Parshat Toldot5 min read

Isaac Reopened Abraham's Wells and Kept Their Names

The Philistines poured earth into Abraham's wells until the rims sat useless in the sun. Isaac came back with a spade and sore shoulders.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. Earth in the Mouth of the Wells
  2. Isaac Put the Old Names Back
  3. Living Water in the Valley
  4. He Named the Place Perversity
  5. The Water Remembered Abraham

The Philistines waited until Abraham was dead before they buried his water.

Isaac Reopened Abraham's Wells and Kept Their Names Click for full size

Earth in the Mouth of the Wells

Gerar knew those wells. Men had lowered ropes into them. Women had filled jars at their mouths. Herds had crowded near them, snorting dust from their noses while the water rose cold from under the ground. Abraham had dug them and named them, and every name fastened his labor to the land.

Then the old man died. The shovels came out.

The Philistines did not smash a monument. They poured earth into the wells until the mouths closed. Dirt swallowed the openings. The ropes went slack. The stones around the rim sat useless in the sun. In a dry country, stopping a well is not mischief. It is a sentence.

No water here. No Abraham here.

Isaac Put the Old Names Back

Isaac returned to a landscape that had been taught to forget. His servants found the places where his father's wells had been, and the work began again. Spades bit into packed soil. Men scraped, lifted, and dug deeper. Every basket of earth that came up from a mouth loosened the Philistine verdict.

Water was the obvious need. Isaac had flocks, herds, servants, tents, and children. A camp cannot live on memory. It needs drinkable water, and it needs it before the heat climbs too high.

When the wells opened again, he gave them back their old names. Not new names. Not names of his own success. The names Abraham had spoken were placed back on the wells like vessels restored to a table. This was kibbud av (כיבוד אב), honor for a father, done with rope, stone, and mud under the fingernails.

To reward him, God left Isaac's name unchanged. Abraham had taken a new name. Jacob would take a new name. Isaac kept the one he was given, because he had kept his father's words on the water.

Living Water in the Valley

The work did not end with the old wells. Isaac's men dug in the valley, where the earth held its secrets under a skin of dust. They cut down through dry layers until the ground changed. The sound changed first. A dull scrape became a wet pull. Then the water came.

Living water.

The shepherds of Gerar arrived before anyone had drunk in peace. They looked at the water and claimed it. "The water is ours," they said. Isaac's servants had dug. Isaac's camp had found the spring. The men of Gerar reached for it anyway.

Earth in a well had become a hand over a new spring. After four attempts Isaac found the well that had followed the patriarchs. Abraham had obtained it after three diggings. Hence Beer-sheba, the well of seven diggings, the same well that will supply Jerusalem in the time of the Messiah.

He Named the Place Perversity

Isaac did not pretend the quarrel was ordinary. He named the place Perversity, because something straight had been bent there. Work had been twisted into theft. A gift from the ground had been dragged into a fight before anyone had drunk in peace.

They dug a second well, and the shepherds strove for that also. He called its name Enmity.

He rose from there and they dug another. For that they did not strive. He called the name of it Room, and Isaac said, "Now the Lord hath made room for us, and we have increased in the land."

The name Perversity stayed like a scar on the first rim. Room was the later breath. He let the injury keep its proper label, and he let the relief keep its proper name. When the men of Gerar tried to turn memory into dirt and water into dispute, Isaac answered by naming what had happened.

The Water Remembered Abraham

At the reopened wells, Abraham's names rose with the water. At the new wells, Perversity and Enmity and Room stood as a record. Isaac's camp learned both kinds of memory, the memory that honors and the memory that refuses to smooth over wrong.

The Philistines had tried to make Abraham's work disappear by filling it with earth. Isaac made the land speak again. Every bucket lifted from the old wells said that a father's labor could be buried, but not cancelled. Every servant who bent over the stones learned that honor is not only spoken in blessings at a bedside. Sometimes it is done with sore shoulders in a valley, while other men argue over the water.

By evening the wells stood open under the sky. The old names had returned. The living water moved below them, patient and cold, as if it had been waiting for Isaac to call it by the right name.

IsaacAbrahamWellsPhilistinesHoly LandGinzbergPatriarchsGerarPatienceTargum Pseudo JonathanGenesisJacobLabanMiracles
← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

3 sources

The texts behind this telling. Some cards carry a translation of the source; others are our own retelling of it, and each card says which. Every card links out to the original.

Legends of the Jews 6:39Legends of the Jews

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Legends of the Jews by Louis Ginzberg (1909) · Public Domain

The Torah hints at it in so many ways. the story turns to the story of Isaac and some very important wells.

Isaac, as we know, was the son of Abraham, and he found himself in Gerar, a Philistine territory. Now, Abraham had dug wells there, crucial sources of life in the arid landscape. But after Abraham's passing, the Philistines, well, they plugged them up. Stopped them. End of story. Not quite.

Isaac, driven by a deep respect for his father – a concept the rabbis call kibbud av v'em – went back and reopened those very wells. Not only that, he even restored the names Abraham had given them. Ginzberg, in his Legends of the Jews, makes a point of saying that Isaac’s reverence was so profound that he insisted on preserving his father's legacy in this very tangible way. Reclaiming and honoring the past.

Here's a fascinating tidbit. To reward Isaac for this profound filial respect, the Holy One, Blessed be He, allowed his name to remain unchanged. Abraham, remember, was originally Abram, and Jacob would later become Israel. But Isaac? Isaac remained Isaac. As Ginzberg points out, this is a direct reward for his honoring of his father's legacy. It's as if the Divine is saying, "You honor your father's name, so your name will be honored."

But the story doesn't end there. Isaac persisted in digging, seeking water in this parched land. After four attempts, he finally struck water. Not just any water, mind you. This was the very well that had followed the Patriarchs! The Midrash Rabbah and other sources tell us that this well, known as Beer-sheba – literally, "the well of seven" or "the well of the oath," depending on which interpretation you prefer – had been discovered by Abraham after three diggings. Isaac's persistence, building on his father's work, made it flow again.

Beer-sheba. Seven diggings. And, according to some traditions, this is no ordinary well. This is the same well that will, in Messianic times, supply water to Jerusalem and its surroundings. A well dug by our ancestors, flowing with life-giving water, sustaining us in the future.

What does it all mean? Well, perhaps it's a reminder that our actions, our respect for those who came before us, have a ripple effect. Isaac's devotion not only honored his father, but it also ensured a source of sustenance for generations to come, even into the Messianic era. It's a powerful evidence of the enduring legacy of family, tradition, and the importance of digging deep, both literally and figuratively, to uncover the wellsprings of our heritage. Remember to honor those who came before you, for they may just hold the key to your future.

Full source
Book of Jubilees 24:29Book of Jubilees

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.Sefaria Community Translation · CC-BY

It's a retelling and expansion of stories we find in Genesis, offering a slightly different perspective.

Our focus? Chapter 24. It's a short, sharp account of Isaac and his struggles over water rights.

"And the servants of Isaac dug a well in the valley, and found living water…" A wellspring! A source of life in the arid landscape. But the joy is short-lived.

"…and the shepherds of Gerar strove with the shepherds of Isaac, saying: 'The water is ours'; and Isaac called the name of the well 'Perversity,' because they had been perverse with us."

Perversity. In Hebrew, the name given to this well is likely related to the idea of twisting or distorting what is right. Isaac's people discover water, a gift from the earth, only to have it immediately contested. They name the well as a reminder of the unfairness they faced.

But the story doesn't end there.

"And they dug a second well, and they strove for that also, and he called its name 'Enmity.'"

The struggle continues. Another well, another dispute. This time, the well is named "Enmity," a symbol of the hostility and antagonism between the groups. You can almost feel the weariness creeping in. How many times can you keep fighting the same battle?

And then, a turning point.

"And he arose from thence and they digged another well, and for that they strove not, and he called the name of it 'Room,' and Isaac said: 'Now the Lord hath made room for us, and we have increased in the land.'"

Finally, a well that isn't contested! Isaac names it "Room" – a place of expansion, of possibility. This is more than just finding water; it's about finding peace, about creating a space where growth and prosperity are possible.

What's so powerful about this little story? It's not just about water. It's about the human condition. It's about the struggles we face, the conflicts we encounter, and the hope that, eventually, we might find a place of "Room." A place where we can flourish without constant opposition.

What "wells" are you digging in your life? What battles are you constantly fighting? And what would it take to find your own "Room"?

Full source
Targum Pseudo-Jonathan on Genesis 26:18Targum Pseudo-Jonathan on Genesis

Retold in our words. Read the original at the link below.The Targum of Jonathan ben Uzziel, trans. J. W. Etheridge, London, 1862 · Public Domain

When the Philistines try to erase Abraham's memory, the Targum Pseudo-Jonathan tells us what Isaac does. He digs. Again. "And Izhak digged again the wells of water which the servants of his father had digged in the days of Abraham his father, and which the Philistaee had stopped after Abraham was dead" (Genesis 26:18).

He did more than dig. He named each well by the old name. Every shaft that Abraham had drilled, Isaac reopened and called by Abraham's word.

Why is this so important?

In the ancient Near East, a name was a claim. When the Philistines stopped up Abraham's wells with earth after he died, they were trying to erase his footprint from the land, to make it as if he had never been there. When Isaac reopens each well and restores each original name, he is not just getting water. He is insisting that Abraham's life mattered and that the covenant was not a footnote.

The rabbis compared this to what every generation must do. The Talmud in Berakhot teaches that Torah study is the reopening of wells. Each generation must dig again through the dirt that has settled on the words of the generation before.

The takeaway

The enemies of a holy life do not always come with swords. Sometimes they come with shovels, filling in what was built. Pseudo-Jonathan's Isaac is the model of response: dig again. Use the old names. Let the water flow where your father's servants once struck it. The covenant is stored in wells, and wells need tending.

Full source