4 min read

Gideon Refused the Crown Three Times and His Son Seized It

They offered him a dynasty after Midian broke. He said no three times. A son of a Shechem concubine took by murder what the father would not touch.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. Three Times He Put It Down
  2. The Son Who Climbed on a Stone
  3. Jotham on the Mountain
  4. The Ephod That Turned After His Death
  5. The Millstone From the Tower
Gideon Refused the Crown Three Times and His Son Seized It Click for full size

Three Times He Put It Down

Israel came to Gideon after the Midianite night and pressed a crown into his hands. "Rule over us, you, your son, and your son's son." He answered three times. "I will not rule over you, nor shall my son rule over you; the Lord shall rule over you." Three offers. Three pushes back. He laid kingship on Heaven and kept his own shoulders free.

God heard the shape of those words. "You speak this way? By your life, a son from you will reign three years, one year for each refusal." The humility was not ignored. It was measured and returned in a coin the house did not expect.

The Son Who Climbed on a Stone

Abimelech, son of Gideon by a concubine of Shechem, took the prophecy and twisted it into a knife. He went to the men of Shechem, the vain and light fellows who still carried small images of Beelzebub in their pockets and kissed them when they thought no one was looking. With their help he murdered his brothers on a stone to clear a path to rule.

He reigned three years, no more, no less. The count of the father's humility became the span of the son's violence. "Before destruction the heart of a man is haughty." That heart was his. He seized what Gideon had set down. The crown sat on a head that had bought it with brothers.

Jotham on the Mountain

Jotham, the youngest, escaped the stone. He climbed Mount Gerizim, the mountain of blessing, and spoke a parable of trees. The olive would not leave its fatness to wave over the trees. The fig would not leave its sweetness. The vine would not leave its wine. The thorn-bush accepted.

Abimelech was the thorn. Othniel, Deborah, and Gideon were the fruitful ones who would not grab a crown that costs a people's peace. Jotham hurled the curse from the height while the blood was still wet in memory. Then he fled. The parable stood in the air over Shechem like pitch.

The Ephod That Turned After His Death

Gideon had made an ephod (אפוד) to honor Manasseh. On the high priest's breastplate, Joseph was represented by Ephraim alone, not by Manasseh too. Gideon meant to wipe out that slight. He consecrated the ephod to God. After his death the object slid into idol use. The thing built for Heaven became a snare. The camp that had followed him into night war drifted toward pocket gods, addiction dressed as habit.

Legacy is a dangerous tool. Even a judge's gift can teach the wrong lesson once the giver is gone. The house that would not let Gideon wear a crown watched Abimelech wear one made of murder, and watched an ephod meant for Manasseh collect kisses it was never built to receive.

The Millstone From the Tower

A woman dropped a millstone from a tower and cracked the story shut. The man who killed on stone died by stone. Three years closed the way a fist closes: hard, brief, empty of the honor Gideon had refused. "Before honor is humility." Gideon wore the first half. Abimelech wore the second half inverted, honor first, destruction hard behind.

Israel had wanted a dynasty from a man who wanted only God's rule. They received a three-year lesson in why the father had said no. The night Midian's camp broke, Gideon could have named himself king while the trumpets still echoed. He did not. He waited until the people offered dynasty in daylight and then refused in triplicate.

Abimelech heard opportunity where Gideon heard danger. Shechem's stone became a slaughter block. The thorn accepted what olive and vine refused. Three years later a millstone finished the parable in bone and dust. The Lord whom Gideon named as only king remained the measure. The son had seized the crown. The crown did not keep him.

GideonAbimelechJothamKingshipHumility
← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

2 sources

The texts behind this telling. Some cards carry a translation of the source; others are our own retelling of it, and each card says which. Every card links out to the original.

Legends of the Jews 2:54Legends of the Jews

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Legends of the Jews by Louis Ginzberg (1909) · Public Domain

Legends of the Jews turns to Gideon's Miracle.

See, when the twelve tribes were represented on the high priest's breastplate, Joseph (of the coat of many colors fame) was represented only by Ephraim, not by Manasseh, too, both sons of Joseph. Gideon, wanting to honor his own tribe of Manasseh, made an ephod bearing its name. He dedicated it to God, sure, but after Gideon's death, people started treating it like an idol!

The very thing meant to honor God became an object of worship itself.

The story takes an even darker turn. The Israelites, it seems, were struggling with their faith. They were "so addicted to the worship of Beelzebub that they constantly carried small images of this god with them in their pockets." Yikes. These were the very people who helped Abimelech, Gideon’s son with his concubine from Shechem, murder his other brothers.

But, as they say, what goes around comes around. As Abimelech murdered his brothers on a stone, he himself was killed by a millstone. Divine justice, perhaps?

This brings us to Jotham, the youngest of Gideon's sons. He was no fool. He knew his stuff. He even knew that, according to Legends of the Jews, long after this drama unfolded, the Samaritans would claim Mount Gerizim was holy because blessings were once pronounced there upon the tribe. That’s why Jotham chose Gerizim as the spot to hurl his curse upon Shechem and its inhabitants. He understood the weight of location, the power of history.

In a parable, Jotham compared Abimelech to a thorn-bush, while he characterized his predecessors, Othniel, Deborah, and Gideon, as an olive-tree, a fig-tree, or a vine. We find a similar sentiment in Judges 9, where Jotham’s fable of the trees is recorded.

What does it all mean? Perhaps it's a cautionary tale about the slippery slope from reverence to idolatry. Or maybe it's a reminder that even the best leaders can leave behind a complicated legacy.

Full source
Midrash Tanchuma Buber, Vayera 29:1Midrash Tanchuma Buber, Vayera

Translation of the source text.Midrash Tanchuma (Buber), Public Domain, on Sefaria · CC-BY-SA

"Before destruction the heart of a man is haughty" (Proverbs 18:12). This is Abimelech, who was not broken until he exalted himself and killed his brothers. "And before honor is humility" (ibid.). This is Gideon his father; for when they said to him, "Rule over us, you, also your son, also your son's son" (Judges 8:22), he said to them, "I will not rule over you, nor shall my son rule over you; the LORD shall rule over you" (Judges 8:23). They said three things to him, and he said three things to them. The Holy One, blessed be He, said to him: You say thus? By your life, I will raise up from you a son who will reign three years, corresponding to the three things that you said. Thus, "and before honor is humility." Therefore, "And Abimelech ruled over Israel three years" (Judges 9:22).

Full source