4 min read

Starving Seleucid Siege Officers Made Peace and Restored the Laws

The siege starved the camp. The stronghold would not fall. An officer chose peace: let them live after their own laws.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. The Sacks Ran Out
  2. Because We Abolished Their Laws
  3. Live After Their Laws
  4. The King Broke the Oath
  5. After the Messengers Left
Starving Seleucid Siege Officers Made Peace and Restored the Laws Click for full size

The Sacks Ran Out

The Seleucid officers counted sacks and found the numbers against them. "We decay daily," one said. "Our food is small. The place we lay siege to is strong. The affairs of the kingdom lie upon us."

Pride had brought them to the walls. Empty bellies suggested another policy. A mule died in its traces and no one had strength to drag it far. Flies found the carcass before men found a plan. Inside the stronghold, Judeans held their laws the way a drowning man holds a rope. The wall did not move.

Because We Abolished Their Laws

Outside, the officers named the cause without flattery. "They are displeased, and have done all these things, because we abolished their laws."

They remembered the months of that abolition. Scrolls of the law ripped and burned in the streets. Anyone found with a book of the covenant put to death. Incense forced at the doors of houses. On the twenty-fifth of the month, sacrifice on an idol altar set upon the altar of God. Abolish the laws, and the nation becomes a fortress no army can swallow.

The men inside the wall remembered more than the streets. After the first victories, Judas had taken the host up to Mount Zion to cleanse the sanctuary. They found it desolate. The altar profaned. The gates burned. Shrubs growing in the courts as in a forest, or on a mountain nobody tended. The priests' chambers pulled down. They tore their clothes. They put ashes on their heads. They fell on their faces and blew the trumpets and cried toward heaven. That ruin was why the stronghold would not open.

Live After Their Laws

"Now therefore let us be friends with these men, and make peace with them, and with all their nation. Covenant that they shall live after their laws, as they did before." The king and the princes were content. Messengers went. The offer was accepted. Steel rested because bread had failed first.

In the stronghold, a mother who had measured water by the cup allowed herself a longer drink. A fighter cleaned a blade and did not sheathe it too quickly. Children ran a short race in the yard and fell laughing, shocked to hear their own noise.

The laws returned to public daylight. Not because the siege camp had loved them. Because the siege camp had failed to starve them out.

The King Broke the Oath

Another season, another king, the same long quarrel. Men left a stronghold under sworn promise. The king entered Mount Zion, saw its strength, and broke the oath he had made. He commanded the wall round about pulled down. Then he fled in haste to Antioch, where Philip held the city, and took it by force in a different war of his own.

He looked at Zion and saw a fort. The hungry officers had given the laws back. This king took the stones. Dust from the torn wall blew into kitchens and seasoned bread with memory.

In the hundred and fifty-first year, Demetrius son of Seleucus left Rome with a few men, took a coastal city, and reigned there. Crowns moved. Judea's laws stayed the stake that would not stay quiet.

After the Messengers Left

When the first camp broke, dust rose in two directions. Foreign columns toward other crises of the kingdom. Judean scouts toward fields that needed hands more than spears for a season. The stronghold's gates opened wider. Someone sang under his breath and stopped, superstitious of joy.

Night after the truce smelled of cooking fires instead of siege pitch. A child slept without counting the hours to the next assault. On Mount Zion, in another year, stones would remember a broken oath. Between those memories, the hungry officers' confession still hung in the tents. "We abolished their laws. Therefore they fought. Therefore we must let them live as before."

The confession is not love. It is enough to open a gate and plant again.

MaccabeesSiegeSeleucidPeaceTorah
← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

4 sources

The texts behind this telling. Some cards carry a translation of the source; others are our own retelling of it, and each card says which. Every card links out to the original.

The Book of Maccabees I 6:64The Book of Maccabees I

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.Sefaria Community Translation · CC-BY

The Seleucid Empire, a dominant force in the ancient world, found itself in just such a predicament. Remember the Maccabees? That small but mighty group of Jewish rebels who dared to stand up to the seemingly invincible Greek-Syrian Empire? Well, the Seleucid king, facing a multitude of problems, started to see the wisdom in making peace.

The passage “We decay daily, and our victuals are but small, and the place we lay siege unto is strong, and the affairs of the kingdom lie upon us.” Can you feel the exhaustion dripping from those words? The Seleucid forces were realizing the siege they were undertaking was too much. They were running out of supplies, facing fierce resistance, and the weight of the entire kingdom was pressing down on them.

It’s a surprisingly human moment. empires is often remembered as these monolithic, unstoppable entities, but this verse reminds us that even they are vulnerable, subject to the same pressures and limitations as anyone else.

So, what was their solution? This is where it gets interesting. They decided to… negotiate. “Now therefore let us be friends with these men, and make peace with them, and with all their nation; And covenant with them, that they shall live after their laws, as they did before: for they are therefore displeased, and have done all these things, because we abolished their laws.” for a second. The very laws that the Seleucids tried to eradicate, the laws that sparked the entire Maccabean revolt, were now being offered back as a peace offering. It's a powerful admission of failure, a recognition that their attempts to force assimilation had backfired spectacularly. The root of the conflict, according to this passage, was the suppression of Jewish law.

The king and his princes agreed. "So the king and the princes were content: wherefore he sent unto them to make peace; and they accepted thereof." Peace talks began.

Why did the Maccabees accept? We can only imagine the complex calculations they had to make. Was this a genuine offer? Could they trust the Seleucids? Or was it a trap? The desire for religious freedom and self-determination must have outweighed the risks. They accepted, and the rest, as they say, is history.

This short passage from Maccabees I offers a fascinating glimpse into the realities of power, the limitations of even the mightiest empires, and the enduring power of faith and resistance. It also forces us to consider the consequences of suppressing cultural and religious identity. What happens when a people are denied the right to live according to their own laws and traditions? The story of the Maccabees, as seen here, reminds us that the answer can be revolution.

Full source
The Book of Maccabees I 7:1The Book of Maccabees I

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.Sefaria Community Translation · CC-BY

Oaths! These weren't just casual promises; they were serious, binding agreements. People were released from a stronghold, probably feeling a sense of relief and maybe even a little hope.

The king, having secured the release, enters Mount Zion. Now, Mount Zion is a big deal. It’s a place laden with historical and spiritual significance. But instead of respecting its importance, the king sees only one thing: its strength. And what does he do? He breaks his oath. Just like that. He commands the walls around Mount Zion to be torn down. Can you imagine the betrayal? The sheer audacity?

He doesn’t stick around to admire his handiwork, though. He hightails it back to Antioch, because apparently, there's more drama waiting for him there. He arrives to find Philip, another player in this game of thrones, has taken control of the city. A battle ensues, and the king manages to seize the city by force.

The story continues. We jump to the one hundred and fifty-first year (according to the Seleucid calendar, of course). Demetrius, the son of Seleucus, arrives from Rome with a small band of men. He lands in a city on the coast and… just like that, he starts to reign. No fanfare, no drawn-out explanations. Just a sudden shift in power.

What are we to make of this rapid-fire sequence of events? It's a reminder that promises can be as fragile as glass, that power is fleeting, and that the world is full of people willing to do whatever it takes to get ahead. It also gives us a glimpse into the turbulent times that shaped the Maccabean revolt, a period of intense struggle and ultimately, of rededication. Maybe that's why we still tell these stories today. They hold a mirror up to our own lives, reminding us that even in the darkest of times, hope – and maybe a little bit of healthy skepticism – are essential.

Full source
The Book of Maccabees I 1:57The Book of Maccabees I

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.Sefaria Community Translation · CC-BY

The Book of Maccabees I turns to When the Seleucids Tried to Erase Jewish Practice.

You're living in your ancestral home, trying to observe your traditions, practice your faith. Then, suddenly, everything changes. Foreign rulers, influenced by Hellenistic culture, begin to impose their ways, attempting to eradicate Jewish practices.

The Book of Maccabees I chillingly recounts these acts of desecration. It tells us, "And burnt incense at the doors of their houses, and in the streets." – the invaders weren't just attacking synagogues or holy sites; they were invading private homes, forcing people to participate in pagan rituals.

It didn't stop there. The attack on Jewish identity went much deeper. The text continues: "And when they had rent in pieces the books of the law which they found, they burnt them with fire."

Can you feel the weight of that? The Torah, the very foundation of Jewish life and law, torn apart and burned. It was a symbolic act, a deliberate attempt to destroy not just physical objects but the very essence of Jewish thought and belief.

And the penalty for resisting? Death.

"And whosoever was found with any the book of the testament, or if any committed to the law, the king’s commandment was, that they should put him to death." Imagine living in constant fear, knowing that simply owning a sacred text could cost you your life. This wasn't just about religious differences; it was about control, about crushing the spirit of a people.

The oppression was relentless, systematic. "Thus did they by their authority unto the Israelites every month, to as many as were found in the cities." Every month, the persecution continued, a constant reminder of the power wielded by the oppressors.

And perhaps the most shocking act of all? "Now the five and twentieth day of the month they did sacrifice upon the idol altar, which was upon the altar of God." The desecration of the Temple, the holiest place in Judaism, with pagan sacrifices. It was an abomination, a direct affront to God and the Jewish people.

This was the world into which the Maccabees were born. A world where faith was tested, where survival meant resistance, and where the flame of hope seemed to flicker precariously.

The story of the Maccabees is more than just a historical account. It's a reminder that even in the darkest of times, the human spirit can endure, that courage can rise against oppression, and that the fight for what you believe in is always worth fighting. It's a story that continues to resonate today, reminding us of the importance of religious freedom and the strength of faith in the face of adversity. What would you have done?

Full source
The Book of Maccabees I 4:40The Book of Maccabees I

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.Sefaria Community Translation · CC-BY

The Book of Maccabees I turns to The Maccabees Find the Temple in Ruins.

The year is roughly 164 BCE. After years of brutal oppression under the Seleucid Empire, and a series of miraculous victories against seemingly insurmountable odds, the Maccabees, a small band of Jewish rebels, stood on the cusp of reclaiming their spiritual heartland. What would they find?

The First Book of Maccabees, a historical text not included in the Hebrew Bible but preserved as ancient Jewish literature, tells us of that moment. "Behold, our enemies are discomfited," they cried. "Let us go up to cleanse and dedicate the sanctuary."

Did they know what awaited them? Probably not fully.

Imagine the collective breath held as the entire army, the whole kahal, the community, ascended Mount Zion. What met their eyes was devastating.

The sanctuary…desolate. Utterly ruined. The altar, the very heart of the Temple service, was profaned. Desecrated. The gates, once symbols of entry into holiness, were burned to the ground. Shrubs and wild plants grew rampant in the courtyards, as if a forest had taken root in what was once the most sacred space on earth. Even the priests’ chambers, the lishkot ha-kohanim, were pulled down, reduced to rubble.

It’s hard to fathom the emotional impact.

The response was visceral. Raw. The text says they rent their clothes – a traditional Jewish act of mourning. They made great lamentation, a deep, sorrowful wail that echoed through the ravaged courtyards. Ashes, symbols of grief and repentance, were cast upon their heads.

They fell to the ground, prostrate, their faces pressed against the defiled earth. And then, the piercing sound of the shofar, the ram’s horn, shattered the silence – a desperate cry to heaven, a plea for mercy and redemption. The trumpets blared, not in celebration, but in mourning and supplication.

That mournful cry?

This wasn't just a physical devastation; it was a spiritual catastrophe. The Temple, the conduit between the Jewish people and God, was in ruins, defiled by idolatry and neglect. The Maccabees weren't just facing a cleanup job; they were facing a profound crisis of faith.

What would they do next? How do you rebuild from such utter devastation, not just physically, but spiritually? The answer, as we know, is with courage, with faith, and with an unwavering commitment to their traditions. This moment of despair, as recorded in the Book of Maccabees, sets the stage for the rededication of the Temple, the event we celebrate as Hanukkah. But before the light could return, they had to confront the darkness. They had to face the ruins. And they had to cry out.

Full source