6 min read

Three Wars and the Figure Walking Out of Edom

Rabbi Ishmael seated the Sanhedrin at the Temple gate and laid out fifteen signs, three wars, and a figure emerging from Edom in crimson garments.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. What Balaam Heard in His Grief
  2. Fifteen Signs Before the End
  3. Three Wars on Three Fronts
  4. The Figure from Edom

Rabbi Ishmael rose without explanation and sent for every member of the court. Great and small, he said. All of them. The summons went out to the third entrance of the house of God, and the sages came.

He sat on a chair of pure marble. His father Elisha had given it to him, brought from his mother's dowry, and the weight of that lineage was in the seat itself, cold stone worn smooth by the hands of the family. Around him the full assembly gathered: Rabban Simon ben Gamliel, Rabbi Eliezer the Great, Rabbi Elazar ben Dama, Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Judah ben Babba, and the others whose names filled the study halls of the age. They took their places. Between the gathered sages and the assembly standing behind them, torches of light appeared, and spiderwebs of fire, a partition neither side could cross. The teacher Rabbi Nehunya ben Hakkanah sat and began to set in order the teachings of the Merkavah, the descent and ascent, how one goes down and how one rises, and this assembly of marble and flame was his classroom.

It was inside this gathering, insulated from the ordinary world by fire and marble and the weight of consecrated company, that Rabbi Ishmael brought forward what he had learned about the end of days.

What Balaam Heard in His Grief

The source of the prophecy ran further back than the assembly. Balaam, the seer Balak hired to curse Israel, had noticed something in the structure of nations that disturbed him. Of all the peoples God had created, only one bore God's name embedded inside it. Only Israel. But then Balaam looked again and saw the name of Ishmael, Abraham's eldest son, ancestor of peoples beyond count. Close enough to Israel's name to echo it. Close enough to create a kind of shadow.

Balaam's cry was a recognition, not a curse. "Alas, who shall live when God establishes him?" (Numbers 24:23). Who survives the days when the children of Ishmael rise? The lament sat inside scripture for generations, waiting for someone to pull the thread.

Rabbi Ishmael pulled it.

Fifteen Signs Before the End

He enumerated them, one after another, in the order he had received them. Fifteen things the children of Ishmael would do in the land of Israel in the latter days.

They will measure the land with ropes. They will change a cemetery into a resting place for sheep, a dunghill. They will measure from the tops of the mountains. Falsehood will multiply and truth will be hidden. Statutes will be removed far from Israel. Sins will increase. The worm-crimson dye will appear in the wool, and insects will cover paper and pen. A rock of the kingdom will be hewn down. The desolated cities will be rebuilt and the roads swept. Gardens and parks will be planted. The broken walls of the Temple will be fenced in. A building will rise in the holy place. Two brothers will rule as princes at the end.

And then, after the two princes, a branch. The Son of David (Daniel 2:44).

The sages in the assembly were quiet. The signs were not all ruin. Roads swept, cities rebuilt, gardens planted. It was the building in the holy place that no one could fully look at, and the two princes, and then, after, the branch. Fourteen things before the fifteenth. Destruction woven into construction until you could not say where one ended and the other began.

Three Wars on Three Fronts

From Balaam's lament and the fifteen signs, Rabbi Ishmael moved to the final convulsions. He drew the image from Isaiah's vision (Isaiah 21:15): "For they fled away from the swords." The word cherev, sword, but plural. He read the three plurals as three separate wars, each one with its own theater.

The first war in the forest of Arabia. "From the drawn sword." A desert war, the drawn blade meaning a conflict begun, a force in motion, an army already past the heart of it of return.

The second on the sea. "From the bent bow." Fleets and coasts, nations fighting over water, the bow drawn but not yet released, everything suspended above the surface.

The third in the great city, which is Rome. "From the grievousness of the war." More grievous than the first two combined. The city that had burned the Temple, held Israel's exiles in its belly for generations, sat at the end of the sequence as the place where everything converged. The third war was not just greater in scale. It was the culminating pressure, the weight that would finally crack Rome open.

The Figure from Edom

And from that cracked city, from the smoke of the third and most grievous war, a figure would emerge walking toward the land of Israel.

Isaiah had seen him too (Isaiah 63:1): "Who is this that comes from Edom, with crimsoned garments from Bozrah? This that is glorious in his apparel, marching in the greatness of his strength? I that speak in righteousness, mighty to save."

Edom was Rome's name in the tradition. Bozrah was its heartland. The crimson on the garments was the residue of war, the color of what a man carries when he walks out of the last battle of history. The figure would see the destruction of the armies, both the first and the second and the third, all the wars witnessed and survived, and then he would come into the land.

The Son of David coming not from the east or the sky or the sea. Coming from Edom. Walking out of Rome's wreckage in red.

Rabbi Ishmael offered no consolation speech, no exhortation. The torches of fire still stood between the sages and the assembly. The marble chair held its cold weight. He had named what was coming: fifteen signs, three wars, one figure. The session of the Sanhedrin at the house of God did what any proper court does with testimony. It received it, and the assembly stood in silence.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

3 sources

The texts this telling draws on, in full. Open a card to read inline, or expand it for a wider, quieter read.

Pirkei DeRabbi Eliezer 30:12Pirkei DeRabbi Eliezer

This ancient text, a non-canonical Midrash (rabbinic interpretive commentary), offers a unique, sometimes cryptic, perspective on the relationship between Israel and the descendants of Ishmael, and the events that will unfold in the "latter days."

He observes that among all the nations God created, only Israel bears God's name. But, he notes, God made the name of Ishmael similar to Israel. This, according to Balaam, is a cause for lament. "Alas, who shall live when God establisheth him?" (Num. 24:23). It's a loaded statement, hinting at a future of conflict and hardship.

What exactly will that future look like? That's where Rabbi Ishmael steps in. He lays out fifteen specific actions that the children of Ishmael will supposedly undertake in the land of Israel in the "latter days." Now, remember, these are interpretations and predictions from a specific historical and theological viewpoint.

The passage unfolds some of these.

Some are quite literal: "They will measure the land with ropes." "They will plant gardens and parks, and fence in the broken walls of the Temple." We see hints of development, of changing landscapes. But then things take a darker turn. "They will change a cemetery into a resting-place for sheep (and) a dunghill." Respect for the dead is a deeply ingrained value in Jewish tradition, so this act would be seen as a grave desecration.

"Falsehood will multiply and truth will be hidden." A classic sign of troubled times. "The statutes will be removed far from Israel; sins will be multiplied in Israel." A breakdown of moral and religious order. "Worm-crimson will be in the wool, and he will cover with insects paper and pen." This one's a bit more obscure, perhaps alluding to corruption or impurity seeping into even the most basic aspects of life and governance. Some understand this as a reference to the use of inferior dyes and writing materials.

And then, a glimmer of hope: "They will rebuild the desolated cities and sweep the ways." Even amidst the chaos, there's a promise of renewal, of rebuilding. "They will build a building in the Holy Place." This is perhaps the most contentious statement. What building? What purpose? Interpretations vary widely.

The prophecy concludes with a dramatic crescendo. "And two brothers will arise over them, princes at the end; and in their days the Branch, the Son of David, will arise, as it is said, 'And in the days of those kings shall the God of heaven set up a kingdom, which shall never be destroyed' (Dan. 2:44)." This speaks of a time of turmoil, led by two powerful figures, ultimately leading to the arrival of the Mashiach (Messiah), the descendant of David, who will usher in an era of everlasting peace and divine sovereignty.

So, what are we to make of all this? Pirkei DeRabbi Eliezer, like many ancient texts, offers a lens through which to view history and to contemplate the future. It's a reminder that the relationship between different peoples is complex and often fraught with tension. But it also holds the promise of redemption, of a future where divine justice and peace will ultimately prevail. It invites us to consider our role in shaping that future, and to work towards a world where truth and understanding triumph over falsehood and division.

Are these prophecies to be taken literally? Are they symbolic? That's up to each of us to contemplate, to wrestle with, and to ultimately find our own understanding within the tradition of Jewish tradition.

Full source
Heikhalot Rabbati 16:3Heikhalot Rabbati

Heikhalot (the heavenly palaces) Rabbati, specifically section 16, and witness a gathering of some of the greatest sages in Jewish history.

The scene opens with Rabbi Ishmael. He doesn't just casually mention something – he declares it: "Straightway I arose and assembled all the Sanhedrin (the supreme rabbinic court), great and small, to the third entrance which was in the house of the Lord." Can you feel the urgency? It wasn't just any meeting; it was a convocation of the most respected legal minds of the time.

Rabbi Ishmael even describes his seat: "a chair of pure marble which Elisha my father gave me, for it was of the goods of her that bore me which she did bring to him in her dowry." A small detail, perhaps, but it adds a layer of personal history and emphasizes the significance of the moment. This wasn't just a chair; it was a family heirloom, a symbol of lineage and tradition.

Who's in attendance at this extraordinary assembly? Get ready for a roll call of legends: Rabban Simon ben Gamliel, Rabbi Eliezer the Great, Rabbi Elazar ben Dama, Elazar ben Shammua, Jonathan ben Dahabhai, Haninah ben Hakkanai, Jonathan ben Uziel, Rabbi Akiba, and Rabbi Judah ben Babba. A veritable Mount Rushmore of rabbinic giants! Imagine being a fly on the wall at that meeting. The sheer intellectual and spiritual power in that room must have been palpable.

But wait, there's more. "All the multitude of companies were standing upon their feet, for they saw spiderwebs of fire and torches of light which made a separation between them and between us." Spiderwebs of fire? Torches of light? This isn't your average study session. This is a glimpse into the otherworldly, a hint of the divine presence manifesting itself. The separation suggests a boundary, a threshold between the mundane and the sacred.

At the center of it all sits Rabbi Nehunya ben Hakkanah. "And Rabbi Nehunya ben Hakkanah sitteth and setteth in order before them all the teachings concerning the Merkabha, [the] descent and [the] ascent, how he descendeth who descendeth, and how he ascendeth who ascendeth."

The Merkabha! Here’s where things get really interesting. The Merkabha (מרכבה) refers to the Divine Chariot, as described in the Book of Ezekiel. It's a central concept in Jewish mysticism, representing God's throne and the celestial realms. Rabbi Nehunya, it seems, is guiding these sages through the intricacies of Merkabha mysticism, specifically the processes of descent (yeridah) and ascent (aliyah) – the spiritual journeys one undertakes to connect with the Divine.: These esteemed rabbis, surrounded by fiery manifestations, are being instructed on how to work through the celestial realms. The text doesn't tell us what those teachings were, only that they were being shared. The mystery, in some ways, is the point.

What does this brief glimpse into Heikhalot Rabbati offer us? It's a reminder that Jewish tradition is not just about laws and commandments; it's also about seeking deeper meaning, exploring the mysteries of the universe, and striving for a connection with the Divine. It’s an invitation to consider the unseen realms, the possibilities that lie beyond our everyday perception. And perhaps, just perhaps, to catch a glimpse of those spiderwebs of fire for ourselves.

Full source
Pirkei DeRabbi Eliezer 30:13Pirkei DeRabbi Eliezer

Specifically, Chapter 30 dives into a prophecy attributed to Rabbi Ishmael concerning the descendants of Ishmael, the son of Abraham. What does it say? Buckle up.

Rabbi Ishmael foretells three future wars of tribulation waged by the sons of Ishmael. He draws upon the prophet Isaiah (21:15) to illustrate this: "For they fled away from the swords." According to this reading, the word "swords" (cherev in Hebrew) is interpreted as signifying wars. And not just one war, but three distinct conflicts, each with its own unique characteristic.

The first, he says, will be "in the forest of Arabia," referencing the phrase "from the drawn sword" in Isaiah. Imagine the clash of armies amidst the dense foliage, a struggle for dominance in the heart of the desert.

The second war, according to Rabbi Ishmael's interpretation, will occur "on the sea," alluded to by the phrase "from the bent bow." Think naval battles, waves crashing against ships as nations vie for control of the waterways.

But it's the third war that is described as the most grievous of all. This one, he says, will take place "in the great city which is in Rome," and it will be more terrible than the previous two, as it is written, "And from the grievousness of the war."

Now, why Rome? What makes this final conflict so significant? The text doesn't explicitly say, but Rome, throughout much of Jewish history, was often seen as a symbol of worldly power, of empire, and sometimes, of oppression. A war centered there, in this view, carries a particular weight.

Here's where it gets really interesting. It is from the aftermath of this third, most terrible war, that "the Son of David shall flourish." The Messiah. He will witness the destruction wrought by these conflicts, the text says, and then he will emerge, coming to the land of Israel, as it is said in Isaiah (63:1): "Who is this that cometh from Edom, with crimsoned garments from Bozrah? this that is glorious in his apparel, marching in the greatness of his strength? I that speak in righteousness, mighty to save."

Edom, often interpreted as Rome and later oppressive empires in some Jewish traditions, and Bozrah, a city associated with judgment, paint a powerful picture. The Messiah, clothed in triumph, arriving to bring salvation after a period of intense turmoil.

What are we to make of this? Is this a literal prophecy? An allegorical depiction of the struggles between nations and the ultimate triumph of good? A message of hope amidst chaos? The Pirkei DeRabbi Eliezer, like many ancient texts, offers a lens through which to view the present and contemplate the future, inviting us to consider our place in the unfolding story of humanity.

Full source