6 min read

Three Pious Men and the Demons That Tested Them

A ruined believer overhears demons boasting their secrets, while three other men face marble, a haunted tree, and a Shabbat spell.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. The Wall Where the Shedim Boasted
  2. The Man Who Came Back on Purpose
  3. The Marble That Asked for a Lamp
  4. The Tree That Ate the Garden
  5. The Nephew Who Rode Into Tiberias

The wager was simple, and the Jew lost it. He and a gentile neighbor had argued over whose faith was true, and a stranger had wandered up to settle the matter, an ordinary-looking man with a calm voice and a fair manner. He ruled for the gentile. The gentile scooped up the stakes, every coin, and walked away rich. Only later, with empty hands and a long road home, did the Jew understand who the judge had been. Satan wears the face of a reasonable man when he wants to ruin you, and he had just emptied a believer's pockets in the name of justice.

Night caught him before shelter did. He pressed himself flat against a wall in the dark and went still, because he had heard voices on the other side, and the voices were not human.

The Wall Where the Shedim Boasted

The shedim had gathered after sundown the way they do, in a place no traveler should sleep, and they were bragging. One demon laughed about a household it had emptied. Another counted ruined harvests like trophies. Then a third leaned in with the best secret of all. The Emperor's daughter lay dying, he said, and no physician in the realm could touch her sickness, because the cure was a thing only a demon knew. He told it to the others in the dark, every step of it, certain no living ear was near.

A fourth demon topped him. Beneath a certain field, it said, ran a hidden spring of sweet water, and the man who uncovered it would never want for anything again.

The Jew did not move. He did not pray aloud, did not gasp, did not give himself away. He simply memorized, word by word, the way a man memorizes the face of someone who owes him. When the sky greyed and the shedim scattered, he was already walking toward the palace.

He cured the princess. He named the hidden spring. The Emperor, who had buried his hope, gave him wealth past counting, far more than any wager had ever held.

The Man Who Came Back on Purpose

Word of the fortune reached the gentile who had won the bet. He saw the shape of it at once. A wall, a night, a crowd of boasting demons, a fortune for the listener. So he went to the same place when the dark came down, and he sat against the same wall, and he waited to get rich.

The shedim came back. They found him.

They knew the difference between a man who had stumbled into their secrets by accident and a man who had come hunting them, and the difference was the whole story. They tore him apart where he sat. The same knowledge that lifted one man out of ruin killed the other for reaching after it, because the unseen world gives nothing to the one who comes grasping.

The Marble That Asked for a Lamp

Elsewhere a pious man drove his spade into his own field and struck stone. He dug, and uncovered a marble figure, finely carved, half swallowed by the dirt of forgotten years. He was brushing off the last of it when the marble spoke.

"Clean me," it said. "Set me in a clean corner of your house, and I will make you rich."

He carried it home. Days later it spoke again, told him his friend was caught in a trap out in the forest, told him to run. He ran, found the man exactly where the marble said, freed him, and was paid handsomely for the rescue. The gifts were real. That was the trick of it. Each one was real.

Then the marble asked for a lamp. "Light a flame in front of me," it said, and the man went cold, because a lamp is not thanks. A lamp is avodah zarah, foreign worship, and the stone had been walking him toward it one true gift at a time. He took up his axe. A demon burst from the marble's mouth and begged. "Spare me," it cried, "and I will give you riches beyond anything you have seen." He swung anyway and broke the thing to gravel.

A year on, digging in his garden, he turned up a buried treasure that no spirit had offered him, coins and vessels laid there long before and meant, it seemed, for a man who would not light the lamp.

The Tree That Ate the Garden

Another pious man owned a tree, the pride of his land, tall and heavy with fruit, beloved by everyone who rested in its shade. A shed had moved into its branches. People gathered, animals grazed, feet trampled the rows, and the crops he lived on were dying under the weight of his most beautiful thing.

He sharpened his axe. The demon heard the stone on the blade and appeared in a panic. "Don't," it pleaded. "I have money. I have jewels. Take them and leave the tree." He understood the offer for what it was, a private covenant with a power that was not God, an altar raised to the wrong lord. He cut the tree down. When the workmen pulled the roots, they found coins and vessels buried beneath the trunk, a treasure given clean, on Heaven's terms, the moment he refused it on the demon's.

The Nephew Who Rode Into Tiberias

Faith does not always get the chance to refuse. In Capernaum on the Sea of Galilee, sorcerers worked their keshafim on Chananya, the nephew of Rabbi Yehoshua, and the spell was built to shame. His body climbed onto a donkey and rode into Tiberias on Shabbat, breaking the holy day in plain sight while his mind watched, helpless, from inside its own walls.

Rabbi Yehoshua came for him. Not with a louder spell, but with a shemen, an anointing oil, and with prayer set against the witchcraft word for word, until the spell let go and Chananya was himself again. Then the rabbi sent him to Babylon, far from the sorcerers, far from the shame, into a town that would know him only as a Jew in good standing. The demons knew his secrets, and his uncle knew the oil and the words. That was the whole contest, and the oil won.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

4 sources

The texts this telling draws on, in full. Open a card to read inline, or expand it for a wider, quieter read.

Exempla of the Rabbis, No. 447Exempla of the Rabbis (Gaster, 1924)

A Jewish man and a gentile once made a wager about whose religion was true. Satan, disguised as an ordinary man, appeared and ruled in favor of the gentile, who took all the money. The Jew was left with nothing.

That night, broken and desperate, the Jewish man happened to rest near a place where demons gathered after dark. He pressed himself against a wall and listened as the shedim (demons) boasted to one another about the destruction they had caused and the secrets they knew.

One demon bragged that he knew how to cure the Emperor's daughter, who was gravely ill and whom no physician could heal. Another revealed the location of a hidden spring of fresh water beneath a certain field, a discovery that would make any man wealthy. A third spoke of yet another secret that could change a man's fortune.

The Jewish man memorized everything he heard. At dawn, when the demons vanished, he went to the Emperor's court, cured the princess using the method the demon had described, and then revealed the hidden spring. The Emperor rewarded him with enormous wealth.

The gentile who had won the original wager heard about this windfall and went to the same spot at night, hoping to overhear the demons himself. But the shedim discovered him. Unlike the Jewish man, who had stumbled upon them by accident and listened in silence, the gentile had come deliberately. And the demons killed him on the spot. The medieval Exempla of the Rabbis preserves this variant alongside Tale No. 29 as a teaching about providence: the same hidden knowledge that saves one person destroys another, depending on who was meant to receive it.

Full source
Gaster, Exempla No. 396The Exempla of the Rabbis (1924)

A pious man was digging in his field one afternoon when his spade struck something hard. He uncovered a marble statue, finely carved, half buried in the soil of generations. As he brushed away the last of the dirt, the statue spoke.

"Clean me," it said. "Place me in a clean corner of your house, and I will give you riches." The man was astonished. He took the statue home and set it on a shelf.

Days later, the statue spoke again. "Your friend is caught in a trap in the forest. Go now and free him, and you will be rewarded." The man ran, found his friend exactly as the statue had described, freed him. And was gifted a generous sum for the rescue.

The statue spoke once more. "Now light a lamp in front of me." And the pious man understood. A lamp was not a gesture of gratitude. A lamp was an act of avodah zarah, foreign worship. The statue had been easing him, gift by gift, toward idolatry.

He reached for his axe and moved to shatter the marble. A demon burst out of the statue's mouth and begged him to stop. "Spare me and I will give you riches beyond anything you have seen." The man did not listen. He raised the axe and broke the statue to pieces.

Gaster's Exempla (1924), No. 396, from the Ben Attar collection, closes the tale quietly. A year later, the man was digging in his garden and found a genuine treasure buried there, not from a demon's bribe, but as a reward from Heaven for the refusal.

Every idol offers you something real at first. The question is what it wants in return. A pious man is the one who can do the math before the lamp is lit.

Full source
Gaster, Exempla No. 395 (Ben Attar)The Exempla of the Rabbis (1924)

A pious man had a magnificent tree in his garden. For years it had been the pride of his land, tall, shady, heavy with fruit. Travelers and neighbors loved to rest beneath it.

Something was wrong. A shed, a demon, had taken up residence in its branches. The tree had become a gathering point: people rested there, let their animals graze nearby, trampled through the surrounding field, and destroyed the crops the man depended on. The garden was slowly being eaten alive by its own most beautiful feature.

The man decided to cut the tree down.

The demon, hearing the axe being sharpened, appeared to him in a rush of desperation. "Don't," the demon pleaded. "Please. Don't cut it. I will pay you. I have money. I have jewels. Take them and leave the tree standing."

The pious man looked at the creature and felt something cold move through him. He understood, in that instant, that the demon's offer was a form of avodah zarah, idol-worship. To accept gifts from a spirit in exchange for sparing its dwelling-place was to enter into a private covenant with a power other than God. The tree had become an altar for the wrong lord.

He cut it down anyway.

When the trunk fell and the workmen began clearing the roots, they found, buried beneath the base of the tree, a genuine treasure, coins, vessels, valuables, placed there long ago and forgotten by whoever buried them (Gaster, Exempla No. 395).

The Ben Attar collection preserves this tale with a quiet moral: the pious man had refused to take wealth on the demon's terms, and precisely because he refused, heaven gave him the same wealth directly, on its own terms. The lesson is that a righteous refusal is not a loss. Sometimes it is the only way the blessing can arrive clean.

Full source
Gaster, Exempla of the Rabbis No. 213b (1924); Kohelet Rabbah 1:8The Exempla of the Rabbis (1924)

In the town of Capernaum on the Sea of Galilee, a dangerous group practiced sorcery. Among their victims was Chananya, the nephew of Rabbi Yehoshua. They cast a spell on him, the sources call it keshafim, witchcraft. And the effect was precisely designed to shame him. He mounted a donkey and rode into the city of Tiberias on Shabbat, violating one of the most public prohibitions of the holy day while his body obeyed the spell and his mind watched helplessly.

Rabbi Yehoshua learned what had happened. He came to his nephew, brought a specific shemen, an anointing ointment. And combined it with counter-formulas of prayer, undoing the spell.

When Chananya was restored to himself, Rabbi Yehoshua did not let him stay in the Galilee. He sent his nephew to Babylon, far from the sorcerers of Capernaum, far from the shame, into a community that would know him only as a Jew in good standing.

Gaster's Exempla (No. 213b, 1924) and Kohelet Rabbah 1:8 preserve the story. The rabbis treated sorcery as real, dangerous, and answerable to Torah, not by counter-magic, but by holy oil, holy words, and a family member willing to come rescue the bewitched.

Full source