Parshat Bereshit4 min read

Adam Lost the Light and Abraham Argued for Mercy

Adam's sin empties six things from creation. Speech collapses at Babel. Then Abraham argues that a world run on pure justice cannot survive.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. Six Things Left With Adam's Sin
  2. The First Fire Came From Two Stones
  3. Speech Failed at Babel and Abraham Received the Sevenfold Blessing
  4. Abraham Challenged the Judge of All the Earth

Six Things Left With Adam's Sin

The Hebrew word toledot, generations, usually appears in Scripture with both its vowel letters. But in Genesis 2:4, the word is written defectively, with two letters missing. The rabbis read the missing letters as a list. They point to six things that left the world when Adam sinned.

Adam's radiance dimmed. His face no longer shone as it had in Eden. Eternal life closed. His height was reduced. The earth's produce fell. The trees' fruit lost its former abundance. The primordial light was concealed.

These are not metaphors for guilt. They are losses felt in the body and in the ground. The soil resisted. The fruit shrank. The man who had been made in divine image walked out of Eden smaller, darker, and mortal.

The First Fire Came From Two Stones

Adam spent the first Shabbat after his expulsion in fear of the dark. When night fell at the end of his first week outside the garden, he did not know if the darkness would lift. God gave him knowledge of two stones, and he struck them against each other and fire appeared.

The midrash says Adam sang over this. He made a blessing over the fire he had discovered. The light he kindled with his own hands was a small compensation for the primordial light that had been hidden away. He could not recover what Eden contained. But he could learn to make light in the dark, which was a different thing, a harder thing, a human thing.

Speech Failed at Babel and Abraham Received the Sevenfold Blessing

After Adam the generations multiplied, and speech with them. By the time of the tower builders, human language had been turned toward a single project: building something tall enough to reach heaven and make a name for themselves. The midrash reads the word sham, there, in that passage as the mirror of Abram's blessing. God would make Abraham's name great. The builders wanted to make a name without God's help.

The tower fell. The languages divided. But Abraham received what the builders had reached for and could not hold. God blessed him seven times in a single passage. I will make you a great nation. I will bless you. I will make your name great. Be a blessing. I will bless those who bless you. Those who curse you I will curse. In you all the families of the earth will be blessed.

Seven blessings to one man who answered when called, in exchange for the single greatness that a whole generation had tried to seize by force.

Abraham Challenged the Judge of All the Earth

When God told Abraham that Sodom would be destroyed, Abraham did not accept it. He stood before God and pressed. Will You sweep away the righteous with the wicked? What if there are fifty righteous in the city? What if there are forty-five? Forty? Thirty? Twenty? Ten?

Each time God agreed to spare the city for the sake of the righteous within it. Abraham pressed because he understood something the midrash names plainly: the world cannot be run on strict justice alone. Pure judgment applied without mercy would consume everything. The judge of all the earth must do justice, but justice that leaves no room for mercy does not keep the world alive.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

5 sources

The texts this telling draws on, in full. Open a card to read inline, or expand it for a wider, quieter read.

Bereshit Rabbah 12:6Bereshit Rabbah

The book of Bereshit Rabbah, a classical collection of Rabbinic interpretations of Genesis, dives deep into this very idea, and it’s wild.

Our entry point is a seemingly minor detail: the Hebrew word toledot, meaning "outgrowths" or "generations." Rabbi Shmuel bar Naḥman points out that, throughout the Torah, this word is usually written in a shortened, or "defective," form. But there are two exceptions: "These are the offspring [toledot] of Peretz…" ((uth 4:1)8) and one other instance we'll get to. So, why the missing letters in most cases?

Rabbi Yudan, quoting Rabbi Avin, offers a stunning explanation: these "defective" spellings correspond to six things that were taken away from Adam after his sin. Six glorious things, lost in that single bite. What were they?

First, his radiance. Remember how Adam and Eve were naked and unashamed? After they sinned, "You alter his countenance and send him away” (Job 14:20). Something about their very being, their presence, was diminished.

Second, his eternal life. Harsh. "For you are dust, [and to dust shall you return]" (Genesis 3:19). Mortality entered the picture.

Third, his stature. This one's fascinating. "The man and his wife hid" (Genesis 3:8). Rabbi Abahu says that at that moment, Adam's height was reduced to a mere hundred cubits. That’s still pretty tall, but it’s a far cry from what he once was!

Fourth and fifth, the extraordinary produce of the earth and the fruit of the tree. "Cursed is the ground on your account" (Genesis 3:17). The abundance and ease of the Garden were gone, replaced by toil and struggle.

And finally, the lights. This is perhaps the most mystical and intriguing loss of all. Rabbi Shimon ben Rabbi Yehuda of Kefar Akko, quoting Rabbi Meir, says that the lights, cursed the day before Shabbat (the Sabbath), were only truly stricken at the conclusion of Shabbat. There’s a debate, though. Rabbi Yosei believed Adam’s glory didn’t even last the night of his creation, citing (Psalms 49:13): “Man [adam] will not go to rest in his splendor…”

Rabbi Yehuda bar Rabbi Simon adds that with the original light of creation, Adam could see from one end of the world to the other! But when God saw the corruption of later generations – Enosh, the Flood, the Dispersion – He hid that light away. "Their light will be withheld from the wicked" (Job 38:15). But don't despair! It wasn't destroyed, but hidden away for the righteous, as (Proverbs 4:18) tells us: “But the path of the righteous is like a dawning light.”

Rabbi Levi, in the name of Rabbi Gezeira, even specifies that this primordial light functioned for thirty-six hours before Adam's sin. Imagine! Twelve hours before Shabbat, twelve during the night, and twelve during the day. Then, darkness.

The Midrash (rabbinic interpretive commentary) describes Adam's fear as darkness approached. He wondered if the serpent was coming to confront him, representing death. So, what did he do? He struck two flint stones together, creating fire and reciting a blessing over it. This is why, according to the school of Rabbi Yishmael, we recite a blessing over light at the conclusion of Shabbat: because that was the beginning of its re-creation.

So, what about that other instance of the word "toledot" written in its full form? Rabbi Berekhya, quoting Rabbi Shmuel, says that these six lost aspects of Adam will be restored when the descendant of Peretz – the Messiah – arrives. The full spelling of toledot in (Ruth 4:18) hints at this coming restoration.

His radiance? "May all those who love Him be like the sun coming out in its might" (Judges 5:31). Eternal life? "For like the days of a tree will be the days of My people…" (Isaiah 65:22). Stature? "I caused you to walk upright [komemiyut]" (Leviticus 26:13). The produce of the earth and fruit of the tree? "For the seed is of peace: The vine will yield its fruit, [and the land will yield its produce]" (Zechariah 8:12). And the lights? "The light of the moon will be like the light of the sun [and the light of the sun will be sevenfold, like the light of the seven days]" (Isaiah 30:26).

Wow. It's a powerful and hopeful message. Even in the face of loss and darkness, the tradition suggests that redemption, restoration, and a return to a state of wholeness are possible. It makes you wonder, doesn’t it? What "lights" can we ignite in our own lives, even in the face of darkness?

Full source
Bereshit Rabbah 38:1Bereshit Rabbah

The familiar version gives us the basic narrative: humanity, united by a single language, decided to build a tower reaching to the heavens. God, displeased with their ambition, confused their language, scattering them across the earth. But what was the deeper meaning? What were they really trying to do?

Bereshit Rabbah, an ancient collection of rabbinic interpretations of the Book of Genesis, offers a fascinating perspective. It explores the verse, "The entire earth was of one language and of common speech" (Genesis 11:1), connecting it to a seemingly unrelated passage from Psalms.

Rabbi Elazar, in the name of Rabbi Yosei bar Zimra, kicks things off by quoting (Psalm 59:12): "Do not kill them, lest my people forget; scatter them by Your power and take them down." Now, The first reading, this Psalm speaks about King David's enemies. The Rabbis, however, are masters of drash, interpreting scripture in multiple layers.

Initially, the Rabbis apply this verse to Do’eg and Ahitofel, two treacherous figures in David's life. David, they say, pleaded with God not to utterly destroy them, "lest my people forget" their wickedness. Instead, scatter them and bring them down from their positions of power. According to this interpretation, Ahitofel advocated for incest and the murder of David (II (Samuel 16:21), 17:2), while Do’eg, according to Naḥman son of Rabbi Shmuel bar Naḥmani, used legal loopholes to condemn David, effectively making his wife available to remarry.

But Rabbi Elazar, again in the name of Rabbi Yosei bar Zimra, takes a sharp turn. He applies this very same verse – "Do not kill them, lest my people forget; scatter them by Your power and take them down" – to the generation of the Dispersion, the builders of the Tower of Babel! It's a startling connection.

Why? What was so terrible that they deserved to be scattered?

Bereshit Rabbah tells us "The sin of their mouths, the words of their lips" (Psalms 59:13) were the problem. This isn’t just about hubris; it’s about what they said. They declared that every 1,656 years, the firmament collapses. Remember, the Flood occurred in year 1656 from Creation. This generation believed the flood wasn’t a divine act, but part of a natural, recurring cycle.

So, what did they plan to do about it? "Come, rather, and let us prepare supports; one to the north, one to the south, one to the west, and the one here will support it to the east.” They intended to build a tower, not to reach God, but to prop up the sky! Their ambition wasn't spiritual; it was a statement of independence, a rejection of divine power. They sought to control the very structure of the universe.

This brings us back to the verse, "The entire earth was of one language [safa] and of common speech." (Genesis 11:1). The text connects the "words of their lips [sefateimo]" (Psalms 59:13) to this unified language. The problem wasn't simply that they spoke the same language, but what they said with it – their arrogant declaration of self-sufficiency and their plan to usurp God’s role.

Therefore, God didn't just punish them for building a tall tower. He scattered them because their unified language was being used to express a dangerous and ultimately destructive idea: that humanity could replace God.

What does this tell us today? Perhaps it's a warning about the power of language. How easily can words unite us, but also be used to spread dangerous ideas? Maybe it's a reminder that true progress comes not from trying to control the universe, but from recognizing our place within it. Perhaps, the story of the Tower of Babel isn't just an ancient myth, but a timeless lesson about the delicate balance between ambition and humility.

Full source
Bereshit Rabbah 39:11Bereshit Rabbah

The Torah portion Lekh Lekha begins with God's instructions to Abraham, "Go forth from your land, from your birthplace, and from your father’s house, to the land that I will show you." And with that instruction comes a powerful promise.

"I will make you a great nation, I will bless you [vaavarekhekha], I will render your name great, and you shall be a blessing" (Genesis 12:2).

What does that really mean? It’s not just a nice sentiment; it’s a many-sided promise, brimming with layers of meaning that our sages have been unpacking for centuries.

The Midrash (rabbinic interpretive commentary), specifically Bereshit Rabbah 39, teases out the nuances of this loaded verse. When God says, "I will make you a great nation," Abraham, ever the pragmatist, apparently responds, "Didn't you already make seventy nations from Noah?" God's reply? "The nation about whom it is written, 'For what great nation is there that has a god so close to them as the Lord our God is to us?' (Deuteronomy 4:7) – that nation I will produce from you." It's not just about quantity, but about quality and closeness to God.

Rabbi Berekhya offers another perspective, suggesting that "I will make you [ve’e’eshkha]" implies a new creation. That from the moment of this new creation, perhaps alluding to the covenant of circumcision or the changing of Abram's name, procreation and legacy will spring forth.

And the blessings keep coming! Rabbi Levi bar Ḥavyat and Rabbi Abba, son of Rabbi Ḥiyya, point out that the verse contains three "greatnesses" and four "blessings." The Midrash sees these as allusions to the three patriarchs (Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob) and the four matriarchs (Sarah, Rebecca, Rachel, and Leah).

Rabbi Ḥiyya takes a practical angle. Travel, while broadening, can also diminish things: procreation, resources, and reputation. But God assures Abraham that he will be protected from these losses. "I will make you a great nation" counters diminished procreation; "I will bless you" addresses dwindling resources; and "I will render your name great" safeguards his reputation. It's like God is saying, "I've got you covered on all fronts."

Now, here's where it gets really interesting. Rabbi Berekhya, citing Rabbi Ḥelbo, says that "I will make you a great nation" means a coin with Abraham's image went out into the world. Imagine that! According to this interpretation, Abraham's image on these coins was an elderly man and woman on one side (representing Abraham and Sarah) and a young man and maiden on the other (symbolizing their rejuvenation upon Isaac's birth). The Midrash then extends this idea, noting that Joshua, David, and Mordechai also had their images on coins, each reflecting aspects of their lives and legacies.

But beyond fame and fortune, there's a deeper layer. Rabbi Yudan states that God will institute a blessing for Abraham in the eighteen benedictions – the Amidah prayer. And Rabbi Aḥuya, in the name of Rabbi Ze’eira, points out that Abraham's blessing precedes God's in the prayer ("Shield of Abraham" before "He revives the dead"), signifying Abraham's pivotal role in our connection to the Divine.

Rabbi Abahu brings a linguistic twist, noting that God doesn't say "Look now heavenward [hashamayim]," but "look now toward heaven [hashamaima]" (Genesis 15:5), with an added heh. The Holy One, blessed be He, says: 'I created the world with the letter heh. I will add the letter heh to your name and then you will procreate.’ It’s a divine makeover, a literal upgrade!

And Rabbi Yudan adds that the numerical value of the letters in "I will bless you [avarekhekha]" equals 248 – a subtle hint at the blessings to come.

But perhaps the most beautiful interpretation is this: Rabbi Berekhya notes that "I will bless you" is already stated. So why does the verse continue with "And you shall be a blessing"? The answer: God is saying, "Until now, I blessed the world. From now on, the blessings are passed to you. Whomever you deem worthy to bless, bless him." The power to bless, to bestow goodness and favor, is passed on to Abraham, and by extension, to us. It's a profound responsibility and an incredible gift.

This isn't just about receiving blessings; it's about becoming a conduit for them. It's about using our lives to bring goodness into the world, to heal, to uplift, and to connect others to the Divine. It's about recognizing the spark of the Divine within ourselves and nurturing it, so that we, too, can be a source of blessing for all.

So, how can we be a berakha, a source of blessing, in our own lives? How can we use our unique gifts and talents to make the world a little brighter, a little kinder, a little more connected? That, my friends, is the challenge and the promise of Lekh Lekha.

Full source
Bereshit Rabbah 49:9Bereshit Rabbah

The familiar story is this: God is about to destroy Sodom and Gomorrah because of their wickedness. But Abraham, ever the righteous advocate, steps in. He challenges God, asking, "Far be it from You to do something like this, to kill the righteous with the wicked! Shall the Judge of all the earth not practice justice?" (Genesis 18:25). It's a bold move, questioning divine judgment itself.

The rabbis of the Midrash (rabbinic interpretive commentary), those ancient interpreters of scripture, unpack Abraham’s words with incredible depth. "Ḥalila from You," Abraham says, using a Hebrew term that Rabbi Yudan explains means "profane for You," or "foreign to You." It would be unthinkable for God to act unjustly. Rabbi Aḥa even suggests that repeating "ḥalila ḥalila" implies a ḥilul, a profaning of God's name. People might lose faith if they perceive injustice.

Rabbi Abba points out that Abraham isn't just concerned with the present situation; he's worried about the precedent it sets. It's not just “from doing this thing,” but “to do something like this” – neither this, nor anything similar, nor anything lesser! Even allowing the righteous to suffer alongside the wicked seems unfair.

Rabbi Levi draws a parallel between Abraham and Job. Both question God's justice. Job cries out, "One matter, therefore, I say: The faultless and the wicked He destroys" (Job 9:22). But here’s the twist: Abraham is rewarded for his challenge, while Job is punished. Why? The Midrash explains that Abraham spoke from a place of mature, well-reasoned thought, "like a ripe fruit." Job, on the other hand, spoke from raw emotion, "like an unripe fruit."

Rabbi Ḥiyya bar Abba suggests a deeper interplay, a divine counter-argument woven into the verse itself. Abraham pleads, "Far be it from You to kill the righteous with the wicked." And the Holy One, Blessed be He, responds "And the righteous will be as the wicked… if they were truly righteous." Are these people really as righteous as Abraham thinks? Are they perhaps "righteous men of inferior quality," as Rabbi Yoḥanan puts it, using the term nivlei – like dates that fall from the tree before they ripen, rotten on the inside? Were the people of Sodom and Gomorrah really as righteous as Abraham seemed to think?

Abraham, however, persists. Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi suggests that Abraham offers to incorporate his own righteousness into the tally, hoping to reach the required number of righteous individuals needed to save the cities. Rabbi Yehuda ben Rabbi Simon takes it further, suggesting Abraham asks God to incorporate Himself!

Rabbi Yehuda ben Rabbi Simon offers another powerful analogy: With a mortal king, one can appeal to a higher authority. But who can restrain God? This is what Abraham meant when he said: “Shall the Judge of all the earth not practice justice?”

Rav Ada adds a layer of complexity, reminding us of God's oath not to bring another flood. Is God trying to circumvent the oath by using fire instead of water?

Finally, Rabbi Levi gets to the heart of the matter: “If You wish to have a world, there can be no strict justice, and if You wish to have strict justice, there can be no world." It's a profound statement. Absolute, unwavering justice might be too harsh for humanity to bear. Some concession, some degree of mercy, is necessary for the world to endure.

God responds, acknowledging Abraham's unique role: “You love righteousness [tzedek] and abhor wickedness… because of this, God your God, has anointed you over your counterparts with the oil of joy.” Abraham is set apart. From Noah to Abraham, ten generations passed, and God only spoke to Abraham, “Go you” (Genesis 12:1).

So, what does this all mean? The story in Bereshit Rabbah isn't just about Sodom and Gomorrah. It’s about the ongoing tension between justice and mercy, between divine judgment and human compassion. It reminds us that questioning, even challenging, God can be a form of profound devotion, especially when it comes from a place of genuine concern for the well-being of others. And maybe, just maybe, it suggests that a world built solely on strict justice is a world that cannot ultimately survive.

Full source
Yalkut Shimoni on Torah 17:3Yalkut Shimoni on Torah

Another interpretation: by the merit of the tribes [the world was created], as it is said, "and these are the names of the tribes" (Ezekiel 48:1), "all these are the tribes of Israel" (Genesis 49:28). Everywhere it says "these," it invalidates what came before; "and these" adds to what came before. Here it says "these" [in Genesis 2:4], invalidating chaos and void and darkness. Rabbi Yehudah says: "and the heaven and the earth were finished" (Genesis 2:1), each in its time; "and all their host," each in its time. Rabbi Nechemyah said to him: but is it not written, "these are the generations of the heaven and the earth when they were created," meaning that on the day they were created they brought forth their generations? Rabbi Yehudah said to him: but is it not written, "there was evening and there was morning, one day" (Genesis 1:5), second, third, fourth, fifth, sixth? Rabbi Nechemyah said: they were like gatherers of figs, each one appearing in its own time; "and the earth brought forth grass" (Genesis 1:12), the grass that had been entrusted to its keeping.

"For in six days the LORD made the heaven and the earth, the sea" (Exodus 20:11). These three things, their creation was made and they waited three days each and brought forth three generations each. The earth on the first, according to the House of Hillel, and waited three days, first, second, third, and brought forth three generations: trees, grasses, and the Garden of Eden. The firmament on the second, and they waited three days, second, third, fourth, and brought forth three generations: sun and moon and constellations. The sea on the third, and waited three days, third, fourth, fifth, and brought forth three generations: birds and fish and Leviathan. Rabbi Azaryah did not say so, but: "on the day the LORD made earth and heaven" (Genesis 2:4), two things are the essence of the world's creation, they waited three days and their work was completed on the fourth. Heaven on the first according to the House of Shammai, they waited three days, first, second, and third, and their work was completed on the fourth, and what was the completion of their work? The luminaries. The earth on the third, "and the earth brought forth grass" (Genesis 1:12), and waited three days, third, fourth, fifth, and their work was completed on the sixth, the human being, as it is said, "I made the earth and created the human upon it" (Isaiah 45:12).

"Generations": every [occurrence of] "generations" in Scripture is spelled deficient [without the second letter vav], except for two: "these are the generations of Perez" (Ruth 4:18) and this one. And why are they deficient? Because of six things that were taken from Adam: his radiance, his life, his height, the fruit of the earth, the fruit of the tree, and the luminaries. His radiance, from where? As it is said, "You change his face and send him away" (Job 14:20). His life, from where? "And to dust you shall return" (Genesis 3:19). His height, from where? As it is said, "and the man hid himself" (Genesis 3:8); his height had been a hundred cubits. The fruit of the earth and the fruit of the tree, as it is said, "cursed is the ground for your sake" (Genesis 3:17). The luminaries were struck at the going out of the Sabbath, and they will not yet return to their full repair until the son of Perez comes. "These are the generations of Perez": his radiance, from where? "And those who love Him are like the going forth of the sun" (Judges 5:31). His life, from where? As it is said, "like the days of a tree shall be the days of My people" (Isaiah 65:22). His height, from where? As it is said, "and I will make you walk upright [kommemiyut]" (Leviticus 26:13), with erect stature, and you shall not fear any creature.

Full source