Job Swore His Own Furrows Would Weep If He Had Cheated Them

Job sat in the ashes with his skin broken open from the soles of his feet to the crown of his head, and he said "my land."

Click for full size

The men around him heard the wrong thing in it. What claim does a man have on the earth? Three cubits of dirt at the end, enough to lie down in, and not a handful more. The ground belongs to God, who fills heaven and earth. And this one, scraping himself with a piece of broken pot, still calling fields by his own name.

Try the World On and See If It Fits

Rabbi Chiyya put the challenge as a scene in a market.

A man is selling a cloak. A stranger walks up and says the cloak is his. Fine, says the seller. Put it on. If it fits you, take it.

So wrap creation around your shoulders, Job. Get an arm into the sky. If the world hangs on you properly, go on calling the furrows yours.

What the Furrows Would Have Said

He answered from inside the ash heap, and the answer had nothing to do with deeds of ownership.

"If my land cries out against me, and its furrows weep together" (Job 31:38). He was not swearing that he owned it. He was swearing on how he had farmed it, and every clause named a way a field learns to scream.

If my land cries out against me: if I held back the tithe. If its furrows weep together: if I sowed it with forbidden mixtures. If I ate its strength without money: if I never redeemed the second tithe. If I crushed the life of its owners: if I kept back the share that belongs to the poor, who are the ones the ground is finally for.

His friends had spent days guessing at a hidden sin. He handed them a witness nobody can bribe. A field that has been cheated learns to cry out, and Job swore his had stayed quiet through every year he still had cattle and walls. Dig up any row I ever planted and ask it.

Ten Sons and the Rightful Tenth

The practice he was swearing on was older than the law that commanded it.

Rabbi Chuna traced the line back. Abraham lifted his hand and refused the spoils of the four kings, and the word for that lifting is the word the Torah would later use for setting aside the priest's portion. Isaac measured out a harvest of a hundredfold, which no sensible farmer does, since blessing does not settle on what has been counted. He measured it because he meant to tithe it, and the blessing came after. Jacob stood at Bethel with a stone under his head and said, "Of all You give me, I will surely tithe to You" (Genesis 28:22).

A Samaritan came at Rabbi Meir with that vow. Your truthful Jacob tithed one tribe out of twelve and never touched the rest. Where is the honest tenth?

Rabbi Meir counted it out for him. Jacob raised Ephraim and Manasseh to full standing, so the sons came to fourteen. Four of the fourteen were firstborn to the four mothers, and a firstborn is already holy, and you cannot tithe what has already been set apart. Fourteen less four leaves ten. Levi was the tenth.

The man had nothing left to say except "happy is your nation."

Rabbi Nechemiah did the other arithmetic. A landlord rents out a field and takes half the crop, or a third, or a quarter, and everyone calls that ordinary business. God sends the wind that moves the clouds, and the clouds, and the rain, and the dew, and the fruit that swells on the branch, and asks for one part in ten.

Spat On Outside the Furnace

Hananiah, Mishael, and Azariah walked out of Nebuchadnezzar's furnace with their clothes unburned, and the crowd that had gathered to watch them die closed in and spat on them.

They kept spitting until it lay on the three of them in clots. You serve a God who let His own House burn, they said. Look at Him. Now look at yourselves.

The three lifted their faces and gave the answer Daniel had given: "To You, O Lord, belongs righteousness, and to us shame of face" (Daniel 9:7).

Rabbi Yudah had already stacked up the evidence for that sentence. Israel carried an idol across the seabed on the very day the water stood up in two walls, and the water let them through anyway. On the morning the manna first fell, they took God's own bread and set it in front of other gods, and the bread fell again the next morning.

If I Am Lying, Let My Words End

"The words of Job are ended" (Job 31:40).

Except that they are not. He keeps talking after that line, and the sages refused to read it as a stray editorial note. They read it as the last clause of the oath. If I am lying about the land, let my speech stop here. Take away the right to stand in front of You and say I have cleared the holy portion out of my house.

His friends had been trying to shut him up with theology for weeks. He offered a harder silence than any of theirs, and he offered it against himself.

Then he sat back down in the ashes and waited to hear whether the ground would say anything.