Parshat Ki Teitzei6 min read

Rizpah's Sackcloth Vigil on the Hill of the Hanged

To end a three-year famine David hangs seven of Saul's sons, and Rizpah guards their bodies on a rock through summer until the rain returns.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. Three Years the Rain Withheld
  2. The Blood the Gibeonites Would Not Sell
  3. Sackcloth on the Rock
  4. The Nations Called the Torah a Forgery
  5. Water Fell from Heaven
Rizpah's Sackcloth Vigil on the Hill of the Hanged Click for full size

Three Years the Rain Withheld

For three years the ground gave nothing. The wells sank. The barley came up thin and yellow and died standing. David could name no sin to explain it, so he went and asked, and the answer came back strange and old. The famine was not for anything he had done. It was for a house already in the grave.

Years before, King Saul had turned on the Gibeonites and put them to the sword. They were the remnant of the men who had once come to Joshua in worn-out sandals, carrying moldy bread and pretending to be travelers from a far country, and had tricked Israel into swearing them a covenant of peace. Their own elders had counseled that lie. Scripture would remember them by a name with a barb hidden in it, elders of shame, the word cut short on the page the way the righteous of Sodom are written short. Cursed, dragged-along converts. And Saul had broken the oath sworn to them and spilled their blood.

The oath did not forget. The land kept the account.

The Blood the Gibeonites Would Not Sell

David went to what was left of the Gibeonites and asked how he could make it right. "We want no silver and no gold from Saul or from his house," they said. They wanted blood for blood. Seven of Saul's sons, handed over to be hung on the hill before the LORD.

He kept back Jonathan's line for the sake of the oath he had sworn his friend, but he took the two sons Saul had by Rizpah the daughter of Aiah, and five more of Saul's grandsons, and put them in the hands of the Gibeonites. On the hill they impaled all seven together and left them hanging in the sun. It was the day after the first festival of Passover, the sixteenth of Nisan, when the barley harvest begins.

The Torah says plainly that a body hung on a tree must not stay there overnight, that it must be buried the same day. These seven would hang for seven months.

Sackcloth on the Rock

Rizpah did not scream and did not beg the king. She took sackcloth and climbed the hill and spread it for herself on the bare rock beneath her sons, and she stayed.

The vultures came down first, and she drove them off. At night the jackals came for the bodies, and she drove them off too. Day after day, through the heat of Nisan and the long dry months after it, she let neither the birds of the sky settle on the dead by day nor the beasts of the field touch them by night.

Over the rock she said words. "He is the Rock, His work is perfect, for all His ways are justice." She said them over the boys she had borne and over the five who hung beside them, on the stone she had made her seat. Ha-Tzur, the Rock, the stone under her body and the God above her folded into the one word she would not stop speaking.

The summer burned on. Passover passed, then the wheat, then the Feast of Weeks, then the dead heat of Av, then the turn of the year, and still she sat, and still the seven hung, and still she kept the wings and the teeth away.

The Nations Called the Torah a Forgery

Travelers from the nations passed the hill and saw the seven hanging month after month, and they began to talk.

"Their own Torah is a forgery," they said. "It is written there that a hanged body must not stay overnight, and these have hung since spring. It is written there that two are not sentenced on a single day, and here are seven condemned together. It is written there that fathers are not put to death for their sons, and these die for a sin that was their father's. The book they carry says one thing and their king does another."

The Israelites answered them. "The fathers of these dead men killed the Gibeonites, and this is the reckoning for it."

"And who were these Gibeonites," the nations asked, "that a whole royal house should hang for them?"

"Converts," Israel said. "The ones who came over in the days of Joshua."

The nations stared. "For the sake of these cursed, dragged-along converts your God held back the rain three years, and would not give it back until a king handed over his own blood?"

"For their sake," Israel said. "He swore them peace, and He kept it, even against Saul."

Water Fell from Heaven

The nations had come to mock a broken law and found instead a God who would starve a kingdom rather than let one oath to the lowest of strangers go unpaid. "There is no god like their God," they said, "and no nation like this nation. There is nothing to hold onto but this people, for their God is greater than all gods." A hundred and fifty thousand of them crossed over that year and joined Israel, so many that when Solomon later counted the converts in the land he could barely number them.

Then, on the seventeenth of Marcheshvan, after the autumn had turned, the rain came. Water dropped from heaven onto the seven at last, and the long drought broke. Greater is the sanctifying of the Name than the profaning of it, and here the whole earth had watched the Name made holy on a bare hill by a woman on a rock.

David heard that the water had fallen and that Rizpah still sat there. He took the bones of the seven, and the bones of Saul and Jonathan, and gave them all a grave in the land of Benjamin, in their father's tomb. Only then did Rizpah come down off the rock.

The God who had held back the rain had already spoken the ending through the prophet. Peace, peace, to the far off and to the near. He had brought the far ones close and rejoiced over the ones dragged in from the edges as over the ones born inside. On a hill of the hanged, in the summer a mother would not leave, He had proven it.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

2 sources

The texts behind this telling. Some cards carry a translation of the source; others are our own retelling of it, and each card says which. Every card links out to the original.

Midrash Shmuel 28:6Midrash Shmuel

Translation of the source text.Midrash Shmuel, Krakow 1893, Public Domain, on Sefaria · CC-BY-SA

"And the king took the two sons of Rizpah, etc., and delivered them into the hands of the Gibeonites, and they hanged them, etc." (2 Samuel 21:8–9). This teaches that they hung seven months, from the close of the first festival day of Passover until the last festival day of the Feast [of Tabernacles].

"And Rizpah the daughter of Aiah took sackcloth and spread it for herself upon the rock" (ibid., v. 10). What is "upon the rock" (el ha-tzur)? Rav Hoshaya said: She was reciting over them, "He is the Rock (ha-Tzur), His work is perfect, etc." (Deuteronomy 32:4).

[Rabbi Abba bar Zemina] in the name of Rabbi Hoshaya: Greater is the sanctification of the Name than the desecration of the Name. Concerning the desecration of the Name it is written, "His body shall not remain all night upon the tree" (ibid. 21:23); but concerning the sanctification of the Name, "from the beginning of harvest until water dropped upon them" (2 Samuel 21:6), from the sixteenth of Nisan until the seventeenth of Marcheshvan, "until water dropped upon them out of heaven, etc."

And the nations of the world would see them and say: The Torah of these people is a forgery! It is written in their Torah, "His body shall not remain all night upon the tree", yet these hang seven months! It is written in the Torah that two are not judged on one day, yet these were the seven of them together (2 Samuel 21:9), this [word] lacks a yod; this is Mephibosheth. It is written in the Torah, "Fathers shall not be put to death for the children", yet these die for the iniquity of their fathers!

Israel said to them: The fathers of these men put these others to death. They said to them: And what was their character? They said to them: These are the proselytes who converted in the days of Joshua. They said to them: And on account of these cursed, dragged-along proselytes the Holy One, blessed be He, did this? They said: There is no god like your God, and there is no nation like this nation; we have none to cleave to but this nation, for their God is greater than all gods. This is what is written, "For the LORD is greater than all gods" (Exodus 18:11). Immediately a hundred and fifty thousand of the nations of the world converted. This is what is written, "And Solomon numbered all the proselytes who were in the land of Israel, after the numbering wherewith David his father had numbered them, and they were found a hundred and fifty thousand [and three thousand and six hundred]. [Of these Solomon made] seventy thousand bearers of burdens and eighty thousand hewers in the mountain" (2 Chronicles 16:17).

And all this, why? To make known the praise of Him who spoke and the world came into being, that He brings near those who are far off and rejoices over the far ones as over the near ones, and offers peace to the far one even before the near one. This is what is written, "He creates the speech of the lips: Peace, peace to him that is far off and to him that is near, etc." (Isaiah 57:19).

Full source
Yalkut Shimoni on Nach 19:2Yalkut Shimoni on Nach

Translation of the source text.Yalkut Shimoni on Nach (Sefaria) · CC-BY-NC

"And our elders and all the inhabitants of our land said to us" (Joshua 9:11). Rabbi Yochanan said: it is written zekenenu, "our elder," that is, elders of shame.

This follows Rabbi Yochanan's own view, for he said: wherever Scripture speaks of righteous people in Sodom, it writes tzadikm defectively.

Full source