5 min read

Moses Hoped for the Priesthood and God Named Aaron Instead

The oil smelled of myrrh and cinnamon. Moses already felt the stones on his chest. God named Aaron, his brother.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. Appoint Me a High Priest
  2. Oil on Aaron's Head
  3. Two Breasts of Torah
  4. Three Crowns and One Above Them
  5. Aaron's Heart After His Sons
Moses Hoped for the Priesthood and God Named Aaron Instead Click for full size

Appoint Me a High Priest

Moses stood in the heat of the camp and waited for the next order. The Tent was up. Oil sat ready in a flask that smelled of myrrh and cinnamon. Smoke from the morning offerings still clung to the canvas.

"Go," said the Holy One. "Appoint Me a High Priest."

"From which tribe?" Moses asked.

"From Levi."

His heart leaped so hard he almost smiled. Levi was his own house. He had carried the tablets. He had spoken with God face to face as a man speaks with his friend. For a breath he already felt the breastplate on his chest, the stones cold against linen, the names of the tribes pressing into him.

The next sentence cut the leap clean in half.

"By your life," said God, "it is Aaron, your brother."

Moses did not argue. He stood holding the flask he had expected for himself. Beloved tribe. Denied office. Brother raised.

Oil on Aaron's Head

Aaron stepped forward when they called him. Moses unstoppered the flask and poured the holy oil on his brother's head. It ran into the beard and down onto the collar of the robe. Moses set the breastplate over Aaron's heart. Twelve stones. Twelve names. Letters cut deep enough that a missing stroke would have broken the atonement.

Without those names, Aaron's service would have been no service at all. He would have stood at the altar and died there. Lineage was not enough. Oil was not enough. The people engraved on his chest had to be complete, every letter, every vowel-point, or the altar would not take him. Rabbi Bivai later said a single missing letter ruined the work. Rabbi Hoshaya said even a missing point was enough to fail the day.

Moses felt the humbling land twice. First, the crown had not come to him. Second, even the brother who wore it did not stand by birth alone. The names of Israel held him up. The High Priest was a man wearing a nation on his heart, not a prince wearing a private honor.

Two Breasts of Torah

Moses took Aaron aside before the people drank from either of them. He spoke every word God had given him, and then he spoke the Ineffable Name, word by word, until Aaron could carry it. What Moses received, he poured. He did not keep a private cistern.

Years later Samuel named both brothers in one breath before Israel. "The Lord who made Moses and Aaron." The Song had already given the image: "Your two breasts" (Song of Songs 4:5). Full of Torah the way a breast is full of milk. Neither greater. Moses not above Aaron. Aaron not above Moses. A breast is the splendor of a woman. So these two were the splendor of Israel, matched, neither permitted to dry up while the other flowed.

A man of flesh waits for the wound, then hunts for a bandage. The Holy One fashions the bandage first and only afterward looks at the cut. Moses and Aaron were that advance care, set in place before the people knew how deep the gash of exile, calf, and complaint would run. "For I will restore health to you, and heal your wounds," says the Lord (Jeremiah 30:17).

Three Crowns and One Above Them

Rabbi Shimon ben Yochai named three crowns and set them on the table. Torah. Priesthood. Kingship. David took kingship. Aaron took priesthood. The crown of Torah lies open for whoever will take it, and the one who takes it is counted as having won them all. No tribe can fence it. No oil is required. A student who sits long enough and lives clean enough can wear what kings and priests cannot monopolize.

Above every crown sits a fourth that no inheritance can guarantee: the crown of a good name. So precious is that name that the Holy One Himself walked a road of five hundred years to make one, to redeem a people and to make Himself a name among them (2 Samuel 7:23). Heaven took a long road for a reputation that cannot be poured from a flask.

Aaron's Heart After His Sons

Aaron's heart broke later, when Nadab and Abihu died with strange fire still in their pans. The camp heard the silence that followed. Aaron did not speak. He stood in the white and let the grief empty him.

Then the divine speech came to him alone. Not through Moses this time. Direct. The precepts of the Lord gladdened what mourning had emptied. A crown for the head. A necklace for the neck. A remedy for the heart. A salve for the eyes. Healing for the flesh. Torah sat on him the way oil had sat on him, and this time it was medicine, not appointment.

Moses had lost the first office and kept the harder work. He taught. He poured. He watched oil run into a beard that was not his. In the end the camp saw two men at the center, not one. The flask went to Aaron. The teaching went through Moses. The good name hung above both, waiting for whoever would earn it without a tribe to lean on.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

3 sources

The texts behind this telling. Some cards carry a translation of the source; others are our own retelling of it, and each card says which. Every card links out to the original.

Midrash Shmuel 23:3Midrash Shmuel

Translation of the source text.Midrash Shmuel, Krakow 1893, Public Domain, on Sefaria · CC-BY-SA

Rabbi Yehudah and Rabbi Nechemyah. Rabbi Yehudah says: The Holy One, blessed be He, said to Moses, "Moses, go and appoint for Me a High Priest." He said to Him, "From which tribe?" He said to him, "From the tribe of Levi." At that moment Moses rejoiced and said, "How beloved is my tribe!" He said to him, "By your life, it is Aaron your brother," as it is said, "And bring near to yourself Aaron your brother" (Exodus 28:1). He said to Him, "With what shall I anoint him?" He said to him, "With the anointing oil," as it is said, "And you shall take the anointing oil, etc." (ibid. 29:7). "But his service is no service, and he is liable to death, were it not for the names of the tribes that are engraved upon his heart," as it is written, "And Aaron shall bear the names, etc." (ibid.).

The Holy One, blessed be He, said: More beloved to Me are the names of the tribes than the tribe of Levi and than the High Priest who is anointed with the anointing oil. Rabbi Bivai said in the name of Rabbi Reuven: If they were missing a single letter, they would not effect atonement. Rabbi Hoshaya taught: Even a single vowel-point.

Rabbi Shimon ben Yochai taught: There are three crowns, the crown of Torah, the crown of priesthood, and the crown of kingship, and the crown of a good name rises above them all. The crown of kingship, David merited it and took it. The crown of priesthood, Aaron merited it and took it. The crown of Torah remains as a rebuke to all who come into the world, to say: For if the crown of priesthood and the crown of kingship were available, I would have merited them and taken them; but behold, the crown of Torah remains, whoever merits it, it is reckoned for him as though he merited them all, and whoever did not merit Torah, did not merit any one of them.

Rabbi Avin said in the name of Rabbi Shimon ben Yochai: We find that the Holy One, blessed be He, went a journey of five hundred years in order to take for Himself a good name, as it is written, "Whom God went to redeem to Himself as a people, to make Himself a name" (2 Samuel 7:23).

Full source
Midrash Shmuel 15:1Midrash Shmuel

Translation of the source text.Midrash Shmuel, Krakow 1893, Public Domain, on Sefaria · CC-BY-SA

"And Samuel said to the people: 'The Lord, who made Moses and Aaron, and who brought up your fathers out of the land of Egypt'" (1 Samuel 12:6). "Your two breasts" (Song of Songs 4:5), [these are Moses and Aaron]. Just as these breasts are full of milk, so Moses and Aaron are full of Torah. Just as these breasts are the splendor of a woman, [so Moses and Aaron are the splendor of Israel; just as these breasts are the praise of a woman,] so Moses and Aaron are the praise of Israel. Just as these breasts are the glory of a woman, so too Moses [and Aaron] are the glory of Israel. Just as with these breasts, neither one of them is greater than its fellow, so Moses was not greater than Aaron, nor Aaron greater than Moses. Just as with these breasts, what the woman eats the infant nurses, so all the Torah that Moses learned he taught to Aaron. This is what is written: "And Moses told Aaron all the words of the Lord" (Exodus 4:28). And the Rabbis say: He revealed to him the Ineffable Name. Rabbi Abba bar Zutra in the name of Rabbi Samuel: A creature of flesh and blood does not prepare the bandage until he sees the wound; but He who spoke and the world came into being, blessed be He, is not so, rather, He prepares the bandage and afterward sees the wound. This is what is written: "For I will restore health to you, and I will heal you of your wounds, says the Lord" (Jeremiah 30:17).

Full source
Vayikra Rabbah 12:3Vayikra Rabbah

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Sefaria Midrash Rabbah, 2022 · CC-BY

Not just Torah as in, "read the text." More like, experience the Torah. The passage begins with a verse from Psalms (19:9): "The precepts of the Lord are upright, gladdening the heart.” But what does that mean, really?

Rabbi Ḥizkiya offers a beautiful, almost poetic interpretation. He says that the words of Torah become a crown for the head, a necklace for the neck, a remedy for the heart, a salve for the eyes, and even a cup of root potion for the intestines! Sounds like a complete wellness package. a bit. Where does he get these images? Well, he backs them up with scripture, of course.

A crown for the head? That comes from Proverbs (1:9): “For they will be a graceful adornment for your head.” And a necklace for the neck? Also Proverbs (1:9): “And necklaces for your neck.” See how the Torah itself illustrates and reinforces its own power?

“A remedy for the heart” goes back to our original verse: “The precepts of the Lord are upright, gladdening the heart.” And for the “salve for the eyes,” we have (Psalms 19:9) again: “The commandments of the Lord are clear, enlightening the eyes.” It's all interconnected, weaving together to paint a picture of Torah as something that revitalizes us from head to toe.

And that "cup of root potion for the intestines? It comes from (Proverbs 3:8): “It will be healing for your navel.” Taken literally, it sounds like a cure for a stomach ache. But maybe it hints at something deeper. Perhaps the Torah can soothe even our deepest, most hidden pains.

But it doesn't stop there. The passage connects this idea to the 248 limbs of the human body, drawing from (Proverbs 4:22): “For they are life for those who find them [and healing for all one's flesh].” The Torah, then, isn't just a mental or emotional exercise; it's something that can bring life and healing to our very physical being.

Then, the text shifts focus to Aaron, the High Priest. Remember what happened to his sons? It was a devastating loss, a source of profound sadness. And yet, when God spoke directly to him, Aaron found joy. Where do we see that? Well, the text points us to the simple phrase: "The Lord spoke with Aaron." This suggests that even in the face of unimaginable grief, connection with the Divine – through Torah, through divine speech – can bring solace and even joy.

So, what does this all mean for us today? It's an invitation, I think, to engage with Torah not just as a set of rules or stories, but as a source of profound healing and joy. It’s a call to see the words of the Torah as something that can adorn us, heal us, and connect us to something bigger than ourselves. It’s a reminder that even in the midst of sadness and difficulty, there is always the possibility of finding light and joy through connection with the Divine. And isn't that something worth striving for?

Full source