5 min read

Simon Maccabeus Fortified the Temple Mount and Stayed

While some Jews volunteered for Greek laws and a gymnasium, Simon strengthened the Temple hill, lived there with his men, and made the day a memorial.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. Volunteers for Another Law
  2. After Brothers Fall, Simon Holds the Hill
  3. A Son at Gazera, Empires Still Moving
  4. A Feast Set in Proper Order
  5. Two Buildings, One City
Simon Maccabeus Fortified the Temple Mount and Stayed Click for full size

Volunteers for Another Law

Before any fort could hold, a softer war opened inside Jerusalem. "And people from the people volunteered and went to the king, and the king ordered them to do according to the laws of the Gentiles." They volunteered. Not only under whip. Under hunger for belonging in a Greek world. They built a gymnasium in Jerusalem according to those laws, a house of bodies and customs that pulled the center of gravity away from the Temple.

Assimilation here is not a mood. It is architecture. A gymnasium in the holy city is a statement about which training shapes a man.

Some ran to the king with eagerness that still stings on the page. They wanted permission to stop being distinct. The king, pleased, ordered them the freedom to erase themselves. That is a strange freedom, and the book refuses to romanticize it.

After Brothers Fall, Simon Holds the Hill

Simon Maccabeus rose when the revolt needed more than a famous name. His brother Judah had lit the war. Simon secured a stretch of independence you could live inside. The people recognized his courage and wisdom and set a day of gladness to remember the recognition, a calendar mark against forgetting.

He did not only win fields. "The hill of the temple that was by the tower he made stronger than it was, and there he dwelt himself with his company." The leader slept beside the Sanctuary he meant to keep. Walls and presence. Stone and schedule.

Other commanders visit holy ground for ceremonies. Simon moved his household of fighters onto the hill. If the Temple fell again, it would fall with him in earshot.

A Son at Gazera, Empires Still Moving

Simon saw that John his son was valiant and made him captain of all the hosts. Continuity without apology. The young man dwelt in Gazera while the father held the Temple hill. Around them the Seleucid board still shifted: in the hundred seventy-second year king Demetrius gathered forces and went into Media for help against Tryphon. Judea's peace sat in a crack between larger wars.

Independence, in this book, is never a finished monument. It is a night watch that has to be reappointed every season.

John at Gazera. Simon on the mount. Demetrius chasing help in Media. Three maps, one nervous peace. The day of gladness had to be celebrated with one eye on the roads.

A Feast Set in Proper Order

Another Maccabean voice, abridging the long work of Jason of Cyrene, admits the sweat of retelling. The accounts were mixed, the words a burden. He ordered events so a reader could run through them, understand, and remember, like a host who takes on the labor of a feast so guests can eat. History itself becomes hospitality when the story is cleared of muddle.

Simon's day of gladness fits that hunger for order. A people that nearly dissolved into gymnasium law needs dates that say: this is when we chose the Temple hill again.

Jason wrote at length. The abridger sweated at night to make the length run. Memory needs a path a tired person can finish. The revolt deserves that kindness.

Two Buildings, One City

Set the gymnasium beside the fortified Temple mount and the choice sharpens. One building trains Jews to look like the nations. One building houses the worship the nations tried to erase, now walled and inhabited by a commander who will not commute from safety.

Volunteers walked to a foreign king for permission to stop being distinct. Simon walked the ramparts so distinction could breathe. John took the armies. Demetrius chased his own civil war. Between those motions a small nation learned that freedom is not only the absence of a Greek decree. It is where the leader sleeps and which house he strengthens.

The day of gladness returns each year in the book's intention, a drumbeat against the voluntary forgetfulness that first opened the gymnasium doors. Remember the hill. Remember who stayed on it. Remember that some wars begin when people ask an empire for new laws, and some peaces begin when a man refuses to leave the Sanctuary unguarded.

Night on the reinforced mount: torches, stone, the smell of oil, a city below that still remembers Greek games. Simon does not need a speech about identity. His address is a bedroll on holy ground. The volunteers had an address too: the king's court, then the gymnasium floor. History keeps both addresses so later Jews can see which door leads where when the next invitation to "volunteer" arrives dressed as progress.

Judah's name still burns in memory. Simon's work is less glamorous and more durable: thicker walls, a son in the field, a feast day that orders the chaos into something a tired people can keep. The abridger of 2 Maccabees would understand. He also chose labor over muddle so the story could be eaten whole. Simon chose a hill over a gymnasium so the people could remain a people.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

3 sources

The texts behind this telling. Some cards carry a translation of the source; others are our own retelling of it, and each card says which. Every card links out to the original.

The Book of Maccabees I 14:1The Book of Maccabees I

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.Sefaria Community Translation · CC-BY

The Book of Maccabees I turns to Simon Maccabeus and the Holy Sanctuary of Temple.

Who is this "he," and what day are we talking about?

The "he" is Simon Maccabeus. He was a leader who rose to prominence after his brothers, including the famous Judah Maccabee, led the Jewish people in a revolt against the Seleucid Empire. This empire, descended from Alexander the Great's conquests, had been oppressing the Jewish people and desecrating the Temple in Jerusalem.

Simon stepped into a leadership void and secured independence for Judea. So, what was this day of gladness? The text doesn’t explicitly say which day. The preceding verses detail a moment of great recognition for Simon. The people acknowledged his leadership, his courage, and his wisdom in securing peace and prosperity. It’s safe to assume that the day being ordained was the anniversary of this recognition, a celebration of liberation and self-determination.

And Simon wasn’t just a military leader; he was a builder, too. "Moreover the hill of the temple that was by the tower he made stronger than it was, and there he dwelt himself with his company." He understood the importance of security, both physical and political. By fortifying the Temple Mount, he was ensuring the safety and stability of his people. He was building a future.

Family was also important. The verse reads, "And when Simon saw that John his son was a valiant man, he made him captain of all the hosts; and he dwelt in Gazera." Simon recognized the potential in his son, John, and entrusted him with a position of great responsibility. This wasn’t just nepotism; it was about ensuring the continuity of leadership, passing the torch to the next generation.

The passage ends with a glimpse of the wider political landscape: "Now in the hundred threescore and twelfth year king Demetrius gathered his forces together, and went into Media to get him help to fight against Tryphon." This reminds us that Judea's newfound independence was fragile. The surrounding empires were constantly vying for power, and Simon had to be ever vigilant to protect his people.

It’s a story about leadership, resilience, and the importance of remembering our history. And it’s evidence of the power of creating traditions, of marking moments of significance so that they can be celebrated and remembered for generations to come. What moments in your own life deserve to be remembered and celebrated? What traditions are you building for the future?

Full source
The Book of Maccabees I (Kahana Translation)The Book of Maccabees I

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.Sefaria-hosted English translation · CC-BY

Our story picks up with a community facing immense pressure. The Book of Maccabees I (Kahana Translation) tells us, "And people from the people volunteered and went to the king, and the king ordered them to do according to the laws of the Gentiles." "Volunteered." What would compel someone to volunteer to abandon their traditions? What kind of promises or threats were involved? What does it mean to leave your community? It paints a vivid picture of internal division and the seductive allure of assimilation.

The narrative doesn't shy away from the consequences. "And they built a gymnasium in Jerusalem according to the laws of the Gentiles." Now, a gymnasium might seem like an odd thing to focus on. But in the context of Hellenistic culture, it was far more than just a place for physical exercise. It was a cultural hub, a symbol of embracing Greek customs, values, and even religious practices.

The implications were profound. Building a gymnasium in the heart of Jerusalem was a direct challenge to Jewish law and tradition. It represented a shift away from the centrality of the Beit Hamikdash (the Holy Temple) and toward the values of the Hellenistic world. It was a step toward cultural assimilation, a move that threatened to erase the distinct identity of the Jewish people.

What choices would you make? Or would you adapt, seeking acceptance and perhaps even power within the new order? The Book of Maccabees I forces us to confront these difficult questions, reminding us that the struggle to preserve one's identity is a timeless and universal one. The story is a reminder that sometimes, the most significant battles are fought not on battlefields, but within the hearts and minds of a people. And sometimes, the hardest choices are the ones that define who we are.

Full source
The Book of Maccabees II 2:29The Book of Maccabees II

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.Sefaria-hosted English translation · CC-BY

That feeling is exactly what the author of 2 Maccabees understood. He recognized that the existing accounts of the Maccabean revolt – that pivotal moment in Jewish history – were, well, a bit of a mess.

He says, straight out, "when I saw that the accounts of events were mixed up, and that its many words were burdensome to the reader..." He wasn't afraid to admit it! And he decided to do something about it.

His goal? To retell the story "in their proper order, in order that the reader would run through them, and that it would be easy [for the reader] to understand them and remember them." He wanted to make the story accessible, engaging, and memorable.

He wasn't naive about the task ahead. He knew it would be challenging. As he puts it, "I certainly knew that in my endeavor to abridge [the book of Jason of Cyrene] a great and heavy task befell me; the sweat of my brow and nights of hard work were prepared for me." He was essentially taking on the role of editor, curator, and storyteller all rolled into one. He was taking the work of Jason of Cyrene and making it more accessible.

Why go through all that trouble? He uses a beautiful metaphor: "Yet when a man will make a feast, the responsibilities of catering to the desires of his guests also fall upon him." If you're inviting people to your table, you want to make sure they have a good experience. You want to nourish them, not overwhelm them.

In a way, that's what good storytelling is all about. It's about taking complex events, rich history, profound ideas, and presenting them in a way that invites people in. It's about making sure the "guests" – the readers, the listeners – can truly savor the story.

So, next time you encounter a dense, complicated narrative, remember the author of 2 Maccabees. Remember his commitment to clarity, his willingness to work hard, and his desire to create a truly welcoming "feast" for his audience. And maybe, just maybe, you'll be inspired to do a little storytelling of your own.

Full source