Parshat Beshalach6 min read

The Nine Who Walked Into Eden and Never Died

A handful of mortals slipped past death into the living Garden, while its apples and pearls keep leaking back into the world they left.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. The Gate That Stays Cracked Open
  2. The Apple That Would Not Be Hoarded
  3. The Treasure on the Wrong Shore
  4. The Map Drawn in Water and Fragrance

The list is nine names long, and it does the one thing no list of mortals should do. It leaves off the dying.

Enoch walked with God and was not, because God took him. Elijah went up in a chariot of fire and never came down. After them the names get stranger. Eliezer, the servant who found a wife for Isaac. Eved-Melech the Ethiopian, who pulled the prophet Jeremiah out of a pit with rags and rotten cords so the ropes would not cut him. Hiram king of Tyre, who sent cedar for the Temple. Yabetz, son of Rabbi Judah the Prince. Serah, daughter of Asher, who lived through four hundred years of slavery and remembered where Joseph's bones lay buried. Bityah, Pharaoh's daughter, who reached into the Nile and lifted out a Hebrew baby. And the one whose name the list barely dares to speak, the Messiah, waiting behind the gate.

Nine who walked into the Garden of Eden in their own bodies. Nine who never died to get there.

The Gate That Stays Cracked Open

Most of the dead reach Eden the long way, stripped of flesh, weighed and judged. These nine took a shortcut that should not exist. The list does not show them sickening and being carried in by angels. It shows them living, breathing, still warm, walking past the turning sword that was set at the east of the Garden to keep everyone out.

If the sword could be passed by living feet even nine times, then the wall between paradise and the world was never solid. It was a membrane. And a membrane leaks both ways.

Things come out of Eden too.

The Apple That Would Not Be Hoarded

There was a fruit that carried the whole Garden inside its skin. One apple, and the air around it smelled the way the world smelled before the first sin, the same fragrance that clung to Jacob's borrowed garments when blind Isaac drew him close and breathed in the scent of a field that God had blessed.

This apple did not rot like other fruit. It healed the sick. It pulled the dying back from the edge. Some said an angel set it in a righteous man's hand. Most said Elijah carried it, the same Elijah who had crossed into the Garden alive and could therefore cross back out with a piece of it.

It came with a rule, and the rule was sharp. The apple could not be kept. A man who closed his fist around it for himself, who hid it in a cupboard against his own old age, watched it shrivel between his fingers until the fragrance went out of it and his hand held a brown and worthless thing. A man who pressed it to a fevered child, who carried it to a stranger's deathbed and asked nothing, found that its power did not run down. The more he gave it away, the more there was to give. Hoard the Garden and it dies in your grip. Spend it and it refuses to empty.

The Treasure on the Wrong Shore

Now run the rivers backward. The Garden had four of them, and one was the Pishon, the river that the old verse says winds through a land of gold and good stones. The Pishon carried Eden's pearls downstream. It emptied into the Gihon, another of the four. The Gihon emptied at last into the Sea of Reeds. And the Sea, patient as water always is, washed those gemstones up onto its own bank and left them lying in the wet sand.

Which is why, on the worst morning of their freedom, Israel was not only running.

Behind them the dust was already rising. Pharaoh's chariots. His horsemen, his whole armed host, coming on fast, with the sea ahead and the desert on either side and no road out. And there, crouched at the waterline with the cavalry bearing down, the people were stooping to fill their hands.

Pearls. Goodly stones. They had walked out of Egypt loaded with Egyptian silver and gold, and here at the dead end of the world a stranger wealth was waiting for them in the sand, drifted all the way down from the Garden their first parents had been driven out of. The same water that once watered Eden for Adam was handing their inheritance back to their freed children, at the exact moment it looked like they had no future at all.

Eden open on one side. Extinction closing on the other. And the people crossed with both fists full.

The Map Drawn in Water and Fragrance

Put the three together and a secret geography appears. There is a road into the Garden that a handful of living bodies have walked, against every rule that says the gate is shut. There is a road out, down which an angel can carry a single apple that smells of the first morning. And there is a road that runs through the riverbeds, depositing Eden's pearls on the shore of a sea where slaves are about to become a people.

The same membrane, three crossings. A man walks in. A fruit comes out. A river quietly returns the jewels.

Enoch and Elijah are on the far side now, breathing the Garden's air. Serah remembered where the bones were buried. Bityah lifted the deliverer out of the water. They are the proof that the gate was never fully shut. And the apple in a dying stranger's room, and the pearl drying in a freed slave's fist, are the proof that even from this side of the sword, Eden keeps reaching through.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

3 sources

The texts this telling draws on, in full. Open a card to read inline, or expand it for a wider, quieter read.

Yalkut Shimoni on Torah 76:9Yalkut Shimoni on Torah

Nine entered the Garden of Eden while still alive. These are they: Enoch, and the Messiah, and Elijah, and Eliezer, and Eved-Melech the Ethiopian, and Hiram king of Tyre, and Yabetz son of Rabbi Judah the Prince, and Serah daughter of Asher, and Bityah daughter of Pharaoh. And some say: remove Hiram, and in his place enters Rabbi Joshua ben Levi.

Full source
Exempla of the Rabbis, No. 374Exempla of the Rabbis (Gaster, 1924)

A miraculous apple from Paradise, a single fruit carrying the fragrance and power of the Garden of Eden, is the subject of this tale, preserved in medieval Jewish and comparative folklore. The apple was not merely food. It was a remnant of the original creation, a piece of the world as it existed before sin entered it.

The story tells of a righteous person who received this apple through extraordinary circumstances, brought by Elijah, or found during a miraculous journey, or bestowed by an angel. The apple had the power to heal any illness, to restore youth, to bring the fragrance of Paradise into the fallen world.

The apple came with a condition: it could not be hoarded. It had to be used for others, not for oneself. The person who tried to keep the apple for their own benefit would find it withering in their hands. The person who gave it away, who used its power to heal the sick or comfort the dying, would find its power inexhaustible.

The sages read this story as a parable about all of God's gifts. Everything that comes from Paradise, wisdom, health, prosperity, love, operates on the same principle. Hoard it and it rots. Give it away and it multiplies. The apple from Eden is a test of character: do you consume it, or do you share it?

The fragrance of the apple, some versions add, was the fragrance of the Garden of Eden itself, the scent that Isaac smelled on Jacob's garments when he blessed him (Genesis 27:27). Paradise is not a place. It is a gift that must be passed from hand to hand, or it ceases to exist.

Full source
Targum Pseudo-Jonathan on Exodus 14:9Targum Pseudo-Jonathan on Exodus

The Targum Pseudo-Jonathan on (Exodus 14:9) pictures a scene the Hebrew leaves blank. While Pharaoh's chariots thunder toward them, what is Israel doing? The Targum says they are gathering pearls and goodly stones.

Not ordinary pearls. The Targum traces a cosmic supply chain. The Pishon river, one of the four rivers of Eden (Genesis 2:11), had carried pearls and precious stones out of the garden. The Pishon emptied into the Gihon, another Eden river. The Gihon emptied into the Sea of Reeds. And the Sea had washed those Eden-born gems onto its bank.

So as the Egyptian army approached, Israel crouched on the shore picking up gemstones that had drifted all the way from paradise. The wealth they had taken from Egypt (Exodus 12:35-36) was being supplemented by a stranger wealth: the wealth of Eden itself.

The image is audacious. Redemption runs through geography. The same water that once flowed through the garden God planted for Adam and Eve now deposits its treasures at the feet of their freed descendants. Even as Egypt closes in, the land is returning Israel's inheritance.

"But all the chariot horses of Pharoh, and his horsemen, and his hosts, were coming." The Targum cuts from pearls to cavalry. Eden is open on one side, extinction on the other. Israel will have to cross the sea with both hands full.

Takeaway: the Targum teaches that even in the narrow place between the desert and the enemy, the Garden is never far.

Full source