The Weeping Farm Boy Who Became a Cistern That Lost No Drop

Click for full size

The Boy Who Wept on Good Soil

Hyrkanos owned more land than a man could cross in a day, and he had sent his son to the worst of it. The field was all stone. Eliezer stood among the rocks with an ox and a plow that snagged on every buried edge, and instead of breaking the ground he sat down in it and wept.

His father came out to the field. "Why are you crying?" Hyrkanos asked. "Does the hard ground grieve you?" A practical man keeps a practical remedy close, so he moved the boy to a smooth, rich stretch of soil, the kind a farmer prays for. Eliezer cut one furrow there and wept over that field too.

"What is it now?" Hyrkanos said. "You have good earth under you and you weep anyway."

Eliezer told him the thing he had been swallowing. "I weep because I want to learn Torah."

His father stared at him. The boy was twenty-eight years old. "You are a grown man," he said. "Marry. Raise sons. Send them to study when the time comes." In his reckoning, learning belonged to boys, or to men with leisure to burn, not to a landowner's heir with fields waiting on him.

Two Weeks of Hunger Until Elijah Came

Eliezer did not argue. He stopped eating.

One day, then another, then a full week, then a second week, until his body was a rattle of bone and the hunger had burned everything out of him but the one wish. On the far side of that fast a figure stood before him whom no farmer can summon. It was Elijah the prophet, may his memory be a blessing.

"Son of Hyrkanos," Elijah said, "why do you weep?"

The answer had not changed through all the starving. "Because I want to learn Torah."

Elijah did not scold the fast or march him home. He handed him a road instead. "If you want to learn Torah," he said, "go up to Jerusalem, to Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai."

The heir of all that land walked off it with nothing in his hands.

He Wept Again Before the Master

Eliezer reached Jerusalem, found the sage, and in front of the greatest teacher of the age he did the one thing he seemed to know how to do. He sat down and wept.

"Why do you weep?" Yochanan asked.

"Because I wish to learn Torah."

"Whose son are you?"

The young man went silent. He had run from a wealthy father's house to sit on the floor of a study hall, and the one question that could open the door or shut it was his own name, and he would not give it. He held the silence and he stayed. Poor, unfed, stubborn past reason, he sat under the master year after year and took in everything set before him, and what went into him did not leak back out.

The Master Who Was Himself the Least

The man Eliezer had run toward carried a strange rank of his own. Hillel the Elder once had eighty disciples. Thirty of them were worthy for the Divine Presence to rest on them as it had rested on Moses, and their generation was not worthy of it. The greatest of the eighty was Jonathan ben Uzziel. The least of all of them was Yochanan ben Zakkai.

The least of Hillel's eighty had left no word of Torah unlearned. Scripture and Mishnah, the fine points of the Law and the fine points of the scribes, the arguments and the old stories, all of it sat inside him in order. "If you have learned much Torah," he used to say, "claim no credit for yourself, because this is the very thing you were made for." The smallest vessel in Hillel's house had turned out to hold the whole tradition, and now that vessel was pouring into others.

A Cistern That Loses Not a Drop

Years on, Yochanan weighed his five students aloud, and he weighed them in water. Eleazar ben Arak he called a swelling spring, a fountain that gathers force and floods past its banks. Joshua ben Hananiah he called a threefold cord not quickly snapped. Jose the priest he called the righteous one of the generation. Simeon ben Nathaniel he called an oasis in the desert that never lets its water sink away.

And Eliezer, the farm boy who had wept on good soil, the master named a plastered cistern that loses not a drop, a glazed pitcher that keeps its wine. Whatever was poured into him stayed at the level it was poured. "If every sage in Israel stood in one pan of the scale," Yochanan said, "and Eliezer ben Hyrkanos in the other, he would outweigh them all."

One voice pushed back. Abba Saul said the master had told it differently, that with Eleazar ben Arak set in the far pan the flooding spring would outweigh even Eliezer and all Israel beside him. The overflowing fountain against the sealed cistern, and the house of study never fully settled which pan dropped.

The spring did not end well. Eleazar followed sweet water to a pleasant town of warm springs and soft living, far from the other scholars, and his renown in Torah drained away in that comfort. The cistern kept its charge. The boy who could not stop weeping on his father's rocks held every drop the master ever poured, and carried the tradition down the years without spilling it.