5 min read

When Simon Paid for Peace in the Holy Land

Simon drives the Akra garrison from Jerusalem with his own silver, cleanses the citadel, and gives Israel a peace every man could sit under.

Curated by Arthur · Told by Maggid ·
Table of Contents
  1. The Promise That Sounded Like Salvation
  2. Simon Rose as the Last Brother
  3. The Citadel That Caged the City
  4. The Land Had Peace

The Promise That Sounded Like Salvation

Royal letters arrived in Jerusalem with the sound of generosity. A foreign king would provide silver for the Temple, support for the walls, fortifications across Judea. The language was of repair and strengthening, of a great power extending its hand to a small people that had suffered enough.

1 Maccabees does not let this language stand unchallenged. The Hasmonean leadership understood the difference between a king's favor and actual security. A king who repairs your walls today has access to those walls tomorrow. A king who funds your Temple has a relationship with your Temple. Royal patronage comes with the assumption that what a patron has built, a patron can also withdraw, and the condition attached to continued support is always the same: continued usefulness to the patron's interests.

Jonathan had navigated this world with considerable skill, playing Seleucid factions against each other, collecting letters of protection from Rome, building enough legitimacy that the Hasmonean high priesthood looked like an established institution rather than a rebel government. Then Tryphon closed the gates of Ptolemais around him and everything Jonathan had built suddenly depended on one man still breathing in a foreign prison.

Simon Rose as the Last Brother

Simon had watched his brothers fall one by one. Judas in open battle. Jonathan in a trap. When the community came to Simon in their grief and their fear and asked him to lead, he accepted, but he made a statement they could hold him to: he would avenge his brothers and fight for the nation and the Holy Place.

He meant it practically. Simon spent his own silver and gold on the war. This detail appears in the public decree the people later issued confirming his leadership, because it distinguished him from every arrangement that had come before. He had not made himself high priest by force and then required the community to fund him. He had made himself the community's creditor by fronting the cost of survival and then accepted the honor the community offered in return.

The Citadel That Caged the City

The Akra in Jerusalem had been a Seleucid citadel inside the city since the days of Antiochus IV. For decades it had been a foreign garrison sitting in Jerusalem's heart, a permanent reminder that the Maccabean victories had been partial, that liberation had a limit, that the city contained its own cage. From its walls the king's men looked down on the Temple courts and on every worshipper who climbed toward them, and the people who passed beneath felt the eyes and the weight of the stone above their heads.

Simon invested in a siege and waited. He cut the garrison off from supply and let hunger do the work that no breach in the wall had managed, and the days stretched on until the men inside had nothing left to eat. When the garrison surrendered from hunger, he did not destroy them. He waited for a day without defiling it, chose the twenty-third day of the second month in the 171st year of the Seleucid era, and entered with praise and palm branches and harps and cymbals and lyres, singing hymns and songs, because great enemies had been crushed and he had removed a great shame from Israel. The branches moved in the marchers' hands and the strings carried over the cleared stones, and the cage that had stood over the city for a generation stood open at last.

The Land Had Peace

What followed under Simon was extraordinary enough that 1 Maccabees uses prophetic language to describe it. Every man sat under his vine and under his fig tree, and no one made them afraid. The image comes from Micah's vision of the final peace, the world after the wars and the oppressions and the empires have finished with each other. 1 Maccabees places it in the present tense under a living man, in a specific generation, as if the prophecy had arrived early.

Old men sat in the squares and talked about good things, and young men put on glorious armor. Simon gave food to cities that needed it and equipped them with weapons. He increased Israel's glory. He went to Joppa and made it his harbor. He went to Gazara and garrisoned it. He turned and found peace had followed the fighting like a season that finally came after a very long delay.

The community confirmed his position in a public assembly, inscribed on bronze tablets and put up in the Temple precincts. He was leader and high priest forever, until a faithful prophet should arise. The forever was the honest kind, meaning for as long as this arrangement can last, which in Judea under the Hasmoneans meant for as long as one man could hold it together by skill, wealth, and the continued willingness of the people to follow him.


← All myths

From the tradition

Sources

3 sources

The texts this telling draws on, in full. Open a card to read inline, or expand it for a wider, quieter read.

The Book of Maccabees I 10:48The Book of Maccabees I

Times were tough. The Maccabees, that heroic family, were leading a revolt against the Seleucid Empire, who were trying to Hellenize Judea – to force Greek culture and religion upon them. It was a fight for their very identity. And in the middle of this struggle, an offer arrives.

Specifically, The passage describes a proposal that sounds almost miraculous. The king, whoever he may be at this point in the tumultuous history of the region, is offering to foot the bill for some serious upgrades. "For the building also and repairing of the works of the sanctuary," the text says, "expenses shall be given of the king’s accounts." The Beit Hamikdash, the Temple in Jerusalem, the very heart of Jewish life, damaged and needing repair. And this king is offering to pay for it. Not just that, but also "for the building of the walls of Jerusalem, and the fortifying thereof round about, expenses shall be given out of the king’s accounts, as also for the building of the walls in Judea." New walls for Jerusalem, fortifications throughout Judea – all paid for by the king! It's an incredible offer.

So, what's the problem?

The problem, as the Book of Maccabees makes clear, is trust. Or rather, the complete lack thereof. "Now when Jonathan and the people heard these words, they gave no credit unto them, nor received them, because they remembered the great evil that he had done in Israel; for he had afflicted them very sore."

That last line is key, isn't it? "He had afflicted them very sore." It doesn’t matter how generous the offer sounds on the surface. The memory of past betrayals, past cruelty, poisons everything. The scars run too deep. You can offer to rebuild the Temple, but can you rebuild trust?

This moment, captured so succinctly in Maccabees, speaks to a timeless human truth. Actions speak louder than words, and past actions speak the loudest of all. A history of oppression and cruelty can negate even the most generous-sounding promises. It leaves a residue of suspicion that's hard to overcome.

What do you think they should have done? Is there a point where the needs of the community outweigh past grievances? It's a question that echoes through history, and one that we still confront today.

Full source
The Book of Maccabees I 14:37The Book of Maccabees I

The Book of Maccabees I turns to Simon Rises as High Priest After Jonathan's Death.

The story unfolds in the First Book of Maccabees, chapter 14.

Jonathan, Simon's brother, had been leading the people and serving as Kohen Gadol (the High Priest), High Priest. He had gathered the nation, striving to rebuild and protect it. But then, tragedy struck. Jonathan "was added to his people," as the text delicately puts it, meaning he died.

That's when the vultures started circling. The enemies of Judea, ever watchful, saw their opportunity. They prepared to invade, intent on destroying the country and, perhaps most devastatingly, laying hands on the Mikdash, the Sanctuary.

What would you do?

In this moment of crisis, Simon Maccabeus stepped forward. He rose up, not just as a leader, but as a defender of his people. He fought for his nation, and here's where it gets really interesting: he spent much of his own substance. This wasn't just about power or glory; it was about sacrifice. He armed the valiant men of his nation and gave them wages. He understood that defending their freedom required resources, and he was willing to put his own wealth on the line.

But that wasn't all. Simon understood the importance of strategic defense. He fortified the cities of Judea, paying special attention to Bethsura. Bethsura, a city on the borders of Judea, was a crucial location. It had previously been used by the enemies as a place to store their weapons, their "armour." Simon recognized its strategic value and set a garrison of Jewish soldiers there, turning a former stronghold of the enemy into a bastion of defense.

It's a powerful image, isn't it? A leader not just leading from the front in battle, but investing his own resources, and thinking strategically about how to protect his people. It makes you wonder, what does true leadership really look like? Is it about power, or is it about service and sacrifice? The story of Simon Maccabeus certainly gives us something to think about.

Full source
The Book of Maccabees I 14:43The Book of Maccabees I

The Book of Maccabees I Chapter 14, offers a snapshot of his leadership and the relative peace he brought to the land. the land had been under Seleucid Greek rule, and the Temple itself defiled. But then came the Maccabees, this family of Jewish priests and warriors who rose up to fight for their religious freedom. The story, usually told during Hanukkah, is so much bigger than just a miracle of oil.

Our text zeroes in on Simon’s accomplishments. “For in his time things prospered in his hands, so that the heathen were taken out of their country…” He expelled the non-Jews, the "heathen" as the text puts it, from the land. More specifically, they were driven out of the akra, the citadel, in Jerusalem.

This akra, "tower" as it's called here, wasn't just any building. It was a stronghold built by the Seleucids right in the City of David, overlooking the Temple. From there, as Maccabees I tells us, they "issued, and polluted all about the sanctuary, and did much hurt in the holy place." Imagine the constant threat, the desecration, the feeling of living under occupation right in your holiest city! It’s no wonder that reclaiming it was such a pivotal moment.

What did Simon do? "But he placed Jews therein. and fortified it for the safety of the country and the city, and raised up the walls of Jerusalem." He didn’t just kick out the Seleucids; he rebuilt, he fortified, he secured. He made Jerusalem a Jewish city again, a safe haven for his people. The high walls were not just physical barriers; they were symbols of resilience and renewed hope.

But here’s where it gets even more interesting. The passage continues: "King Demetrius also confirmed him in the high priesthood according to those things, And made him one of his friends, and honoured him with great honour." Demetrius, the Seleucid king, recognized Simon’s authority and even honored him.

Talk about a shift in power!

This recognition emphasizes the political savvy of Simon Maccabeus. He wasn't just a warrior; he was a diplomat, a leader who could negotiate and secure his people's future. He gained recognition from a Seleucid king, no less.

So, what does this short passage tell us? It’s more than just a historical record. It’s a glimpse into a time of transformation, of reclaiming not just land, but identity and religious freedom. It reminds us that even in the face of seemingly insurmountable odds, resilience, faith, and strong leadership can pave the way for a brighter future. It’s a evidence of the power of Simon Maccabeus’s vision and the enduring spirit of the Jewish people. And that, my friends, is a story worth remembering.

Full source