Instead of joining in the despair, he turned to the one source of true hope: prayer.

Here’s the thing: Moses, mindful of their suffering, didn’t offer a long, drawn-out plea. He kept it short, simple, and direct. And, just as quickly, God responded. God's instruction, as recounted in Legends of the Jews by Rabbi Louis Ginzberg, was surprising. He told Moses to take a piece of laurel wood, inscribe upon it the great and glorious name of God, and cast it into the water. And just like that, the bitter turned sweet.

Isn't that fascinating? The Midrash (rabbinic interpretive commentary), specifically Midrash Rabbah, often explores these divine paradoxes. We expect sweetness to come from sweetness. But here, God transforms bitterness with bitterness. The Zohar tells us that everything contains its opposite. This miracle wasn’t just about quenching thirst. It was about teaching a profound lesson. The Israelites, witnessing this, recognized their error. "O Lord of the world!" they cried, "We sinned against Thee when we murmured about the water."

Marah became more than just the site of a water miracle. It was here, according to tradition, that God gave Israel essential precepts – important laws and teachings. Things like the Sabbath rest, marriage laws, and civil laws. God said to them, "If you observe these statutes, you will receive many more." These included the Ten Commandments, the Halakot (Jewish law), and the Haggadot (narrative traditions). The Torah, God promised, would bring them happiness and life.

The message was clear: living an upright life, dealing virtuously with others – this was paramount. As Ginzberg puts it, God would value such behavior as if they had fulfilled all the commandments! And, furthermore, He would shield them from the diseases that plagued Egypt.

But there was a condition. If they disregarded God's laws and were afflicted by illness, then God would also be their physician. "As soon as you observe the laws," He promised, "the diseases shall vanish."

So, Marah wasn't just about water. It was about a covenant, a promise, and a profound lesson in faith, obedience, and the transformative power of divine intervention.

Full source
Legends of the Jews 2:106Legends of the Jews

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Legends of the Jews by Louis Ginzberg (1909) · Public Domain

The story of the Golden Calf is a foundation of the Torah, a moment of profound betrayal after the incredible miracle of the Exodus. But according to the legends, Moses himself bore some of the responsibility, or at least that's what God implied.

"Moses," God says, according to Ginzberg's retelling in Legends of the Jews, "when Israel was still in Egypt, I told you to lead them out, but not to bring along the erev rav, the mixed multitude. But you, in your humility, persuaded Me to accept them, these penitents. And now your people have seduced Israel to idolatry!"

Can you imagine the weight of that? Moses, the leader, the lawgiver, being told that his own compassion had led to this catastrophe. You can almost feel his despair. He almost gives up interceding for Israel.

Then, in a moment of divine back-and-forth, God shows Moses a glimmer of hope. It's almost as if God wants Moses to argue, to plead. "Even in Egypt," God says, "I foresaw what this people would do. You only foresaw the receiving of the Torah on Sinai, but I foresaw the worship of the Calf as well."

This is key. God isn't surprised. According to God, this was all foreseen, even before the Exodus. And this gives Moses new courage.

So, Moses, ever the advocate, begins to argue. "Lord of the world," he says, "Israel has indeed created a rival for You. This Calf is supposed to do what only You can do! Make the stars appear, send the dew.."

But God interrupts, "Moses, you're mistaken. The idol is absolutely nothing."

And Moses, quick as ever, seizes on that. "If it's nothing," he argues, "why are You angry with Your people for worshipping nothing?"

He continues, pointing out that God Himself said it was the erev rav, the mixed multitude, who were primarily to blame. He offers to vouch for the righteous among them: Aaron, his sons, Joshua, Caleb, and many others.

But God is resolute. "I have vowed," He says, quoting (Exodus 22:19), "that 'He that sacrificeth unto any god, save unto the Lord only, he shall be utterly destroyed,' and a vow that has once passed My lips, I cannot retract."

Now, this is where the story takes a truly remarkable turn. Moses, the student of God, dares to use God's own teachings against Him.

"Lord of the world!" Moses exclaims. "Haven't You given us the law of absolution from a vow? Doesn't a learned man have the power to absolve anyone from their vows? Every judge who desires his decisions to be valid must subject himself to the law. And You, who prescribed this law, must subject Yourself to it, and through me be absolved from Your vow!"

Imagine the audacity! Moses, a mortal man, suggesting that he can absolve God from His own oath. It's an incredible moment of chutzpah, of righteous defiance.

According to Legends of the Jews, Moses then wraps himself in his robe, sits down, and commands God to allow him to absolve Him. He instructs God to say, "I repent of the evil that I had determined to bring upon My people." And then, Moses cries out, "You are absolved from Thine oath and vow!"

This isn't about power, but about relationship. Moses is not trying to usurp God's authority, but to remind Him of His own mercy, of the principles of justice and forgiveness that He Himself established. It's evidence of the profound bond between God and Moses, a relationship built on both reverence and a fierce, unwavering love for the people of Israel.

It’s a reminder that even in moments of deep crisis and apparent divine decree, there’s room for dialogue, for pleading, and perhaps, even for changing the course of destiny. What does this story teach us about our own relationships with authority, with tradition, and with the divine? And what does it say about the power of human compassion and courage in the face of seemingly insurmountable odds?

Full source
Legends of the Jews 2:138Legends of the Jews

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Legends of the Jews by Louis Ginzberg (1909) · Public Domain

The story begins with Moses, fresh from his encounter with God on Mount Sinai. He comes down with the Ten Commandments, radiating… literally. The Israelites, still reeling from their sin of the Golden Calf, are awestruck, even a little intimidated by the light emanating from his face. "We were humbled by God because of our sin," they say to Moses, as recounted in Ginzberg's Legends of the Jews. "God has forgiven us, but you, Moses, have been exalted, while we remain humbled."

Moses, ever the advocate for his people, takes their concerns straight to God. "When you humbled them, you humbled me too," he pleads. "If you've raised me up, shouldn't you raise them up as well?"

God responds with reassurance. "Truly, as I have exalted thee, so will I exalt them also," He says, according to the tale. But then comes a peculiar request: "Record their number, and through this show the world how near to My heart is the nation that before all others acknowledged Me as their king."

This is where it gets interesting. Moses balks. "O Lord of the world!" he exclaims, "You have so many nations, but you don't bother counting them. Why single out Israel?"

God's response is powerful. "All these multitudes do not belong to Me," He says, "they are doomed to the destruction of Gehenna" – often translated as hell, but perhaps better understood as a place of purification. "But Israel is My possession. And as a man most prizes the possession he paid for most dearly, so is Israel most dear to Me, because I have with great exertions made it My own." God sees Israel as a precious possession, something painstakingly acquired. It's a relationship built on effort, on both sides.

But Moses isn't done questioning. He reminds God of the promise to Abraham: "I will make thy seed as the stars in the heavens," – an uncountable multitude. How can he reconcile that promise with the command to count them?

God, in His infinite wisdom, provides a unique solution. "Thou needest not actually count them," He explains. "But if thou wouldst determine their number, add together the numerical value of the names of the tribes, and the result will be their number."

This is a fascinating insight into Jewish thought. In Hebrew, each letter also represents a number. This system, called gematria, allows for hidden meanings and connections to be revealed through numerical analysis.

So, Moses does as instructed. He adds up the numerical values of the tribes' names and arrives at a total. But here's the kicker: the total is sixty myriads (hundreds of thousands) less three thousand. According to the story, those three thousand were lost to the plague that followed the sin of the Golden Calf.

This detail highlights the difference between the first census at the Exodus and the second one.

The Midrash Rabbah uses an analogy to illustrate God's actions: "God treated Israel as did that king his herd, who ordered the shepherds tell the tale of the sheep when he heard that wolves had been among them and had killed some, having this reckoning made in order to determine the amount of his loss."

So, what does it all mean? On one level, it's a story about the special relationship between God and Israel. God's desire to count them, even in a symbolic way, reflects His deep affection and investment in their well-being. It's also a story about accountability. Even in a relationship built on love and promise, actions matter.

Perhaps the story also hints at the idea that being "chosen" isn't always easy. It comes with expectations, with responsibilities. The Israelites are singled out, yes, but not just for blessings. They're also held to a higher standard. And maybe, just maybe, that's what makes them so special in God's eyes.

Full source
Targum Pseudo-Jonathan on Genesis 49:22Targum Pseudo-Jonathan on Genesis

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Targum of Jonathan ben Uzziel, trans. J. W. Etheridge, London, 1862 · Public Domain

Joseph's blessing is the longest Jacob delivers, and Targum Pseudo-Jonathan packs it with detail no translator could resist. "Joseph, my son, thou hast become great and mighty.. because thou didst subdue thy inclination in the matter of thy mistress, and in the work of thy brethren" (Genesis 49:22).

Two tests shaped Joseph. The first was Potiphar's wife, who pursued him day after day until he fled her grip, leaving his cloak behind (Genesis 39:12). The Targum calls her "thy mistress", the wife of the master who had trusted him. The temptation was not only desire; it was convenience, safety, career. Joseph walked straight through that door and into prison rather than betray that trust.

The second test was his brothers. When famine drove them to Egypt and they knelt before him without recognizing him, Joseph held the entire arc of their sin in his hand. He could have destroyed them. He chose reconciliation (Genesis 45:4-5).

Then the Targum adds a breathtaking scene. As Joseph rode through Egyptian streets in his viceroy's chariot, "the daughters of princes walking on the high places cast before thee bracelets and chains of gold, that thou shouldst lift up thine eyes upon them." Joseph kept his eyes down. The man who had already refused one woman's embrace would not trade his soul for a hundred. Jacob blesses him, on the deathbed, for the discipline of downcast eyes.

Full source