Parshat Bereshit7 min read

The Seven Names of the Giants and the Judge Who Has No Court Above

Seven names of doom mark the giants of the flood, and Abraham later faces the one Judge with no higher court to overturn His verdict.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. The Roll of Names That Was Also a Sentence
  2. The Later Ones Learned Nothing From the Earlier
  3. The Man Who Would Not Let the Verdict Stand
  4. The King Who Has No One Above Him

A woman went out into the marketplace and came home pregnant. She had not lain with her husband. She had only looked up, and what she looked up at was so vast that her body answered it before she chose to, and nine months later she bore a son in the image of the thing she had seen. This was how the giants multiplied now. A glance was enough. The earth filled with their children, and there was no longer anywhere to stand where one of them did not throw its shadow.

The sages who came after counted seven names for them, and each name was less a label than a verdict already spoken.

The Roll of Names That Was Also a Sentence

They called them Emim, because terror went out from them like heat. Whoever saw one felt the dread land on him whole, the way dread lands in a dream the instant before falling. They called them Rephaim, because the heart of anyone who looked grew soft and useless as melting wax, the courage running out of a man before he could decide to run.

They called them Gibborim, the mighty, and Rabbi Yochanan kept the proof in a single bone. The marrow of one giant's thighbone measured twelve cubits, a stretch of dead man longer than the roof of a house. They called them Zamzummim, the masters and chiefs of war, the ones who planned the slaughter and never lost the appetite for it. They called them Anakim, and here the rabbis split. Some said the giants simply heaped giants upon giants until the world ran out of room. Rabbi Acha said no, the name meant their necks reached the orb of the sun, and they tilted their faces up into the burning wheel and gave it orders. "Bring down rain for us," they said to the sun, as though heaven were a servant who had forgotten his place.

They called them Avvim, because they ensnared the world and trapped it and laid it waste, until even the prophets borrowed the word for ruin and said it three times over a doomed thing, a ruin, a ruin, a ruin. And last they called them Nephilim, the fallen, three falls folded into one word. They cast the world down. They fell out of the world themselves. And through their endless lust they filled the world with miscarriages, with the unborn dropped like spoiled fruit, so that even the wombs of the earth were full of their ruin.

The Later Ones Learned Nothing From the Earlier

What should have frightened them did not. The generation of the flood had the drowned generation of Enosh behind them, and looked at that grave and learned nothing. The men of renown the verse calls them, the men of the great name, and Rabbi Acha turned the phrase inside out. Children of churls, another verse calls such men, children of no name at all. So which was it, men of renown or men of no name? Both, and they were the same thing. They made the world a desolation, and the world made a desolation of them, and the only name they left behind was the sound of the place they had emptied.

God watched the wickedness swell. Not wickedness that held steady, but wickedness that grew, great and ever-growing, doubling on itself like the giants themselves. From the hour the sun rose until the hour it set there was no break in it, and the evil inclination renewed itself in every heart each morning the way hunger comes back no matter how a man ate the night before. Even its Maker had given up calling it anything kinder. He called it evil.

So God said the unbearable thing. He said He regretted having made the human being on the earth. And the sages noticed that the same word for regret also means comfort, the word a son uses when he comforts his grieving brothers and speaks to their hearts. God said, in effect, that He had done well to ready a grave for them. The grief and the resolve arrived in one breath.

The Man Who Would Not Let the Verdict Stand

Years on, when the same fire-and-water arithmetic of judgment came round again over the cities of the plain, one man refused to let it pass in silence. Abraham stood before the Judge and did the thing no one before him had dared, with ten generations between Noah and himself and not one of them willing to open his mouth in heaven's court.

"Far be it from You," Abraham said, and Rabbi Yudan heard in that soft word something hard. It is profane for You, he was saying. It is a fabrication. There is a desecration of Your own Name in it. "Will You sweep away the righteous with the wicked? Shall the Judge of all the earth not do justice?"

Then Abraham named the trap, and named it to God's face. "If You want a world, there can be no strict judgment. If You want strict judgment, there can be no world. You are holding the rope at both ends. You want the world to stand and You want every account settled, and You cannot have the two at once. Relent a little, or the world cannot bear its own weight."

The King Who Has No One Above Him

He pressed harder, because the cities were already smoking in the future. "A king of flesh and blood has someone over him," Abraham said. "A petition climbs from the duke to the prefect, from the prefect to the general, and there is always a higher court to overturn the lower. You have no court above You. There is no one to appeal to over Your head. And precisely because there is no one to restrain You, will You not restrain Yourself? Will You not do justice?"

God did not strike him for it. God said instead, "You have loved righteousness and hated wickedness." You loved to acquit My creatures and hated to condemn them, and for that, of all the ten generations, I spoke with no one but you. Two men in the world would later say almost the same words. Job said God destroys the blameless and the wicked alike, and Job was punished for it. Abraham said the same accusation and was rewarded, because Abraham said it to save the guilty and Job said it to indict the Judge. The sentence was identical. The heart underneath it was not, and heaven judges the heart.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

2 sources

The texts this telling draws on, in full. Open a card to read inline, or expand it for a wider, quieter read.

Yalkut Shimoni on Torah 47:1Yalkut Shimoni on Torah

"The Nephilim were on the earth" (Genesis 6:4). Seven names were given to them: Emim, Rephaim, Gibborim, Zamzummim, Anakim, Avvim, Nephilim. Emim, because anyone who saw them, terror (eimah) would fall upon him. Rephaim, because anyone who saw them, his heart would grow weak (rafeh) as wax. Gibborim, Rabbi Abba bar Kahana said in the name of Rabbi Yochanan: the marrow of the thighbone of one of them measured twelve cubits. Zamzummim, Rabbi Yose bar Chanina said: masters and chiefs of war. Anakim, the Rabbis and Rabbi Acha differed: the Rabbis say they multiplied giants (anakim) upon giants; Rabbi Acha said they would reach the orb of the sun with their necks (anak) and say, "Bring down rain for us." Avvim, because they ensnared (tzadu) the world and were driven from the world and caused the world to be laid waste, as you say, "A ruin (avvah), a ruin, a ruin I will make it" (Ezekiel 21:32). Rabbi Eleazar son of Rabbi Shimon said: they were as expert in the soils as snakes; in the Galilee they call a snake an avya. Nephilim, because they cast down (hippilu) the world, and they fell (naflu) from the world, and they filled the world with miscarriages (nefalim) through their licentiousness. "And also after that" (Genesis 6:4), the later ones did not learn from the earlier: the flood generation from the generation of Enosh, and the generation of the Dispersion from the flood generation. "And also after that, when the sons of God came in to the daughters of men." Rabbi Berekhiah said: a woman would go out to the marketplace and so forth, and she would go and have relations and conceive a young man like the one she had seen. "The men of renown (anshei ha-shem)", Rabbi Acha said: "Children of churls, children of no-name" (Job 30:8), yet you say men of renown? Rather, they laid the world waste (heshimu) and were laid waste from the world and caused the world to be made desolate. Rabbi Levi in the name of Rabbi Shmuel bar Nachman said: men whose names were specified above. For Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi said: all these names are expressions of rebellion, "Irad" (Genesis 4:18), he expelled (oradan) them from the world; "Mehujael," I am wiping out (matishan) them from the world; "Lamech," what need have I (mah li) of Lamech and his descendants? Rabbi Yochanan said: "These were the mighty men of old, the men of renown", and who specified their deeds? Eliphaz the Temanite, Bildad the Shuhite, and Zophar the Naamathite. Rabbi says: had Job come into the world only to detail for us the doings of the flood, that would suffice for him. Rav Chanan said: had Elihu come only to explain for us the matter of the coming down of rains, that would suffice for him, for Rabbi Yochanan said: every mention of light regarding Elijah refers only to the coming down of rains. Rabbi Hoshaya the Great said: it refers only to the giving of the Torah, as you say, "For the commandment is a lamp and the Torah is light" (Proverbs 6:23). Rabbi Acha in the name of Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi said: dispute is as grave as the flood generation; it is said here "men of renown," and it is said there, "princes of the congregation, called to the assembly, men of renown" (Numbers 16:2), just as "men of renown" said there refers to dispute [the rebellion of Korah], so "men of renown" said here refers to dispute. "And the LORD saw that the wickedness of man was great" (Genesis 6:5), great and ever-growing. We have heard of the flood generation, who were judged with water, and the Sodomites, who were judged with fire. From where do we apply what is said here to there and what is said there to here? Scripture says "great" here and "great" there as a gezeira shava [verbal analogy]. "And every inclination of the thoughts of his heart was only evil all the day", from when the sun rose until it set there was no hope in them, as it is written, "The murderer rises with the light" (Job 24:14). The evil inclination is grievous, for even its Maker called it evil, as it is said, "for the inclination of man's heart is evil" (Genesis 8:21). Rav Yitzchak said: a man's inclination renews itself against him every day, as it is said, "only evil all the day." "And the LORD repented that He had made man on the earth" (Genesis 6:6). The Holy One, blessed be He, said: I did well that I prepared a grave for them; it is written here "and He repented (vayinnachem)," and it is written there, "and he comforted (vayenachem) them and spoke to their hearts" (Genesis 50:21).

Full source
Yalkut Shimoni on Torah 83:5Yalkut Shimoni on Torah

"Far be it from You to do such a thing, to kill the righteous with the wicked" (Genesis 18:24-25). [Abraham argued:] You swore and said that You would not bring a flood upon the world. Why are You being cunning about the oath? A flood of water You do not bring, but a flood of fire You bring? If so, You have not discharged the oath. "Shall the Judge of all the earth not do justice?" If You seek a world, there is no [strict] judgment; and if You seek [strict] judgment, there is no world. You are grasping the rope at both ends: You desire a world and You desire judgment. If You do not relent a little, the world cannot stand.

The Holy One, blessed be He, said to Abraham, "You have loved righteousness and hated wickedness" (Psalms 45:8). "You have loved righteousness", to justify My creatures; "and hated wickedness", you hated to condemn them; "therefore God has anointed you with the oil of gladness above your fellows." What is "above your fellows"? From Noah until you there are ten generations, and of them all I spoke with not one of them except with you.

Rabbi Yudan said: "Far be it" (chalilah) means: it is profane (chullin) for You, it is a fabrication for You; there is a desecration of the Name in the matter. It is not written here "to do a thing" (davar) but "such a thing" (ka-davar), neither this nor anything like it nor anything lesser than it. Rabbi Levi said: Two men said the same thing, Abraham and Job. Abraham said, "Far be it from You," and Job said, "It is all one; therefore I say, He destroys the blameless and the wicked" (Job 9:22). Abraham received reward for it; Job was punished for it.

Rabbi Chiyya bar Abba said: There is a confusion of questions here. Abraham said, "Far be it from You to do such a thing, to kill the righteous with the wicked," and the Holy One, blessed be He, said, "the righteous shall be as the wicked", suspend [judgment] upon the wicked for the sake of the righteous, for they are merely deceptive righteous ones. For Rabbi Yochanan said: Wherever "righteous ones" (tzaddikim) is said regarding Sodom, it is written defectively [tzaddikm], the view of Rabbi Yochanan who said of "And our elders and all the inhabitants of our land said to us" (Joshua 9:11), "our elders" is written [defectively], elders of worthlessness, that is, elders of shame.

Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi said: Abraham said, "Combine My deeds and let them add up to the count of fifty." Rabbi Yehudah son of Rabbi Simon said: [God replied,] "Are you not the righteous one of the world? Combine yourself with them and let them add up to the count of fifty." Rabbi Yehudah son of Rabbi Simon said: Thus Abraham said to Him, "A king of flesh and blood, an appeal is presented to him from the duke to the prefect, from the prefect to the general, and You, because there is none above You to whom to present an appeal, will You not do justice?" Rabbi Yehudah son of Rabbi Simon said: "When You wished to judge Your world, You handed it over to two, Romulus and Remus, so that if one of them wished to do a thing, his fellow would restrain him; and You, because there is none to restrain You, will You not do justice?"

Full source