The Soul Demanded an Accounting and the Intellect Asked What a Lack Is

The Neshamah (the higher soul) did not sit down. She stood at the edge of the lamplight with her hands open, the way a woman stands who has come straight from a house of mourning and not yet washed. "I have heard you," she said, "and your words are settled on me." She said settled the way a man says a stone is settled on his chest.

Click for full size

Across the table the Sekhel waited. It had spent a long time laying groundwork with her, one foundation under another. It had promised all of it would eventually hold something up. She had come to collect.

The Ruler She Refused to Give Up

She began with the one thing she would not surrender.

"Take away the supervisor over all this," she said, "and every wonder in the world turns into a puzzle with no solution. The rains. The fact that anything continues at all instead of stopping. I would drift in doubt forever and nothing would ever be answered, because nobody would be there to answer." She set two fingers flat on the table. "One who governs, all-powerful, not forced and not coerced and not pushed into His acts by matter or by any rival. Without that I cannot rest, and I will not pretend I can."

The Sekhel did not argue.

"Then what you carried in here is not a doubt about whether God is," it said. "It is a bill you want paid."

"It is."

The Charge She Laid on the Table

"You told me His acts come out of completeness," she said. "That He does not merely hold completeness, He is it. Very well. Then look at the thing He made."

She went through what she had watched from inside a body. The child buried by the parent. The prayer that goes up in full voice and comes back with nothing in its mouth.

"I do not understand the working of this straightforward completeness of His," she said. "By everything visible, that is not how completeness conducts itself. And you already told me the true completeness cannot be grasped at all. So you have handed me a rule I can neither watch working nor take apart."

Then she said the harder thing.

"Men have watched what I have watched and they counted. One power that gives the bread, another that takes the child. Two authorities up there, because they could not make one authority answer for both. That mistake did not fall out of the sky. It came out of rooms like this one, from nobody answering."

The Intellect Turned the Question Around

The Sekhel did not comfort her. It did not tell her the suffering was smaller than she thought, or that her eyes had gone bad.

"Before I account for what a complete Ruler does with a crooked world," it said, "answer me one thing. What is a lack?"

She stared at it.

"You have used the word all night. Crooked. Deficient. Missing. Out of everything the two of us laid down, a great root comes up now, and the root is this. What is chisaron, deficiency, and what is the shlemut, the completion that answers it? How did lack come to be in a made world at all? By what road is it repaired, and what follows the repair?"

She had come for consolation and been handed work.

"That is not an answer," she said.

"It is the only door into the answer."

The Rules Etched Before the First Morning

So the Sekhel gave her the arrangement.

Before anything ran, an order was set. Rules, a system, a whole organization built to deliver to creation both the good and its opposite. Not a hand reaching down each morning to decide who eats and who is buried. The consequences were etched into the fabric of the thing in advance, the way a weaver strings the warp before one colored thread crosses it, so that every figure the cloth will ever show is already permitted or forbidden by threads nobody can see. Both qualities belong to the character of the world.

The Neshamah heard it out. Then she said, "You have not removed one grave. You have filed it."

"I have told you that nobody lost track of it," said the Sekhel.

The Governance That Keeps Its Face Covered

"There is a rule running underneath the one you can see," it went on. "It works with its face covered, and it will keep working that way until the end that was fixed before you were sent down into flesh. At that end the crookedness gets shown for what it was, which is nothing that ever stood on its own, and every grave you counted tonight gets counted again in the other direction."

"When."

"Not tonight."

She laughed once, without any pleasure in it. "Then the explanation is extremely broad."

"It is. As broad as everything that has happened and everything that has not happened yet. You asked for the accounting of a Ruler with no border. Did you expect it to sit in your palm?"

The Lamp She Carried Back Down

The Neshamah stood a long while without speaking.

She had walked in to turn the world's crookedness into an accusation, and she was being handed it as material instead. The lack was not the flaw in the plan. It was the portion left unfinished on purpose and assigned to her, and the repair of it was not something she would watch from a bench.

"I want to be settled," she said. "Not soothed. Settled."

"Then take up the deficiency," said the Sekhel. "Settled comes to a soul with its hands in the work."

She picked up the lamp. The flame leaned hard, righted itself, and went on burning badly, the way a flame burns in a room with a draft nobody can find. She carried it out anyway.